{
  "origin": "Original completed model assessment with transport metadata and machine paths removed; not a coordinator verdict.",
  "assessment": {
    "paper_info": {
      "title": "Cubulating random quotients of hyperbolic cubulated groups",
      "total_elements": 57,
      "elements_with_proofs": 22,
      "counting_convention": "The total counts distinct theorem-environment elements, including definitions, conventions, remarks, and open problems. The two named restatements of earlier theorems are not counted again. The proof count counts results accompanied by an explicit proof environment, counting the shared sketch for the two generalized propositions separately. Four enumerated subclaims inside Proposition 6.3 are assessed with that proposition rather than counted separately."
    },
    "historical_audit": {
      "cutoff_date": "2023-04-24",
      "basis": "journal_received",
      "date_evidence": "Author-hosted journal PDF, first page (printed p.622): Received by the editors April 24, 2023; DOI 10.1090/btran/180; SHA256 e267fab251e659d2cf15938beb21386cd984a1064e3abd9d3064db2f128b8629",
      "reference_inspection": "No external reference was inspected. Publication information below comes from the supplied bibliography, not an independent bibliographic or theorem audit.",
      "statement_scope": "Imported-result descriptions identify the statements needed by the manuscript. They do not certify that the cited source has precisely those hypotheses or conclusions.",
      "chronology_findings": [
        "The bibliography identifies most principal inputs as publications before 2023.",
        "The supplied record does not establish that the needed version of HaglundSemiSimple was available by April 24, 2023. The bibliography gives only a 2023 journal publication. A dated earlier version containing the axis theorem is required.",
        "The April 2023 identifier for CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum does not establish availability on or before April 24. Its submission date and relevant version remain unresolved.",
        "CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes is identified as an October 2023 preprint and is inadmissible as an original proof input at this cutoff.",
        "BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations is listed as in preparation. Its availability and contents at the cutoff are unresolved, and it is not used to justify the main results."
      ],
      "knowledge_limit": "Model knowledge cannot be restricted retrospectively with certainty. This assessment therefore does not use remembered later results to discharge the manuscript's proof obligations; imported results are supported only by the supplied dated evidence and remain uninspected."
    },
    "verification_results": [
      {
        "label": "Theorem 1.1",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_1_1",
        "source_label": "Thm:main",
        "argument_gist": "Replace the cubulation by a subdivided essential core, thicken sampled axes to compact convex quasi-circles, use probabilistic bounds to obtain cubical C'(1/20), and apply the hyperbolicity and cubulation criteria. Primitivity removes torsion stabilizers.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:LoosenUp",
            "evidence": "Define $J = J(\\widetilde X)$ as in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
            "evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
            "evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
            "evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:C'20Proper",
            "evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:Primitive",
            "evidence": "\\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $w_i$ is  primitive."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "CapraceSageev2011",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Proposition 3.5, used to replace the action by an essential convex core without changing the growth exponents or the relevant coarse geometry.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The original proper cocompact cubical action must satisfy the hypotheses of the essential-core proposition.",
              "The selected core must be invariant, convex, and cocompact.",
              "Its essential hyperplane stabilizers must correspond to those used in the definition of a."
            ],
            "locator": "Proposition 3.5",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2011",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 21(4):851--891, 2011.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "2011 journal article",
            "evidence": "Second, if some hyperplane of $X$ is inessential, we replace $X$ by its essential core, as in \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}, which has the same growth exponents $a$ and $b$."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The cone-piece input depends on the unproved cyclic-disjointness assertion in Lemma 4.11 and the incomplete bounded-data argument in Lemma 4.13. These are central proof obligations, not merely missing citations.",
          "The wall-piece proof is invalid as written when a=0, an explicitly important case of the theorem.",
          "The deterministic cubulation criterion has an omitted separation verification and uninspected imported properness/cocompactness inputs.",
          "The axis theorem used through Convention 4.3 has unresolved pre-cutoff version evidence.",
          "The phrase 'for any set' should explicitly mean a uniformly sampled tuple or set, not a simultaneous assertion about every set of short conjugacy classes."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The final assembly and the constants are correct conditional on the preceding inputs: alpha/(alpha+2) at alpha=1/20 equals 1/41. The supplied argument nevertheless does not complete those inputs. No counterexample to the intended nonelementary random-quotient theorem is established by this review."
      },
      {
        "label": "Corollary 1.2",
        "element_type": "corollary",
        "element_id": "corollary_1_2",
        "source_label": "Cor:LowDensity",
        "argument_gist": "Combine the main theorem with strict growth separation between the ambient group and essential hyperplane stabilizers.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:main",
            "evidence": "Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary:"
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
            "evidence": "See  \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "This is a correct conditional consequence, but it inherits the unresolved proof obligations of Theorem 1.1."
        ],
        "reasoning": "For a nonelementary hyperbolic cubulation, essential hyperplane stabilizers are quasiconvex and infinite index. Once strict growth separation and Theorem 1.1 are established in the relevant geodesic metric, a positive admissible density follows."
      },
      {
        "label": "Theorem 1.3",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_1_3",
        "source_label": "Thm:OtherSample",
        "argument_gist": "Establish loose small cancellation in the sampling space Upsilon, transfer it to cubical small cancellation with multiplicative loss lambda, and apply the same cubulation argument as in Theorem 1.1.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
            "evidence": "\\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon} implies that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the presentation  $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ and any choice of basepoint and axes."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:QITranslation",
            "evidence": "Now, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} implies that  with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha)$ with $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
            "evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:Primitive",
            "evidence": "Finally, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $g_i$ is  primitive."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:C'20Proper",
            "evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The theorem inherits the central cone-piece counting gap through Propositions 5.4 and 5.5.",
          "The application of Proposition 5.7 omits verification of its lower bound on all sampled translation lengths. Lemma 4.16 has the needed analogue, but it must be invoked.",
          "Proposition 5.7 contains a definite additive-constant arithmetic error.",
          "The final cubulation and axis inputs have the same verification and chronology limitations as Theorem 1.1."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The density conversion is algebraically correct: substituting alpha=1/20 into b(alpha/lambda)/(alpha/lambda+2) gives b/(40lambda+1). The omitted long-relator condition is readily addressed, but it does not repair the earlier counting argument."
      },
      {
        "label": "Corollary 1.4",
        "element_type": "corollary",
        "element_id": "corollary_1_4",
        "source_label": "Cor:H2Action",
        "argument_gist": "Use b=1 and a=0 for a pentagonally tiled closed hyperbolic surface, together with the optimal metric comparison, in Theorem 1.3.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:OtherSample",
            "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
            "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "Huber",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "The curvature-minus-one compact hyperbolic surface growth exponent is 1.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The surface group is a cocompact lattice in Isom(H^2).",
              "Lengths are measured in the curvature-minus-one hyperbolic metric."
            ],
            "locator": "No theorem number supplied",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "1959",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Math. Ann.}, 138:1--26, 1959.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "1959 journal article",
            "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The statement does not assume S is closed or compact, or that its pentagonal tiling is finite. Those conditions are needed for the asserted application of Theorem 1.3 and b=1. Arbitrary noncompact or infinite-type tiled surfaces are not covered, and the stated uniform sample can even fail to be a finite set.",
          "For closed surfaces, the corollary still inherits Theorem 1.3 and the unverified pictorial lower-bound argument in Proposition 6.3."
        ],
        "reasoning": "With the closed-surface hypothesis added and the prerequisite results established, the numerical threshold follows: 40lambda+1 is approximately 63.508, so 1/63.51 is strictly below the required threshold."
      },
      {
        "label": "Definition 2.2: growth assertion",
        "element_type": "definition",
        "element_id": "definition_2_2",
        "source_label": "Def:Growth",
        "argument_gist": "Define an orbit-counting growth exponent and assert that finite generation, properness, and cocompactness bound the counting function exponentially.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The assertion that the orbit growth is at most exponential under the stated metric-space hypotheses is false. A geodesic or suitable quasi-geodesic assumption is missing."
        ],
        "reasoning": "A self-contained counterexample is G=F_3 acting on itself with d(x,y)=sqrt(|x^{-1}y|), where word length uses the standard free basis. This is a proper left-invariant metric, and the quotient is a point. Its radius-n ball is a word ball of radius floor(n^2), so its cardinality grows like 5^(n^2), not exponentially in n. This defect does not affect the intended applications to geodesic spaces."
      },
      {
        "label": "Theorem 2.3",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_2_3",
        "source_label": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
        "argument_gist": "Import strict exponential growth separation for infinite-index quasiconvex subgroups.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "DahmaniFuterWise",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, invoked for existence of growth exponents and strict growth separation of an infinite-index quasiconvex subgroup.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "G is a nonelementary hyperbolic group.",
              "H is quasiconvex and infinite index.",
              "The ambient action satisfies the source theorem's metric-space hypotheses; those hypotheses must be checked rather than replaced by arbitrary proper cocompact metric actions."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 1.1",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2019",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc.}, 167(3):505--530, 2019.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "2019 journal article",
            "evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}."
          },
          {
            "bibliography_key": "MYJ",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Corollary 2.8, cited as an independent source of the same growth-separation conclusion.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The group, subgroup, and ambient metric action satisfy the exact source hypotheses.",
              "In particular, the source must justify finite exponential growth in the chosen metric."
            ],
            "locator": "Corollary 2.8",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2020",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Groups Geom. Dyn.}, 14(2):369--411, 2020.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "2020 journal article",
            "evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "DahmaniFuterWise",
            "role": "background",
            "locator": "Theorem 1.3",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "evidence": "See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ is a CAT(0) cube complex and $H$ is a hyperplane stabilizer."
          }
        ],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "As stated for an arbitrary metric space, the theorem is false. A suitable ambient geodesic or quasi-geodesic hypothesis is missing.",
          "The exact hypotheses of the two cited results have not been inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "In the metric counterexample from Definition 2.2, take H=F_2 as a proper free factor of F_3. Both logarithmic growth quotients tend to infinity, since the ball counts grow like 3^(n^2) and 5^(n^2), respectively. Thus finite exponents do not exist, and allowing extended exponents does not give a strict inequality. The intended geodesic-space application may be correct."
      },
      {
        "label": "Theorem 2.4",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_2_4",
        "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
        "argument_gist": "Combine pure exponential orbit growth with exponential lower and upper bounds for primitive conjugacy classes.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "Coornaert93",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 7.12, used for A exp(bn) <= f(n) <= B exp(bn).",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "A nonelementary group acts properly and cocompactly on a hyperbolic space satisfying the source's geometric hypotheses.",
              "The growth exponent is computed in that same orbit metric."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 7.12",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "1993",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Pacific J. Math.}, 159(2):241--270, 1993.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "1993 journal article",
            "evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}."
          },
          {
            "bibliography_key": "CoornaertKnieper2002",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, used for the primitive conjugacy-class bounds A exp(bn)/n <= p_n <= B exp(bn).",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The exact source hypotheses must cover the group action and the manuscript's notion of primitive conjugacy class.",
              "The length convention must agree with translation length, or differ from it by a uniformly bounded amount."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 1.1",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2002",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 12(3):464--478, 2002.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "2002 journal article",
            "evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The proof consists entirely of uninspected external inputs.",
          "The primitive-class formulation, treatment of torsion, ambient-space hypotheses, and translation-length convention require comparison with the cited versions."
        ],
        "reasoning": "There is no internal deduction to check beyond combining the two inputs and adjusting common constants. Bibliographic dates precede the cutoff, but that does not verify the quoted theorems."
      },
      {
        "label": "Remark 2.5",
        "element_type": "remark",
        "element_id": "remark_2_5",
        "source_label": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
        "argument_gist": "Replace counting one vertex orbit by counting all vertex orbits using cocompactness.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper constant $B$) on the number of vertices in a metric ball in $\\Upsilon$, where the vertices being counted are not required to be in the $G$--orbit of the basepoint $x$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "For arbitrary cell complexes, cocompactness alone does not explicitly supply local finiteness or finitely many vertex orbits. State the needed finiteness assumption."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The assertion is valid for the locally finite universal covers of compact cube complexes used in Section 4: finitely many vertex orbits give a finite sum of shifted orbit-counting bounds."
      },
      {
        "label": "Remark 2.6",
        "element_type": "remark",
        "element_id": "remark_2_6",
        "source_label": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
        "argument_gist": "A proper power of length at most n has a root of length at most n/2, so proper powers have exponentially smaller conjugacy growth.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}  implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The displayed sum over root lengths does not explicitly count the possible power exponents.",
          "The argument uses exact scaling of lengths of powers and a positive lower bound on primitive translation lengths; these hold in the later axis setting but are not stated here.",
          "The upper bound for all conjugacy classes, used subsequently, should be recorded explicitly rather than inferred from the primitive-class bound without discussing powers."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The exponential negligibility conclusion is sound in the intended torsion-free axis setting. New repair, separate from the supplied proof: if the shortest nontrivial translation length is epsilon>0, sum the primitive-class bound over power exponents 2 <= m <= n/epsilon. Each summand is at most B exp(bn/2), giving O(n exp(bn/2)); division by A exp(bn)/n gives O(n^2 exp(-bn/2))."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 3.3",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_3_3",
        "source_label": "Lem:1/12 lift",
        "argument_gist": "Import the embedding of relator cones in the universal cover under cubical C'(1/12).",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorems 3.32 and 4.1, invoked to embed every cone Y_i in the universal cover of X* under C'(1/12).",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "X* is a cubical presentation by local isometries of nonpositively curved cube complexes.",
              "The presentation satisfies the source's C'(1/12) condition, including its conventions for pieces and symmetries."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorems 3.32 and 4.1",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Annals of Mathematics Studies 209, 2021",
            "evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{Lem:1/12 lift}"
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "This is an uninspected imported result; source piece conventions and any symmetry hypotheses need checking."
        ],
        "reasoning": "No internal proof is supplied. Its appearance before the wallspace construction does not by itself make it an additional dependency of every later claim."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 3.4",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_3_4",
        "source_label": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
        "argument_gist": "Import preservation of hyperbolicity for compact cubical C'(1/14) presentations.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Lemma 3.70 and Theorem 4.7, used to deduce hyperbolicity of pi_1 X*.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "pi_1 X is hyperbolic.",
              "X* is compact.",
              "X* satisfies cubical C'(1/14) with the source's piece conventions."
            ],
            "locator": "Lemma 3.70 and Theorem 4.7",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Annals of Mathematics Studies 209, 2021",
            "evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{lem:1/14 hyperbolic}"
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The cited external theorem and its exact hypotheses were not inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The later applications do check compactness, hyperbolicity of the original group, and a stronger small-cancellation constant, conditional on their preceding arguments."
      },
      {
        "label": "Theorem 3.5",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_3_5",
        "source_label": "Thm:C'20Proper",
        "argument_gist": "Pair antipodal hyperplanes in each quasi-circle to form walls, prove B(8), pieceful convexity, and the separation criterion, then use the imported cubulation and torsion theorems.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:cubulating X star",
            "evidence": "We have thus verified that \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} applies, hence $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts with torsion stabilizers"
          },
          {
            "source_label": "rem:pieceful convexity",
            "evidence": "Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "HaglundSemiSimple",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "After cubical subdivision, the generator of the relevant cyclic stabilizer has an invariant combinatorial geodesic axis.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The isometry acts on the relevant CAT(0) cube complex.",
              "The subdivision removes the obstruction addressed by the source's axis theorem.",
              "The resulting axis lies in the invariant convex subcomplex under consideration."
            ],
            "locator": "No theorem number supplied",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": null,
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Ann. Math. Qu\\'{e}.}, 47(2):249--261, 2023.",
            "date_basis": "Only a 2023 journal year is supplied; availability by April 24 is unresolved",
            "version": "2023 journal article; earlier applicable version not documented",
            "evidence": "Since we have subdivided $X$ at least once, $g$ stabilizes a geodesic axis $\\widetilde{v_i} \\subset \\widetilde{Y_i}$, by \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}."
          },
          {
            "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 4.2 and Remark 4.3, used to place every torsion element in a relator automorphism group.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The presentation satisfies the small-cancellation and symmetry hypotheses of the torsion theorem.",
              "The relator automorphism groups are identified with the relevant cyclic extensions."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 4.2 and Remark 4.3",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Annals of Mathematics Studies 209, 2021",
            "evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 4.2 and Rem 4.3]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, we know that when $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$,\nany torsion element in  $\\pi_1X^*$ lies in $\\Aut(Y_i \\rightarrow X)$ for some lift $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "In checking Hypothesis 3.8(4), the proof establishes that U_2 is not 2-proximate to either endpoint, but does not establish the other required conclusion: U_2 separates p and q.",
          "The chosen u_2 is merely a hyperplane whose carrier contains the midpoint. That does not, by itself, say that the geodesic crosses u_2.",
          "The transition from torsion stabilizers to a proper action, and the assertion of cocompactness from compactness of X, require precise justification from the external cubulation theorem or an additional argument. Torsion stabilizers alone do not logically imply properness.",
          "Availability of the imported axis theorem at the cutoff is unresolved.",
          "The final sentence of the theorem states freeness on the universal cover of X*, whereas the needed conclusion is freeness on the dual CAT(0) cube complex."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The displayed quantitative estimates are otherwise consistent: alpha<1/20 leaves room for the required midpoint distance inequalities after subdivision. A plausible repair of the separation step would choose a hyperplane dual to an edge of kappa near its midpoint and prove that its antipodal partner is not crossed, but that argument is not supplied here. The theorem is not disproved by the omission."
      },
      {
        "label": "Remark 3.7",
        "element_type": "remark",
        "element_id": "remark_3_7",
        "source_label": "rem:pieceful convexity",
        "argument_gist": "Import a sufficient separation condition on distinct lifts of a carrier to obtain pieceful convexity.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Remark 5.43: if distinct translates of a hyperplane carrier are farther apart than the maximal piece diameter, the hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The hyperplane and its carrier satisfy the source's embedding and cubical-presentation assumptions.",
              "M bounds every piece diameter in the cone.",
              "Every distinct carrier translate has distance greater than M."
            ],
            "locator": "Remark 5.43",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Annals of Mathematics Studies 209, 2021",
            "evidence": "\\begin{rem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Rem~5.43]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{rem:pieceful convexity}"
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The imported criterion was not inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "Theorem 3.5 gives the separation estimate required by this restated criterion. Whether the restatement includes all original hypotheses remains an external verification task."
      },
      {
        "label": "Theorem 3.8",
        "element_type": "theorem",
        "element_id": "theorem_3_8",
        "source_label": "Thm:cubulating X star",
        "argument_gist": "Restate the external properness machinery in terms of small cancellation, pieceful convexity, wall cutting, and an endpoint separation condition.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 5.44, combined with Lemma 3.70 and Corollary 5.45, as restated in the four numbered hypotheses of Theorem 3.8, yielding torsion cell stabilizers on the dual cube complex.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "C'(1/14) and B(6).",
              "Every cone hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
              "Every infinite-order cone automorphism is cut by a cone wall.",
              "The full separation condition in Hypothesis (4), including that the new wall separates p and q.",
              "Any additional source hypotheses needed for the claimed simplification."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 5.44; Lemma 3.70; Corollary 5.45",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Annals of Mathematics Studies 209, 2021",
            "evidence": "The following is a simplified restatement of \\cite[Thm~5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, which also incorporates\n \\cite[Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The equivalence of the simplified hypotheses to the original theorem's assumptions has not been checked.",
          "The stated conclusion only mentions torsion stabilizers; the additional properness and cocompactness used in Theorem 3.5 must be accounted for explicitly."
        ],
        "reasoning": "This is an imported criterion rather than an internally proved theorem. It is one of the principal external bottlenecks."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.2",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_2",
        "source_label": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
        "argument_gist": "At a point far from the line, find a hyperplane crossing an initial cube at a definite angle; hyperbolicity forces that hyperplane to separate the point from the line.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "SageevWiseCores",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Remark 3.2, used for a dimension-dependent positive angle between a shortest CAT(0) segment and a hyperplane in its initial cube.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "A finite-dimensional CAT(0) cube complex.",
              "The segment and initial cube satisfy the geometric setup of the remark.",
              "The angle bound is uniform in the dimension."
            ],
            "locator": "Remark 3.2",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2015",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 143(7):2731--2741, 2015.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "2015 journal article",
            "evidence": "Sageev and Wise have observed  \\cite[Remark~3.2]{SageevWiseCores} that the first cube met by $s$ contains a midcube of  a hyperplane $H$ that intersects $s$ at an angle bounded away from $0$."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The proof switches to CAT(0) geodesics and angle arguments without explicitly reconciling them with the combinatorial geodesics used for relators.",
          "The claimed contradiction with thinness is only sketched; the uniform distance bound should be derived from the two angle bounds.",
          "The external angle observation was not inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The mechanism is plausible and standard in this setting, but the proof should specify the metric on the line and the uniform comparison needed to obtain the stated combinatorial hull bound. No counterexample to the lemma is demonstrated."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.5",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_5",
        "source_label": "Lem:LoosenUp",
        "argument_gist": "Project endpoints of a large actual piece to nearby axes and extend along an axis to recover the lost additive length.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ \nthat are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The statement allows any bi-infinite geodesic in a quasi-circle, whereas the thickness lemma directly concerns the geodesic whose hull defines that quasi-circle. Uniformly replacing the defining axis needs an additional fellow-traveling observation and possibly an enlarged K.",
          "The cone-piece conclusion needs the corresponding axes to satisfy the no-common-boundary-endpoint requirement in Definition 4.4. This is not verified in the proof.",
          "Maximal segments need not have vertex endpoints or integer looseness exactly as written; bounded rounding should be stated."
        ],
        "reasoning": "For distinct noncommensurable axes and a uniform thickness bound, the endpoint calculation is correct: a d-length overlap gives a segment of length at least d-2K, and extension by K at each end produces length at least d with 3K-close endpoints."
      },
      {
        "label": "Remark 4.6",
        "element_type": "remark",
        "element_id": "remark_4_6",
        "source_label": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
        "argument_gist": "Explain that loose wall-pieces control all carrier intersections, not only intersections with hyperplanes disjoint from the relator.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:LoosenUp",
            "evidence": "Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "valid",
        "issues": [],
        "reasoning": "This accurately distinguishes the two definitions and identifies the stronger control needed for the carrier-diameter hypothesis of Theorem 3.5."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 4.7",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_4_7",
        "source_label": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
        "argument_gist": "Encode a bad relator as a long segment near a hyperplane followed by an unrestricted segment, compare exponential counts, and union-bound over sampled relators.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "Meanwhile, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded above by $B'e^{a|s|}$, for some constant $B'$ depending on $J$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The final constant B/[A(1-exp(-a))] is undefined when a=0. This includes cyclic hyperplane stabilizers, one of the paper's principal examples.",
          "The cited ambient-group growth theorem does not directly establish the asserted hyperplane-neighborhood count at its exact exponent a. Elementary stabilizers require separate counting, and existence of a growth exponent alone is insufficient for a pure exponential upper bound.",
          "The normalization of starting points and the count over possible segment lengths are compressed into the factor n without a complete encoding argument.",
          "The asserted notation C=C(J,X) suppresses possible dependence on alpha."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The exponential balance c-alpha(b-a)<0 is correct. New repair for the demonstrated denominator error, separate from the supplied proof: retain the preceding denominator 1-exp(-(a alpha+b(1-alpha))). It is positive even when a=0 because b>0 and alpha<1. This does not itself verify the earlier counting bound."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.9",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_9",
        "source_label": "Lem:ThinQuad",
        "argument_gist": "Apply thinness of geodesic quadrilaterals and the bounded lengths of the two connecting sides.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "valid",
        "issues": [],
        "reasoning": "A geodesic quadrilateral is 2delta-thin. A point close to a short connecting side is then within J+2delta of the opposite long side. The proof establishes exactly the claimed bound."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.10",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_10",
        "source_label": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
        "argument_gist": "Orientation reversal approximately swaps overlap endpoints; consequently h^2 moves an endpoint only boundedly, forcing the overlap close to an axis and hence bounded.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:ThinQuad",
            "evidence": "Furthermore, as in \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad},"
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Conv:NiceX",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Conv:NiceX},\n$h$ has an invariant geodesic axis $\\widetilde v$ in \n$\\widetilde X$, hence\n $\\stabletrans{h} \\geq 1$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The inference that y is 2delta-close to the opposite long side merely from dist(y,q)>J is not justified; excluding closeness to the short side requires room for the additional 2delta.",
          "The uniform quasi-geodesic constants for the h^2-orbits should be derived explicitly from bounded step length and a uniform positive stable-length lower bound.",
          "After subdivisions retaining the original metric, the lower bound should be stated in the retained metric rather than assumed to be exactly 1."
