{
  "schema": 1,
  "date": "2026-10-19",
  "reviewed_edition": "1205.4416v2",
  "reviewed_pdf_sha256": "b6eecaba8a4e5902607d11e473cd72d08b4bf42817f4c18ea7c1fe165010beb2",
  "expanded_source_sha256": "9939002e09d4f1726684edebc860d0b6f9dce839e4ea6761c41c4660ef932f64",
  "package_parts": [
    "reading.zip",
    "panel-review.zip"
  ],
  "public_selection": {
    "reading_records": [
      "source_manifest.json",
      "source-v2.tar",
      "native-arxiv-v2/Apoll19.tex",
      "native-arxiv-v2/Apoll19.bbl",
      "native-arxiv-v2/AKstyle.sty",
      "native-arxiv-v2/Orbit11.pdf",
      "native-arxiv-v2/pic.pdf",
      "native-arxiv-v2/picInf.pdf"
    ],
    "accepted_assessment_names": [
      "local-001",
      "local-002",
      "local-003",
      "local-004",
      "local-005",
      "local-006",
      "local-007",
      "local-008",
      "local-009",
      "local-010",
      "local-011",
      "local-012",
      "local-014",
      "local-015",
      "local-017",
      "local-019",
      "local-020",
      "local-021",
      "local-022",
      "local-023",
      "local-024",
      "local-025",
      "local-026",
      "local-027",
      "local-028",
      "local-029",
      "local-030",
      "local-031",
      "local-032",
      "local-033",
      "local-034",
      "local-035",
      "local-036",
      "local-037",
      "local-038",
      "local-040",
      "local-041",
      "local-042",
      "local-043",
      "local-044",
      "local-045",
      "local-046",
      "local-047",
      "local-048",
      "local-049",
      "local-050",
      "local-051",
      "local-052",
      "local-053",
      "local-054",
      "local-055",
      "local-056",
      "local-057",
      "local-058",
      "local-059",
      "local-060",
      "local-061",
      "local-062",
      "local-064",
      "local-065",
      "local-066",
      "local-067",
      "local-068",
      "local-069",
      "local-071",
      "local-073",
      "initial-1-01",
      "initial-4-01",
      "astra-technical-02",
      "gemini-technical-01"
    ],
    "supporting_records": [
      "rejected-local-013.txt",
      "rejected-local-039.txt",
      "rejected-local-070.txt",
      "initial-1-arbitration.md",
      "initial-1-arbitration.json",
      "brief-initial-1-01.json",
      "initial-2-arbitration.md",
      "initial-2-arbitration.json",
      "rejected-initial-2-01.txt",
      "brief-initial-2-01.json",
      "initial-3-arbitration.md",
      "initial-3-arbitration.json",
      "rejected-initial-3-01.txt",
      "brief-initial-3-01.json",
      "initial-4-arbitration.md",
      "initial-4-arbitration.json",
      "brief-initial-4-01.json",
      "astra-technical-arbitration.md",
      "astra-technical-arbitration.json",
      "rejected-astra-technical-01.txt",
      "brief-astra-technical-01.json",
      "brief-astra-technical-02.json",
      "gemini-technical-arbitration.md",
      "gemini-technical-arbitration.json",
      "brief-gemini-technical-01.json",
      "rejected-gemini-technical-02.txt",
      "brief-gemini-technical-02.json",
      "rejected-gemini-technical-03.txt",
      "brief-gemini-technical-03.json",
      "rejected-gemini-technical-04.txt",
      "brief-gemini-technical-04.json",
      "rejected-gemini-technical-05.txt",
      "brief-gemini-technical-05.json",
      "attempts.json",
      "coverage-costs.json",
      "brief-local-000.json",
      "brief-local-001.json",
      "brief-local-002.json",
      "brief-local-003.json",
      "brief-local-004.json",
      "brief-local-005.json",
      "brief-local-006.json",
      "brief-local-007.json",
      "brief-local-008.json",
      "brief-local-009.json",
      "brief-local-010.json",
      "brief-local-011.json",
      "brief-local-012.json",
      "brief-local-013.json",
      "brief-local-014.json",
      "brief-local-015.json",
      "brief-local-016.json",
      "brief-local-017.json",
      "brief-local-018.json",
      "brief-local-019.json",
      "brief-local-020.json",
      "brief-local-021.json",
      "brief-local-022.json",
      "brief-local-023.json",
