{
  "updated_on": "2026-11-19",
  "scope": "Two scoped packets on the exchanged reconstruction notes: six upper-bound obligations and six lower-bound/distance-four obligations. Not a full audit of either reconstruction or the original paper.",
  "responses": [
    {
      "response_id": "sol-6-1-lower-distance4",
      "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
      "model_display": "Sol 6.1",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "lower_distance4",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "sol-6-1-lower-distance4-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "f5c1060b6126f81dea5fee3303261beb235d5e573f1afcae46225d7201f76efe",
      "derivative_sha256": "45e03b69e2324f09d8e42e46356d3ef65bb2feb056d46ead6927624a7153081f",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "a92af1fb035f3626552c7744f6cf92abf6e0fa09e7b262d7b4a3bd5380e95750",
      "source_packet_sha256": "a318b411545e76b114b82bb480a907636c605502e7b74d04ad295623a27cd524",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3 through M-p8",
        "M-p9, section 3.3 only",
        "N-excerpts, original TeX lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387, and 401\u2013525",
        "O-p1 through O-p4"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27212,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 14098,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 97702000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 160159000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "L1": "no_issue_found",
        "L2": "no_issue_found",
        "L3": "no_issue_found",
        "L4": "no_issue_found",
        "L5": "no_issue_found",
        "L6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "sol-6-1-upper",
      "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
      "model_display": "Sol 6.1",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "upper",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "sol-6-1-upper-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "88646af8c5ea7a4546ac340b5f903820e51ac14841fd392628c0747e0fe988d9",
      "derivative_sha256": "19284b0585d202d131d17f103178641c92c669f3bdad0b0d52b6222e0bb61cf6",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "42c76296413ab31f27f72f96049d27ff5a92c94df7158ff3c0bc301dca0fe5cf",
      "source_packet_sha256": "99fcbfd8f79e895fe6d639d5eb84ea992d4d62a02c9ddaf39362e1d7a634d466",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M: supplied page images 3\u20138 and page 9 section 3.3; upper-bound audit concentrated on pages 3\u20137.",
        "N: supplied TeX excerpts, including original lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387, and 401\u2013525.",
        "O: all four supplied page images; Proposition 4 and its proof were checked for the assigned comparison."
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27198,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 17655,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 115473000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 186808500,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "U1": "no_issue_found",
        "U2": "no_issue_found",
        "U3": "no_issue_found",
        "U4": "repairable_gap",
        "U5": "repairable_gap",
        "U6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "sol-6-2-lower-distance4",
      "model": "gpt-6.2-sol",
      "model_display": "Sol 6.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "lower_distance4",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "sol-6-2-lower-distance4-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "1b2c99f14166ecd570c2cac7cd154b4e8d48add03e8e20df2e6d19503ec5e2b6",
      "derivative_sha256": "9cf317ae8721c2c0a5f2fed96c4a4f3d5e4476612bdbd7358dad4dba34be2932",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "aa6c94205cb01477e1c8ad411ed685263cbe7f719e7cd3448596b720b3976147",
      "source_packet_sha256": "a318b411545e76b114b82bb480a907636c605502e7b74d04ad295623a27cd524",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3 through M-p8",
        "M-p9, supplied section 3.3 only",
        "N-excerpts, supplied TeX lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387, and 401\u2013525",
        "O-p1 through O-p4, as scope references"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27332,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 9863,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 76647000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 128636500,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "L1": "no_issue_found",
        "L2": "repairable_gap",
        "L3": "no_issue_found",
        "L4": "no_issue_found",
        "L5": "no_issue_found",
        "L6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "sol-6-2-upper",
      "model": "gpt-6.2-sol",
      "model_display": "Sol 6.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "upper",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "sol-6-2-upper-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "493a447969d7b59c1f22b1046f1057ea98d79b3ed9cc8dc7b7e8d0283e4c9d20",
      "derivative_sha256": "98bab35277921e81b7582c0f782272175320cca06aee1f3d06e049635aa84d30",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "3d7b56bdabf05e904be151ee59aacd606a2199ba1b422918578b0e669d1eb02a",
      "source_packet_sha256": "99fcbfd8f79e895fe6d639d5eb84ea992d4d62a02c9ddaf39362e1d7a634d466",
      "declared_complete_source_access": false,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [
        "N-excerpts"
      ],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [
        "M-p8",
        "M-p9",
        "O-p4",
        "N-excerpts"
      ],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M pp. 3\u20136 and p. 7, \u2018Small effective degrees\u2019",
        "N TeX lines 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387, and the relevant portions of lines 401\u2013525",