        ],
        "reasoning": "These are constant-control omissions rather than a demonstrated failure of the bounded-overlap conclusion. Enlarging the constants and using the uniform positive translation-length lower bound available in the intended compact cubical action plausibly repairs the argument."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.11",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_11",
        "source_label": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
        "argument_gist": "Encode a second relator using its fellow-traveling segment and a free remainder; for self-pieces, try to remove two disjoint occurrences of the same information.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:ThinQuad",
            "evidence": "Furthermore, by \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, every point of $s'$ lies within distance $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$ of some point of $s$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the number of such conjugacy classes satisfies"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The self-piece proof asserts that s and v' project to disjoint portions of the closed geodesic because their chosen lifts have small overlap. This is false without controlling overlap modulo the period of w.",
          "Replacing h by h g^N, where g translates the axis of w, leaves h times the axis unchanged but shifts h^{-1}s' by an arbitrary number of periods. The overlap in Definition 4.8 can therefore be made empty without changing either projected occurrence. Small overlap of those chosen lifts does not imply projected disjointness.",
          "Consequently, the asserted fundamental domain y_1 v' y_2 s and the count obtained by subtracting twice the piece length are not established.",
          "In the separate-sample argument, the warm-up linear bound cannot be absorbed uniformly into the claimed exponential bound for unrestricted d>ell. The later applications only require d<=ell/3, but the lemma states a broader range.",
          "Equation (Eqn:InitialCountS) uses |w| where the remainder-length estimate requires |w'|. The final bound using ell can be recovered, but the intermediate inequality is incorrect as written."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The cyclic-disjointness problem is a demonstrated error in the supplied reasoning, not just an uninspected standard fact. A normalization of h modulo the relator period, together with a separate treatment of wrapping and long overlaps, is required before this counting argument is valid. The intended probability estimate is not disproved here."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.12",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_12",
        "source_label": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
        "argument_gist": "Bound cancellation at the joins of a periodic path and apply a local-to-global quasi-geodesic principle.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorem 4, invoked as a local-to-global principle converting uniformly controlled local quasi-geodesics into global quasi-geodesics.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The ambient geodesic space is delta-hyperbolic.",
              "The periodic path has suitable local quasi-geodesic constants on a scale exceeding the local-to-global threshold.",
              "The cited theorem must apply in this generality, not only to the geometric setting of its original formulation."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorem 4",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "1984",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock {\\em Geom. Dedicata}, 16(2):123--148, 1984.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "1984 journal article",
            "evidence": "Now,  apply a ``local to global'' principle for quasi-geodesics. See e.g.\\ Cannon~\\cite[Thm 4]{cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The proof does not state the local quasi-geodesic constants or verify the required local scale.",
          "The finite-possibilities argument for short y requires normalization modulo the cocompact action and combinatorial endpoints.",
          "The general hyperbolic-space scope of the cited theorem has not been inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "This is a plausible bounded-cancellation lemma in the intended torsion-free cubical setting, but the supplied proof is a sketch rather than a complete quantitative derivation."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.13",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_13",
        "source_label": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
        "argument_gist": "Discard short relators and small overlaps, use orientation preservation for large overlaps, and encode a long repeated portion through uniformly fellow-traveling periodic quasi-geodesics.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with probability at most $M_2 \\ell^2  e^{-b d}$"
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, $h$ preserves the orientation on $s$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
            "evidence": "Thus, in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:InfiniteWord}, we  conclude that  $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$ is an $\\eta$--quasigeodesic  for some $\\eta  = \\eta( \\delta, J) >0$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The small-overlap branch imports the invalid projected-disjointness argument from Lemma 4.11.",
          "In Case 1, the statement that all of y_2 y_3 is determined by y_1 and universally bounded data is not established by fellow-traveling alone. A complete finite encoding must specify the endpoint or length choices and bound the number of possibilities.",
          "Case 2 replaces J by J+2delta but retains R(J,delta). The large-overlap argument needs its threshold checked for the enlarged looseness constant.",
          "The conclusion combines five types of events by taking the maximum of their constants. A union bound requires their sum, unless disjointness and an additional argument are supplied.",
          "There are minor path-order and exponent typographical inconsistencies, including the use of (x_1 y_1)^infinity where the constructed path is y_1 x_1."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The geometric periodicity mechanism is credible, but the exponentially sharp counting estimate is not proved by the supplied sketch. New repair for the last constant error only: taking M=sum_j M_j bounds the union of the five events. That elementary correction does not close the encoding and cyclic-overlap gaps."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 4.14",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_4_14",
        "source_label": "Prop:FewConePieces",
        "argument_gist": "Absorb the polynomial factor M ell^2 into an arbitrarily small loss in the exponential decay exponent.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
            "evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
            "evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The proposition inherits the uncompleted counting estimates of Lemmas 4.11 and 4.13."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The argument of this proposition is algebraically correct conditional on those estimates: d>log(M ell^2)/(b(1-phi)) gives M ell^2 exp(-bd)<exp(-b phi d)."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.15",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_15",
        "source_label": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
        "argument_gist": "Apply the pairwise piece estimate to k^2 pairs and choose phi so that the exponential union bound decays.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:FewConePieces",
            "evidence": "When $\\ell$ is sufficiently large,  \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} says that  for every pair $(i,j)$, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ between $w_i$ and $w_j$ is less than $e^{-bd\\phi}$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The result inherits Proposition 4.14's unresolved probabilistic input.",
          "The proof invokes the preceding proposition for arbitrary d>=2q ell, although that proposition only treats d<=ell/3. It suffices to apply it at d=2q ell; this should be stated."
        ],
        "reasoning": "At d=2q ell, the condition q<=1/6 gives the required upper range, and the union-bound exponent is strictly negative. Thus the local argument is valid after this minor range clarification, conditional on Proposition 4.14."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.16",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_16",
        "source_label": "Lem:Systole",
        "argument_gist": "Short conjugacy classes are exponentially sparse, and the allowed number of samples does not overcome that decay.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that\n$|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The quoted upper bound is stated for primitive classes, while the numerator counts all classes. The all-class upper bound should first be deduced explicitly, with a changed constant, using the proper-power estimate."
        ],
        "reasoning": "Once that bookkeeping is supplied, the proof is correct: the failure probability is bounded by a polynomial times exp((c-bq)ell), which tends to zero exponentially."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 4.17",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_4_17",
        "source_label": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
        "argument_gist": "Balance the absolute piece bound and the shortest-relator bound using q=alpha/(alpha+2).",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
            "evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:Systole",
            "evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The proposition inherits the central cone-piece counting gap through Lemma 4.15."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The balancing calculation is correct: alpha<=2/5 implies q<=1/6, and 2q/(1-q)=alpha. No additional error appears in this final conversion."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 4.18",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_4_18",
        "source_label": "Lem:Primitive",
        "argument_gist": "Union-bound the exponentially small probability of sampling a proper power.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Rem:NonPrimitive}, the probability that $[g_i]$ is non-primitive is bounded above by"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The proof depends on correcting the power-counting and metric qualifications in Remark 2.6."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The union bound itself is correct. An O(ell^2 exp(-b ell/2)) single-sample bound gives exponential convergence whenever c<b/2."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 5.4",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_5_4",
        "source_label": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
        "argument_gist": "Repeat the cone-piece counting in Upsilon, replacing vertex endpoints by nearby orbit points and absorbing bounded length errors.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
            "evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "evidence": "we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfectly well to the $G$--action on $\\Upsilon$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The generalization inherits the unresolved cyclic-overlap and encoding problems of Proposition 4.17.",
          "The statement omits the range 0<alpha<=2/5 present in Proposition 4.17. The sketch does not justify the larger asserted range.",
          "Orbit-point perturbations need a finite-to-one encoding argument, including possible finite point stabilizers, rather than only the assertion that lengths change boundedly."
        ],
        "reasoning": "Bounded endpoint perturbations preserve exponential rates in principle, and the main application uses a small alpha within the original range. They do not repair the missing combinatorial encoding."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 5.5",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_5_5",
        "source_label": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
        "argument_gist": "Repeat the wall-piece argument for neighborhoods of quasiconvex subgroup orbits in the general sampling space.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
            "evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The sketch must repair the a=0 counting treatment inherited from Proposition 4.7.",
          "An upper bound on growth exponents alone does not give an upper bound C exp(an) at the exact exponent. The strict density inequality permits a small exponent slack, but that argument is not supplied.",
          "The finite encoding after moving endpoints to orbit points should be stated."
        ],
        "reasoning": "Unlike Proposition 4.7, this proposition only asserts overwhelming probability, not an exact polynomial-exponential bound. The strict inequality allows small losses in the subgroup exponent, so the identified growth-bound problem is likely repairable without altering the stated density."
      },
      {
        "label": "Corollary 5.6",
        "element_type": "corollary",
        "element_id": "corollary_5_6",
        "source_label": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
        "argument_gist": "Intersect the high-probability cone-piece and wall-piece events.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
            "evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:"
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
            "evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "major_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The logical combination is correct, but the corollary inherits Proposition 5.4's unresolved proof and omitted alpha-range qualification."
        ],
        "reasoning": "A union bound on the two failure events is sufficient; no independence is needed."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 5.7",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_5_7",
        "source_label": "Prop:QITranslation",
        "argument_gist": "A long cubical overlap maps to fellow-traveling axes or a quasiconvex subgroup orbit in Upsilon. Trim bounded end regions, apply small cancellation there, and absorb additive errors using the strict gap between lambda and barred lambda.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in  \\widetilde w_i$ and $x_j, y_j \\in \\widetilde w_j$ that are $K$--close to $x$ and $y$, respectively."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
            "evidence": "Since $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha / \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, p, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$"
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "In the wall-piece calculation, -2(eta+lambda_2(K+1)+epsilon+psi+2delta)-2eta is incorrectly rewritten as -2(2eta+lambda_2(K+1)+epsilon+psi+delta). The correct final delta term inside the parentheses is 2delta.",
          "The stated dependence of M suppresses the quasi-isometry's additive constant epsilon and the separate distortion constants, although the proof uses them.",
          "The proof assumes large finite diameters are attained and does not explicitly address unbounded intersections. This can be handled by choosing arbitrarily distant pairs, but should be said.",
          "The cone-piece argument should verify the no-common-endpoint condition needed to invoke the loose-piece definition.",
          "Strict trimming inequalities need a small extra margin to exclude the adjacent short sides of a thin quadrilateral."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The central multiplicative argument is sound: d is bounded by (lambda/barred lambda) alpha systole plus a uniform additive constant, and lambda/barred lambda<1 absorbs that constant for long relators. New repair for the arithmetic error: replace the affected delta terms by 2delta and enlarge M accordingly. This changes no density constant."
      },
      {
        "label": "Remark 5.8",
        "element_type": "remark",
        "element_id": "remark_5_8",
        "source_label": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
        "argument_gist": "Propose replacing worst-case quasi-isometry distortion by mean distortion for typical relators and, conjecturally, typical pieces.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:QITranslation",
            "evidence": "We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Equation (1.1), Theorem 1.2, and Theorem 4.23, used respectively for existence of mean distortion and a large-deviation typicality statement in the Cayley-graph setting.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The pair of metrics lies in the metric class covered by the cited version.",
              "The large-deviation statement applies to the manuscript's sampling of conjugacy classes, or a conversion from element sampling is supplied."
            ],
            "locator": "Equation (1.1); Theorem 1.2; Theorem 4.23",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2021-04",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock arXiv:2104.13451, 2021.",
            "date_basis": "Year and month encoded in the supplied arXiv citation; relevant version not verified",
            "version": "Unspecified version of arXiv:2104.13451",
            "evidence": "See~\\cite[Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve} for a proof that the limit exists."
          },
          {
            "bibliography_key": "CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "A claimed deduction from Equation (5.2) establishing typicality for conjugacy classes in general Upsilon.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The needed equation and deduction were available in a version on or before April 24, 2023.",
              "The result covers both metrics and the conjugacy-class sampling measure used here."
            ],
            "locator": "Equation (5.2)",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": null,
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock arXiv:2304.13209, 2023.",
            "date_basis": "Only April 2023 is established by the supplied citation; day and applicable version unresolved",
            "version": "Unspecified version of arXiv:2304.13209",
            "evidence": "For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us\n that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}."
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
            "role": "excluded",
            "locator": "Theorem 1.4",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2023-10",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock arXiv:2310.10595, 2023.",
            "date_basis": "October 2023 encoded in the supplied arXiv citation",
            "version": "Unspecified October 2023 preprint version",
            "exclusion_basis": "Postdates the recorded cutoff",
            "evidence": "If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}."
          }
        ],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "One cited typicality input is explicitly post-cutoff and another has unresolved availability at the cutoff.",
          "The claimed conversion from the cited results to uniform conjugacy-class sampling is not supplied.",
          "The average of displacement ratios includes the identity term 0/0; it should omit that finite exceptional set.",
          "The extension from typical relators to typical pieces is explicitly open and must not be treated as an established improvement."
        ],
        "reasoning": "This remark is not needed for either main theorem. Its proposed cancellation of mean distortion is a conditional strategy, not an existing proof of a stronger density statement."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 6.1",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_6_1",
        "source_label": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
        "argument_gist": "Take the ratio d/c of the sharp upper and lower multiplicative metric-comparison constants.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
            "evidence": "Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}."
          },
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
            "evidence": "Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The proposition depends on the pictorial lower-bound and sharpness arguments of Proposition 6.3, which cannot be fully checked from the supplied text without the figure contents."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The ratio formula follows correctly from the two-sided metric comparison. The numerical value is consistent with the displayed elementary formulas."
      },
      {
        "label": "Lemma 6.2",
        "element_type": "lemma",
        "element_id": "lemma_6_2",
        "source_label": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
        "argument_gist": "Use Lambert quadrilateral identities, the hyperbolic cosine rule, and a two-right-angle quadrilateral formula to calculate seven local lengths.",
        "dependencies": [],
        "external_inputs": [
          {
            "bibliography_key": "Ratcliffe:Foundations",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "Theorems 3.5.8 and 3.5.9 for Lambert quadrilaterals, and Theorem 3.5.3 for the hyperbolic cosine rule.",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The quadrilateral has the right angles and side placement shown in the cited formulas.",
              "The triangles and metric have constant curvature -1.",
              "The source is the third edition, whose numbering is cited."
            ],
            "locator": "Theorems 3.5.3, 3.5.8, and 3.5.9",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "2019",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Springer, third edition, 2019.",
            "date_basis": "Edition and publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "Third edition, 2019",
            "evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have"
          },
          {
            "bibliography_key": "Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
            "role": "proof_input",
            "imported_result": "The page-88 quadrilateral identity cosh(2g)=-sinh^2(4a)+cosh^2(4a)cosh(2a).",
            "required_hypotheses": [
              "The quadrilateral has two right angles at the ends of the side of length 2a.",
              "The adjacent sides both have length 4a.",
              "The side configuration matches the cited formula."
            ],
            "locator": "Page 88, first formula in the last block of displayed equations",
            "audit_status": "not_inspected",
            "available_from": "1989",
            "date_evidence": "\\newblock Walter de Gruyter \\& Co., Berlin, 1989.",
            "date_basis": "Publication year reported in the supplied bibliography",
            "version": "1989 book",
            "evidence": "According to first formula in the last block of displayed equations on \\cite[page 88]{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry}, we have"
          }
        ],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "minor_issues",
        "issues": [
          "The side placements defining the quantities, especially g, depend on external figure files not present as viewable images in the supplied text.",
          "The cited source identities were not inspected."
        ],
        "reasoning": "All displayed algebraic substitutions are correct. Independently checking the formulas from the stated triangle and quadrilateral configurations gives the displayed expressions and compatible numerical values. The remaining limitation is identification of those configurations with the figure-defined lengths."
      },
      {
        "label": "Proposition 6.3",
        "element_type": "proposition",
        "element_id": "proposition_6_3",
        "source_label": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
        "argument_gist": "For the upper bound, shortcut a cubical geodesic between edge midpoints. For the lower bound, partition a hyperbolic geodesic by pentagonal altitudes and compensate short type-I intervals using neighboring longer intervals.",
        "dependencies": [
          {
            "source_label": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
            "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}, every edge of $w$ has hyperbolic length $2b$."
          }
        ],
        "external_inputs": [],
        "external_references": [],
        "verdict": "unverifiable",
        "issues": [
          "The exhaustive five-type classification and the four enumerated compensation claims depend essentially on figure files whose geometric content cannot be inspected from the supplied text.",
          "The type-I/IV and type-I/III/type-I minimization assertions require verification that the specified perpendicular or symmetric configurations are the global minima under the crossing constraints.",
          "A perturbation avoiding vertices generally produces a nongeodesic path; preserving the one-crossing arguments should be justified by choosing a nearby geodesic or taking a limit.",
          "The strict final inequality fails in configurations attaining equality type V throughout; the required non-strict lower bound remains sufficient."
        ],
        "reasoning": "The upper estimate by midpoint shortcuts is valid. Conditional on the four compensation claims, the lower-bound bookkeeping works: lenders are of non-type-I, so the selected groups are disjoint, with at most two borrowers per type-III lender. The numerical comparisons 3a>2c, g>2c, and 2e>3c are correct. The geometric premises and sharpness constructions remain unverified, not disproved."
      }
    ],
    "argument_gist": "The intended theorem is stability of hyperbolicity and cocompact cubulation under sufficiently sparse random conjugacy-class quotients of a hyperbolic cubulated group. Relators are thickened from axes to compact convex quasi-circles. The probabilistic core must show that overlaps with other relators and hyperplane carriers occupy less than a prescribed fraction of each relator. A deterministic antipodal-wall construction then produces a dual cube complex, with primitivity ensuring freeness. The principal bottlenecks are the cyclic self-overlap encoding, the exact hypotheses and conclusions of the imported cubulation machinery, and the historical availability of the axis input.",
    "argument_steps": [
      {
        "title": "Growth and sampling",
        "gist": "Obtain exponential orbit and conjugacy growth, strict growth separation for essential hyperplane stabilizers, concentration of relator lengths near the cutoff, and scarcity of proper powers.",
        "claims": [
          "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "Lem:Systole",
          "Lem:Primitive"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Deterministic cubulation criterion",
        "gist": "Pair antipodal cone hyperplanes, verify B(8), pieceful convexity, and separation, and invoke external cubical small-cancellation and torsion results.",
        "claims": [
          "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "lem:1/14 hyperbolic"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Geometric replacement of pieces",
        "gist": "Use uniform hull thickness to turn actual cubical intersections into loose fellow-traveling segments, including intersections needed to bound cone hyperplane carriers.",
        "claims": [
          "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Wall-piece counting",
        "gist": "A long portion constrained near a hyperplane grows at the subgroup rate a rather than the ambient rate b, producing the density restriction c<alpha(b-a).",
        "claims": [
          "Prop:WallPieceControl"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Cone-piece counting",
        "gist": "Control separate relators, small-overlap self-pieces, and large-overlap self-pieces. Combine exponential rarity with a k-squared union bound and relator-length concentration to obtain c<b alpha/(alpha+2).",
        "claims": [
          "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "Prop:ConePieceSystole"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Main cubical sampling theorem",
        "gist": "Choose alpha<1/20 satisfying both density restrictions, construct the cubical presentation, prove hyperbolicity, and obtain a free cocompact action on its dual cube complex.",
        "claims": [
          "Thm:main",
          "Cor:LowDensity"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Transfer from another sampling metric",
        "gist": "Repeat the counting in Upsilon and transfer small cancellation to the cubulation. The product of the two multiplicative distortion constants creates the lambda loss.",
        "claims": [
          "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "Prop:QITranslation",
          "Thm:OtherSample"
        ]
      },
      {
        "title": "Pentagonal example",
        "gist": "Calculate local hyperbolic lengths and compare the hyperbolic and combinatorial metrics sharply, giving lambda=d/c and the explicit surface density.",
        "claims": [
          "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "Cor:H2Action"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "external_references": [
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Gromov93",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Chapter 9",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Gromov introduced the \\emph{density model} of random groups \\cite[Chapter 9]{Gromov93}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Introduction; Sections 4--5; Theorem 3",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Ollivier proved that the same phase transition at density $\\frac{1}{2}$ occurs in quotients of any torsion-free hyperbolic group \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Zuk03",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "\\.Zuk showed that random groups at density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ satisfy Kazhdan's property (T), with overwhelming probability \\cite{Zuk03}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "KotowskiSquared",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See  Kotowski and Kotowski \\cite{KotowskiSquared} for full details, and Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier05invitation} for an excellent survey of related topics."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Ollivier05invitation",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Introduction; Sections I.2.c; page 31",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Indeed, the probabilistic pigeonhole principle \\cite[p. 31]{Ollivier05invitation} implies that at any density larger than $\\frac{1}{40}$ there will almost surely be pieces that fellow-travel for more than $\\frac{1}{20}$ of their length."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Ashcroft:PropertyT",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Very recently, Ashcroft extended this result, proving that random quotients of a hyperbolic group at density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ have property  (T) \\cite{Ashcroft:PropertyT}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "NibloRoller98",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "The property of being \\emph{cocompactly cubulated} -- acting properly and cocompactly on a CAT(0) cube complex -- can be viewed as a strong negation of property (T) \\cite{NibloRoller98}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "WiseSmallCanCube04",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "hence are cocompactly cubulated by  \\cite{WiseSmallCanCube04}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "OllivierWiseDensity",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Ollivier and Wise  \\cite{OllivierWiseDensity} showed that the same conclusion holds at density $d < \\frac{1}{6}$."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "MackayPrzytycki",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Montee:Cubulation",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Ashcroft:Cubulation",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Odrzygozdz",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z  \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thesis} for cubulation results in the square probability model."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Duong:Thesis",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z  \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thesis} for cubulation results in the square probability model."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Agol:VirtualHaken",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "A theorem of Agol~\\cite{Agol:VirtualHaken} implies $\\overline G$ is \\emph{virtually special}, meaning $\\overline G$ virtually embeds into a right-angled Artin group."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "HaglundWiseCoxeter",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Then, by a theorem of Haglund and Wise~\\cite{HaglundWiseCoxeter}, all quasiconvex subgroups of $\\overline G$ are separable."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "HsuWiseGraphProducts",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "DavisJan00",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "studied topologically \nsince the work of Furman~\\cite{Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective}, and metrically since the work of Reyes~\\cite[Def 1.2]{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Definition 1.2",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "studied topologically \nsince the work of Furman~\\cite{Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective}, and metrically since the work of Reyes~\\cite[Def 1.2]{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Introduction",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See \\cite{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics,CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum,BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Introduction and discussion of Conjecture 7.8",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "available_from": null,
        "date_evidence": "\\newblock In preparation.",
        "date_basis": "Undated bibliography entry",
        "version": "Unspecified manuscript in preparation",
        "evidence": "Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations} have very recently proved \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold}, formalizing the intuition in the above discussion."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Margulis:Growth",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "By a theorem of Huber \\cite{Huber}, generalized by Margulis \\cite{Margulis:Growth}, the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\HH^2$ is $b=1$."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "JankiewiczWise",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Overview and Problem 7.3",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "This criterion is of independent interest, and has already been used in the work of Jankiewicz and Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "BridsonHaefliger",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Page 230",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "It is a standard property of isometries of metric spaces that the limit exists and is independent of $x$ \\cite[page 230]{BridsonHaefliger}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "MartinSteenbock",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Problem 7.3",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See Martin--Steenbock~\\cite{MartinSteenbock} and Jankiewicz--Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "Osin2007",
        "role": "conditional",
        "locator": "Discussion following Problem 7.6",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "use another hyperbolic Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient"
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "GrovesManning2008",
        "role": "conditional",
        "locator": "Discussion following Problem 7.6",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "use another hyperbolic Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient"
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "DGO",
        "role": "conditional",
        "locator": "Discussion following Problem 7.6",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "use another hyperbolic Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient"
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "KahnMarkovic09",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Discussion of Conjecture 7.8",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "See Kahn and Markovic \\cite{KahnMarkovic09}."
      },
      {
        "bibliography_key": "BergeronHaglundWiseSimple",
        "role": "background",
        "locator": "Discussion of Conjecture 7.8",
        "audit_status": "not_inspected",
        "evidence": "one may move a single hypersurface by many elements of $\\operatorname{Comm}(\\Gamma)$, as in \\cite{BergeronHaglundWiseSimple}, to achieve  a cubulation of $\\Gamma$"
      }
    ],
    "open_elements": [
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.1",
        "source_label": "Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity",
        "status": "Open problem, not asserted as proved"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.2",
        "source_label": "Prob:GeneralOptimalDensity",
        "status": "Open problem, not asserted as proved"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.3",
        "source_label": "Prob:FreeProdOptimalDensity",
        "status": "Open problem, not asserted as proved"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.4",
        "source_label": "",
        "status": "Open problem on relatively hyperbolic cubulated groups"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.5",
        "source_label": "",
        "status": "Open problem on acylindrically hyperbolic cubulated groups"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.6",
        "source_label": "",
        "status": "Open problem on groups with torsion"
      },
      {
        "label": "Problem 7.7",
        "source_label": "",
        "status": "Open problem on relatively hyperbolic random quotients"
      },
      {
        "label": "Conjecture 7.8",
        "source_label": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
        "status": "Not proved internally; the claimed external resolution has unresolved dated source evidence"
      },
      {
        "label": "Question 7.9",
        "source_label": "Ques:OptimalCubulation",
        "status": "Open question, not a proof dependency"
      },
      {
        "label": "Question 7.10",
        "source_label": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
        "status": "Open question, not a proof dependency"
      }
    ],
    "retrospective_note": {
      "summary": "The supplied text contains material added or cited after the recorded received-date cutoff, notably the October 2023 cube-complex typicality citation. That material is separated from the original proof audit. The claimed resolution of Conjecture 7.8 by an undated work in preparation is likewise not used to justify any original proof obligation.",
      "effect_on_main_proofs": "Neither the typicality discussion nor the claimed resolution of Conjecture 7.8 is needed for the stated main theorems."
    },
    "overall_assessment": {
      "validity_score": 62,
      "summary": "The manuscript has a coherent and mathematically substantial strategy, with correct density balancing and a useful separation between deterministic cubulation and probabilistic counting. However, the supplied proof does not rigorously establish the central self-piece estimate, and several additional hypotheses, constants, and imported results require correction or verification. These findings do not demonstrate that the intended main random-quotient theorems are false.",
      "critical_issues": [
        "Lemma 4.11 confuses overlap of chosen lifts with overlap modulo the relator period; its asserted disjoint projected occurrences do not follow.",
        "Lemma 4.13 does not provide the finite encoding needed for its exponential self-piece estimate.",
        "Theorem 3.5 omits verification that the constructed wall separates the prescribed endpoints and does not explicitly justify all properness and cocompactness conclusions.",
        "Definition 2.2 and Theorem 2.3 are false for arbitrary proper cocompact metric actions without an additional geometric hypothesis.",
        "Corollary 1.4 lacks the compactness or closed-surface hypothesis required by its proof.",
        "The applicable pre-cutoff version of the axis theorem is not documented."
      ],
      "minor_issues": [
        "The wall-piece proof divides by 1-exp(-a), which vanishes in the important case a=0.",
        "The proper-power count omits multiplicities of power exponents and should explicitly establish an all-conjugacy-class upper bound.",
        "The sum of the five exceptional-event bounds in Lemma 4.13 is replaced incorrectly by their maximum.",
        "The wall calculation in Proposition 5.7 drops a delta term.",
        "Several estimates suppress dependence on alpha or on the additive quasi-isometry constant.",
        "The alpha range in Proposition 5.4 exceeds the range proved by the cited internal argument.",
        "The examples described as holding at density 1/41 should say strictly below 1/41.",
        "The ancillary claim of a virtual surjection onto F_2 needs a nonelementarity qualification.",
        "The sharp pentagonal lower bound depends on unavailable figure content and unverified geometric minimization assertions."
      ],
      "strengths": [
        "The overall proof architecture and internal division of labor are clear.",
        "The two competing density restrictions are derived and balanced correctly.",
        "Loose pieces are a useful device for controlling both genuine small-cancellation pieces and cone hyperplane carriers.",
        "The quasi-isometric transfer argument correctly isolates multiplicative distortion from bounded additive errors.",
        "The elementary pentagonal algebra is consistent and gives a concrete quantitative example.",
        "The discussion distinguishes prospective improvements involving typical pieces from the established main strategy."
