{
  "source_sha256": "6580d9db9c81bffde15106e3a43d6220c800e724143953fab968bcb40475a321",
  "review_policy": {
    "schema": 1,
    "cutoff_date": "1964-11-04",
    "basis": "received_date",
    "evidence": "Original printed page 195 states Received 4 November 1964. APS metadata has a nominal publication date of November 1; use the explicit received date for the historical cutoff and record the discrepancy.",
    "status": "recorded",
    "rule": "external-results-available-by-cutoff"
  },
  "nodes": {
    "formulation": {
      "outcome": "supported",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "The mathematical model is coherent under its explicit functional form; physical motivation is separately conditional.",
      "source_quote": "Now we make the hypothesis [2], and it seems one at least worth considering, that if the two measure-\nments are made at places remote from one another the orientation of one magnet",
      "statement_status": "locally_supported",
      "statement_argument": "Equation (2) uses one normalized nonnegative setting-independent distribution and deterministic setting-local responses. These are the premises of the tested representation, not deductions from an unrestricted notion of locality.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Identify exactly the hypotheses encoded by equations (1)-(3) and the perfect-correlation argument. Separate the mathematical model, its physical motivation and what follows without extra assumptions. Audit the 1964 text on its stated terms, without importing later results.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates."
    },
    "illustrations": {
      "outcome": "repair_verified",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "The angle instruction and function label need local corrections; the main inequality does not depend on these examples.",
      "source_quote": "Firstly, there is no difficulty in giving a hidden variable account of spin measurements on a single \nparticle^ Suppose we have a spin half particle in a pure spin state with polar",
      "statement_status": "locally_supported",
      "statement_argument": "Choose the specified separation theta-prime=(pi/2)(1-cos(theta)), rather than always rotating toward p; theta=2pi/3 demonstrates the wording error. Correct the label of B in equation (9) to B(b,lambda). Hemisphere and sphere-lune expectations then give the stated illustrations under their stated mixture assumptions.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Check all three supplied illustrative constructions and equations (4)-(11), including the angular prescriptions, normalization and what each example does or does not reproduce. These are illustrations, not premises of the main inequality.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates.",
      "repair_verified": true,
      "repair_explanation": "Choose the specified separation theta-prime=(pi/2)(1-cos(theta)), rather than always rotating toward p; theta=2pi/3 demonstrates the wording error. Correct the label of B in equation (9) to B(b,lambda). Hemisphere and sphere-lune expectations then give the stated illustrations under their stated mixture assumptions.",
      "original_hypotheses_preserved": true
    },
    "inequality": {
      "outcome": "supported",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "The exact inequality and explicit singlet contradiction are supported.",
      "source_quote": "The main result will now be proved. Because p is a normalized probability distribution,\n(12)\nand because of the properties (1), P in (2) cannot be less than -1 . It can reach - 1 a",
      "statement_status": "locally_supported",
      "statement_argument": "Perfect anticorrelation gives A=-B almost everywhere for each selected setting. A finite union of null sets suffices. Equations (12)-(15) give |P(a,b)-P(a,c)|<=1+P(b,c), contradicted by a.c=0 and a.b=b.c=1/sqrt(2) with P=-a.b.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Check equations (12)-(15), null-set issues and the stated incompatibility with the singlet correlation. Distinguish the algebraic inequality from prose regularity claims. Use only the supplied model assumptions.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates."
    },
    "approximation": {
      "outcome": "repair_verified",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "The factor-four approximation bound is supported after restoring the omitted integral sign in (21).",
      "source_quote": "Nor can the quantum mechanical correlation (3) be arbitrarily closely approximated by the form (2). \nThe formal proof of this may be set out as follows. We would not worry about fa",
      "statement_status": "locally_supported",
      "statement_argument": "Independent normalized angular averaging gives bounded responses. Insert the missing integral in (21), justified by (18),(19). The displayed algebra then gives 4(epsilon+delta)>=sqrt(2)-1, excluding arbitrarily small uniform error for sufficiently narrow caps.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Check equations (16)-(22), independent angular averaging, bounded response functions, constants and the explicit vector example. Determine precisely what type of approximation is excluded; do not replace the printed proof with a later inequality.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates.",
      "repair_verified": true,
      "repair_explanation": "Independent normalized angular averaging gives bounded responses. Insert the missing integral in (21), justified by (18),(19). The displayed algebra then gives 4(epsilon+delta)>=sqrt(2)-1, excluding arbitrarily small uniform error for sufficiently narrow caps.",
      "original_hypotheses_preserved": true
    },
    "embedding": {
      "outcome": "repair_verified",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "The literal joint zero extensions do not establish locality. The explicitly checked local-extension repair preserves the conditional existential result.",
      "source_quote": "In a more formal way, assuming [7] that any Hermitian oper-\nator with a complete set of eigenstates is an \u201c observable\u201d , the result is easily extended to other systems. \nIf the tw",
      "statement_status": "locally_supported",
      "statement_argument": "Extend each Pauli observable by zero on its own subsystem, then use X_1 tensor I and I tensor X_2. On the embedded matched-basis singlet, correlations are -a.b and zero outcomes have probability zero. The repaired operators are local and satisfy the earlier inequality hypotheses. Astra independently checks this under the source observable postulate; no experimental accessibility claim follows from dimension alone.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Check the subspace construction and zero-extension of the observables. Specify the quantum state and observable assumptions needed; assess what exactly follows for higher-dimensional systems.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates.",
      "repair_verified": true,
      "repair_explanation": "Extend each Pauli observable by zero on its own subsystem, then use X_1 tensor I and I tensor X_2. On the embedded matched-basis singlet, correlations are -a.b and zero outcomes have probability zero. The repaired operators are local and satisfy the earlier inequality hypotheses. Astra independently checks this under the source observable postulate; no experimental accessibility claim follows from dimension alone.",
      "original_hypotheses_preserved": true
    },
    "interpretation": {
      "outcome": "confirmed_defect",
      "origin": "curated_source_check",
      "summary": "Section VI does not establish its instantaneous-propagation or Lorentz-invariance implications. This concerns those claims only; the inequality is supported.",
      "source_quote": "In a theory in which parameters are added to quantum mechanics to determine the results of individual \nmeasurements, without changing the statistical predictions, there must be a m",
      "statement_status": "unresolved",
      "statement_argument": "The equations contain no propagation law or spacetime transformation rule, so functional distant-setting dependence does not by itself establish the stronger temporal and relativistic assertions. They remain unresolved, not refuted. Astra rejects an operational-communication objection because the source speaks of fixed-hidden-variable dependence.",
      "explanation_url": "report.pdf",
      "scope": "Assess whether each physical conclusion in Section VI is established by the mathematical argument under its stated assumptions. Distinguish correlations, influences, operational communication and invariance claims where the text warrants it. Mark unproved interpretive implications separately from mathematical defects; use no later experimental results.",
      "checked_by": "Sol/Fable independent reviews, Codex source checks, and Astra on selected objections; not human grades or formal certificates."
    }
  }
}