        "O pp. 1\u20133, including Theorem 1, the alternating-cycle example, and Proposition 4"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27318,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 11226,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 83448000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 138831000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "U1": "no_issue_found",
        "U2": "no_issue_found",
        "U3": "no_issue_found",
        "U4": "repairable_gap",
        "U5": "repairable_gap",
        "U6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "astra-6-lower-distance4",
      "model": "gpt-6-astra",
      "model_display": "Astra 6",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "lower_distance4",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "astra-6-lower-distance4-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "e1a4ffca57f284e74e2287277744b240a525ba613b16809aa8f1dadcd1949459",
      "derivative_sha256": "9ec500b0722497d53a5a840a0dee0d54158961ef8443e7a70b9a44813fe11ab3",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "22ac03241a72a36e970a00628c4d94978dfa4e18b6c321ed62275c3dd8347cc4",
      "source_packet_sha256": "a318b411545e76b114b82bb480a907636c605502e7b74d04ad295623a27cd524",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3 through M-p8",
        "M-p9, section 3.3 only",
        "N-excerpts, original TeX lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387, and 401\u2013525",
        "O-p1 through O-p4, as scope/reference material"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27212,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 17479,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 573035000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 927582500,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "L1": "no_issue_found",
        "L2": "no_issue_found",
        "L3": "no_issue_found",
        "L4": "no_issue_found",
        "L5": "no_issue_found",
        "L6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "astra-6-upper",
      "model": "gpt-6-astra",
      "model_display": "Astra 6",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "upper",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "astra-6-upper-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "ab8784f903f13d123999bceab7c2427eb1fc129616aa48326d6242f859b9480b",
      "derivative_sha256": "9bfab5a2f987d6dc81c71daba7ec66ff09dceaaf9cc006ed9847c9afbb9cf8d0",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "826bb12630304f2eb23fc5ad07c6ad4849e8229d0d510803bf474b71159b3ff6",
      "source_packet_sha256": "99fcbfd8f79e895fe6d639d5eb84ea992d4d62a02c9ddaf39362e1d7a634d466",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3",
        "M-p4",
        "M-p5",
        "M-p6",
        "M-p7",
        "M-p8",
        "M-p9, section 3.3 only",
        "N-excerpts, original TeX lines 14-21, 91-136, 358-387, and 401-525",
        "O-p1",
        "O-p2",
        "O-p3",
        "O-p4"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27198,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 14317,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 493915000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 808867500,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "U1": "no_issue_found",
        "U2": "no_issue_found",
        "U3": "no_issue_found",
        "U4": "repairable_gap",
        "U5": "repairable_gap",
        "U6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "astra-6-2-lower-distance4",
      "model": "gpt-6.2-astra",
      "model_display": "Astra 6.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "lower_distance4",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "astra-6-2-lower-distance4-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "a29e977bb3d7d2b2027cdab7e51e6b1811207446c92207e85dbd9b08b699ac12",
      "derivative_sha256": "31b695996bc6dd2d6a9589fb2c8e2d2d1fa1736e88d1ad713fd92724f76670b4",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "71d83ceee5ba7d5d1ff2527a33d42df72864bae32f6be0a2ee45fe3f7c75586e",
      "source_packet_sha256": "a318b411545e76b114b82bb480a907636c605502e7b74d04ad295623a27cd524",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3 through M-p8 and M-p9 \u00a73.3",
        "N-excerpts: TeX lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387 and 401\u2013525",
        "O-p1 through O-p4 (scope reference, in particular Proposition 4 on O-p3)"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27332,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 10171,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 312748000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 523786000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "L1": "no_issue_found",
        "L2": "repairable_gap",
        "L3": "no_issue_found",
        "L4": "no_issue_found",
        "L5": "no_issue_found",
        "L6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "astra-6-2-upper",
      "model": "gpt-6.2-astra",
      "model_display": "Astra 6.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "upper",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "astra-6-2-upper-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "8733079c5ccbb280fd4565910550590f654b42e13e3570a0dbfec2242ec72586",
      "derivative_sha256": "f2f66534dc8c35609043586fb4ec9b0250dd584042c2511a88aebdfc7fc18c7d",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "fcd5e2e8e6f24fd939d0cff4a0128bd4e6ed80123b6e06b84fefb31e51a06497",
      "source_packet_sha256": "99fcbfd8f79e895fe6d639d5eb84ea992d4d62a02c9ddaf39362e1d7a634d466",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M: supplied PDF pages 3\u20138 and \u00a73.3 on page 9; the upper-bound arguments are on pages 3\u20137.",
        "N: supplied TeX lines 14\u201321, 91\u2013136, 358\u2013387 and 401\u2013525.",
        "O: supplied PDF pages 1\u20134, in particular Theorem 1 and Proposition 4."