      ]
    },
    "roadmap": {
      "schema_version": 1,
      "title": "Cubulating random quotients of hyperbolic cubulated groups",
      "source": {
        "name": "manuscript",
        "sha256": "fc24f58e14c923fb6ab5564f7ed4ca420240b71d5fa5f8007cd8c228c6f309c8",
        "characters": 177992,
        "lines": 2607
      },
      "argument_gist": "The intended theorem is stability of hyperbolicity and cocompact cubulation under sufficiently sparse random conjugacy-class quotients of a hyperbolic cubulated group. Relators are thickened from axes to compact convex quasi-circles. The probabilistic core must show that overlaps with other relators and hyperplane carriers occupy less than a prescribed fraction of each relator. A deterministic antipodal-wall construction then produces a dual cube complex, with primitivity ensuring freeness. The principal bottlenecks are the cyclic self-overlap encoding, the exact hypotheses and conclusions of the imported cubulation machinery, and the historical availability of the axis input.",
      "review_provenance": {
        "pipeline": "full-text-batch",
        "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
        "reasoning_effort": "high"
      },
      "review_policy": {
        "schema": 1,
        "cutoff_date": "2023-04-24",
        "basis": "journal_received",
        "evidence": "Author-hosted journal PDF, first page (printed p.622): Received by the editors April 24, 2023; DOI 10.1090/btran/180; SHA256 e267fab251e659d2cf15938beb21386cd984a1064e3abd9d3064db2f128b8629",
        "status": "recorded",
        "rule": "external-results-available-by-cutoff"
      },
      "phases": [
        {
          "title": "Growth and sampling",
          "gist": "Obtain exponential orbit and conjugacy growth, strict growth separation for essential hyperplane stabilizers, concentration of relator lengths near the cutoff, and scarcity of proper powers.",
          "claims": [
            "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
            "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
            "Rem:NonPrimitive",
            "Lem:Systole",
            "Lem:Primitive"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Deterministic cubulation criterion",
          "gist": "Pair antipodal cone hyperplanes, verify B(8), pieceful convexity, and separation, and invoke external cubical small-cancellation and torsion results.",
          "claims": [
            "rem:pieceful convexity",
            "Thm:cubulating X star",
            "Thm:C'20Proper",
            "lem:1/14 hyperbolic"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Geometric replacement of pieces",
          "gist": "Use uniform hull thickness to turn actual cubical intersections into loose fellow-traveling segments, including intersections needed to bound cone hyperplane carriers.",
          "claims": [
            "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
            "Lem:LoosenUp",
            "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Wall-piece counting",
          "gist": "A long portion constrained near a hyperplane grows at the subgroup rate a rather than the ambient rate b, producing the density restriction c<alpha(b-a).",
          "claims": [
            "Prop:WallPieceControl"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Cone-piece counting",
          "gist": "Control separate relators, small-overlap self-pieces, and large-overlap self-pieces. Combine exponential rarity with a k-squared union bound and relator-length concentration to obtain c<b alpha/(alpha+2).",
          "claims": [
            "Lem:ThinQuad",
            "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
            "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
            "Lem:InfiniteWord",
            "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
            "Prop:FewConePieces",
            "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
            "Prop:ConePieceSystole"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Main cubical sampling theorem",
          "gist": "Choose alpha<1/20 satisfying both density restrictions, construct the cubical presentation, prove hyperbolicity, and obtain a free cocompact action on its dual cube complex.",
          "claims": [
            "Thm:main",
            "Cor:LowDensity"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Transfer from another sampling metric",
          "gist": "Repeat the counting in Upsilon and transfer small cancellation to the cubulation. The product of the two multiplicative distortion constants creates the lambda loss.",
          "claims": [
            "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
            "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
            "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
            "Prop:QITranslation",
            "Thm:OtherSample"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Pentagonal example",
          "gist": "Calculate local hyperbolic lengths and compare the hyperbolic and combinatorial metrics sharply, giving lambda=d/c and the explicit surface density.",
          "claims": [
            "Lem:PentagonLengths",
            "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
            "Prop:PentagonalQI",
            "Cor:H2Action"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "nodes": [
        {
          "id": "namedtheorem:line:64",
          "kind": "namedtheorem",
          "label": "Namedtheorem 1",
          "title": "",
          "section": null,
          "statement": "}{",
          "argument_gist": "}{",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 64,
            "line_end": 64,
            "char_start": 1757,
            "char_end": 1797
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "section:1",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 1",
          "title": "Introduction",
          "section": "section:1",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 243,
            "line_end": 385,
            "char_start": 7364,
            "char_end": 25271
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:main",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 1.1",
          "title": "",
          "section": "section:1",
          "statement": "Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex, and suppose that $G$ is hyperbolic. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to the universal cover $\\widetilde X$. Let $a$ be the maximal growth exponent of a stabilizer of an essential hyperplane of $\\widetilde X$. Let $k\\leq e^{c \\ell}$, where \\[ c \\:< \\: \\min \\left\\{ \\frac{(b-a)}{20}, \\, \\frac{b}{41} \\right\\} . \\] Then with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, for any set of conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ with translation length $|g_i| \\leq \\ell$, the group $G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and is the fundamental group of a compact, non-positively curved cube complex.",
          "argument_gist": "Replace the cubulation by a subdivided essential core, thicken sampled axes to compact convex quasi-circles, use probabilistic bounds to obtain cubical C'(1/20), and apply the hyperbolicity and cubulation criteria. Primitivity removes torsion stabilizers.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 275,
            "line_end": 287,
            "char_start": 10482,
            "char_end": 11220
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The cone-piece input depends on the unproved cyclic-disjointness assertion in Lemma 4.11 and the incomplete bounded-data argument in Lemma 4.13. These are central proof obligations, not merely missing citations.",
              "The wall-piece proof is invalid as written when a=0, an explicitly important case of the theorem.",
              "The deterministic cubulation criterion has an omitted separation verification and uninspected imported properness/cocompactness inputs.",
              "The axis theorem used through Convention 4.3 has unresolved pre-cutoff version evidence.",
              "The phrase 'for any set' should explicitly mean a uniformly sampled tuple or set, not a simultaneous assertion about every set of short conjugacy classes."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The final assembly and the constants are correct conditional on the preceding inputs: alpha/(alpha+2) at alpha=1/20 equals 1/41. The supplied argument nevertheless does not complete those inputs. No counterexample to the intended nonelementary random-quotient theorem is established by this review."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Cor:LowDensity",
          "kind": "cor",
          "label": "Cor 1.2",
          "title": "",
          "section": "section:1",
          "statement": "Let $X$ be a compact non-positively curved cube complex, such that $\\pi_1 X$ is hyperbolic and nonelementary. Then, at a sufficiently low density, generic quotients of $\\pi_1 X$ are cocompactly cubulated and hyperbolic.",
          "argument_gist": "Combine the main theorem with strict growth separation between the ambient group and essential hyperplane stabilizers.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 314,
            "line_end": 318,
            "char_start": 15896,
            "char_end": 16159
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "This is a correct conditional consequence, but it inherits the unresolved proof obligations of Theorem 1.1."
            ],
            "reasoning": "For a nonelementary hyperbolic cubulation, essential hyperplane stabilizers are quasiconvex and infinite index. Once strict growth separation and Theorem 1.1 are established in the relevant geodesic metric, a positive admissible density follows."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 1.3",
          "title": "",
          "section": "section:1",
          "statement": "Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex, and suppose that $G$ is hyperbolic. Suppose that $G$ also acts properly and cocompactly on a geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$, where every non-trivial element of $G$ stabilizes a geodesic axis. Suppose that there is a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $\\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$, and let $a$ be the maximal growth exponent in $\\Upsilon$ of a stabilizer of an essential hyperplane of $\\widetilde X$. Let $k\\leq e^{c \\ell}$, where \\[ c<\\min \\left\\{ \\frac{(b-a)}{20 \\lambda}, \\, \\frac{b}{40 \\lambda +1} \\right\\} . \\] Then with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, for any set of conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ with translation length $|g_i|_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\leq \\ell$, the group $\\overline{G} = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and is the fundamental group of a compact, non-positively curved cube complex.",
          "argument_gist": "Establish loose small cancellation in the sampling space Upsilon, transfer it to cubical small cancellation with multiplicative loss lambda, and apply the same cubulation argument as in Theorem 1.1.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 340,
            "line_end": 355,
            "char_start": 19662,
            "char_end": 20701
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The theorem inherits the central cone-piece counting gap through Propositions 5.4 and 5.5.",
              "The application of Proposition 5.7 omits verification of its lower bound on all sampled translation lengths. Lemma 4.16 has the needed analogue, but it must be invoked.",
              "Proposition 5.7 contains a definite additive-constant arithmetic error.",
              "The final cubulation and axis inputs have the same verification and chronology limitations as Theorem 1.1."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The density conversion is algebraically correct: substituting alpha=1/20 into b(alpha/lambda)/(alpha/lambda+2) gives b/(40lambda+1). The omitted long-relator condition is readily addressed, but it does not repair the earlier counting argument."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Cor:H2Action",
          "kind": "cor",
          "label": "Cor 1.4",
          "title": "",
          "section": "section:1",
          "statement": "Let $S$ be a hyperbolic surface tiled by regular right-angled pentagons, and let $G = \\pi_1 S$. For a number $\\ell \\gg 0$, let $k \\leq e^{ \\ell / 63.51}$, and let $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ be conjugacy classes in $G$, chosen uniformly at random from among those of $\\widetilde S$--length at most $\\ell$. Then with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the group $\\overline{G} = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and is the fundamental group of a compact, non-positively curved cube complex.",
          "argument_gist": "Use b=1 and a=0 for a pentagonally tiled closed hyperbolic surface, together with the optimal metric comparison, in Theorem 1.3.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 362,
            "line_end": 366,
            "char_start": 21660,
            "char_end": 22211
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The statement does not assume S is closed or compact, or that its pentagonal tiling is finite. Those conditions are needed for the asserted application of Theorem 1.3 and b=1. Arbitrary noncompact or infinite-type tiled surfaces are not covered, and the stated uniform sample can even fail to be a finite set.",
              "For closed surfaces, the corollary still inherits Theorem 1.3 and the unverified pictorial lower-bound argument in Proposition 6.3."
            ],
            "reasoning": "With the closed-surface hypothesis added and the prerequisite results established, the numerical threshold follows: 40lambda+1 is approximately 63.508, so 1/63.51 is strictly below the required threshold."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "sec:growth",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 2",
          "title": "Growth",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 385,
            "line_end": 482,
            "char_start": 25271,
            "char_end": 31176
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:TransLength",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 2.1",
          "title": "Translation lengths",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a group acting properly and cocompactly on a metric space $\\Upsilon$, and let $g \\in G$ be an infinite-order element. The translation length of $g$ is defined to be $|g|_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\inf \\{ \\dist(x, gx) : x \\in \\Upsilon \\}$. The stable translation length of $g$ is \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist(x, g^n x)}{n}, for an arbitrary $x \\in \\Upsilon$. It is a standard property of isometries of metric spaces that the limit exists and is independent of $x$ \\cite[page 230]{BridsonHaefliger}.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G$ be a group acting properly and cocompactly on a metric space $\\Upsilon$, and let $g \\in G$ be an infinite-order element. The translation length of $g$ is defined to be $|g|_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\inf \\{ \\dist(x, gx) : x \\in \\Upsilon \\}$. The stable translation length of $g$ is \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist(x, g^n x)}{n}, for an arbitrary $x \\in \\Upsilon$. It is a standard property of isometries of metric spaces that the limit exists and is independent of $x$ \\cite[page 230]{BridsonHaefliger}.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 389,
            "line_end": 396,
            "char_start": 25449,
            "char_end": 26126
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:Growth",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 2.2",
          "title": "Growth",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a finitely generated group acting properly and cocompactly on a metric space $\\Upsilon$. Fix a basepoint $x \\in \\Upsilon$ and a subset $H \\subset G$. The growth function of $H$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ is the function $f_{H,\\Upsilon}:\\naturals \\rightarrow \\naturals$ defined by f_{H,\\Upsilon}(n) = \\# \\left\\{ h\\in H: \\dist_\\Upsilon(x, \\, hx)\\leq n \\right\\} . Since $G$ is a quotient of a finite-rank free group, and the action on $\\Upsilon$ is proper, the growth function $f_{H,\\Upsilon}$ is no larger than exponential. Thus it makes sense to consider the logarithm of $f$. The growth exponent of $H$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ is \\xi_H (\\Upsilon) = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{ \\log f_{H,\\Upsilon}(n) }{n} , whenever the limit exists. We emphasize that the limit depends a great deal on $\\Upsilon$. However, triangle inequalities in $\\Upsilon$ imply that $\\xi_H(\\Upsilon)$ is independent of the basepoint.",
          "argument_gist": "Define an orbit-counting growth exponent and assert that finite generation, properness, and cocompactness bound the counting function exponentially.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 407,
            "line_end": 423,
            "char_start": 26772,
            "char_end": 27839
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The assertion that the orbit growth is at most exponential under the stated metric-space hypotheses is false. A geodesic or suitable quasi-geodesic assumption is missing."
            ],
            "reasoning": "A self-contained counterexample is G=F_3 acting on itself with d(x,y)=sqrt(|x^{-1}y|), where word length uses the standard free basis. This is a proper left-invariant metric, and the quotient is a point. Its radius-n ball is a word ball of radius floor(n^2), so its cardinality grows like 5^(n^2), not exponentially in n. This defect does not affect the intended applications to geodesic spaces."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 2.3",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a non-elementary hyperbolic group acting properly and cocompactly on a metric space $\\Upsilon$. Let $H$ be a quasiconvex subgroup of infinite index. Then the growth exponents $\\xi_H$ and $\\xi_G$ exist, and \\[ \\xi_H(\\Upsilon) < \\xi_G (\\Upsilon). \\]",
          "argument_gist": "Import strict exponential growth separation for infinite-index quasiconvex subgroups.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 428,
            "line_end": 435,
            "char_start": 28461,
            "char_end": 28768
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "As stated for an arbitrary metric space, the theorem is false. A suitable ambient geodesic or quasi-geodesic hypothesis is missing.",
              "The exact hypotheses of the two cited results have not been inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "In the metric counterexample from Definition 2.2, take H=F_2 as a proper free factor of F_3. Both logarithmic growth quotients tend to infinity, since the ball counts grow like 3^(n^2) and 5^(n^2), respectively. Thus finite exponents do not exist, and allowing extended exponents does not give a strict inequality. The intended geodesic-space application may be correct."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 2.4",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a nonelementary group acting properly and cocompactly on a $\\delta$--hyperbolic metric space $\\Upsilon$. Then, there exist positive constants $A,B, b, n_0$, where $b = \\xi_G(\\Upsilon)$, such that the following hold for $n \\geq n_0$. [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item The total number $f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n)$ of elements that translate a basepoint $x \\in \\Upsilon$ by distance at most $n$ satisfies \\[ A e^{bn} \\leq f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n) \\leq B e^{bn} . \\] \\item The number $p_n$ of primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ satisfies \\[ A \\frac{e^{bn}}{n} \\leq p_n \\leq B e^{bn} . \\]",
          "argument_gist": "Combine pure exponential orbit growth with exponential lower and upper bounds for primitive conjugacy classes.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 457,
            "line_end": 460,
            "char_start": 29813,
            "char_end": 30032
          },
          "proof_opening": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}. Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 439,
            "line_end": 456,
            "char_start": 29030,
            "char_end": 29811
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The proof consists entirely of uninspected external inputs.",
              "The primitive-class formulation, treatment of torsion, ambient-space hypotheses, and translation-length convention require comparison with the cited versions."
            ],
            "reasoning": "There is no internal deduction to check beyond combining the two inputs and adjusting common constants. Bibliographic dates precede the cutoff, but that does not verify the quoted theorems."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "kind": "rem",
          "label": "Rem 2.5",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper constant $B$) on the number of vertices in a metric ball in $\\Upsilon$, where the vertices being counted are not required to be in the $G$--orbit of the basepoint $x$. This holds because of the cocompactness of the $G$--action.",
          "argument_gist": "Replace counting one vertex orbit by counting all vertex orbits using cocompactness.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 463,
            "line_end": 466,
            "char_start": 30036,
            "char_end": 30486
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "For arbitrary cell complexes, cocompactness alone does not explicitly supply local finiteness or finitely many vertex orbits. State the needed finiteness assumption."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The assertion is valid for the locally finite universal covers of compact cube complexes used in Section 4: finitely many vertex orbits give a finite sum of shifted orbit-counting bounds."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "kind": "rem",
          "label": "Rem 2.6",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "statement": "The upper bound on the number $p_n$ of primitive classes in \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the number of non-primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ is bounded above by \\[ \\sum_{j = 1}^{n/2} B e^{bj} < n B e^{bn/2} \\ll p_n. \\] Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most \\[ \\frac{ n^2 B}{A} e^{-bn/2} . \\] Hence, for large $n$, the non-primitive conjugacy classes form a vanishingly small proportion of all conjugacy classes up to length $n$.",
          "argument_gist": "A proper power of length at most n has a root of length at most n/2, so proper powers have exponentially smaller conjugacy growth.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 467,
            "line_end": 479,
            "char_start": 30488,
            "char_end": 31172
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The displayed sum over root lengths does not explicitly count the possible power exponents.",
              "The argument uses exact scaling of lengths of powers and a positive lower bound on primitive translation lengths; these hold in the later axis setting but are not stated here.",
              "The upper bound for all conjugacy classes, used subsequently, should be recorded explicitly rather than inferred from the primitive-class bound without discussing powers."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The exponential negligibility conclusion is sound in the intended torsion-free axis setting. New repair, separate from the supplied proof: if the shortest nontrivial translation length is epsilon>0, sum the primitive-class bound over power exponents 2 <= m <= n/epsilon. Each summand is at most B exp(bn/2), giving O(n exp(bn/2)); division by A exp(bn)/n gives O(n^2 exp(-bn/2))."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 3",
          "title": "Cubical presentations and small-cancellation theory",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 482,
            "line_end": 789,
            "char_start": 31176,
            "char_end": 52457
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:CubicalPres",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 3.1",
          "title": "Cubical presentation",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "A cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X | Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\rangle$ consists of non-positively curved cube complexes $X$ and $Y_i$, and a set of local isometries $Y_i \\looparrowright X$. The cubical presentation $X^*$ corresponds to a topological space, also denoted $X^*$, consisting of $X$ with a cone on each $Y_i$. Accordingly, we call each $Y_i$ a cone of $X^*$.",
          "argument_gist": "A cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X | Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\rangle$ consists of non-positively curved cube complexes $X$ and $Y_i$, and a set of local isometries $Y_i \\looparrowright X$. The cubical presentation $X^*$ corresponds to a topological space, also denoted $X^*$, consisting of $X$ with a cone on each $Y_i$. Accordingly, we call each $Y_i$ a cone of $X^*$.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 490,
            "line_end": 493,
            "char_start": 31635,
            "char_end": 32086
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:Piece",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 3.2",
          "title": "Pieces",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "Let $X^* = \\langle X | Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\rangle$ be a cubical presentation. A cone-piece of $X^*$ between $Y_i$ and $Y_j$ is a component of $\\widetilde{Y}_i \\cap \\widetilde{Y}_j$, for some choice of lifts of $\\widetilde Y_i$ and $\\widetilde Y_j$ to $\\widetilde X$, excluding the case where $\\widetilde Y_i = \\widetilde Y_j$. A wall-piece of $X^*$ in $Y_i$ is a non-empty intersection of $\\widetilde{Y}_i \\cap N(\\widetilde{U})$, where $\\widetilde{U}$ is a hyperplane that is disjoint from $\\widetilde{Y}_i$. Given a constant $\\alpha > 0$, we say that $X^*$ satisfies the $C'(\\alpha)$ small-cancellation condition if for every cone-piece or wall-piece $P$ involving $Y_i$, we have $\\diameter (P) < \\alpha \\systole{ Y_i }$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $X^* = \\langle X | Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\rangle$ be a cubical presentation. A cone-piece of $X^*$ between $Y_i$ and $Y_j$ is a component of $\\widetilde{Y}_i \\cap \\widetilde{Y}_j$, for some choice of lifts of $\\widetilde Y_i$ and $\\widetilde Y_j$ to $\\widetilde X$, excluding the case where $\\widetilde Y_i = \\widetilde Y_j$. A wall-piece of $X^*$ in $Y_i$ is a non-empty intersection of $\\widetilde{Y}_i \\cap N(\\widetilde{U})$, where $\\widetilde{U}$ is a hyperplane that is disjoint from $\\widetilde{Y}_i$. Given a constant $\\alpha > 0$, we say that ",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 503,
            "line_end": 512,
            "char_start": 32689,
            "char_end": 33485
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:1/12 lift",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 3.3",
          "title": "\\hbox{\\cite[Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "If $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{12})$, then every cone $Y_i \\looparrowright X^*$ lifts to an embedding $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "argument_gist": "Import the embedding of relator cones in the universal cover under cubical C'(1/12).",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 515,
            "line_end": 519,
            "char_start": 33583,
            "char_end": 33819
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "This is an uninspected imported result; source piece conventions and any symmetry hypotheses need checking."
            ],
            "reasoning": "No internal proof is supplied. Its appearance before the wallspace construction does not by itself make it an additional dependency of every later claim."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 3.4",
          "title": "\\hbox{\\cite[Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "If $\\pi_1 X$ is hyperbolic and $X^*$ is compact and $C'(\\frac{1}{14})$, then $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic.",
          "argument_gist": "Import preservation of hyperbolicity for compact cubical C'(1/14) presentations.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 523,
            "line_end": 526,
            "char_start": 33947,
            "char_end": 34155
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The cited external theorem and its exact hypotheses were not inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The later applications do check compactness, hyperbolicity of the original group, and a stronger small-cancellation constant, conditional on their preceding arguments."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 3.5",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "Let $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ be a $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ cubical presentation. Suppose that $X$ is compact, and every $Y_i$ is compact and deformation retracts to a closed--geodesic. In addition, suppose that for every hyperplane $U \\subset Y_i$, the carrier $N(U)$ is embedded, the complement $Y_i \\setminus U$ is contractible, and $\\diameter (N(U)) < \\frac{1}{20} \\systole{Y_i}$. Then $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts properly and cocompactly on a CAT(0) cube complex dual to a wallspace structure on $\\widetilde{X^*}$ satisfying the $B(8)$ condition. Moreover, if $\\overline g \\in \\pi_1 X^* \\setminus \\{1\\}$ stabilizes a cell of the dual cube complex, then $\\overline g$ is the image of an element $g \\in \\pi_1 X$ such that a conjugate of some $\\pi_1 Y_i$ lies in $\\langle g \\rangle$. In particular, if each $\\pi_1 Y_i$ is maximal cyclic, then $\\pi_1X^*$ acts freely on $\\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "argument_gist": "Pair antipodal hyperplanes in each quasi-circle to form walls, prove B(8), pieceful convexity, and the separation criterion, then use the imported cubulation and torsion theorems.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 532,
            "line_end": 542,
            "char_start": 34295,
            "char_end": 35244
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "In checking Hypothesis 3.8(4), the proof establishes that U_2 is not 2-proximate to either endpoint, but does not establish the other required conclusion: U_2 separates p and q.",
              "The chosen u_2 is merely a hyperplane whose carrier contains the midpoint. That does not, by itself, say that the geodesic crosses u_2.",
              "The transition from torsion stabilizers to a proper action, and the assertion of cocompactness from compactness of X, require precise justification from the external cubulation theorem or an additional argument. Torsion stabilizers alone do not logically imply properness.",
              "Availability of the imported axis theorem at the cutoff is unresolved.",
              "The final sentence of the theorem states freeness on the universal cover of X*, whereas the needed conclusion is freeness on the dual CAT(0) cube complex."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The displayed quantitative estimates are otherwise consistent: alpha<1/20 leaves room for the required midpoint distance inequalities after subdivision. A plausible repair of the separation step would choose a hyperplane dual to an edge of kappa near its midpoint and prove that its antipodal partner is not crossed, but that argument is not supplied here. The theorem is not disproved by the omission."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:B6",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 3.6",
          "title": "$B(6)$ and $B(8)$ conditions",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "Suppose that $X^*= \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is a $C'(\\frac{1}{12})$ cubical presentation. A $B(6)$ structure on $X^*$ consists of a wallspace structure on each $Y_i$, which is preserved by its automorphisms, and satisfies a certain small-cancellation condition (see \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for an example). More precisely: [\\:\\: ($1$)] \\item The collection of hyperplanes of each $Y_i$ is partitioned into classes satisfying the following conditions. No two hyperplanes in the same class cross or osculate; in particular, the carrier of each hyperplane $u_j$ embeds. The union $U = \\cup u_j$ of the hyperplanes in a class is called a wall. Furthermore, for each wall $U$, there are halfspaces $\\overleftarrow{U},\\overrightarrow{U}$ such that $Y_i = \\overleftarrow{U} \\cup \\overrightarrow{U}$ and $U = \\overleftarrow{U} \\cap \\overrightarrow{U}$. \\item $\\Aut(Y_i\\rightarrow X)$ preserves the above wallspace structure on $Y_i$. \\item If $P$ is a path in $Y_i$ that is the concatenation of at most 7 piece-paths and $P$ starts and ends on the carrier $N(U)$ of a wall $U$, then $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(U)$. The $B(8)$ condition is defined by replacing \\eqref{B6:homotopy} with the stronger condition: [\\:\\: ($1'$)] \\setcounter{enumi}{2} \\item If $P$ is a path that is the concatenation of at most 8 piece-paths and $P$ starts and ends on the carrier $N(U)$ of a wall then $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(U)$.",
          "argument_gist": "Suppose that $X^*= \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is a $C'(\\frac{1}{12})$ cubical presentation. A $B(6)$ structure on $X^*$ consists of a wallspace structure on each $Y_i$, which is preserved by its automorphisms, and satisfies a certain small-cancellation condition (see \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for an example). More precisely: [\\:\\: ($1$)] \\item The collection of hyperplanes of each $Y_i$ is partitioned into classes satisfying the following conditions. No two hyperplanes in the same class cross or osculate; in particular, the carrier o",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 556,
            "line_end": 580,
            "char_start": 36440,
            "char_end": 38114
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "kind": "rem",
          "label": "Rem 3.7",
          "title": "\\hbox{\\cite[Rem~5.43]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "Let $M$ be the maximal diameter of any piece of $Y$ in $X^*$. Then a hyperplane $u$ of $Y$ is piecefully convex provided its carrier $N=N(u)$ satisfies: $\\dist_{\\widetilde Y}(g\\widetilde N,\\widetilde N)>M$ for any translate $g\\widetilde N\\neq \\widetilde N\\subset \\widetilde Y$.",
          "argument_gist": "Import a sufficient separation condition on distinct lifts of a carrier to obtain pieceful convexity.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 617,
            "line_end": 623,
            "char_start": 39915,
            "char_end": 40291
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The imported criterion was not inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "Theorem 3.5 gives the separation estimate required by this restated criterion. Whether the restatement includes all original hypotheses remains an external verification task."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "kind": "thm",
          "label": "Thm 3.8",
          "title": "",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "statement": "Suppose that $X^* = \\langle X \\mid \\{Y_i\\} \\rangle$ satisfies the following hypotheses: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{14})$ and satisfies the $B(6)$ condition. \\item Each hyperplane of each cone $Y_i$ is piecefully convex. \\item For each $Y_i$, each infinite order element of $\\Aut(Y_i)$ is cut by a wall of $Y_i$. \\item Let $\\kappa\\rightarrow Y_i$ be a geodesic with endpoints $p,q$. Let $u_1$ and $u_1'$ be distinct hyperplanes in the same wall of $Y_i$. Suppose $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1$, and either $u_1'$ is $1$--proximate to $q$ or $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1'$. Then there is a wall $U_2$ in $Y_i$ that separates $p,q$ but is not $2$--proximate to $p$ or $q$. Then $\\pi_1X^*$ acts with torsion stabilizers on the dual cube complex of the $B(6)$ structure.",
          "argument_gist": "Restate the external properness machinery in terms of small cancellation, pieceful convexity, wall cutting, and an endpoint separation condition.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 627,
            "line_end": 642,
            "char_start": 40453,
            "char_end": 41583
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The equivalence of the simplified hypotheses to the original theorem's assumptions has not been checked.",
              "The stated conclusion only mentions torsion stabilizers; the additional properness and cocompactness used in Theorem 3.5 must be accounted for explicitly."