      "brief-local-024.json",
      "brief-local-025.json",
      "brief-local-026.json",
      "brief-local-027.json",
      "brief-local-028.json",
      "brief-local-029.json",
      "brief-local-030.json",
      "brief-local-031.json",
      "brief-local-032.json",
      "brief-local-033.json",
      "brief-local-034.json",
      "brief-local-035.json",
      "brief-local-036.json",
      "brief-local-037.json",
      "brief-local-038.json",
      "brief-local-039.json",
      "brief-local-040.json",
      "brief-local-041.json",
      "brief-local-042.json",
      "brief-local-043.json",
      "brief-local-044.json",
      "brief-local-045.json",
      "brief-local-046.json",
      "brief-local-047.json",
      "brief-local-048.json",
      "brief-local-049.json",
      "brief-local-050.json",
      "brief-local-051.json",
      "brief-local-052.json",
      "brief-local-053.json",
      "brief-local-054.json",
      "brief-local-055.json",
      "brief-local-056.json",
      "brief-local-057.json",
      "brief-local-058.json",
      "brief-local-059.json",
      "brief-local-060.json",
      "brief-local-061.json",
      "brief-local-062.json",
      "brief-local-063.json",
      "brief-local-064.json",
      "brief-local-065.json",
      "exact_orbits.py",
      "exact-orbits.json",
      "exact_smoothing.py",
      "exact-smoothing.json",
      "exact_local_roots.py",
      "exact-local-roots.json",
      "exact-evidence-manifest.json",
      "historical-source-checks.md",
      "historical-initial-source-assessment.md",
      "historical-local-review.md",
      "historical-local-review.json",
      "comparison-scope.md",
      "decision-records.json"
    ],
    "current_documents": [
      "panel-review.md",
      "evidence.md",
      "reports.md",
      "coverage-costs.md"
    ]
  },
  "original_accepted_assessment_hashes": {
    "local-001": "cdc521fd60d41b073077c25011db656adb65faab96f0f009189bdf935c73ecd3",
    "local-002": "252fc6499fb67736f7fa0bf6521bc06d660479ef3f9af7352e43b45895811a14",
    "local-003": "99df3d68c12e52ffe1297c4747517b8a5b6c4b48a04f1259d0b8d287cc8f9289",
    "local-004": "340b04549a7770ab8f1cbafd721cb5580a940f4f42a2a52274408c105de0dc10",
    "local-005": "d7a00a2af304a56dec21c00aa944c2636e49e2483905463e0fe3ec94b2fba8eb",
    "local-006": "2bf71eb167da6e0f59c9d28f876112b9b8410b233e09b7ede9cb0222e1434ed9",
    "local-007": "4444b27b8de021d0c56ac8c200de88a3217abf624c4f55c78491904064f78345",
    "local-008": "a078098749757b58cd6451cd3727a4a57e413b717efb498f6a1773eba3a1e2e0",
    "local-009": "7637c15d93cdbe62ac83c05a75f0e9b86f1e9b371e77e880dc5b45de67337439",
    "local-010": "d3099deca8cf7f43cc0015b77e2feee6dfc03c5225ebc7bf8d1c58c699a4217c",
    "local-011": "08effe8a8385a71dde5bc6a52ec794f4b93f6454b33e5c2c2e129ad12e2c5fac",
    "local-012": "0244f368a4e35f991979991b9176252c25f6992144ba425b7e3b1fdd078cf3be",
    "local-014": "ed180425722f14eeb365b5ad7d2e881cd4d92c110eb62fe6e0e511e59df43d67",
    "local-015": "de021cfc318703b5c1d8c2b6c4de42371716db60583c707d0964ed553710f74f",
    "local-017": "bc59c6377eeb260098e9e51926a876b529e980697e21f64d6d277ab7f5c7890e",
    "local-019": "e0a93622435a8fd409f94b50b2aba03dec11ab08dc277d3d0ce99a59c982db14",
    "local-020": "8dd753a45e77b6150c087e51533e58a001f2b213a7790bde9ec49b2f83618488",
    "local-021": "abc1398fb0cb7eea02e50411e29bfee752e2322f7a489a00a494d98bac931b1b",
    "local-022": "0877dbd8fd64775d1c82c3ada62b1aff0234f5ac814ca74ba9fc242957cd60a7",
    "local-023": "aee13e77ee381e191fa20b3a0d580aa0a921798af780bfec986d55857110d492",
    "local-024": "753597b6cb59c797784152e3ee88c223c1d776de3053444d5fd3d88fec405e83",
    "local-025": "0bdc0fc3e7f50058bc684bef9512a3ef2c2593d1f35029032bc49cb546e2d5be",
    "local-026": "8e14727ef7dee011426bea3a6fa790ee906e017af9e7bd4a4948d1e80833b418",
    "local-027": "82e5e84596d595bd361e39b628ecb40248c99b556342de22686bffd5abf51e18",
    "local-028": "0e669e84b2447dbdf288119347c486d6701b5cdf3fc088aad2501bf1c4582b87",
    "local-029": "8942a596ef8948744050c9cf0d23cb0c05a23dd4f1675c26b7de138bedd725ae",