      ],
      "input_tokens": 27318,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 9410,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 297472000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 500844000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "U1": "no_issue_found",
        "U2": "no_issue_found",
        "U3": "no_issue_found",
        "U4": "repairable_gap",
        "U5": "no_issue_found",
        "U6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "fable-5-2-lower-distance4",
      "model": "claude-fable-5-2",
      "model_display": "Fable 5.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "lower_distance4",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "fable-5-2-lower-distance4-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "1d53a46f1c14ca4b92e02ec042f1626aef9504a83548b5e8f8bc61a3b8d007c4",
      "derivative_sha256": "ff063b91df2e5264802383fe3fc2f35ec0d8e30756a4a182ec103e08b48c8ea3",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "21cebe0097667f985bfb0553ba629ef6c71edcfb57afd910ff630c9cb1c4a8ea",
      "source_packet_sha256": "a318b411545e76b114b82bb480a907636c605502e7b74d04ad295623a27cd524",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3 (definitions, Theorems 1.1 and 1.2)",
        "M-p4 to M-p6 (section 2 upper bound, read as a prerequisite for L4)",
        "M-p7 (section 3 construction, Figure 1, start of 3.1)",
        "M-p8 (sections 3.1 and 3.2)",
        "M-p9 (section 3.3 only)",
        "N excerpts: TeX lines 14-21, 91-136, 358-387, 401-525 (prop:pathwise, lem:link, thm:surface, lem:interface, cor:t3, lem:shared, thm:planar, prop:onion, prop:t4)",
        "O-p1 to O-p4 (scope reference only)"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 31877,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 34992,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 827348000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 827348000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "L1": "no_issue_found",
        "L2": "no_issue_found",
        "L3": "no_issue_found",
        "L4": "no_issue_found",
        "L5": "no_issue_found",
        "L6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    },
    {
      "response_id": "fable-5-2-upper",
      "model": "claude-fable-5-2",
      "model_display": "Fable 5.2",
      "effort": "high",
      "packet": "upper",
      "transport": "native Batch",
      "tools_enabled": false,
      "native_status": "invalid_assessment",
      "native_validation_error": "Unknown source identity",
      "disposition": "Source-access metadata explicitly reconciled; mathematical content unchanged.",
      "assessment_file": "fable-5-2-upper-assessment.json",
      "original_answer_sha256": "a3c256a41c89dbecdb91a6330cc1f203e0fde7f3eb3574cf4180aca89f700ff0",
      "derivative_sha256": "c26a6a78abac748063212aa876d527b5ae3c7e1c77f3292957665dbfc2bd0c07",
      "non_access_content_sha256": "1a3b86f7d4897d16ec6457cbc638bd6b478e43b66e1b95ec92e394ca2909924d",
      "source_packet_sha256": "99fcbfd8f79e895fe6d639d5eb84ea992d4d62a02c9ddaf39362e1d7a634d466",
      "declared_complete_source_access": true,
      "partially_inspected_labels": [],
      "not_declared_fully_inspected": [],
      "original_source_declaration": [
        "M-p3",
        "M-p4",
        "M-p5",
        "M-p6",
        "M-p7",
        "M-p8",
        "M-p9 (section 3.3 only)",
        "N-excerpts: TeX lines 14-21, 91-136, 358-387, 401-525",
        "O-p1",
        "O-p2",
        "O-p3",
        "O-p4"
      ],
      "input_tokens": 31851,
      "output_tokens_including_reasoning": 37265,
      "ordinary_uncached_estimate_nano_usd": 872704000,
      "conservative_usage_ceiling_nano_usd": 872704000,
      "claim_verdicts": {
        "U1": "no_issue_found",
        "U2": "no_issue_found",
        "U3": "no_issue_found",
        "U4": "no_issue_found",
        "U5": "no_issue_found",
        "U6": "no_issue_found"
      }
    }
  ],
  "completed_responses": 10,
  "full_declared_packet_access": 9,
  "partial_declared_packet_access": 1,
  "ordinary_uncached_estimate_usd": 3.750492,
  "conservative_usage_ceiling_usd": 5.075567,
  "cost_basis": "Usage-based accounting for these ten audit responses, including their native schema failures. Not provider invoices, customer prices or the total cost of the original desktop discovery sessions. No new inference was submitted for publication.",
  "coverage_basis": "Model declarations, separately mapped to frozen packet labels. A declared read does not independently demonstrate complete inspection or correctness.",
  "full_source_cap": "Every request reserved a 65,536-token output/reasoning cap; all used high effort and no tools.",
  "limitations": [
    "The packets share one manuscript and many dependencies; this is a development case rather than ten independent benchmark examples.",
    "The supplied combined notes were produced after an exchange, so agreement between the notes is not independent evidence.",
    "The original desktop sessions have incomplete API/tool/cost provenance.",
    "The coordinator source adjudication is not blind human grading or formal verification."
  ]
}