            ],
            "reasoning": "This is an imported criterion rather than an internally proved theorem. It is one of the principal external bottlenecks."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:Pieces",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 4",
          "title": "Controlling pieces in generic quotients",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 789,
            "line_end": 1517,
            "char_start": 52457,
            "char_end": 106270
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:QuasiAxis",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 4.1",
          "title": "Quasi-axes",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Let $\\widetilde w, \\widetilde w'$ be bi-infinite geodesics in a metric space $\\Upsilon$. We declare them to be equivalent, and write $\\widetilde w \\approx \\widetilde w'$, whenever $\\widetilde w \\subset \\neb_r(\\widetilde w')$ for some $r \\geq 0$. In the main case of interest, when $\\Upsilon$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic, we can use a uniform value $r = 2\\delta$, and deduce that $\\widetilde w \\approx \\widetilde w'$ if and only if $\\bdy \\widetilde w = \\bdy \\widetilde w'$. Let $g$ be a hyperbolic isometry of $\\Upsilon$. A quasi-axis for $g$ is a bi-infinite geodesic $\\widetilde w \\subset \\Upsilon$ such that $g \\widetilde w \\approx \\widetilde w$. When $\\Upsilon$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic, any geodesic connecting the fixed points of $g$ on $\\bdy \\Upsilon$ is a quasi-axis for $g$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $\\widetilde w, \\widetilde w'$ be bi-infinite geodesics in a metric space $\\Upsilon$. We declare them to be equivalent, and write $\\widetilde w \\approx \\widetilde w'$, whenever $\\widetilde w \\subset \\neb_r(\\widetilde w')$ for some $r \\geq 0$. In the main case of interest, when $\\Upsilon$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic, we can use a uniform value $r = 2\\delta$, and deduce that $\\widetilde w \\approx \\widetilde w'$ if and only if $\\bdy \\widetilde w = \\bdy \\widetilde w'$. Let $g$ be a hyperbolic isometry of $\\Upsilon$. A quasi-axis for $g$ is a bi-infi",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 803,
            "line_end": 812,
            "char_start": 53632,
            "char_end": 54477
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.2",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Let $\\widetilde{X}$ be a $\\delta$--hyperbolic, finite dimensional CAT(0) cube complex. Then there is a uniform constant $K = K(\\widetilde{X})$ with the following property. For every bi-infinite geodesic $\\widetilde{w}$, the convex hull of $ \\widetilde w $ satisfies \\[ \\hull \\left( \\widetilde w \\right) \\subset \\neb_K(\\widetilde{w} ) . \\]",
          "argument_gist": "At a point far from the line, find a hyperplane crossing an initial cube at a definite angle; hyperbolicity forces that hyperplane to separate the point from the line.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 824,
            "line_end": 831,
            "char_start": 55004,
            "char_end": 56236
          },
          "proof_opening": "Consider a vertex $p \\in \\widetilde{X}$ that lies far from $\\widetilde w$. Let $s$ be a shortest CAT(0) (non-combinatorial) geodesic segment from $p$ to $\\widetilde w$, oriented outward from $p$. Sageev and Wise have observed \\cite[Remark~3.2]{SageevWiseCores} that the first cube met by $s$ contains a midcube of a hyperplane $H$ that intersects $s$ at an angle bounded away from $0$. The angle bound depends only on the dimension of the cube, hence can be taken uniformly over $\\widetilde X$. We claim that when $s$ is sufficiently long, $H \\cap \\widetilde w = \\emptyset$. In other words, $H$ separates $p$ from $\\widetilde w$, hence $p \\notin \\hull(\\widetilde w)$. The claim holds because an inter",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 815,
            "line_end": 823,
            "char_start": 54481,
            "char_end": 55002
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The proof switches to CAT(0) geodesics and angle arguments without explicitly reconciling them with the combinatorial geodesics used for relators.",
              "The claimed contradiction with thinness is only sketched; the uniform distance bound should be derived from the two angle bounds.",
              "The external angle observation was not inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The mechanism is plausible and standard in this setting, but the proof should specify the metric on the line and the uniform comparison needed to obtain the stated combinatorial hull bound. No counterexample to the lemma is demonstrated."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Conv:NiceX",
          "kind": "conv",
          "label": "Conv 4.3",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "From now until the start of the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main}, the symbol $X$ denotes a compact non-positively curved cube complex, such that $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic for some $\\delta$. We assume that $G = \\pi_1 X$ is nonelementary. We assume that $X$ has been subdivided at least once, so that every $g \\neq 1$ stabilizes a geodesic axis in $\\widetilde X$ \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}. Finally, we assume that every hyperplane of $X$ is essential. This assumption is harmless, because every non-positively curved cube complex $X'$ contains a convex essential core, whose hyperplanes are essential. See, for instance, Caprace and Sageev \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}.",
          "argument_gist": "From now until the start of the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main}, the symbol $X$ denotes a compact non-positively curved cube complex, such that $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic for some $\\delta$. We assume that $G = \\pi_1 X$ is nonelementary. We assume that $X$ has been subdivided at least once, so that every $g \\neq 1$ stabilizes a geodesic axis in $\\widetilde X$ \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}. Finally, we assume that every hyperplane of $X$ is essential. This assumption is harmless, because every non-positively curved cube complex $X'$ contains a co",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 848,
            "line_end": 855,
            "char_start": 57067,
            "char_end": 57795
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 4.4",
          "title": "Loose pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. Fix a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. We define $J$--loose pieces first in $\\widetilde X$, then in $X$. Consider bi-infinite geodesics $\\widetilde w, \\widetilde w'$ that do not share an endpoint in $\\bdy \\widetilde X$. Then a $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $\\widetilde w'$ is the maximal geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ whose endpoints are contained in $\\neb_{J} (\\widetilde w')$. The companion of $s$ is the maximal segment $s' \\subset \\widetilde w'$ whose endpoints are at distance $J$ from the corresponding endpoints of $s$. Now, let $w, w'$ be closed--geodesics in $X$. If $w \\neq w'$, a $J$--loose cone-piece between $w$ and $w'$ is the projection of a $J$--loose cone-piece between preimages $\\widetilde w$ and $\\widetilde w'$. A $J$--loose cone-piece between $w$ and itself arises in the above scenario where $\\widetilde w' = h\\widetilde w$ for some $h \\notin \\stab_G(\\widetilde w)$. In a similar manner, a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w$ is a maximal geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde{w}$ whose endpoints are contained in $\\neb_J (N(\\widetilde{U}))$ for a hyperplane $U$. A $J$--loose wall-piece in a closed--geodesic $w$ is the projection of a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. Fix a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. We define $J$--loose pieces first in $\\widetilde X$, then in $X$. Consider bi-infinite geodesics $\\widetilde w, \\widetilde w'$ that do not share an endpoint in $\\bdy \\widetilde X$. Then a $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $\\widetilde w'$ is the maximal geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ whose endpoints are contained in $\\neb_{J} (\\widetilde w')$. The companion of $s$ is the maximal segment $s' \\subset \\widetilde w'$ whose endpoints are at distance $J$ fr",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 859,
            "line_end": 872,
            "char_start": 57893,
            "char_end": 59271
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.5",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Consider a cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\rangle$. Suppose that $\\widetilde X$ is hyperbolic and that every $Y_i$ is a quasi-circle. Let $\\widetilde w_i$ be a bi-infinite geodesic in $\\widetilde Y_i$. Then there is a constant $J = J(\\widetilde{X})$ such that the following hold for every $d \\geq 0$: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item Every diameter $ \\geq d$ cone-piece of $X^*$ between $Y_i$ and $Y_j$ determines a $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde w_i$ and $\\widetilde w_j$, of diameter $\\geq d$. \\item Every diameter $ \\geq d$ wall-piece of $X^*$ in $Y_i$ determines a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w_i$, also of diameter $\\geq d$. \\item Every diameter $\\geq d$ intersection between $\\widetilde Y_i$ and a hyperplane carrier $N(U)$ determines a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w_i$, of diameter $\\geq d$. Furthermore, we may take $J \\leq 3K$, where $K$ is the constant of \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}.",
          "argument_gist": "Project endpoints of a large actual piece to nearby axes and extend along an axis to recover the lost additive length.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 891,
            "line_end": 902,
            "char_start": 60505,
            "char_end": 61420
          },
          "proof_opening": "First, consider cone-pieces. Let $p,q \\in \\widetilde Y_i \\cap \\widetilde Y_j$ be points such that $\\dist(p,q) \\geq d$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ that are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively. Applying \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness} to the quasi-circle $Y_j$ shows that $p_i, q_i$ are $2K$--close to $\\widetilde w_j$. Since $\\widetilde w_i$ is a geodesic, we have $\\dist(p_i, q_i) \\geq d - 2K$. Extending the segment $[p_i, q_i]$ by $K$ in each direction, we obtain a geodesic segment $[p_i', q_i'] \\subset \\widetilde w_i$ whose length is at least $d$ and whose endpoints lie in $\\neb_{3K}(\\widetilde w_j)$. Thus $[p_i, q_i]$ is contained i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 878,
            "line_end": 889,
            "char_start": 59450,
            "char_end": 60502
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The statement allows any bi-infinite geodesic in a quasi-circle, whereas the thickness lemma directly concerns the geodesic whose hull defines that quasi-circle. Uniformly replacing the defining axis needs an additional fellow-traveling observation and possibly an enlarged K.",
              "The cone-piece conclusion needs the corresponding axes to satisfy the no-common-boundary-endpoint requirement in Definition 4.4. This is not verified in the proof.",
              "Maximal segments need not have vertex endpoints or integer looseness exactly as written; bounded rounding should be stated."
            ],
            "reasoning": "For distinct noncommensurable axes and a uniform thickness bound, the endpoint calculation is correct: a d-length overlap gives a segment of length at least d-2K, and extension by K at each end produces length at least d with 3K-close endpoints."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "kind": "rem",
          "label": "Rem 4.6",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Besides the looseness constant $J$, there is one important respect in which \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece} is more general than \\Cref{Def:Piece}. Whereas the definition of a wall-piece in $Y_i$ requires the hyperplane $U$ to be disjoint from $Y_i$, the definition of a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w_i$ has no analogous restriction. Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces. When we apply \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we will care about all intersections between $Y_i$ and hyperplane carriers in $X$, and all such intersections will be controlled using $J$--loose wall-pieces.",
          "argument_gist": "Explain that loose wall-pieces control all carrier intersections, not only intersections with hyperplanes disjoint from the relator.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 903,
            "line_end": 906,
            "char_start": 61422,
            "char_end": 62133
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "valid",
            "issues": [],
            "reasoning": "This accurately distinguishes the two definitions and identifies the stronger control needed for the carrier-diameter hypothesis of Theorem 3.5."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 4.7",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. For each non-trivial conjugacy class $\\pi_1 X$, choose a representative closed--geodesic. Let $a < b$ be growth exponents as above, let $\\alpha \\in (0,1)$, and fix a positive number $c < \\alpha(b-a)$. Then, for every $J \\in \\naturals$, there is a constant $C=C(J,X)$, with the following property. For $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$, choose conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k] \\in \\mathcal{G}(\\ell)$ uniformly at random. Let $w_i$ be the closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. Then, for all $\\ell \\gg 0$, the probability that some $w_i$ contains a $J$--loose wall-piece of diameter at least $\\alpha \\systole{w_i}$ is bounded above by \\[ C \\ell^2 e^{ (c+(a -b) \\alpha) \\ell } . \\] Consequently, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all $J$--loose wall-pieces in $w_i$ have diameter less than $\\alpha |g_i|$.",
          "argument_gist": "Encode a bad relator as a long segment near a hyperplane followed by an unrestricted segment, compare exponential counts, and union-bound over sampled relators.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 938,
            "line_end": 1005,
            "char_start": 64286,
            "char_end": 67714
          },
          "proof_opening": "Let $\\Pi(\\alpha,\\ell)$ denote the proportion of representative closed--geodesics $w$ of length at most $\\ell$ such that $w$ contains a $J$--loose wall piece of diameter at least $\\alpha \\systole{w}$. That is, $\\Pi(\\alpha,\\ell)$ denotes the proportion of all $w$ of length at most $\\ell$ such that $ \\widetilde w \\cap \\neb_J (N(\\widetilde{U})) $ contains the endpoints of a segment of length at least $\\alpha \\systole{w}$ for some hyperplane $U$. Our goal is to estimate $\\Pi(\\alpha, \\ell)$. For each $n \\leq \\ell$, let $\\mathcal{U}(n,\\alpha)$ be the set of (conjugacy representatives of) closed--geodesics $w$ of length exactly $ n$ that contain a $J$--loose wall-piece $s$ with $|s| \\geq \\alpha n$. ",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 923,
            "line_end": 936,
            "char_start": 63371,
            "char_end": 64283
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The final constant B/[A(1-exp(-a))] is undefined when a=0. This includes cyclic hyperplane stabilizers, one of the paper's principal examples.",
              "The cited ambient-group growth theorem does not directly establish the asserted hyperplane-neighborhood count at its exact exponent a. Elementary stabilizers require separate counting, and existence of a growth exponent alone is insufficient for a pure exponential upper bound.",
              "The normalization of starting points and the count over possible segment lengths are compressed into the factor n without a complete encoding argument.",
              "The asserted notation C=C(J,X) suppresses possible dependence on alpha."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The exponential balance c-alpha(b-a)<0 is correct. New repair for the demonstrated denominator error, separate from the supplied proof: retain the preceding denominator 1-exp(-(a alpha+b(1-alpha))). It is positive even when a=0 because b>0 and alpha<1. This does not itself verify the earlier counting bound."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 4.8",
          "title": "Orientation and overlaps",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Let $w \\to X$ be a closed--geodesic. Choose distinct preimages $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$ of $w$ and a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. Suppose $s = [p,q] \\subset \\widetilde w$ is a $J$--loose piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$, such that $|s| > 2J$. Let $s' = [p',q'] \\subset h\\widetilde w$ be the companion of $s$, so that $\\dist(p,p')=J =\\dist(q,q')$. Suppose that $\\widetilde w$ is oriented from $p$ to $q$, and transfer this orientation to $h \\widetilde w$ via $h$. Since $|s| = \\dist(p,q) > 2J$, the endpoints $p',q'$ of the companion $s'$ cannot coincide. We say that $h$ preserves orientation on $s$ if $p'$ comes before $q'$ in the orientation on $h \\widetilde w$, and reverses orientation on $s$ otherwise. See \\Cref{Fig:Overlap}. The $h$--overlap in $s$ is the interval $u = s \\cap h^{-1} s'$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $w \\to X$ be a closed--geodesic. Choose distinct preimages $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$ of $w$ and a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. Suppose $s = [p,q] \\subset \\widetilde w$ is a $J$--loose piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$, such that $|s| > 2J$. Let $s' = [p',q'] \\subset h\\widetilde w$ be the companion of $s$, so that $\\dist(p,p')=J =\\dist(q,q')$. Suppose that $\\widetilde w$ is oriented from $p$ to $q$, and transfer this orientation to $h \\widetilde w$ via $h$. Since $|s| = \\dist(p,q) > 2J$, the endpoints $p',q'$ of the ",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1035,
            "line_end": 1045,
            "char_start": 69030,
            "char_end": 69960
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.9",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose that $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic. Let $Q$ be a geodesic quadrilateral with corners $p,q,q',p'$, such that $\\dist(p,p') \\leq J$ and $\\dist(q,q')\\leq J$. Then every point $x \\in [p,q]$ lies within distance $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$ of some point of $[p',q']$.",
          "argument_gist": "Apply thinness of geodesic quadrilaterals and the bounded lengths of the two connecting sides.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1061,
            "line_end": 1064,
            "char_start": 71192,
            "char_end": 71494
          },
          "proof_opening": "This is standard. Since triangles in $\\widetilde X$ are $\\delta$--thin, then quadrilaterals are $2\\delta$--thin. Thus $x \\in [p,q]$ is $2\\delta$--close to some point $x' \\in [p,p'] \\cup [p',q'] \\cup [q',q]$. But every point of $[p,p'] \\cup [q',q]$ is $J$--close to $[p',q']$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1057,
            "line_end": 1060,
            "char_start": 70870,
            "char_end": 71190
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "valid",
            "issues": [],
            "reasoning": "A geodesic quadrilateral is 2delta-thin. A point close to a short connecting side is then within J+2delta of the opposite long side. The proof establishes exactly the claimed bound."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.10",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose $X$ is compact and $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic. For every $J \\in \\naturals$, there is a constant $R = R(J, \\delta) \\geq 10J$ such that the following holds. Suppose that $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ is a $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$, where $h$ reverses orientation on $s$. Then the $h$--overlap $u \\subset s$ has diameter $|u| \\leq R$.",
          "argument_gist": "Orientation reversal approximately swaps overlap endpoints; consequently h^2 moves an endpoint only boundedly, forcing the overlap close to an axis and hence bounded.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1073,
            "line_end": 1129,
            "char_start": 71944,
            "char_end": 75306
          },
          "proof_opening": "In the notation of \\Cref{Def:OverlapOrientation}, the overlap is $u = [p,q] \\cap h^{-1}[p', q']$. Since $h$ is orientation-reversing, the endpoints of $u$ are $x \\in \\{p, h^{-1}q'\\}$ and $y \\in \\{q, h^{-1}p'\\}$. We begin by showing there is a constant $L = L(J, \\delta)$ such that \\dist(x, hy) \\leq L \\quad \\text{and} \\quad \\dist(y, hx) \\leq L. To prove \\eqref{Eqn:EndpointsClose}, we consider two cases. For the first case, suppose that $\\dist(p,h^{-1}q') \\leq 2J$ and $\\dist(q,h^{-1}p') \\leq 2J$. Since $x \\in \\{p, h^{-1}q'\\}$ and $hy \\in \\{p',hq\\}$, triangle inequalities imply that \\[ \\dist(x,hy) \\leq \\dist(x,p) + \\dist(p,p') + \\dist(p', hy) \\leq 2J + J + 2J = 5J. \\] By an identical calculation",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1066,
            "line_end": 1072,
            "char_start": 71497,
            "char_end": 71942
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The inference that y is 2delta-close to the opposite long side merely from dist(y,q)>J is not justified; excluding closeness to the short side requires room for the additional 2delta.",
              "The uniform quasi-geodesic constants for the h^2-orbits should be derived explicitly from bounded step length and a uniform positive stable-length lower bound.",
              "After subdivisions retaining the original metric, the lower bound should be stated in the retained metric rather than assumed to be exactly 1."
            ],
            "reasoning": "These are constant-control omissions rather than a demonstrated failure of the bounded-overlap conclusion. Enlarging the constants and using the uniform positive translation-length lower bound available in the intended compact cubical action plausibly repairs the argument."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.11",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose that every non-trivial element of $\\pi_1 X$ stabilizes a geodesic in a $\\delta$--hyperbolic space $\\widetilde X$. For each non-trivial conjugacy class in $\\pi_1 X$, choose a closed--geodesic in $X$ that represents it. Fix constants $J, R \\in \\naturals$. Then, for all $d > 2J$ and all $\\ell$ sufficiently large, the following holds: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item Among all pairs of conjugacy classes $[g], [g']$ of length at most $\\ell$, the proportion whose representative closed--geodesics have a $J$--loose cone piece of diameter $\\geq d$ is less than $M \\ell^2 \\, e^{-b d}$, for a constant $M = M(X, J)$. \\item Among all conjugacy classes $[g]$ of length at most $\\ell$, the proportion whose representative closed--geodesic has a $J$--loose cone piece with itself, with diameter $\\geq d$ and overlap of length $\\leq R$, is less than $M_0 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, for a constant $M_0 = M_0(X, J, R)$.",
          "argument_gist": "Encode a second relator using its fellow-traveling segment and a free remainder; for self-pieces, try to remove two disjoint occurrences of the same information.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1150,
            "line_end": 1232,
            "char_start": 76505,
            "char_end": 85838
          },
          "proof_opening": "Before beginning the probabilistic portion of the proof, we make a reduction, introduce notation, and name some constants. Let $D$ be the diameter of $X$. Let $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$, and let $V$ be the maximal number of vertices in a ball of radius $(D+J+\\mathring J)$ in $\\widetilde X$. Let $W$ be the maximal number of vertices in a ball of radius $n_0$, where $n_0$ is the threshold constant of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}. Fix a basepoint $x_0 \\in \\widetilde X$. Suppose that $[g], [g']$ are conjugacy classes represented by closed--geodesics $w, w'$ that have a $J$--loose cone-piece. (For now, we do not place any constraint on the lengths of $w, w'$, or the piece.) By \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1133,
            "line_end": 1148,
            "char_start": 75450,
            "char_end": 76502
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The self-piece proof asserts that s and v' project to disjoint portions of the closed geodesic because their chosen lifts have small overlap. This is false without controlling overlap modulo the period of w.",
              "Replacing h by h g^N, where g translates the axis of w, leaves h times the axis unchanged but shifts h^{-1}s' by an arbitrary number of periods. The overlap in Definition 4.8 can therefore be made empty without changing either projected occurrence. Small overlap of those chosen lifts does not imply projected disjointness.",
              "Consequently, the asserted fundamental domain y_1 v' y_2 s and the count obtained by subtracting twice the piece length are not established.",
              "In the separate-sample argument, the warm-up linear bound cannot be absorbed uniformly into the claimed exponential bound for unrestricted d>ell. The later applications only require d<=ell/3, but the lemma states a broader range.",
              "Equation (Eqn:InitialCountS) uses |w| where the remainder-length estimate requires |w'|. The final bound using ell can be recovered, but the intermediate inequality is incorrect as written."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The cyclic-disjointness problem is a demonstrated error in the supplied reasoning, not just an uninspected standard fact. A normalization of h modulo the relator period, together with a separate treatment of wrapping and long overlaps, is required before this counting argument is valid. The intended probability estimate is not disproved here."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.12",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose $X$ is compact and $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic. Choose a non-trivial element $h \\in \\pi_1 X$. Suppose that $yx$ is a path from $p \\in \\widetilde X$ to $hp \\in \\widetilde X$. Suppose that each of $x$ and $y$ is a geodesic, and that $|x| \\leq J$ for some $J \\geq 0$. Define $L$ to be the maximal length of a terminal segment of $y$ that is a $2\\delta$ fellow-traveler with an initial segment of $hy$. Let $(yx)^\\infty$ denote the bi-infinite path $\\cdots h^{-1} (yx) h^0(y x) h^1(yx) h^2 (yx) \\cdots$. Then $(yx)^\\infty$ is an $\\eta$--quasigeodesic, with $\\eta$ depending only on $J$, $\\delta$, and $L$.",
          "argument_gist": "Bound cancellation at the joins of a periodic path and apply a local-to-global quasi-geodesic principle.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1246,
            "line_end": 1252,
            "char_start": 86517,
            "char_end": 87047
          },
          "proof_opening": "If $|y|$ is small, there are only finitely many possibilities for $yx$. The bi-infinite path $(yx)^\\infty$ lies at bounded distance from some quasi-axis of $h$. So, take the worst case scenario for the quasigeodesic constant $\\eta$. If $|y|$ is large, we have large geodesic subpaths of $(yx)h(y)$. By hypothesis, we have a bound $L$ on the length of backtracking in $(yx)h(y)$. Now, apply a ``local to global'' principle for quasi-geodesics. See e.g.\\ Cannon~\\cite[Thm 4]{cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1233,
            "line_end": 1244,
            "char_start": 85840,
            "char_end": 86514
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The proof does not state the local quasi-geodesic constants or verify the required local scale.",
              "The finite-possibilities argument for short y requires normalization modulo the cocompact action and combinatorial endpoints.",
              "The general hyperbolic-space scope of the cited theorem has not been inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "This is a plausible bounded-cancellation lemma in the intended torsion-free cubical setting, but the supplied proof is a sketch rather than a complete quantitative derivation."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.13",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose $X$ is compact and $\\widetilde X$ is hyperbolic. Fix a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. Then there is a constant $M = M(X, J)$ such that for all sufficiently large $\\ell$ and for all $d \\in [2J+1, \\, \\ell/3]$, the following holds. Among all conjugacy classes $[g]$ of length at most $\\ell$, the proportion whose representative closed--geodesic has a $J$--loose cone piece with itself, with diameter $\\geq d$, is less than $M \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$.",
          "argument_gist": "Discard short relators and small overlaps, use orientation preservation for large overlaps, and encode a long repeated portion through uniformly fellow-traveling periodic quasi-geodesics.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1265,
            "line_end": 1348,
            "char_start": 87969,
            "char_end": 95000
          },
          "proof_opening": "Consider a closed--geodesic $w$ representing the conjugacy class $[g]$. As a warm-up, we dismiss the (non-generic) possibility where $|w| \\leq 2 d$. Since $d \\leq \\ell/3$, it follows that $|w| \\leq 2 \\ell / 3$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the total number of conjugacy classes of length at most $2 \\ell/3$ is at most $B e^{2 \\ell/3}$, whereas the total number of length at most $\\ell$ is at least $A e^{b \\ell}/\\ell$. Thus, the probability that $|w|$ is at most $2/3$ of the allowed length is \\[ \\frac{\\mathcal{G}(2\\ell/3)}{\\mathcal{G}(\\ell)} \\leq \\frac{B e^{2 b\\ell/3}}{A e^{b \\ell}/\\ell} = \\frac{B\\ell }{A} e^{-b\\ell/3} \\leq \\frac{B}{A} \\ell \\, e^{-bd} . \\] Thus the ",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1258,
            "line_end": 1264,
            "char_start": 87464,
            "char_end": 87967
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The small-overlap branch imports the invalid projected-disjointness argument from Lemma 4.11.",
              "In Case 1, the statement that all of y_2 y_3 is determined by y_1 and universally bounded data is not established by fellow-traveling alone. A complete finite encoding must specify the endpoint or length choices and bound the number of possibilities.",
              "Case 2 replaces J by J+2delta but retains R(J,delta). The large-overlap argument needs its threshold checked for the enlarged looseness constant.",
              "The conclusion combines five types of events by taking the maximum of their constants. A union bound requires their sum, unless disjointness and an additional argument are supplied.",
              "There are minor path-order and exponent typographical inconsistencies, including the use of (x_1 y_1)^infinity where the constructed path is y_1 x_1."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The geometric periodicity mechanism is credible, but the exponentially sharp counting estimate is not proved by the supplied sketch. New repair for the last constant error only: taking M=sum_j M_j bounds the union of the five events. That elementary correction does not close the encoding and cyclic-overlap gaps."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 4.14",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose $X$ is compact and $\\widetilde X$ is hyperbolic. Fix constants $J \\in \\naturals$ and $\\phi \\in (0,1)$ and $C > 2/b(1-\\phi)$. Then, for all sufficiently large $\\ell$ and for all $d \\in [C \\log \\ell, \\, \\ell/3]$, the following holds. Suppose that conjugacy classes $[g],[g']$ are chosen at random from among those of length at most $\\ell$. Then there is an $e^{-bd\\phi}$ upper bound on the probability that there is a $J$--loose piece of diameter at least $d$ between the representative closed--geodesics. Similarly, for a randomly chosen conjugacy class $[g]$ of length at most $\\ell$, there is an $e^{-bd\\phi}$ upper bound on the probability that there is a $J$--loose piece of diameter at least $d$ between the representative closed--geodesic and itself.",
          "argument_gist": "Absorb the polynomial factor M ell^2 into an arbitrarily small loss in the exponential decay exponent.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1360,
            "line_end": 1373,
            "char_start": 95822,
            "char_end": 96757
          },
          "proof_opening": "Let $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}. Combining the two lemmas, we see that a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ in the closed--geodesic representing $[g]$ occurs with probability at most $M \\ell^2 \\, e^{-bd}$. Now, let $C > \\frac{2}{b(1-\\phi)}$ be as in the statement of the lemma. Then, choosing $\\ell$ large ensures that the additive difference $\\big( C \\log \\ell - \\frac{ 2\\log \\ell}{b(1-\\phi)} \\big)$ is as large as we like. In particular, for $\\ell \\gg 0$ and $d \\geq C \\log \\ell$, we have \\[ d \\geq C \\log \\ell > \\frac{2 \\log \\ell }{b (1-\\phi) } + \\frac{ \\log M }{b (1-\\phi)",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1351,
            "line_end": 1359,
            "char_start": 95004,
            "char_end": 95820
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The proposition inherits the uncompleted counting estimates of Lemmas 4.11 and 4.13."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The argument of this proposition is algebraically correct conditional on those estimates: d>log(M ell^2)/(b(1-phi)) gives M ell^2 exp(-bd)<exp(-b phi d)."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.15",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Fix constants $q \\in \\big( 0,\\frac{1}{6} \\big]$ and $J \\in \\naturals$. Let $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$, where $c< q b$ and $b$ is the growth exponent of $\\widetilde X$. Select conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ at random from among those of length at most $\\ell$, with each $[g_i]$ represented by a closed--geodesic $w_i$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all $J$--loose cone-pieces among the $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $2 q \\ell$.",
          "argument_gist": "Apply the pairwise piece estimate to k^2 pairs and choose phi so that the exponential union bound decays.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1389,
            "line_end": 1408,
            "char_start": 97730,
            "char_end": 99081
          },
          "proof_opening": "Since $c< q b$, we may choose a constant $\\phi \\in (0,1)$ such that $c < q b \\phi^2$. We will consider pieces of diameter at least $d\\geq 2 q \\ell$. Since $d$ is bounded below by a linear function of $\\ell$, the logarithmic hypothesis on $d$ in \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} is satisfied for $\\ell \\gg 0$. The above choices imply that there are $k^2 \\leq e^{2c \\ell} < e^{2 q b \\phi^2 \\ell}$ pairs of indices $(i,j)$. When $\\ell$ is sufficiently large, \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} says that for every pair $(i,j)$, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ between $w_i$ and $w_j$ is less than $e^{-bd\\phi}$. (This includes the case $w_i = w_j$.) Thus the total probability that s",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1379,
            "line_end": 1387,
            "char_start": 97207,
            "char_end": 97727
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The result inherits Proposition 4.14's unresolved probabilistic input.",
              "The proof invokes the preceding proposition for arbitrary d>=2q ell, although that proposition only treats d<=ell/3. It suffices to apply it at d=2q ell; this should be stated."