    "local-030": "38a813185dfa341960b823dfe604472230defe65a7b259cd13ffd024e12fdead",
    "local-031": "9921452a27c0ea300789be18e32e974b353768e50c7d904b223cdb0481c425fa",
    "local-032": "acd1d81f19d6d0b095b59374a08a0236880312ca336716f0d6eb987a34da16fe",
    "local-033": "ba9870da74d6de26bb7d0fd0c1b1bf9bf02d3aa403410d7ce3f7923c0a3e4d97",
    "local-034": "814a02afb23093ab3e44bec2f3a245bfb8a013e789d74e0fafa09b7d5606e6ee",
    "local-035": "84408b65f245676792fb396ffb79dba565c13804a47a4c031aff1027574e274f",
    "local-036": "076e1a37a4af766951477c35fca8ae5ab1d96445a42f0bbde50ce94d2fec68d7",
    "local-037": "2efe5472502a3928538725372ccd230c03eccae29517a44ddb95c3fd51d8a221",
    "local-038": "0f77f053ba6fdfadcb32ca61ee78ac87ab7dfae5475628083e576104e7180260",
    "local-040": "33c41a1c90b07c3d30aa4dc389a3a7a0be119c723837cc8223b055bac5e9f6c9",
    "local-041": "1dd1fc2e25c5526b564adc840a2324a080eb809bc41535def9cee75b7b34e711",
    "local-042": "7487d55134177a6bbc15426973e0c5791296ddccb4b7444c6c1896c28292ebf9",
    "local-043": "8f1eaf98980d2b3fb16b0463cfbb8b5f8f7eaebb99684eab64b4bb98fdbb66e5",
    "local-044": "cac7c55e5117ca96d86a2948beb2ef831bab7cf14711bed48852a91d4f5c6831",
    "local-045": "d372bb9a097ce246c7295c3e30710eeb7f6eac63902ccbc5e6b8eb8090dc03b7",
    "local-046": "07242c91bb15be07dc02eb40e4d20ac51d4c8351d352534b4fffdd04ca9cef0c",
    "local-047": "5a68c959c045b517d2feeba7426ac1703951737ca961b3feffd05269d2f647db",
    "local-048": "2713e76a1c043b4673322f2b55cf10ad0603478590c08d53ded2cf0312658c83",
    "local-049": "53fe9a77f3905294fecd00ee00f5af0fc83795396b14dc219181e283618c651c",
    "local-050": "6a514fe6197a3977b206315b369f073e85991a9c14a2b47f879a9b278b25fbce",
    "local-051": "c12201e67b3747f299ca4e53454cf2bafc30fd26cdd265267474d8af1fb05bdd",
    "local-052": "2ac7412089e07aef6339ddcee0c960890f287cfe1661cbc91557e75b8085c193",
    "local-053": "e5bfd067656ac1fbeb3bfa957d36e58650dfd72116b3babbbfbf175030e03ed1",
    "local-054": "a590eb7a3ed8032293b43a8dc600adf3528eee75ada9abdbd54771a1d120b941",
    "local-055": "e063f1231fb9ea63276da0086a3c9af74976e2eec6fea56c9d112f53765f2f4c",
    "local-056": "eaca4ac21e57d83f06b077755e63575c4aa2a07a4abc5d35bfb43efce510beb8",
    "local-057": "d111014457aeba6e8a1d51f13a5ccb4118094a1a5b4d7bdf563c43443776cf22",
    "local-058": "269205fc64849f1cce4d81fd20aac705ae41209697a4f4adfc75dbda92f429d5",
    "local-059": "916a726dd4c15782788e3b90dc7a92d14271cb9d3b801a6ddefbb7ad0132b934",
    "local-060": "3b7ebaf7c8f2cb1383dec4061e56df94eff6d20e6613e07c1625436acb471c74",
    "local-061": "ac71379595519c5292f6679c72303bfeb171eaaa0d8394ffe754e7c271e0a2f9",
    "local-062": "bc86661a5ccdb40838b1c05b645ae5479a3a6f851bf61a6309083f8c4fa4d014",
    "local-064": "7d94f5832b340b9fd37aaec5ff92238f6bab390b6313ec934b1c8eaf694561ba",
    "local-065": "a2442429641d3904bd99d957b755c0e4b1e30e180120cd11c522a06ff913ccf3",
    "local-066": "a1f1fa78da72044a15400617f83836f6a5da732836d34673ef5330edf7960f1c",
    "local-067": "862e59b1939d9b92640af2c050df6469e24f76979cdee88886e2175dacd26abb",
    "local-068": "378aa7a73d069a1932970189aa887ff10e9c328e0aa869d334de450e762549e4",
    "local-069": "1f67ec1e45cf5f982d267d9c379e75e5d5cf4f6001d96138d9d1bf111637511e",
    "local-071": "d8d873146008deb45983dee9dc754752099c5e9413a3894402b56709b2e369f5",
    "local-073": "1c8e2f2577cb984c69d163892ca87340e96864dce84bad08d29099be27485436",
    "initial-1-01": "068ca6827b27cd68120f0cbe72d576f0306c89e60d90e2b3f195f3d9b80ea655",
    "initial-4-01": "2437923333bd8924dcad033323fe31f781edcaac8e6f473d4a725a4c6e969080",
    "astra-technical-02": "15221c13cdbc6494185d662bf303ed89841cfa3d48650d14ef32918c5eacfb63",
    "gemini-technical-01": "7c0c7df075910c9a589d854d76d08be9b22de6fccfe66a7053d3b62fedee66e6"
  },
  "excluded": "Provider envelopes, hidden reasoning, credentials and private operational ledgers. External cached reference full texts are identified, not redistributed.",
  "note": "Exporter scrubs local paths/operational metadata in public copies. This inventory binds original assessment hashes; source-record.json binds manuscript identity."
}