            ],
            "reasoning": "At d=2q ell, the condition q<=1/6 gives the required upper range, and the union-bound exponent is strictly negative. Thus the local argument is valid after this minor range clarification, conditional on Proposition 4.14."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:Systole",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.16",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Select conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ at random from among those of length at most $\\ell$, where $ k \\leq e^{c\\ell}$ for some constant $c < q b$ where $0<q<1$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, we have: $\\min\\{ | g_i | : 1 \\leq i \\leq k \\} \\geq (1-q)\\ell$.",
          "argument_gist": "Short conjugacy classes are exponentially sparse, and the allowed number of samples does not overcome that decay.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1414,
            "line_end": 1426,
            "char_start": 99416,
            "char_end": 100011
          },
          "proof_opening": "Let $w_i$ be a closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that $|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is \\[ \\frac{\\mathcal{G}((1-q)\\ell)}{\\mathcal{G}(\\ell)} \\leq \\frac{Be^{b (1-q) \\ell}}{A e^{b\\ell}/ \\ell} = \\frac{B}{A}\\ell e^{-bq\\ell}. \\] Thus the conditional probability that $|w_i|<(1- q) \\ell$ for some $1\\leq i\\leq k$ is bounded above by $( k\\frac{B\\ell}{A} )e^{-b q\\ell}$. This upper bound approaches zero exponentially quickly when $k\\leq e^{c\\ell}$ and $c< q b$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1409,
            "line_end": 1414,
            "char_start": 99083,
            "char_end": 99415
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The quoted upper bound is stated for primitive classes, while the numerator counts all classes. The all-class upper bound should first be deduced explicitly, with a changed constant, using the proper-power estimate."
            ],
            "reasoning": "Once that bookkeeping is supplied, the proof is correct: the failure probability is bounded by a polynomial times exp((c-bq)ell), which tends to zero exponentially."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 4.17",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Fix $J \\in \\naturals$ and $\\alpha \\in \\big( 0, \\frac{2}{5} \\big]$. Suppose conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ are chosen at random from among all those of length at most $\\ell$. Assume that $k \\leq e^{c\\ell}$ for some constant $c < b\\alpha/(\\alpha+2)$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all $J$--loose cone-pieces among the closed--geodesics representing $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ have diameter strictly less than $ \\alpha |g_i |$ for every $i$.",
          "argument_gist": "Balance the absolute piece bound and the shortest-relator bound using q=alpha/(alpha+2).",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1435,
            "line_end": 1443,
            "char_start": 100543,
            "char_end": 101298
          },
          "proof_opening": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$. Observe that the hypothesis $\\alpha \\leq \\frac{2}{5}$ implies $q \\leq \\frac{1}{6}$, as required for \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter}. With this value of $q$, \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} says that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all cone-pieces have diameter strictly less than $ \\frac{2 \\alpha}{\\alpha+2} \\ell $. Meanwhile, \\Cref{Lem:Systole} says that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, $\\min_{i=1}^k \\{|g_i | \\} \\geq (1-q) \\ell = \\frac{2}{\\alpha+2} \\ell$. Putting together the last two results, we conclude that the diameter of every cone-piece in $w_i$ is le",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1428,
            "line_end": 1434,
            "char_start": 100014,
            "char_end": 100541
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The proposition inherits the central cone-piece counting gap through Lemma 4.15."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The balancing calculation is correct: alpha<=2/5 implies q<=1/6, and 2q/(1-q)=alpha. No additional error appears in this final conversion."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:Primitive",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 4.18",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "statement": "Suppose $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$ for some constant $c < b/2$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, a set of $k$ randomly chosen conjugacy classes has the property that each one is primitive.",
          "argument_gist": "Union-bound the exponentially small probability of sampling a proper power.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1452,
            "line_end": 1463,
            "char_start": 101604,
            "char_end": 102011
          },
          "proof_opening": "By \\Cref{Rem:NonPrimitive}, the probability that $[g_i]$ is non-primitive is bounded above by \\[ \\frac{\\ell^2 B}{A} e^{-b\\ell/2} . \\] Thus the probability that a $k$--tuple of conjugacy classes contains a non-primitive class is at most \\[ k \\frac{ \\ell^2 B}{A} e^{-b \\ell/2} \\leq \\frac{ \\ell^2 B}{A} e^{(c-b/2)\\ell}, \\] which goes to $0$ as $\\ell \\to \\infty$ because $(c-b/2) < 0$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1448,
            "line_end": 1451,
            "char_start": 101353,
            "char_end": 101602
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The proof depends on correcting the power-counting and metric qualifications in Remark 2.6."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The union bound itself is correct. An O(ell^2 exp(-b ell/2)) single-sample bound gives exponential convergence whenever c<b/2."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 5",
          "title": "Generalization to other metric spaces",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1517,
            "line_end": 1898,
            "char_start": 106270,
            "char_end": 139301
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Conv:NiceUpsilon",
          "kind": "conv",
          "label": "Conv 5.1",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "The following assumptions and terminology hold throughout this section. Let $G$ be a nonelementary, torsion-free group acting properly and cocompactly on a $\\delta$--hyperbolic geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$. Let $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be a collection of infinite index quasiconvex subgroups of $G$, which will remain fixed for the rest of this section. (In the main case of interest, the $H_i$ are hyperplane stabilizers of some action of $G$ on a CAT(0) cube complex $\\widetilde X$.) Fix a basepoint $\\upsilon \\in \\Upsilon$. We assume that every nontrivial element $g \\in G$ stabilizes a geodesic axis $\\widetilde \\gamma \\subset \\widetilde \\Upsilon$. For every conjugacy class $[g]$, we choose a representative closed--geodesic $\\gamma \\subset G \\backslash \\Upsilon$. Then every $g \\in [g]$ stabilizes some preimage $\\widetilde \\gamma$ of $\\gamma$.",
          "argument_gist": "The following assumptions and terminology hold throughout this section. Let $G$ be a nonelementary, torsion-free group acting properly and cocompactly on a $\\delta$--hyperbolic geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$. Let $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be a collection of infinite index quasiconvex subgroups of $G$, which will remain fixed for the rest of this section. (In the main case of interest, the $H_i$ are hyperplane stabilizers of some action of $G$ on a CAT(0) cube complex $\\widetilde X$.) Fix a basepoint $\\upsilon \\in \\Upsilon$. We assume that every nont",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1523,
            "line_end": 1532,
            "char_start": 107116,
            "char_end": 108155
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:LoosePieceOtherMetric",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 5.2",
          "title": "Loose pieces in $\\Upsilon$",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Fix a constant $J > 0$. Consider bi-infinite geodesics $\\widetilde \\gamma, \\widetilde \\gamma' \\subset \\Upsilon$ that do not share an endpoint in $\\bdy \\Upsilon$. Observe that $\\widetilde \\gamma \\cap \\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is a closed set because $\\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is a closed neighborhood, and is bounded because the geodesics do not share an endpoint. Thus $\\widetilde \\gamma \\cap \\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is compact. A $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde \\gamma$ and $\\widetilde \\gamma'$ is the maximal geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde \\gamma$ whose endpoints lie in $\\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$. The companion of $s$ is the maximal segment $s' \\subset \\widetilde \\gamma'$ whose endpoints are at distance $J$ from the corresponding endpoints of $s$. Now, let $\\gamma, \\gamma'$ be closed--geodesics in $G \\backslash \\Upsilon$. Then a $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\gamma$ and $\\gamma'$ is the projection of a $J$--loose cone-piece between arbitrary preimages $\\widetilde \\gamma$ and $\\widetilde \\gamma'$, excluding the case where $\\widetilde \\gamma = \\widetilde \\gamma'$. A $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde \\gamma$ is a maximal geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde{\\gamma}$ whose endpoints are contained in $\\neb_J (g H_i p)$ for one of the chosen subgroups $H_i$ and for some $g \\in G$. A $J$--loose wall-piece in a closed--geodesic $\\gamma$ is the projection of a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde \\gamma$.",
          "argument_gist": "Fix a constant $J > 0$. Consider bi-infinite geodesics $\\widetilde \\gamma, \\widetilde \\gamma' \\subset \\Upsilon$ that do not share an endpoint in $\\bdy \\Upsilon$. Observe that $\\widetilde \\gamma \\cap \\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is a closed set because $\\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is a closed neighborhood, and is bounded because the geodesics do not share an endpoint. Thus $\\widetilde \\gamma \\cap \\neb_{J} (\\widetilde \\gamma')$ is compact. A $J$--loose cone-piece between $\\widetilde \\gamma$ and $\\widetilde \\gamma'$ is the maximal geodesic se",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1537,
            "line_end": 1546,
            "char_start": 108161,
            "char_end": 109750
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "kind": "defn",
          "label": "Defn 5.3",
          "title": "Cube-free $C'(\\alpha)$ presentations",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Let $\\Upsilon$, $\\delta$, $\\upsilon$, $G$, and $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceUpsilon}. Let $\\kappa_j$ be the quasiconvexity constant of the orbit $H_j \\upsilon$, and let $\\kappa = \\max_j \\{ \\kappa_j \\} + 2 \\delta$. Let $g_1, \\ldots, g_k$ be infinite-order elements of $G$. For each $g_i$, let $\\gamma_i \\to G \\backslash \\Upsilon$ be the chosen closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. Since each $g_i$ stabilizes an axis $\\widetilde \\gamma_i \\subset \\Upsilon$, we have $|\\gamma_i| = |g_i|_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$ in \\Cref{Def:TransLength}. The presentation $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is called $C'(\\alpha)$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, \\upsilon, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$ if [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item For every $g_i, g_j$, the diameter of any $2\\delta$--loose cone-piece between $\\gamma_i$ and $\\gamma_j$ is less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$. \\item For every $g_i$, any $\\kappa$--loose wall-piece in $\\gamma_i$ has diameter less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $\\Upsilon$, $\\delta$, $\\upsilon$, $G$, and $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceUpsilon}. Let $\\kappa_j$ be the quasiconvexity constant of the orbit $H_j \\upsilon$, and let $\\kappa = \\max_j \\{ \\kappa_j \\} + 2 \\delta$. Let $g_1, \\ldots, g_k$ be infinite-order elements of $G$. For each $g_i$, let $\\gamma_i \\to G \\backslash \\Upsilon$ be the chosen closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. Since each $g_i$ stabilizes an axis $\\widetilde \\gamma_i \\subset \\Upsilon$, we have $|\\gamma_i| = |g_i|_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$ i",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1547,
            "line_end": 1564,
            "char_start": 109752,
            "char_end": 111012
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 5.4",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ acting on $\\Upsilon$. Consider conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ in $G$, chosen uniformly from all conjugacy classes of $\\Upsilon$--length at most $\\ell$. Suppose $ k \\leq e^{c\\ell}$ for some constant $c < b\\alpha/(\\alpha+2)$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralConePiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds.",
          "argument_gist": "Repeat the cone-piece counting in Upsilon, replacing vertex endpoints by nearby orbit points and absorbing bounded length errors.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1567,
            "line_end": 1574,
            "char_start": 111100,
            "char_end": 111647
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The generalization inherits the unresolved cyclic-overlap and encoding problems of Proposition 4.17.",
              "The statement omits the range 0<alpha<=2/5 present in Proposition 4.17. The sketch does not justify the larger asserted range.",
              "Orbit-point perturbations need a finite-to-one encoding argument, including possible finite point stabilizers, rather than only the assertion that lengths change boundedly."
            ],
            "reasoning": "Bounded endpoint perturbations preserve exponential rates in principle, and the main application uses a small alpha within the original range. They do not repair the missing combinatorial encoding."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 5.5",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$, and let $a$ be an upper bound on the growth exponents of the $H_j$. Note that all lengths and growths are measured with respect to the action on $\\Upsilon$. Consider conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ in $G$, chosen uniformly from all conjugacy classes of $\\Upsilon$--length at most $\\ell$. Suppose $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$ for some $c < \\alpha(b-a)$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralWallPiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds.",
          "argument_gist": "Repeat the wall-piece argument for neighborhoods of quasiconvex subgroup orbits in the general sampling space.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1584,
            "line_end": 1598,
            "char_start": 112321,
            "char_end": 114518
          },
          "proof_opening": "The proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} are nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively. There are two differences in the argument. The primary difference is that $\\Upsilon$ is substituted for $\\widetilde{X}$, and hyperplane stabilizers are replaced by general quasiconvex subgroups $H_i$. The requirement that every infinite-order element of $\\pi_1 X$ stabilizes a geodesic axis (compare \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}), which was heavily used in the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, is mirrored in our setting by the same requirement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1577,
            "line_end": 1582,
            "char_start": 111651,
            "char_end": 112318
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The sketch must repair the a=0 counting treatment inherited from Proposition 4.7.",
              "An upper bound on growth exponents alone does not give an upper bound C exp(an) at the exact exponent. The strict density inequality permits a small exponent slack, but that argument is not supplied.",
              "The finite encoding after moving endpoints to orbit points should be stated."
            ],
            "reasoning": "Unlike Proposition 4.7, this proposition only asserts overwhelming probability, not an exact polynomial-exponential bound. The strict inequality allows small losses in the subgroup exponent, so the identified growth-bound problem is likely repairable without altering the stated density."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "kind": "cor",
          "label": "Cor 5.6",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$, and let $a$ be an upper bound on the growth exponents of the $H_i$. As above, choose a basepoint $\\upsilon \\in \\Upsilon$, and a representative closed--geodesic in $G \\backslash \\Upsilon$ for every conjugacy class in $G$. Let $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$, where $c < \\min \\{ \\alpha(b-a), b\\alpha/(\\alpha+2) \\}$, and consider conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ in $G$, chosen uniformly from all conjugacy classes of $\\Upsilon$--length at most $\\ell$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the presentation $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha)$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, \\upsilon, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$.",
          "argument_gist": "Intersect the high-probability cone-piece and wall-piece events.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1601,
            "line_end": 1608,
            "char_start": 114619,
            "char_end": 115488
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "major_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The logical combination is correct, but the corollary inherits Proposition 5.4's unresolved proof and omitted alpha-range qualification."
            ],
            "reasoning": "A union bound on the two failure events is sufficient; no independence is needed."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 5.7",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "Let $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex whose immersed hyperplanes are essential, and let $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be their fundamental groups. Suppose that $G$ acts properly and cocompactly on a $\\delta$--hyperbolic geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$ that admits a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde{X}$. Let $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ be conjugacy classes in $G$. For each $i$, let $\\widetilde{Y_i} = \\hull(\\widetilde w_i)$, where $\\widetilde w_i$ is an axis for $g_i$ in $\\widetilde{X}$. Finally, let $Y_i = \\langle g_i \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde{Y_i}$. Suppose that, for some $\\overline{\\lambda} > \\lambda$, the presentation $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, p, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$. Then there exists a constant $M = M(\\alpha, \\delta, \\kappa, \\lambda, \\overline{\\lambda}, X)$ such that whenever $\\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\geq M$ for all $i$, the following holds. The cubical presentation $\\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is $C'( \\alpha)$. Moreover, every hyperplane $U \\subset Y_i$ has a carrier $N(U)$ of diameter strictly less than $\\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$.",
          "argument_gist": "A long cubical overlap maps to fellow-traveling axes or a quasiconvex subgroup orbit in Upsilon. Trim bounded end regions, apply small cancellation there, and absorb additive errors using the strict gap between lambda and barred lambda.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1627,
            "line_end": 1800,
            "char_start": 117235,
            "char_end": 130317
          },
          "proof_opening": "We begin by recalling the above definition of a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry. By \\Cref{Eqn:Lambda12}, there is a ($G$--equivariant) function $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$, along with positive constants $\\lambda_1, \\lambda_2, \\epsilon$ such that $\\lambda_1 \\lambda_2 = \\lambda$ and \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) - \\epsilon \\: \\leq \\: \\dist_{\\Upsilon} (f(x), f(y)) \\: \\leq \\: \\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon. We can now relate the systole of $Y_i$ in $X$ to the (stable) translation length of $g_i$ in $\\Upsilon$. By \\Cref{Def:Piece} and \\Cref{Def:TransLength}, we have \\[ \\systole{Y_i} = |g_i|_{{}_X} \\geq \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist_{\\w",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1614,
            "line_end": 1625,
            "char_start": 115946,
            "char_end": 117232
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "In the wall-piece calculation, -2(eta+lambda_2(K+1)+epsilon+psi+2delta)-2eta is incorrectly rewritten as -2(2eta+lambda_2(K+1)+epsilon+psi+delta). The correct final delta term inside the parentheses is 2delta.",
              "The stated dependence of M suppresses the quasi-isometry's additive constant epsilon and the separate distortion constants, although the proof uses them.",
              "The proof assumes large finite diameters are attained and does not explicitly address unbounded intersections. This can be handled by choosing arbitrarily distant pairs, but should be said.",
              "The cone-piece argument should verify the no-common-endpoint condition needed to invoke the loose-piece definition.",
              "Strict trimming inequalities need a small extra margin to exclude the adjacent short sides of a thin quadrilateral."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The central multiplicative argument is sound: d is bounded by (lambda/barred lambda) alpha systole plus a uniform additive constant, and lambda/barred lambda<1 absorbs that constant for long relators. New repair for the arithmetic error: replace the affected delta terms by 2delta and enlarge M accordingly. This changes no density constant."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "kind": "rem",
          "label": "Rem 5.8",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "statement": "In the above proof of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, all of the probabilistic arguments happen inside \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon}, which combines Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece}. By contrast, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} involves a global assumption (a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry), and the proof works entirely in the language of coarse geometry without invoking any counting or probability. One can envision a strengthening of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} that tracks the behavior of a typical conjugacy class and a typical piece. To make this precise, choose a basepoint $x \\in \\widetilde X$ and let $B_n(\\widetilde X) = \\{ g \\in G : \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x, gx) \\leq n\\}$. Define $B_n(\\Upsilon)$ similarly, and recall from \\Cref{Def:Growth} that $f_{G, \\Upsilon}(n)$ counts the cardinality of $B_n(\\Upsilon)$. Define the mean distortion of $\\widetilde X$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ to be \\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) \\: = \\: \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{1}{f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n)} \\sum_{g \\in B_n(\\Upsilon)} \\!\\! \\frac{\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x, gx)}{n} \\: = \\: \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{1}{f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n)} \\sum_{g \\in B_n(\\Upsilon)} \\!\\! \\frac{\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x, gx)}{\\dist_{\\Upsilon}(\\upsilon, g\\upsilon)}. In words, $\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon)$ measures the average factor by which an element of $G$ sampled using $\\Upsilon$ gets stretched in $\\widetilde X$. See~\\cite[Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve} for a proof that the limit exists. The mean distortion can be bounded as follows. Suppose there is a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$, as in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate}, so that $f(x) = \\upsilon$. Then \\[ \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\leq \\frac{1}{\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon)} \\leq \\lambda_2. \\] For a chosen $\\epsilon > 0$, an element $g \\in G$ or a conjugacy class $[g]$ is called $\\Upsilon$--typical if \\left(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) - \\epsilon\\right) \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\leq \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_X} \\leq \\left(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) + \\epsilon\\right) \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon}. For each $\\epsilon > 0$, a conjugacy class sampled uniformly from all those of $\\Upsilon$--length at most $\\ell$ will be $\\Upsilon$--typical with overwhelming probability. Indeed, if $\\Upsilon$ is the Cayley graph of $G$ with respect to some generating set, this follows from a large deviation result of Cantrell and Tanaka~\\cite[Thm 4.23]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve}. If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}. For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}. We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}. The proof begins by observing that every conjugacy class $[g_i]$ satisfies $ \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} \\geq (\\lambda_2)^{-1} \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$; see \\Cref{Eqn:SystoleComparison}. Since $[g_i]$ is $\\Upsilon$--typical with overwhelming probability, we may replace $(\\lambda_2)^{-1}$ by $\\big( \\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) - \\epsilon \\big)$. Next, the proof of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} uses the constant $\\lambda_1$ to pass from the diameter of a piece in $X^*$ to the diameter of a loose piece in $\\Upsilon$; see \\Cref{Eqn:PieceDistortionUpsilon}. If one knew that a cone-piece or wall-piece in $X^*$, coming from a random presentation as in the statement of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, also corresponds to an $\\Upsilon$--typical group element of $G$, one could replace $\\lambda_1$ by $\\big(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) + \\epsilon \\big)$. The upshot would be that the product $\\lambda = \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2$ would be replaced by the quotient $\\big(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) + \\epsilon \\big) /\\big( \\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) - \\epsilon \\big)$, which approaches $1$ as $\\epsilon \\to 0$. Whether the pieces coming from a random presentation (sampled using lengths in $\\Upsilon$) can be represented by $\\Upsilon$--typical group elements is an interesting problem. See \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces}.",
          "argument_gist": "Propose replacing worst-case quasi-isometry distortion by mean distortion for typical relators and, conjecturally, typical pieces.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1853,
            "line_end": 1894,
            "char_start": 134619,
            "char_end": 139296
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "One cited typicality input is explicitly post-cutoff and another has unresolved availability at the cutoff.",
              "The claimed conversion from the cited results to uniform conjugacy-class sampling is not supplied.",
              "The average of displacement ratios includes the identity term 0/0; it should omit that finite exceptional set.",
              "The extension from typical relators to typical pieces is explicitly open and must not be treated as an established improvement."
            ],
            "reasoning": "This remark is not needed for either main theorem. Its proposed cancellation of mean distortion is a conditional strategy, not an existing proof of a stronger density statement."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 6",
          "title": "Pentagonal surfaces",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1898,
            "line_end": 2266,
            "char_start": 139301,
            "char_end": 161236
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 6.1",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "statement": "Let $T$ be the tiling of $\\HH^2$ by regular right-angled pentagons, with hyperbolic metric $\\dist_\\HH$. The dual tiling $T^*$, with five quadrilaterals at every vertex, can be identified with a CAT(0) square complex $\\widetilde X$, with combinatorial metric $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}$. Then the identity map $\\operatorname{id} \\from (\\widetilde X, \\dist_{\\widetilde X}) \\to (\\HH^2, \\dist_\\HH)$ is a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry, where \\[ \\lambda = \\frac{ \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) }{\\arccosh(K+1) } \\approx 1.5627 \\qquad \\text{for} \\qquad K = \\cos \\big( \\tfrac{2\\pi}{5} \\big). \\] Furthermore, this value of $\\lambda$ is optimal.",
          "argument_gist": "Take the ratio d/c of the sharp upper and lower multiplicative metric-comparison constants.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1905,
            "line_end": 1913,
            "char_start": 139782,
            "char_end": 140452
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The proposition depends on the pictorial lower-bound and sharpness arguments of Proposition 6.3, which cannot be fully checked from the supplied text without the figure contents."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The ratio formula follows correctly from the two-sided metric comparison. The numerical value is consistent with the displayed elementary formulas."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "kind": "lem",
          "label": "Lem 6.2",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "statement": "Let $P \\subset \\HH^2$ be a regular right-angled pentagon. Label lengths as in \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}. Set $K = \\cos \\big( \\frac{2\\pi}{5} \\big)$. Then the labeled lengths can be expressed as follows: a &= \\arccosh \\big( \\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 0.5306. \\\\ b &= \\arccosh \\left( \\tfrac{1}{\\sqrt{1-K}} \\right) \\approx 0.6269. \\\\ c &= \\arccosh(K+1) \\approx 0.7672. \\\\ d &= \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. [width=2in]{PentagonLengths.pdf} \\put(35,-2){$a$} \\put(60,-2){$a$} \\put(12,13){$a$} \\put(84,13){$a$} \\put(4,42){$a$} \\put(93,42){$a$} \\put(12,69){$a$} \\put(84,69){$a$} \\put(35,86){$a$} \\put(61,86){$a$} \\put(36,60){$b$} \\put(58,60){$b$} \\put(28,37){$b$} \\put(70,38){$b$} \\put(48,73){$c$} \\put(30,27){$d/2$} \\put(61,28){$d/2$} \\put(47,47){$\\theta$} [width=2.8in]{PentagonLengths2.pdf} \\put(48,-2){$2a$} \\put(19,19){$2a$} \\put(77,19){$2a$} \\put(5,49){$2a$} \\put(90,49){$2a$} \\put(37,48){$2a$} \\put(60,48){$2a$} \\put(60,20){$e$} \\put(33,34){$f/2$} \\put(60,33.5){$f/2$} \\put(23,63){$g$} \\put(77,63){$g$} \\caption{Lengths in a right-angled pentagon, as computed in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. } Furthermore, the length $g$ of a geodesic segment contained in two adjacent right-angled pentagons, as in \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, satisfies 2g = \\arccosh(1+2K (8 K^2+8K+1)^2) \\approx 3.1838.",
          "argument_gist": "Use Lambert quadrilateral identities, the hyperbolic cosine rule, and a two-right-angle quadrilateral formula to calculate seven local lengths.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "proof_anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1979,
            "line_end": 2050,
            "char_start": 143186,
            "char_end": 146546
          },
          "proof_opening": "In \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, left, the right-angled pentagon $P$ is subdivided into five isometric quadrilaterals, arranged symmetrically about the center point of $P$. Each quadrilateral $Q$ has two sides of length $a$, two sides of length $b$, three right angles, and one angle of $\\theta = \\frac{2\\pi}{5}$. The presence of three right angles makes $Q$ a Lambert quadrilateral or almost rectangular quadrilateral in the terminology of Ratcliffe \\cite[Sec 3.5]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ K = \\cos \\theta = \\sinh^2 a, \\] hence $K+1 = \\cosh^2 a$, implying \\Cref{Eqn:ALength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.8]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ \\cosh^2 b = \\lef",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1918,
            "line_end": 1976,
            "char_start": 141321,
            "char_end": 143182
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "minor_issues",
            "issues": [
              "The side placements defining the quantities, especially g, depend on external figure files not present as viewable images in the supplied text.",
              "The cited source identities were not inspected."
            ],
            "reasoning": "All displayed algebraic substitutions are correct. Independently checking the formulas from the stated triangle and quadrilateral configurations gives the displayed expressions and compatible numerical values. The remaining limitation is identification of those configurations with the figure-defined lengths."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "kind": "prop",
          "label": "Prop 6.3",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "statement": "Let $T$ be the tiling of $\\HH^2$ by regular right-angled pentagons, with hyperbolic metric $\\dist_\\HH$. The dual tiling $T^*$, with five quadrilaterals at every vertex, can be identified with a CAT(0) square complex $\\widetilde X$, with combinatorial metric $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}$. Then there is a constant $\\epsilon > 0$ such that for all $x,y \\in \\widetilde X^{0}$, the distances $\\dist_\\HH(x,y)$ and $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y)$ can be compared as follows: c \\cdot \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) - \\epsilon \\: \\leq \\: \\dist_\\HH(x,y) \\: \\leq \\: d \\cdot \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon, where the constants $c,d$ are as in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Furthermore, the multiplicative constants $c,d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} are sharp.",
          "argument_gist": "For the upper bound, shortcut a cubical geodesic between edge midpoints. For the lower bound, partition a hyperbolic geodesic by pentagonal altitudes and compensate short type-I intervals using neighboring longer intervals.",
          "gist_origin": "review_model",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2054,
            "line_end": 2061,
            "char_start": 146778,
            "char_end": 147618
          },
          "review": {
            "verdict": "unverifiable",
            "issues": [
              "The exhaustive five-type classification and the four enumerated compensation claims depend essentially on figure files whose geometric content cannot be inspected from the supplied text.",
              "The type-I/IV and type-I/III/type-I minimization assertions require verification that the specified perpendicular or symmetric configurations are the global minima under the crossing constraints.",
              "A perturbation avoiding vertices generally produces a nongeodesic path; preserving the one-crossing arguments should be justified by choosing a nearby geodesic or taking a limit.",
              "The strict final inequality fails in configurations attaining equality type V throughout; the required non-strict lower bound remains sufficient."
            ],
            "reasoning": "The upper estimate by midpoint shortcuts is valid. Conditional on the four compensation claims, the lower-bound bookkeeping works: lenders are of non-type-I, so the selected groups are disjoint, with at most two borrowers per type-III lender. The numerical comparisons 3a>2c, g>2c, and 2e>3c are correct. The geometric premises and sharpness constructions remain unverified, not disproved."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:Problems",
          "kind": "section",
          "label": "Section 7",
          "title": "Problems",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2266,
            "line_end": 2607,
            "char_start": 161236,
            "char_end": 177992
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.1",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Determine the optimal density at which random quotients of a surface group $G$ are cubulated. How does the answer depend on the choice of proper metric on $G$?",
          "argument_gist": "Determine the optimal density at which random quotients of a surface group $G$ are cubulated. How does the answer depend on the choice of proper metric on $G$?",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2270,
            "line_end": 2273,
            "char_start": 161362,
            "char_end": 161579
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prob:GeneralOptimalDensity",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.2",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Given a non-positively curved cube complex $X$ such that $G = \\pi_1 X$ is hyperbolic, find the optimal density such that quotients of $G$ are cubulated. How does the answer depend on $X$ and the growth rate of its hyperplanes?",
          "argument_gist": "Given a non-positively curved cube complex $X$ such that $G = \\pi_1 X$ is hyperbolic, find the optimal density such that quotients of $G$ are cubulated. How does the answer depend on $X$ and the growth rate of its hyperplanes?",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2274,
            "line_end": 2277,
            "char_start": 161581,
            "char_end": 161866
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Prob:FreeProdOptimalDensity",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.3",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $G = G_1 * G_2$ be a free product of cubulated groups. Find the optimal density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated. Letting $G_i = \\pi_1 X_i$, where $X_i$ is a non-positively curved cube complex, we think of $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X = X_1 \\cup A \\cup X_2$, where $A \\cong[0,n]$ is an arc glued to $X_1$ and $X_2$ at its endpoints. Does the optimal density depend on the length of $A$? See Martin--Steenbock~\\cite{MartinSteenbock} and Jankiewicz--Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G = G_1 * G_2$ be a free product of cubulated groups. Find the optimal density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated. Letting $G_i = \\pi_1 X_i$, where $X_i$ is a non-positively curved cube complex, we think of $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X = X_1 \\cup A \\cup X_2$, where $A \\cong[0,n]$ is an arc glued to $X_1$ and $X_2$ at its endpoints. Does the optimal density depend on the length of $A$? See Martin--Steenbock~\\cite{MartinSteenbock} and Jankiewicz--Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2280,
            "line_end": 2284,
            "char_start": 161964,
            "char_end": 162513
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "prob:line:2285",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.4",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a relatively hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that there is a density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated (and relatively hyperbolic).",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G$ be a relatively hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that there is a density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated (and relatively hyperbolic).",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2285,
            "line_end": 2288,
            "char_start": 162515,
            "char_end": 162763
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "prob:line:2289",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.5",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be an acylindrically hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that there is a density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G$ be an acylindrically hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that there is a density at which random quotients of $G$ are cubulated.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2289,
            "line_end": 2292,
            "char_start": 162765,
            "char_end": 162990
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "prob:line:2295",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.6",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Generalize \\Cref{Thm:main} to cubulated hyperbolic groups with torsion.",
          "argument_gist": "Generalize \\Cref{Thm:main} to cubulated hyperbolic groups with torsion.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2295,
            "line_end": 2298,
            "char_start": 163068,
            "char_end": 163163
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "prob:line:2303",
          "kind": "prob",
          "label": "Prob 7.7",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a non-elementary relatively hyperbolic group. Prove that there is a density such that all low-density quotients of $G$ are again relatively hyperbolic. Note that the (torsion-free) hyperbolic case was already handled by Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G$ be a non-elementary relatively hyperbolic group. Prove that there is a density such that all low-density quotients of $G$ are again relatively hyperbolic. Note that the (torsion-free) hyperbolic case was already handled by Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2303,
            "line_end": 2306,
            "char_start": 163675,
            "char_end": 163971
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
          "kind": "conj",
          "label": "Conj 7.8",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $M = \\HH^n / \\Gamma$ be a closed hyperbolic $n$--manifold. Assume that either $n \\leq 3$ or that $M$ is arithmetic of simplest type. Then, for every $\\lambda > 1$, $M$ is homotopy equivalent to a compact non-positively curved cube complex $X$ such that there is a $\\Gamma$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde X$ to $\\widetilde M$.",
          "argument_gist": "Let $M = \\HH^n / \\Gamma$ be a closed hyperbolic $n$--manifold. Assume that either $n \\leq 3$ or that $M$ is arithmetic of simplest type. Then, for every $\\lambda > 1$, $M$ is homotopy equivalent to a compact non-positively curved cube complex $X$ such that there is a $\\Gamma$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde X$ to $\\widetilde M$.",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2311,
            "line_end": 2314,
            "char_start": 164111,
            "char_end": 164525
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Ques:OptimalCubulation",
          "kind": "question",
          "label": "Question 7.9",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Let $G$ be a cubulated, hyperbolic group that acts geometrically on a metric space $\\Upsilon$. Is it true that for every $\\lambda > 1$, there exists a (proper, cocompact) $G$--action on a non-positively curved cube complex $\\widetilde X$, admitting a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$?",
          "argument_gist": "Let $G$ be a cubulated, hyperbolic group that acts geometrically on a metric space $\\Upsilon$. Is it true that for every $\\lambda > 1$, there exists a (proper, cocompact) $G$--action on a non-positively curved cube complex $\\widetilde X$, admitting a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$?",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2325,
            "line_end": 2328,
            "char_start": 166163,
            "char_end": 166554
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "kind": "question",
          "label": "Question 7.10",
          "title": "",
          "section": "Sec:Problems",
          "statement": "Suppose, as in \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, that $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Suppose $G$ is hyperbolic, and acts properly and cocompactly on a geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$. Consider a cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$. Let $D = \\diameter(X)$. For $\\epsilon > 0$, a piece $P$ of $X^*$ is called $\\Upsilon$--typical if there are points $x,y \\in P$ realizing $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) = \\diameter(P)$, and an $\\Upsilon$--typical group element $g \\in G$ such that $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(gx, y) \\leq D$. Recall that $\\Upsilon$--typical group elements are defined in \\Cref{Eqn:UpsilonTypical}, using an additive constant $\\epsilon$. Suppose that $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ have been sampled uniformly from among all the conjugacy classes satisfying $\\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\leq \\ell$, and $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is the cubical presentation associated to $G / \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$. What is the distribution of pieces (above a certain threshold of diameter)? Is it true that with overwhelming probability, all sufficiently large pieces of $X^*$ are $\\Upsilon$--typical?",
          "argument_gist": "Suppose, as in \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, that $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Suppose $G$ is hyperbolic, and acts properly and cocompactly on a geodesic metric space $\\Upsilon$. Consider a cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$. Let $D = \\diameter(X)$. For $\\epsilon > 0$, a piece $P$ of $X^*$ is called $\\Upsilon$--typical if there are points $x,y \\in P$ realizing $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) = \\diameter(P)$, and an $\\Upsilon$--typical group element $g \\in G$ such that $\\dist_{\\",
          "gist_origin": "extractive_statement",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2331,
            "line_end": 2340,
            "char_start": 166671,
            "char_end": 167924
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "manuscript",
          "kind": "paper",
          "label": "Cubulating random quotients of hyperbolic cubulated groups",
          "argument_gist": "The intended theorem is stability of hyperbolicity and cocompact cubulation under sufficiently sparse random conjugacy-class quotients of a hyperbolic cubulated group. Relators are thickened from axes to compact convex quasi-circles. The probabilistic core must show that overlaps with other relators and hyperplane carriers occupy less than a prescribed fraction of each relator. A deterministic antipodal-wall construction then produces a dual cube complex, with primitivity ensuring freeness. The principal bottlenecks are the cyclic self-overlap encoding, the exact hypotheses and conclusions of the imported cubulation machinery, and the historical availability of the axis input.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1,
            "line_end": 2607,
            "char_start": 0,
            "char_end": 177992
          },
          "gist_origin": "review_model"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:Lambda12",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:Lambda12",
          "owner": "section:1",
          "section": "section:1",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 328,
            "line_end": 329,
            "char_start": 18089,
            "char_end": 18109
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "h $\\lambda_1 \\lambda_2 = \\lambda$, where every pair of points $x,y \\in X$ satisfies \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) - \\epsilon \\: \\leq \\: \\dist_{\\Upsilon} (f(x), f(y)) \\: \\leq \\: \\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon. The product $\\lambda_1 \\lambda_2 = \\lambda$ remains unchanged if the metric on one of the spaces $\\widetilde X$ or $\\Upsilon$"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "owner": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 442,
            "line_end": 442,
            "char_start": 29348,
            "char_end": 29371
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "\\xi_G(\\Upsilon)$, such that the following hold for $n \\geq n_0$. [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item The total number $f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n)$ of elements that translate a basepoint $x \\in \\Upsilon$ by distance at most $n$ satisfies \\[ A e^{bn} \\leq f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n) \\leq B e^{bn} . \\] \\item The number $p_n$ of primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ sa"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "owner": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "section": "sec:growth",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 446,
            "line_end": 447,
            "char_start": 29558,
            "char_end": 29585
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "silon$ by distance at most $n$ satisfies \\[ A e^{bn} \\leq f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n) \\leq B e^{bn} . \\] \\item The number $p_n$ of primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ satisfies \\[ A \\frac{e^{bn}}{n} \\leq p_n \\leq B e^{bn} . \\] Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\ci"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:CubicalPres",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:CubicalPres",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 553,
            "line_end": 554,
            "char_start": 36402,
            "char_end": 36425
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ch wall. Unlike the setting of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, $\\pi_1 X$ is not hyperbolic in this example.} [$B(6)$ and $B(8)$ conditions] Suppose that $X^*= \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is a $C'(\\frac{1}{12})$ cubical presentation. A $B(6)$ structure on $X^*$ consists of a wallspace structure on each $Y_i$, which is preserved by its automorphism"
        },
        {
          "id": "B6:wallspace",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "B6:wallspace",
          "owner": "Def:B6",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 560,
            "line_end": 560,
            "char_start": 36879,
            "char_end": 36899
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "n (see \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for an example). More precisely: [\\:\\: ($1$)] \\item The collection of hyperplanes of each $Y_i$ is partitioned into classes satisfying the following conditions. No two hyperplanes in the same class cross or osculate; in particular, the carrier of each hyperplane $u_j$ embeds. The union $U = \\cup u_j$ of the hyperplanes in a class is called a \\emph{"
        },
        {
          "id": "B6:aut",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "B6:aut",
          "owner": "Def:B6",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 564,
            "line_end": 564,
            "char_start": 37425,
            "char_end": 37439
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "erleftarrow{U} \\cup \\overrightarrow{U}$ and $U = \\overleftarrow{U} \\cap \\overrightarrow{U}$. \\item $\\Aut(Y_i\\rightarrow X)$ preserves the above wallspace structure on $Y_i$. \\item If $P$ is a path in $Y_i$ that is the concatenation of at most 7 piece-paths and $P$ starts and ends on the carrier $N(U)$ of a wall $U$, then $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(U)$. \\end{enum"
        },
        {
          "id": "B6:homotopy",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "B6:homotopy",
          "owner": "Def:B6",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 566,
            "line_end": 566,
            "char_start": 37529,
            "char_end": 37548
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "el{B6:aut} $\\Aut(Y_i\\rightarrow X)$ preserves the above wallspace structure on $Y_i$. \\item If $P$ is a path in $Y_i$ that is the concatenation of at most 7 piece-paths and $P$ starts and ends on the carrier $N(U)$ of a wall $U$, then $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(U)$. The $B(8)$ condition is defined by replacing \\eqref{B6:homotopy} with the stronger condition:"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:B8",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:B8",
          "owner": "Def:B6",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 575,
            "line_end": 575,
            "char_start": 37907,
            "char_end": 37921
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "6:homotopy} with the stronger condition: [\\:\\: ($1'$)] \\setcounter{enumi}{2} \\item If $P$ is a path that is the concatenation of at most 8 piece-paths and $P$ starts and ends on the carrier $N(U)$ of a wall then $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(U)$. In the above, a piece-path in $Y$ is a path in a piece of $Y$. Meanwhile, $\\Aut(Y_i\\rightarrow X"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:B6",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:B6",
          "owner": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 630,
            "line_end": 630,
            "char_start": 40617,
            "char_end": 40631
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ngle X \\mid \\{Y_i\\} \\rangle$ satisfies the following hypotheses: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{14})$ and satisfies the $B(6)$ condition. \\item Each hyperplane of each cone $Y_i$ is piecefully conve"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:Pieceful",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:Pieceful",
          "owner": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 632,
            "line_end": 632,
            "char_start": 40856,
            "char_end": 40876
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "\\item Each hyperplane of each cone $Y_i$ is piecefully convex. \\item For each $Y_i$, each infinite order element of $\\Aut(Y_i)$ is cut by a wall of $Y_i$. \\item Let $\\kappa\\rightarrow Y_i$ be a geodesic with endpoints $p,q$. Let $u_1$ and $u_1'$ be distinct hyper"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:CutWall",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:CutWall",
          "owner": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 633,
            "line_end": 633,
            "char_start": 40939,
            "char_end": 40958
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "\\item Each hyperplane of each cone $Y_i$ is piecefully convex. \\item For each $Y_i$, each infinite order element of $\\Aut(Y_i)$ is cut by a wall of $Y_i$. \\item Let $\\kappa\\rightarrow Y_i$ be a geodesic with endpoints $p,q$. Let $u_1$ and $u_1'$ be distinct hyperplanes in the same wall of $Y_i$. Suppose $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:Separation",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:Separation",
          "owner": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 634,
            "line_end": 634,
            "char_start": 41051,
            "char_end": 41073
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "utWall} For each $Y_i$, each infinite order element of $\\Aut(Y_i)$ is cut by a wall of $Y_i$. \\item Let $\\kappa\\rightarrow Y_i$ be a geodesic with endpoints $p,q$. Let $u_1$ and $u_1'$ be distinct hyperplanes in the same wall of $Y_i$. Suppose $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1$, and either $u_1'$ is $1$--proximate to $q$ or $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1'$. Then there is"
        },
        {
          "id": "fig:KappaAndFriends",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "fig:KappaAndFriends",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 660,
            "line_end": 661,
            "char_start": 42288,
            "char_end": 42315
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "c $\\kappa$, we have to verify that neither $p$ nor $q$ is $2$--proximate to $U_2 = u_2 \\cup u_2'$.} [Proof of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}] Observe that \\Cref{Def:Piece} of the $C'(\\alpha)$ condition involves a strict inequality. Since $X^*$ is a finite $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ presentation, we may choose a constant $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ such that $X^*$ is $C'(\\alpha)$ and such"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:FarHyperplanes",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:FarHyperplanes",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 700,
            "line_end": 700,
            "char_start": 45621,
            "char_end": 45647
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ot u', x') \\nonumber \\\\ & > \\left( \\frac{1}{2} \\systole{Y} - 2^{-m} \\right) - 2 \\alpha \\systole{Y} \\\\ & > 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}, because $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $m$ is chosen so that $2^{-m}$ is tiny. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. In lieu of the $B(6)$ condition of \\Cref{Def:B6}, we will in fact verify the strong"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 701,
            "line_end": 702,
            "char_start": 45678,
            "char_end": 45709
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "Y} - 2^{-m} \\right) - 2 \\alpha \\systole{Y} \\\\ & > 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}, because $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $m$ is chosen so that $2^{-m}$ is tiny. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. In lieu of the $B(6)$ condition of \\Cref{Def:B6}, we will in fact verify the stronger $B(8)$ condition. To check Condition~\\eqref{B6:wallspace}"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:KappaUpper",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:KappaUpper",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 734,
            "line_end": 735,
            "char_start": 48721,
            "char_end": 48743
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "\\dot p, \\dot q) + \\dist(\\dot q, q) \\nonumber \\\\ &< \\frac{1}{2} \\systole{Y} + 2 \\alpha \\systole{Y}. For the lower bound on $|\\kappa|$, recall that there is a wall $U_1 = u_1 \\cup u_1'$ such that $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1$, and either $u_1'$ is $1$--proximate to $q$ or $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1'$. See \\Cref{fig:KappaAndFriends}. If $\\kappa$ intersec"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:KappaLower",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:KappaLower",
          "owner": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "section": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 744,
            "line_end": 745,
            "char_start": 49504,
            "char_end": 49526
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "systole{Y} \\nonumber \\\\ & > \\left( \\frac{1}{2} \\systole{Y} - 2^{-m} \\right) - 3\\alpha \\systole{Y}. Now, let $y$ be the midpoint of $\\kappa$, and let $u_2$ be a hyperplane such that $y \\in N(u_2)$. Let $u_2'$ be the other hyperplane in the same wall $U_2$. We claim that neither $u_2$ nor $u_2'$ is $2$--proximate to $p$ or $q$. To see this, we will check that $\\dist(\\{p, q\\}, u_2) > 2"
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:Loose",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Sec:Loose",
          "owner": "Sec:Pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 798,
            "line_end": 799,
            "char_start": 53458,
            "char_end": 53475
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "c metric spaces in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. \\subsection{Loose pieces and convex hulls of quasi-axes} Let $\\Upsilon$ be a metric space. For any subset $s \\subset \\Upsilon$ and $J > 0$, the notation $\\neb_J(s)$ denotes the closed $J$--neighborhood of $s$. [Quasi-axes] Let $\\widetilde w, \\widetilde w'$ be bi-infinite geodesics in a metric space $\\Upsilon$. We decl"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:HyperplaneInY",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:HyperplaneInY",
          "owner": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 885,
            "line_end": 885,
            "char_start": 60176,
            "char_end": 60201
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "$ in $Y_i$ determines a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w_i$, also of diameter $\\geq d$. \\item Every diameter $\\geq d$ intersection between $\\widetilde Y_i$ and a hyperplane carrier $N(U)$ determines a $J$--loose wall-piece in $\\widetilde w_i$, of diameter $\\geq d$. Furthermore, we may take $J \\leq 3K$, where $K$ is the constant of \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}. \\end{lem"
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:WallPiece",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Sec:WallPiece",
          "owner": "Sec:Pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 908,
            "line_end": 909,
            "char_start": 62160,
            "char_end": 62181
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "intersections will be controlled using $J$--loose wall-pieces. \\subsection{Wall-pieces} Our next goal is to give a criterion on the growth of the number of relators ensuring that with overwhelming probability, the diameter of wall-pieces in a cubical presentation is bounded by $\\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$. We formulate the criterion in terms of loose pieces, for greater applicability in \\"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:WallPieceCyclicPerm",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:WallPieceCyclicPerm",
          "owner": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 962,
            "line_end": 963,
            "char_start": 65802,
            "char_end": 65833
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ct cyclic permutations of $w$, the number of elements in $\\mathcal{U}(n,\\alpha)$ is | \\mathcal{U}(n,\\alpha) | \\leq n \\cdot B e^{a |s| } e^{b |y|} = B n \\, e^{a |s| + b (|w|-|s|) } \\leq B n \\, e^{(a \\alpha + b(1-\\alpha)) n} . Summing over all lengths up to $\\ell$, we obtain: \\sum_{n=1}^\\ell | \\mathcal{U}(n,\\alpha) | & \\leq \\sum_{n=1}^\\ell Bn e^{(a"
        },
        {
          "id": "eq:bigwallpiece propertion",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "eq:bigwallpiece propertion",
          "owner": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 983,
            "line_end": 984,
            "char_start": 66803,
            "char_end": 66837
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "acyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$. Thus \\Pi(\\alpha, \\ell) \\leq \\frac{ \\sum | \\mathcal{U}(n,\\alpha) |}{| \\mathcal{G}(\\ell) |} \\leq \\ell^2 e^{(a-b)\\alpha \\ell } \\cdot \\frac{B } { A (1 - e^{-a } ) }. Among all choices $(w_1,w_2,\\ldots, w_k) \\in \\mathcal{G}(\\ell)^k$, the proportion of $k$--tuples where some $w_i \\in \\ma"
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:ConePiece",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Sec:ConePiece",
          "owner": "Sec:Pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1007,
            "line_end": 1008,
            "char_start": 67771,
            "char_end": 67792
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "l) \\to 0$ as $\\ell \\to \\infty$. \\subsection{Cone-pieces between two closed--geodesics} Our next goal is to control cone-pieces whose diameter is bounded below by a constant $d$. The gist of the following sequence of lemmas is that the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ declines exponentially with $d$. See \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces}. We will need to emplo"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:Overlap",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:Overlap",
          "owner": "Sec:Pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1031,
            "line_end": 1032,
            "char_start": 68995,
            "char_end": 69014
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "e, $h$ reverses orientation on the piece $s$, and $s$ has nontrivial $h$--overlap $[p, h^{-1}p']$.} [Orientation and overlaps] Let $w \\to X$ be a closed--geodesic. Choose distinct preimages $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$ of $w$ and a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. Suppose $s = [p,q] \\subset \\widetilde w$ is a $J$--loose piece between $\\wi"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "owner": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1076,
            "line_end": 1077,
            "char_start": 72257,
            "char_end": 72283
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "h^{-1}p'\\}$. We begin by showing there is a constant $L = L(J, \\delta)$ such that \\dist(x, hy) \\leq L \\quad \\text{and} \\quad \\dist(y, hx) \\leq L. To prove \\eqref{Eqn:EndpointsClose}, we consider two cases. For the first case, suppose that $\\dist(p,h^{-1}q') \\leq 2J$ and $\\dist(q,h^{-1}p') \\leq 2J$. Since $x \\in \\{p, h^{-1}q'\\}$ and $hy \\in \\{p',hq\\}$, triangle"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:SeparateSample",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:SeparateSample",
          "owner": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1139,
            "line_end": 1140,
            "char_start": 75870,
            "char_end": 75896
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "d > 2J$ and all $\\ell$ sufficiently large, the following holds: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item Among all pairs of conjugacy classes $[g], [g']$ of length at most $\\ell$, the proportion whose representative closed--geodesics have a $J$--loose cone piece of diameter $\\geq d$ is less than $M \\ell^2 \\, e^{-b d}$, for a constant $M = M(X, J)$. \\item Among al"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "owner": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1143,
            "line_end": 1144,
            "char_start": 76153,
            "char_end": 76186
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "e of diameter $\\geq d$ is less than $M \\ell^2 \\, e^{-b d}$, for a constant $M = M(X, J)$. \\item Among all conjugacy classes $[g]$ of length at most $\\ell$, the proportion whose representative closed--geodesic has a $J$--loose cone piece with itself, with diameter $\\geq d$ and overlap of length $\\leq R$, is less than $M_0 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, for a constant $M_0 = M_0(X, J, R)$. \\end{enum"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:InitialCountS",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:InitialCountS",
          "owner": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1183,
            "line_end": 1184,
            "char_start": 81647,
            "char_end": 81672
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "of $s$, the number of choices for $(s'y')^{\\pm 1}$ up to path-homotopy is at most 2\\cdot V^2 \\cdot B e^{b|y'|} \\leq 2 V^2 B e^{b(|w| - |s| + 2 J)} \\leq 2 V^2 B e^{b(\\ell - |s| + 2 J)}. Recall that the companion $s'$ is determined by the $J$--loose cone-piece $s \\subset \\widetilde w$. There are $|w| \\leq \\ell$ possible choices of where the projection of $s$ begin"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:ConePieceInitialCount",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:ConePieceInitialCount",
          "owner": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1189,
            "line_end": 1190,
            "char_start": 82342,
            "char_end": 82375
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "h that the $J$--loose cone-piece $s$ has diameter at least $d$, is bounded above by \\sum_{|s| = d}^\\ell \\ell \\cdot 2 V^2 B e^{b(\\ell - |s| + 2 J)} < \\sum_{|s| = d}^\\infty \\ell \\cdot 2 V^2 B e^{b(\\ell - |s| + 2 J)} = \\frac{ 2 V^2 B \\ell \\, e^{b(\\ell-d + 2J) )}}{ 1 - e^{-b} }. By increasing the constant $B$ if needed, we may ensure that the above exponential bound s"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap",
          "owner": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1326,
            "line_end": 1327,
            "char_start": 92141,
            "char_end": 92172
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "is a geodesic of length $\\delta'$ from the endpoint of $y_3$ to some point on $(y_1 x_1)^\\infty$.} Let $\\delta' = \\delta'(\\delta, J)$ be a uniform constant such that $\\eta(\\delta,J)$--quasigeodesic quadrilaterals in $\\widetilde X$ must be $\\delta'$--thin. Then it follows that $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$ and $(y_3 x_3)^\\infty$ are $\\delta'$--fellow-travelers. Since the endpoint of $y_3$ is"
        },
        {
          "id": "Sec:MainProof",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Sec:MainProof",
          "owner": "Sec:Pieces",
          "section": "Sec:Pieces",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1374,
            "line_end": 1375,
            "char_start": 96819,
            "char_end": 96840
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "^{-b \\phi d }. \\qedhere \\] \\subsection{Controlling pieces among many conjugacy classes} We can now apply \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} to bound the probability of a large $J$--loose cone-piece between a pair of conjugacy classes that are sampled from a large collection, where ``large'' is defined as a fraction of the systole. See \\Cref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}. We can then combine this res"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:GeneralConePiece",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:GeneralConePiece",
          "owner": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1558,
            "line_end": 1558,
            "char_start": 110631,
            "char_end": 110659
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "espect to $(\\Upsilon, \\upsilon, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$} if [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item For every $g_i, g_j$, the diameter of any $2\\delta$--loose cone-piece between $\\gamma_i$ and $\\gamma_j$ is less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$. \\item For every $g_i$, any $\\kappa$--loose wall-piece in $\\gamma_i$ has diameter less than $ \\alpha \\stable"
        },
        {
          "id": "Itm:GeneralWallPiece",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Itm:GeneralWallPiece",
          "owner": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1560,
            "line_end": 1560,
            "char_start": 110827,
            "char_end": 110855
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ce between $\\gamma_i$ and $\\gamma_j$ is less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$. \\item For every $g_i$, any $\\kappa$--loose wall-piece in $\\gamma_i$ has diameter less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$. The results of \\Cref{Sec:Pieces} have the following generalization to this context. Let $G$,"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:LambdaRestate",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:LambdaRestate",
          "owner": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1629,
            "line_end": 1630,
            "char_start": 117548,
            "char_end": 117573
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ants $\\lambda_1, \\lambda_2, \\epsilon$ such that $\\lambda_1 \\lambda_2 = \\lambda$ and \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) - \\epsilon \\: \\leq \\: \\dist_{\\Upsilon} (f(x), f(y)) \\: \\leq \\: \\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon. We can now relate the systole of $Y_i$ in $X$ to the (stable) translation length of $g_i$ in $\\Upsilon$. By \\Cref{Def:Piece} an"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:SystoleComparison",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:SystoleComparison",
          "owner": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1638,
            "line_end": 1639,
            "char_start": 118141,
            "char_end": 118170
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "or an arbitrary point $q \\in \\widetilde X$. Letting $q' = f(q) \\in \\Upsilon$ yields \\lambda_2 \\systole{Y_i} \\geq \\lambda_2 \\! \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(q, g_i^n q)}{n} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(q, g_i^n q) + \\epsilon}{n} \\ \\geq \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist_\\Upsilon(q', g_i^n q')}{n} = \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon} ."
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:InfinitelyManyPrimes",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:InfinitelyManyPrimes",
          "owner": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1683,
            "line_end": 1684,
            "char_start": 121586,
            "char_end": 121618
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "tween $\\widetilde \\gamma_i$ and $\\widetilde \\gamma_j$ will contain the segment $[x_i''', y_i''']$.} Observe that the second inequality in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate} gives \\[ \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i'', x_j'') \\leq \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i', x_j') + 2 \\eta \\leq \\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x_i, x_j) + \\epsilon + 2 \\eta \\leq \\lambda_2 \\cdot 2K + \\epsilon + 2 \\eta. \\] and similarly $\\dist_\\Upsil"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:PieceDistortionUpsilon",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:PieceDistortionUpsilon",
          "owner": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1693,
            "line_end": 1694,
            "char_start": 122070,
            "char_end": 122104
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "+ 2 \\eta$. At the same time, the first inequality in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate} gives \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i'', y_i'') \\geq \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i', y_i') - 2 \\eta \\geq \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x_i, y_i) - \\epsilon - 2 \\eta \\geq \\frac{d - 2K}{\\lambda_1} - \\epsilon - 2 \\eta. Thus, when $d$ is sufficiently large, we have $\\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i'', y_i'') > 2 \\lambda"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:MeanDistortion",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:MeanDistortion",
          "owner": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1862,
            "line_end": 1863,
            "char_start": 135640,
            "char_end": 135666
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "fine the mean distortion of $\\widetilde X$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ to be \\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) \\: = \\: \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{1}{f_{G,\\Upsilon}(n)} \\sum_{g \\in B_n(\\Upsilon)} \\"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:UpsilonTypical",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:UpsilonTypical",
          "owner": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "section": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1879,
            "line_end": 1880,
            "char_start": 136938,
            "char_end": 136964
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ment $g \\in G$ or a conjugacy class $[g]$ is called $\\Upsilon$--typical if \\left(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) - \\epsilon\\right) \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\leq \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_X} \\leq \\left(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) + \\epsilon\\right) \\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon}. For each $\\epsilon > 0$, a conjugacy class sampled uniformly from all those of $\\"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:ALength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:ALength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1923,
            "line_end": 1923,
            "char_start": 141669,
            "char_end": 141688
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "{align} a &= \\arccosh \\big( \\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 0.5306. \\\\ b &= \\arccosh \\left( \\tfrac{1}{\\sqrt{1-K}} \\right) \\approx 0.6269. \\\\ c &= \\arccosh(K+1) \\approx 0.7672. \\\\ d &= \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265."
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:BLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:BLength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1924,
            "line_end": 1924,
            "char_start": 141759,
            "char_end": 141778
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "x 0.5306. \\\\ b &= \\arccosh \\left( \\tfrac{1}{\\sqrt{1-K}} \\right) \\approx 0.6269. \\\\ c &= \\arccosh(K+1) \\approx 0.7672. \\\\ d &= \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. \\begin{fig"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:CLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:CLength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1925,
            "line_end": 1925,
            "char_start": 141818,
            "char_end": 141837
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "c{1}{\\sqrt{1-K}} \\right) \\approx 0.6269. \\\\ c &= \\arccosh(K+1) \\approx 0.7672. \\\\ d &= \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. [width=2in]{PentagonLengths.pdf} \\put(3"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:DLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:DLength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1926,
            "line_end": 1926,
            "char_start": 141887,
            "char_end": 141906
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "\\arccosh(K+1) \\approx 0.7672. \\\\ d &= \\arccosh(2 K^2 + 2K + 1) \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. [width=2in]{PentagonLengths.pdf} \\put(35,-2){$a$} \\put(60,-2){$a$} \\put(12,13){$a$} \\put(84,13){$a$} \\put(4,"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:ELength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:ELength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1927,
            "line_end": 1927,
            "char_start": 141969,
            "char_end": 141988
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": ") \\approx 1.1989. \\\\ e &= \\arccosh \\big( (2K+1)\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. [width=2in]{PentagonLengths.pdf} \\put(35,-2){$a$} \\put(60,-2){$a$} \\put(12,13){$a$} \\put(84,13){$a$} \\put(4,42){$a$} \\put(93,42){$a$} \\put(12,69){$a$} \\put(84,69){$a$} \\put(35,86){$a$} \\put("
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:FLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:FLength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1928,
            "line_end": 1929,
            "char_start": 142035,
            "char_end": 142054
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": ")\\sqrt{K+1} \\big) \\approx 1.2265. \\\\ f &= \\arccosh(4K^2 + 4K+1) \\approx 1.6169. [width=2in]{PentagonLengths.pdf} \\put(35,-2){$a$} \\put(60,-2){$a$} \\put(12,13){$a$} \\put(84,13){$a$} \\put(4,42){$a$} \\put(93,42){$a$} \\put(12,69){$a$} \\put(84,69){$a$} \\put(35,86){$a$} \\put(61,86){$a$} \\put(36,60){$b$} \\put(58,60){$b$} \\put(28,37){$b$} \\pu"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1967,
            "line_end": 1968,
            "char_start": 142830,
            "char_end": 142857
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "{overpic} \\caption{Lengths in a right-angled pentagon, as computed in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. } Furthermore, the length $g$ of a geodesic segment contained in two adjacent right-angled pentagons, as in \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, satisfies 2g = \\arccosh(1+2K (8 K^2+8K+1)^2) \\approx 3.1838."
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:GLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:GLength",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1972,
            "line_end": 1973,
            "char_start": 143081,
            "char_end": 143100
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "ef{Fig:PentagonLengths}, satisfies 2g = \\arccosh(1+2K (8 K^2+8K+1)^2) \\approx 3.1838. In \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, left, the right-angled pentagon $P$ is subdivided into five isometric quadrilaterals, arranged symmetrically about the center point of $P$. Each quadrilateral $Q$ has tw"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1994,
            "line_end": 1995,
            "char_start": 144402,
            "char_end": 144435
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "iangle, with legs of length $x,y$ and hypotenuse of length $z$, the lengths satisfy \\cosh x \\cdot \\cosh y = \\cosh z. Now, consider the distances between the midpoints of edges in the right-angled pentagon $P$. By \\eqref{Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean}, the midpoints of two adjacent edges are separated by distance $c$, where \\[ \\cosh c = \\cosh^2 a = \\sinh^2 a + 1 = K +"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:Fenchel",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:Fenchel",
          "owner": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2034,
            "line_end": 2035,
            "char_start": 146054,
            "char_end": 146073
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "block of displayed equations on \\cite[page 88]{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry}, we have \\cosh(2g) = - \\sinh^2(4a) + \\cosh^2(4a) \\cosh(2a). Above, we have already computed that $\\cosh(2a)=2K+1$, hence \\[ \\cosh(4a) = 2 \\cosh^2(2a) - 1 = 8 K^2 + 8K + 1. \\] Substituting all this into \\Cref{Eqn:Fenchel} gives \\cosh(2g) & = - \\sinh^2(4a) + \\cosh^2(4a) \\cosh(2a"
        },
        {
          "id": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "owner": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2057,
            "line_end": 2058,
            "char_start": 147422,
            "char_end": 147445
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "(x,y) - \\epsilon \\: \\leq \\: \\dist_\\HH(x,y) \\: \\leq \\: d \\cdot \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon, where the constants $c,d$ are as in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Furthermore, the multiplicative constants $c,d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} are sharp. Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$. Thus \\Cref{Prop:Pentagonal"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:Shortcut",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:Shortcut",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2080,
            "line_end": 2081,
            "char_start": 148483,
            "char_end": 148503
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "c$ and $d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} is demonstrated by the right and left panels, respectively.} We begin by proving the second inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube}. Let $w \\to \\widetilde X$ be a combinatorial geodesic in $\\widetilde X$ with endpoints $x, y \\in \\widetilde X^{0}$. By choosing a sufficiently large additive constant $\\epsilon$, we may assume without l"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:Altitudes",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:Altitudes",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2115,
            "line_end": 2116,
            "char_start": 150679,
            "char_end": 150700
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "cutting through a right-angled pentagon, and the altitude $\\ell$ altitude associated to each $s$.} To prove the first inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube}, with its optimal multiplicative constant, we make the following definitions. An altitude of a right-angled pentagon $P$ is a geodesic segment $\\ell$ from a vertex to the midpoint of the opposite edge. If $s \\subset P$ i"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:Types",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:Types",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2146,
            "line_end": 2147,
            "char_start": 153112,
            "char_end": 153129
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "$\\gamma$ both enters and exits $P \\cup P'$ through sides adjacent to the shared side $P \\cap P'$.} There are five combinatorial possibilities for a segment $\\gamma_i$ between two altitudes, corresponding to five types of intersections between $\\gamma$ and two adjacent pentagons. See \\Cref{Fig:Types}. If $\\ell$ and $\\ell'$ are the altitudes in adjacent pentagons $P$ and $P'$, respe"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:TypesWithLengths",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:TypesWithLengths",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2186,
            "line_end": 2187,
            "char_start": 154534,
            "char_end": 154562
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "nd two adjacent pentagons, the highlighted segment shows the infimal length between the altitudes.} In type I, \\Cref{Fig:TypesWithLengths} shows that the worst-case scenario for $\\len(\\gamma_i)$ is $a \\approx 0.5306$; since $a < c$, this complicated case is analyzed below. In type II, \\Cref{Fig:TypesWithLengths} shows that we always have $\\len(\\gamma_i) \\geq 2a > c$. In type III, w"
        },
        {
          "id": "Claim:AdjacentType",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Claim:AdjacentType",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2194,
            "line_end": 2194,
            "char_start": 155299,
            "char_end": 155325
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "o analyze segments $\\gamma_i$ of type I. We claim the following: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item If $\\gamma_i$ is of type I, and $2 < i < n-1$, then there is an adjacent index $j = i \\pm 1$ such that the corresponding segment $\\gamma_j$ is of type II, III, or IV. \\item If $\\gamma_j$ is of type II or IV, then $\\gamma_i$ is the only type--I segment adjacent to $\\g"
        },
        {
          "id": "Claim:AdjacentII",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Claim:AdjacentII",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2196,
            "line_end": 2196,
            "char_start": 155499,
            "char_end": 155523
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "index $j = i \\pm 1$ such that the corresponding segment $\\gamma_j$ is of type II, III, or IV. \\item If $\\gamma_j$ is of type II or IV, then $\\gamma_i$ is the only type--I segment adjacent to $\\gamma_j$. \\item For all types of $\\gamma_j$, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i) + \\len(\\gamma_j) \\geq \\min(3a, g) > 2c$. \\item If $\\gamma_j$ is of type III, an"
        },
        {
          "id": "Claim:TotalLength",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Claim:TotalLength",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2197,
            "line_end": 2197,
            "char_start": 155640,
            "char_end": 155665
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "of type II or IV, then $\\gamma_i$ is the only type--I segment adjacent to $\\gamma_j$. \\item For all types of $\\gamma_j$, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i) + \\len(\\gamma_j) \\geq \\min(3a, g) > 2c$. \\item If $\\gamma_j$ is of type III, and furthermore $\\gamma_j$ also adjacent to a type--I segment $\\gamma_{k}$ where $k = i \\pm 2$, then $\\len(\\gamma_i) + \\len(\\gamma_j) + \\len(\\ga"
        },
        {
          "id": "Claim:AdjacentIII",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Claim:AdjacentIII",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2198,
            "line_end": 2198,
            "char_start": 155765,
            "char_end": 155790
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "For all types of $\\gamma_j$, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i) + \\len(\\gamma_j) \\geq \\min(3a, g) > 2c$. \\item If $\\gamma_j$ is of type III, and furthermore $\\gamma_j$ also adjacent to a type--I segment $\\gamma_{k}$ where $k = i \\pm 2$, then $\\len(\\gamma_i) + \\len(\\gamma_j) + \\len(\\gamma_k) \\geq 2e > 3c$. Assuming these claims, we can complete the proof as follows. By Claim~\\ref{Claim:Adjac"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:TypeINeighbors",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:TypeINeighbors",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2222,
            "line_end": 2223,
            "char_start": 157346,
            "char_end": 157372
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "nt of type I. The next segment of $\\gamma$ in pentagons $Q \\cup R$ must be of type II, III, or IV.} \\Cref{Fig:TypeINeighbors} illustrates the proof of Claims~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}. The geodesic $\\gamma$ intersects the left-most pair of pentagons $\\{P, Q\\}$ in a segment $\\gamma_i \\subset \\gamma$ of type I. We assume without loss of generality that the in"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:LengthTwoSegments",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:LengthTwoSegments",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2244,
            "line_end": 2245,
            "char_start": 159181,
            "char_end": 159210
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "}$ are highlighted. In type III, $\\gamma_{i+1}$ must intersect $\\ell_{\\rm II}$ or $\\ell_{\\rm IV}$.} For the three combinatorial types of $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$, \\Cref{Fig:LengthTwoSegments} illustrates the infimal lengths of $(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j)$. Let $\\ell_{\\rm II}, \\ell_{\\rm III}, \\ell_{\\rm IV}$ be the terminal altitudes for the three possible types of $\\gamma_j$. If $\\ga"
        },
        {
          "id": "Fig:LengthThreeSegments",
          "kind": "anchor",
          "label": "Fig:LengthThreeSegments",
          "owner": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "section": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2258,
            "line_end": 2259,
            "char_start": 160736,
            "char_end": 160767
          },
          "argument_gist": "",
          "excerpt": "uration, each half of $(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_{i+1} \\cup \\gamma_{i+2})$ is a segment of length $e$.} Finally, \\Cref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments} illustrates the proof of Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentIII}. If $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$ is of type III and $\\gamma_i, \\gamma_{i+2}$ are both of type I, then the shortest possible length of $(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j \\cup \\gamma_k)$ is $2e > 3c$, wh"
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Agol:VirtualHaken",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Ago13] Agol:VirtualHaken",
          "bibliography_key": "Agol:VirtualHaken",
          "bibliography_number": "Ago13",
          "title": "Ian Agol. \\newblock The virtual {H}aken conjecture. \\newblock {\\em Doc. Math.}, 18:1045--1087, 2013. \\newblock With an appendix by Agol, Daniel Groves, and Jason Manning.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2350,
            "line_end": 2356,
            "char_start": 168600,
            "char_end": 168807
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[AM15] AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative",
          "bibliography_key": "AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative",
          "bibliography_number": "AM15",
          "title": "Yago Antol\\'{\\i}n and Ashot Minasyan. \\newblock Tits alternatives for graph products. \\newblock {\\em J. Reine Angew. Math.}, 704:55--83, 2015.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2356,
            "line_end": 2361,
            "char_start": 168807,
            "char_end": 168999
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Ashcroft:PropertyT",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Ash22a] Ashcroft:PropertyT",
          "bibliography_key": "Ashcroft:PropertyT",
          "bibliography_number": "Ash22a",
          "title": "Calum~J. Ashcroft. \\newblock Property {(T)} in random quotients of hyperbolic groups at densities above 1/3. \\newblock arXiv:2202.12318, 2022.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2361,
            "line_end": 2367,
            "char_start": 168999,
            "char_end": 169182
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Ashcroft:Cubulation",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Ash22b] Ashcroft:Cubulation",
          "bibliography_key": "Ashcroft:Cubulation",
          "bibliography_number": "Ash22b",
          "title": "Calum~J. Ashcroft. \\newblock Random groups do not have {Property (T)} at densities below 1/4. \\newblock arxiv:2206.14616, 2022.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2367,
            "line_end": 2372,
            "char_start": 169182,
            "char_end": 169349
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:BridsonHaefliger",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[BH99] BridsonHaefliger",
          "bibliography_key": "BridsonHaefliger",
          "bibliography_number": "BH99",
          "title": "Martin~R. Bridson and Andr{\\'e} Haefliger. \\newblock {\\em Metric spaces of non-positive curvature}. \\newblock Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1999.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2372,
            "line_end": 2377,
            "char_start": 169349,
            "char_end": 169524
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:BergeronHaglundWiseSimple",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[BHW11] BergeronHaglundWiseSimple",
          "bibliography_key": "BergeronHaglundWiseSimple",
          "bibliography_number": "BHW11",
          "title": "Nicolas Bergeron, Fr{\\'e}d{\\'e}ric Haglund, and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Hyperplane sections in arithmetic hyperbolic manifolds. \\newblock {\\em J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2)}, 83(2):431--448, 2011.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2377,
            "line_end": 2382,
            "char_start": 169524,
            "char_end": 169761
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[BR] BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "bibliography_key": "BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "bibliography_number": "BR",
          "title": "Nic Brody and Eduardo Reyes. \\newblock Approximating hyperbolic lattices by cubulations. \\newblock In preparation.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2382,
            "line_end": 2387,
            "char_start": 169761,
            "char_end": 169924
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Can84] cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
          "bibliography_key": "cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
          "bibliography_number": "Can84",
          "title": "James~W. Cannon. \\newblock The combinatorial structure of cocompact discrete hyperbolic groups. \\newblock {\\em Geom. Dedicata}, 16(2):123--148, 1984.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2387,
            "line_end": 2392,
            "char_start": 169924,
            "char_end": 170120
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 4, invoked as a local-to-global principle converting uniformly controlled local quasi-geodesics into global quasi-geodesics.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The ambient geodesic space is delta-hyperbolic.",
                "The periodic path has suitable local quasi-geodesic constants on a scale exceeding the local-to-global threshold.",
                "The cited theorem must apply in this generality, not only to the geometric setting of its original formulation."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[CK02] CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "bibliography_key": "CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "bibliography_number": "CK02",
          "title": "Michel Coornaert and Gerhard Knieper. \\newblock Growth of conjugacy classes in {G}romov hyperbolic groups. \\newblock {\\em Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 12(3):464--478, 2002.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2392,
            "line_end": 2397,
            "char_start": 170120,
            "char_end": 170323
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, used for the primitive conjugacy-class bounds A exp(bn)/n <= p_n <= B exp(bn).",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The exact source hypotheses must cover the group action and the manuscript's notion of primitive conjugacy class.",
                "The length convention must agree with translation length, or differ from it by a uniformly bounded amount."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Coornaert93",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Coo93] Coornaert93",
          "bibliography_key": "Coornaert93",
          "bibliography_number": "Coo93",
          "title": "Michel Coornaert. \\newblock M\\'esures de {P}atterson--{S}ullivan sur le bord d'un \\'espace hyperbolique au sens de {G}romov. \\newblock {\\em Pacific J. Math.}, 159(2):241--270, 1993.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2397,
            "line_end": 2403,
            "char_start": 170323,
            "char_end": 170537
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 7.12, used for A exp(bn) <= f(n) <= B exp(bn).",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "A nonelementary group acts properly and cocompactly on a hyperbolic space satisfying the source's geometric hypotheses.",
                "The growth exponent is computed in that same orbit metric."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[CR23a] CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "bibliography_key": "CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "bibliography_number": "CR23a",
          "title": "Stephen Cantrell and Eduardo Reyes. \\newblock Marked length spectrum rigidity from rigidity on subsets. \\newblock arXiv:2304.13209, 2023.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2403,
            "line_end": 2408,
            "char_start": 170537,
            "char_end": 170728
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "A claimed deduction from Equation (5.2) establishing typicality for conjugacy classes in general Upsilon.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The needed equation and deduction were available in a version on or before April 24, 2023.",
                "The result covers both metrics and the conjugacy-class sampling measure used here."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[CR23b] CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
          "bibliography_key": "CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
          "bibliography_number": "CR23b",
          "title": "Stephen Cantrell and Eduardo Reyes. \\newblock Rigidity phenomena and the statistical properties of group actions on {CAT(0)} cube complexes. \\newblock arXiv:2310.10595, 2023.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2408,
            "line_end": 2414,
            "char_start": 170728,
            "char_end": 170951
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
              "role": "excluded",
              "claimed_role": "excluded",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "",
              "required_hypotheses": []
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:CapraceSageev2011",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[CS11] CapraceSageev2011",
          "bibliography_key": "CapraceSageev2011",
          "bibliography_number": "CS11",
          "title": "Pierre-Emmanuel Caprace and Michah Sageev. \\newblock Rank rigidity for {CAT}(0) cube complexes. \\newblock {\\em Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 21(4):851--891, 2011.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2414,
            "line_end": 2419,
            "char_start": 170951,
            "char_end": 171140
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:main",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Proposition 3.5, used to replace the action by an essential convex core without changing the growth exponents or the relevant coarse geometry.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The original proper cocompact cubical action must satisfy the hypotheses of the essential-core proposition.",
                "The selected core must be invariant, convex, and cocompact.",
                "Its essential hyperplane stabilizers must correspond to those used in the definition of a."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[CT21] CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "bibliography_key": "CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "bibliography_number": "CT21",
          "title": "Stephen Cantrell and Ryokichi Tanaka. \\newblock The manhattan curve, ergodic theory of topological flows and rigidity. \\newblock arXiv:2104.13451, 2021.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2419,
            "line_end": 2425,
            "char_start": 171140,
            "char_end": 171342
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Equation (1.1), Theorem 1.2, and Theorem 4.23, used respectively for existence of mean distortion and a large-deviation typicality statement in the Cayley-graph setting.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The pair of metrics lies in the metric class covered by the cited version.",
                "The large-deviation statement applies to the manuscript's sampling of conjugacy classes, or a conversion from element sampling is supplied."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[DFW19] DahmaniFuterWise",
          "bibliography_key": "DahmaniFuterWise",
          "bibliography_number": "DFW19",
          "title": "Fran\\c{c}ois Dahmani, David Futer, and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Growth of quasiconvex subgroups. \\newblock {\\em Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc.}, 167(3):505--530, 2019.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2425,
            "line_end": 2430,
            "char_start": 171342,
            "char_end": 171550
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, invoked for existence of growth exponents and strict growth separation of an infinite-index quasiconvex subgroup.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "G is a nonelementary hyperbolic group.",
                "H is quasiconvex and infinite index.",
                "The ambient action satisfies the source theorem's metric-space hypotheses; those hypotheses must be checked rather than replaced by arbitrary proper cocompact metric actions."
              ]
            },
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
              "role": "background",
              "claimed_role": "background",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "",
              "required_hypotheses": []
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:DGO",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[DGO17] DGO",
          "bibliography_key": "DGO",
          "bibliography_number": "DGO17",
          "title": "Fran\\c{c}ois Dahmani, Vincent Guirardel, and Denis~V. Osin. \\newblock Hyperbolically embedded subgroups and rotating families in groups acting on hyperbolic spaces. \\newblock {\\em Mem. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 245(1156):v+152, 2017.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2430,
            "line_end": 2436,
            "char_start": 171550,
            "char_end": 171801
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:DavisJan00",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[DJ00] DavisJan00",
          "bibliography_key": "DavisJan00",
          "bibliography_number": "DJ00",
          "title": "Michael~W. Davis and Tadeusz Januszkiewicz. \\newblock Right-angled {A}rtin groups are commensurable with right-angled {C}oxeter groups. \\newblock {\\em J. Pure Appl. Algebra}, 153(3):229--235, 2000.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2436,
            "line_end": 2442,
            "char_start": 171801,
            "char_end": 172029
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Duong:Thesis",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Duo17] Duong:Thesis",
          "bibliography_key": "Duong:Thesis",
          "bibliography_number": "Duo17",
          "title": "Yen Duong. \\newblock {\\em On Random Groups: the Square Model at Density $d < 1/3$ and as Quotients of Free Nilpotent Groups}. \\newblock PhD thesis, University of Illinois at Chicago, 2017.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2442,
            "line_end": 2448,
            "char_start": 172029,
            "char_end": 172251
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Fen89] Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "bibliography_key": "Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "bibliography_number": "Fen89",
          "title": "Werner Fenchel. \\newblock {\\em Elementary geometry in hyperbolic space}, volume~11 of {\\em de Gruyter Studies in Mathematics}. \\newblock Walter de Gruyter \\& Co., Berlin, 1989. \\newblock With an editorial by Heinz Bauer.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2448,
            "line_end": 2455,
            "char_start": 172251,
            "char_end": 172519
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "The page-88 quadrilateral identity cosh(2g)=-sinh^2(4a)+cosh^2(4a)cosh(2a).",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The quadrilateral has two right angles at the ends of the side of length 2a.",
                "The adjacent sides both have length 4a.",
                "The side configuration matches the cited formula."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Fur02] Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective",
          "bibliography_key": "Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective",
          "bibliography_number": "Fur02",
          "title": "Alex Furman. \\newblock Coarse-geometric perspective on negatively curved manifolds and groups. \\newblock In {\\em Rigidity in dynamics and geometry ({C}ambridge, 2000)}, pages 149--166. Springer, Berlin, 2002.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2455,
            "line_end": 2462,
            "char_start": 172519,
            "char_end": 172784
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:GrovesManning2008",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[GM08] GrovesManning2008",
          "bibliography_key": "GrovesManning2008",
          "bibliography_number": "GM08",
          "title": "Daniel Groves and Jason~Fox Manning. \\newblock Dehn filling in relatively hyperbolic groups. \\newblock {\\em Israel J. Math.}, 168:317--429, 2008.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2462,
            "line_end": 2467,
            "char_start": 172784,
            "char_end": 172965
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Gromov93",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Gro93] Gromov93",
          "bibliography_key": "Gromov93",
          "bibliography_number": "Gro93",
          "title": "Mikhail Gromov. \\newblock Asymptotic invariants of infinite groups. \\newblock In {\\em Geometric group theory, Vol.\\ 2 (Sussex, 1991)}, pages 1--295. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1993.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2467,
            "line_end": 2473,
            "char_start": 172965,
            "char_end": 173183
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:HaglundSemiSimple",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Hag23] HaglundSemiSimple",
          "bibliography_key": "HaglundSemiSimple",
          "bibliography_number": "Hag23",
          "title": "Fr\\'{e}d\\'{e}ric Haglund. \\newblock Isometries of {CAT(0)} cube complexes are semi-simple. \\newblock {\\em Ann. Math. Qu\\'{e}.}, 47(2):249--261, 2023.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2473,
            "line_end": 2478,
            "char_start": 173183,
            "char_end": 173369
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:C'20Proper",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "After cubical subdivision, the generator of the relevant cyclic stabilizer has an invariant combinatorial geodesic axis.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The isometry acts on the relevant CAT(0) cube complex.",
                "The subdivision removes the obstruction addressed by the source's axis theorem.",
                "The resulting axis lies in the invariant convex subcomplex under consideration."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Huber",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Hub59] Huber",
          "bibliography_key": "Huber",
          "bibliography_number": "Hub59",
          "title": "Heinz Huber. \\newblock Zur analytischen {T}heorie hyperbolischen {R}aumformen und {B}ewegungsgruppen. \\newblock {\\em Math. Ann.}, 138:1--26, 1959.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2478,
            "line_end": 2484,
            "char_start": 173369,
            "char_end": 173542
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Cor:H2Action",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "The curvature-minus-one compact hyperbolic surface growth exponent is 1.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The surface group is a cocompact lattice in Isom(H^2).",
                "Lengths are measured in the curvature-minus-one hyperbolic metric."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:HsuWiseGraphProducts",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[HW99] HsuWiseGraphProducts",
          "bibliography_key": "HsuWiseGraphProducts",
          "bibliography_number": "HW99",
          "title": "Tim Hsu and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock On linear and residual properties of graph products. \\newblock {\\em Michigan Math. J.}, 46(2):251--259, 1999.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2484,
            "line_end": 2489,
            "char_start": 173542,
            "char_end": 173728
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:HaglundWiseCoxeter",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[HW10] HaglundWiseCoxeter",
          "bibliography_key": "HaglundWiseCoxeter",
          "bibliography_number": "HW10",
          "title": "Fr{\\'e}d{\\'e}ric Haglund and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Coxeter groups are virtually special. \\newblock {\\em Adv. Math.}, 224(5):1890--1903, 2010.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2489,
            "line_end": 2494,
            "char_start": 173728,
            "char_end": 173910
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:JankiewiczWise",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[JW22] JankiewiczWise",
          "bibliography_key": "JankiewiczWise",
          "bibliography_number": "JW22",
          "title": "Kasia Jankiewicz and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Cubulating small cancellation free products. \\newblock {\\em Indiana Univ. Math. J.}, 71(4):1397--1409, 2022.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2494,
            "line_end": 2499,
            "char_start": 173910,
            "char_end": 174098
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:KotowskiSquared",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[KK13] KotowskiSquared",
          "bibliography_key": "KotowskiSquared",
          "bibliography_number": "KK13",
          "title": "Marcin Kotowski and Micha\\l{ } Kotowski. \\newblock Random groups and property {$(T)$}: \\.{Z}uk's theorem revisited. \\newblock {\\em J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2)}, 88(2):396--416, 2013.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2499,
            "line_end": 2504,
            "char_start": 174098,
            "char_end": 174310
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:KahnMarkovic09",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[KM12] KahnMarkovic09",
          "bibliography_key": "KahnMarkovic09",
          "bibliography_number": "KM12",
          "title": "Jeremy Kahn and Vladimir Markovic. \\newblock Immersing almost geodesic surfaces in a closed hyperbolic three manifold. \\newblock {\\em Ann. of Math. (2)}, 175(3):1127--1190, 2012.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2504,
            "line_end": 2510,
            "char_start": 174310,
            "char_end": 174523
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Margulis:Growth",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Mar69] Margulis:Growth",
          "bibliography_key": "Margulis:Growth",
          "bibliography_number": "Mar69",
          "title": "Gregory~A. Margulis. \\newblock Certain applications of ergodic theory to the investigation of manifolds of negative curvature. \\newblock {\\em Funkcional. Anal. i Prilo\\v zen.}, 3(4):89--90, 1969.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2510,
            "line_end": 2516,
            "char_start": 174523,
            "char_end": 174755
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Montee:Cubulation",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Mon23] Montee:Cubulation",
          "bibliography_key": "Montee:Cubulation",
          "bibliography_number": "Mon23",
          "title": "MurphyKate Montee. \\newblock Random groups at density {$d<3/14$} act non-trivially on a {CAT}(0) cube complex. \\newblock {\\em Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 376(3):1653--1682, 2023.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2516,
            "line_end": 2522,
            "char_start": 174755,
            "char_end": 174970
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:MackayPrzytycki",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[MP15] MackayPrzytycki",
          "bibliography_key": "MackayPrzytycki",
          "bibliography_number": "MP15",
          "title": "John~M. Mackay and Piotr Przytycki. \\newblock Balanced walls for random groups. \\newblock {\\em Michigan Math. J.}, 64(2):397--419, 2015.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2522,
            "line_end": 2527,
            "char_start": 174970,
            "char_end": 175140
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:MartinSteenbock",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[MS17] MartinSteenbock",
          "bibliography_key": "MartinSteenbock",
          "bibliography_number": "MS17",
          "title": "Alexandre Martin and Markus Steenbock. \\newblock A combination theorem for cubulation in small cancellation theory over free products. \\newblock {\\em Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble)}, 67(4):1613--1670, 2017.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2527,
            "line_end": 2533,
            "char_start": 175140,
            "char_end": 175381
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:MYJ",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[MYJ20] MYJ",
          "bibliography_key": "MYJ",
          "bibliography_number": "MYJ20",
          "title": "Katsuhiko Matsuzaki, Yasuhiro Yabuki, and Johannes Jaerisch. \\newblock Normalizer, divergence type, and {P}atterson measure for discrete groups of the {G}romov hyperbolic space. \\newblock {\\em Groups Geom. Dyn.}, 14(2):369--411, 2020.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2533,
            "line_end": 2539,
            "char_start": 175381,
            "char_end": 175640
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Corollary 2.8, cited as an independent source of the same growth-separation conclusion.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The group, subgroup, and ambient metric action satisfy the exact source hypotheses.",
                "In particular, the source must justify finite exponential growth in the chosen metric."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:NibloRoller98",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[NR98] NibloRoller98",
          "bibliography_key": "NibloRoller98",
          "bibliography_number": "NR98",
          "title": "Graham~A. Niblo and Martin~A. Roller. \\newblock Groups acting on cubes and {K}azhdan's property ({T}). \\newblock {\\em Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 126(3):693--699, 1998.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2539,
            "line_end": 2544,
            "char_start": 175640,
            "char_end": 175837
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Odrzygozdz",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Odr18] Odrzygozdz",
          "bibliography_key": "Odrzygozdz",
          "bibliography_number": "Odr18",
          "title": "Tomasz Odrzyg\\'{o}\\'{z}d\\'{z}. \\newblock Cubulating random groups in the square model. \\newblock {\\em Israel J. Math.}, 227(2):623--661, 2018.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2544,
            "line_end": 2549,
            "char_start": 175837,
            "char_end": 176009
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Oll04] Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "bibliography_key": "Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "bibliography_number": "Oll04",
          "title": "Yann Ollivier. \\newblock Sharp phase transition theorems for hyperbolicity of random groups. \\newblock {\\em GAFA, Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 14(3):595--679, 2004.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2549,
            "line_end": 2554,
            "char_start": 176009,
            "char_end": 176209
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Ollivier05invitation",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Oll05] Ollivier05invitation",
          "bibliography_key": "Ollivier05invitation",
          "bibliography_number": "Oll05",
          "title": "Yann Ollivier. \\newblock {\\em A {J}anuary 2005 invitation to random groups}, volume~10 of {\\em Ensaios Matem\\'aticos [Mathematical Surveys]}. \\newblock Sociedade Brasileira de Matem\\'atica, Rio de Janeiro, 2005.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2554,
            "line_end": 2560,
            "char_start": 176209,
            "char_end": 176462
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Osin2007",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Osi07] Osin2007",
          "bibliography_key": "Osin2007",
          "bibliography_number": "Osi07",
          "title": "Denis~V. Osin. \\newblock Peripheral fillings of relatively hyperbolic groups. \\newblock {\\em Invent. Math.}, 167(2):295--326, 2007.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2560,
            "line_end": 2565,
            "char_start": 176462,
            "char_end": 176621
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:OllivierWiseDensity",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[OW11] OllivierWiseDensity",
          "bibliography_key": "OllivierWiseDensity",
          "bibliography_number": "OW11",
          "title": "Yann Ollivier and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Cubulating random groups at density less than {$1/6$}. \\newblock {\\em Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 363(9):4701--4733, 2011.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2565,
            "line_end": 2570,
            "char_start": 176621,
            "char_end": 176823
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Rat19] Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "bibliography_key": "Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "bibliography_number": "Rat19",
          "title": "John~G. Ratcliffe. \\newblock {\\em Foundations of hyperbolic manifolds}, volume 149 of {\\em Graduate Texts in Mathematics}. \\newblock Springer, third edition, 2019.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2570,
            "line_end": 2576,
            "char_start": 176823,
            "char_end": 177029
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorems 3.5.8 and 3.5.9 for Lambert quadrilaterals, and Theorem 3.5.3 for the hyperbolic cosine rule.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The quadrilateral has the right angles and side placement shown in the cited formulas.",
                "The triangles and metric have constant curvature -1.",
                "The source is the third edition, whose numbering is cited."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Rey23] Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
          "bibliography_key": "Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
          "bibliography_number": "Rey23",
          "title": "Eduardo Reyes. \\newblock The space of metric structures on hyperbolic groups. \\newblock {\\em J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2)}, 107(3):914--942, 2023.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2576,
            "line_end": 2581,
            "char_start": 177029,
            "char_end": 177210
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:SageevWiseCores",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[SW15] SageevWiseCores",
          "bibliography_key": "SageevWiseCores",
          "bibliography_number": "SW15",
          "title": "Michah Sageev and Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Cores for quasiconvex actions. \\newblock {\\em Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.}, 143(7):2731--2741, 2015.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2581,
            "line_end": 2586,
            "char_start": 177210,
            "char_end": 177383
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Remark 3.2, used for a dimension-dependent positive angle between a shortest CAT(0) segment and a hyperplane in its initial cube.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "A finite-dimensional CAT(0) cube complex.",
                "The segment and initial cube satisfy the geometric setup of the remark.",
                "The angle bound is uniform in the dimension."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:WiseSmallCanCube04",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Wis04] WiseSmallCanCube04",
          "bibliography_key": "WiseSmallCanCube04",
          "bibliography_number": "Wis04",
          "title": "Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock Cubulating small cancellation groups. \\newblock {\\em GAFA, Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 14(1):150--214, 2004.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2586,
            "line_end": 2591,
            "char_start": 177383,
            "char_end": 177548
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[Wis21] WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "bibliography_key": "WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "bibliography_number": "Wis21",
          "title": "Daniel~T. Wise. \\newblock {\\em The structure of groups with a quasiconvex hierarchy}, volume 209 of {\\em Annals of Mathematics Studies}. \\newblock Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2021.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2591,
            "line_end": 2597,
            "char_start": 177548,
            "char_end": 177784
          },
          "review_reference_roles": [
            {
              "consumer": "Lem:1/12 lift",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorems 3.32 and 4.1, invoked to embed every cone Y_i in the universal cover of X* under C'(1/12).",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "X* is a cubical presentation by local isometries of nonpositively curved cube complexes.",
                "The presentation satisfies the source's C'(1/12) condition, including its conventions for pieces and symmetries."
              ]
            },
            {
              "consumer": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Lemma 3.70 and Theorem 4.7, used to deduce hyperbolicity of pi_1 X*.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "pi_1 X is hyperbolic.",
                "X* is compact.",
                "X* satisfies cubical C'(1/14) with the source's piece conventions."
              ]
            },
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:C'20Proper",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 4.2 and Remark 4.3, used to place every torsion element in a relator automorphism group.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The presentation satisfies the small-cancellation and symmetry hypotheses of the torsion theorem.",
                "The relator automorphism groups are identified with the relevant cyclic extensions."
              ]
            },
            {
              "consumer": "rem:pieceful convexity",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Remark 5.43: if distinct translates of a hyperplane carrier are farther apart than the maximal piece diameter, the hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "The hyperplane and its carrier satisfy the source's embedding and cubical-presentation assumptions.",
                "M bounds every piece diameter in the cone.",
                "Every distinct carrier translate has distance greater than M."
              ]
            },
            {
              "consumer": "Thm:cubulating X star",
              "role": "proof_input",
              "claimed_role": "proof_input",
              "audit_status": "not_inspected",
              "imported_result": "Theorem 5.44, combined with Lemma 3.70 and Corollary 5.45, as restated in the four numbered hypotheses of Theorem 3.8, yielding torsion cell stabilizers on the dual cube complex.",
              "required_hypotheses": [
                "C'(1/14) and B(6).",
                "Every cone hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
                "Every infinite-order cone automorphism is cut by a cone wall.",
                "The full separation condition in Hypothesis (4), including that the new wall separates p and q.",
                "Any additional source hypotheses needed for the claimed simplification."
              ]
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "external:Zuk03",
          "kind": "external",
          "label": "[{\\.Z}uk03] Zuk03",
          "bibliography_key": "Zuk03",
          "bibliography_number": "{\\.Z}uk03",
          "title": "A.~{\\.Z}uk. \\newblock Property ({T}) and {K}azhdan constants for discrete groups. \\newblock {\\em Geom. Funct. Anal.}, 13(3):643--670, 2003.",
          "urls": [],
          "argument_gist": "",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2597,
            "line_end": 2602,
            "char_start": 177784,
            "char_end": 177952
          }
        }
      ],
      "edges": [
        {
          "from": "Def:TransLength",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eorem, $|g_i|$ is the translation length of $g_i$ acting on the universal cover $\\widetilde X$; see \\Cref{Def:TransLength}. The growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\widetilde X$ is a constant $b > 0$ such that the number of $G$--orbit points in an",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 288,
            "line_end": 288,
            "char_start": 11337,
            "char_end": 11359
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Growth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "number of $G$--orbit points in an $\\ell$--ball in $\\widetilde X$ is approximately $e^{b \\ell}$. See \\Cref{Def:Growth} and \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth} for a more precise characterization. The growth exponent of a hyperplane stabilizer is defined ana",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 288,
            "line_end": 288,
            "char_start": 11555,
            "char_end": 11572
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "oints in an $\\ell$--ball in $\\widetilde X$ is approximately $e^{b \\ell}$. See \\Cref{Def:Growth} and \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth} for a more precise characterization. The growth exponent of a hyperplane stabilizer is defined analogously. A hyperplane $\\wi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 288,
            "line_end": 288,
            "char_start": 11577,
            "char_end": 11603
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "etracts to $X'$, where all hyperplanes of $X'$ are essential. The model of randomness employed in \\Cref{Thm:main} is that we are sampling uniformly from the set of conjugacy classes whose translation length on $\\widetilde X$ is at most $\\ell$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 294,
            "line_end": 294,
            "char_start": 12205,
            "char_end": 12220
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "of spheres, and the growth of group elements is nearly the same as the growth of conjugacy classes (\\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}). Therefore, small variations in the model of randomness tend to have no effect on the conclusions one can reach about random quo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 294,
            "line_end": 294,
            "char_start": 12740,
            "char_end": 12766
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "vier05invitation}) for a detailed and axiomatic discussion of this phenomenon. The conclusion of \\Cref{Thm:main} --- that $\\overline G = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and cocompactly cubulated --- has powerful consequences. A th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13094,
            "char_end": 13109
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}. \\subsection{Density and optimality of constants} In \\Cref{Thm:main}, the density of the random presentation $G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is $\\frac{c}{b}$. Thus all densities in the conclusion of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 300,
            "line_end": 300,
            "char_start": 13751,
            "char_end": 13766
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "s surveyed at the start of the Introduction. The primary reason for needing the low density is that \\Cref{Thm:main} is proved by establishing that random quotients of $G$ satisfy the $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ cubical small cancellation condition. (See",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 302,
            "line_end": 302,
            "char_start": 14158,
            "char_end": 14173
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "t random quotients of $G$ satisfy the $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ cubical small cancellation condition. (See \\Cref{Def:Piece} for the definition and \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} for the precise statement that $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ plus several mild hypotheses impli",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 302,
            "line_end": 302,
            "char_start": 14303,
            "char_end": 14319
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "'(\\frac{1}{20})$ cubical small cancellation condition. (See \\Cref{Def:Piece} for the definition and \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} for the precise statement that $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ plus several mild hypotheses implies cubulation of the quotient.) Indeed, the p",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 302,
            "line_end": 302,
            "char_start": 14343,
            "char_end": 14364
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "hypotheses are nearly optimal for ensuring $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ small cancellation. Strengthening \\Cref{Thm:main} beyond density $\\frac{1}{40}$ would require one of two improvements. First, one could attempt to strengthen \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 305,
            "line_end": 305,
            "char_start": 14835,
            "char_end": 14850
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nsity $\\frac{1}{40}$ would require one of two improvements. First, one could attempt to strengthen \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} and establish the cubulation of $C'(\\alpha)$ quotients for some parameter $\\alpha > \\frac{1}{20}$. Second, one could move away fr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 306,
            "line_end": 306,
            "char_start": 14960,
            "char_end": 14981
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$G$ have strictly lower growth exponents than $G$ itself. See \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below. Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary: \\label{Cor:LowDen",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 310,
            "line_end": 310,
            "char_start": 15769,
            "char_end": 15794
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below. Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary: Let $X$ be a compact non-positively curved cube comp",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 310,
            "line_end": 310,
            "char_start": 15837,
            "char_end": 15852
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ng conclusion is known for quotients of free groups. This supports our belief that the constants in \\Cref{Thm:main} can be improved considerably, especially for surface groups. See \\Cref{Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity} and \\Cref{Prob:GeneralOptimalD",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 319,
            "line_end": 319,
            "char_start": 16573,
            "char_end": 16588
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "t the constants in \\Cref{Thm:main} can be improved considerably, especially for surface groups. See \\Cref{Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity} and \\Cref{Prob:GeneralOptimalDensity}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 319,
            "line_end": 319,
            "char_start": 16654,
            "char_end": 16687
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prob:GeneralOptimalDensity",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "be improved considerably, especially for surface groups. See \\Cref{Prob:SurfaceOptimalDensity} and \\Cref{Prob:GeneralOptimalDensity}. \\subse",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 319,
            "line_end": 319,
            "char_start": 16692,
            "char_end": 16725
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "wo spaces can lead to rather distinct samples of short words. Nonetheless, there is an analogue of \\Cref{Thm:main} for sampling words in $G$ with respect to an action on $\\Upsilon$. To formulate the next theorem, we introduce the following non-",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 326,
            "line_end": 326,
            "char_start": 17618,
            "char_end": 17633
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "c and is the fundamental group of a compact, non-positively curved cube complex. As with \\Cref{Thm:main}, this result is non-vacuous, because hyperplane stabilizers in $G$ have strictly lower exponential growth rates (with respect to",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 356,
            "line_end": 356,
            "char_start": 20711,
            "char_end": 20726
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$G$ have strictly lower exponential growth rates (with respect to $\\Upsilon$) than $G$ itself. By \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below, we have $b >a$, hence we may choose $c >0$. As a special case, suppose that a group $G$ preserves a tiling of $\\HH^2$ by",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 357,
            "line_end": 357,
            "char_start": 20890,
            "char_end": 20915
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cite{Margulis:Growth}, the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\HH^2$ is $b=1$. Furthermore, in \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}, we show that the optimal multiplicative constant in a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde X$ to $\\HH^2$ is $\\lambda \\appro",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 359,
            "line_end": 359,
            "char_start": 21425,
            "char_end": 21449
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde X$ to $\\HH^2$ is $\\lambda \\approx 1.5627$. Consequently, \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} has the following corollary. Let $S$ be a hyperbolic surface tiled by regular right-angled pe",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 360,
            "line_end": 360,
            "char_start": 21605,
            "char_end": 21627
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:H2Action",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "the fundamental group of a compact, non-positively curved cube complex. In particular, \\Cref{Cor:H2Action} says that quotients of surface groups, with words sampled from a pentagonal hyperbolic metric, are cubulated and hyperbolic at de",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 367,
            "line_end": 367,
            "char_start": 22228,
            "char_end": 22247
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:LowDensity",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cal metric, where we obtain the same conclusion at density $\\frac{1}{41}$; see the discussion after \\Cref{Cor:LowDensity}. The multiplicative gap between these densities is essentially the constant $\\lambda$. Studying the effect of quasiisometry cons",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 367,
            "line_end": 367,
            "char_start": 22558,
            "char_end": 22579
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cocompact hyperbolic structures are limit points of metrics coming from cocompact cubulations. See \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} and the subsequent discussion. This conjecture has been recently proved by Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 370,
            "line_end": 370,
            "char_start": 23069,
            "char_end": 23104
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "sec:growth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ecently proved by Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}. \\subsection{Overview} \\Cref{sec:growth} reviews several results about the growth of a hyperbolic group, including the existence of a growth exponent and the statement th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 374,
            "line_end": 374,
            "char_start": 23262,
            "char_end": 23279
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ment that infinite-index quasiconvex subgroups have a lower growth exponent than the ambient group. \\Cref{sec:cubical presentation background} reviews the definitions of cubical small-cancellation theory and proves \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, a non-probabilistic cubulation cri",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 375,
            "line_end": 375,
            "char_start": 23502,
            "char_end": 23544
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "al presentation background} reviews the definitions of cubical small-cancellation theory and proves \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, a non-probabilistic cubulation criterion for $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ small-cancellation quotients of a cubulated group. This criterio",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 375,
            "line_end": 375,
            "char_start": 23617,
            "char_end": 23638
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "of Jankiewicz and Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}. The probabilistic arguments supporting the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main} are contained in \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}. In that section, we control the sizes of pieces in a generic cubical presentation and show th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 23935,
            "char_end": 23950
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Pieces",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "kiewiczWise}. The probabilistic arguments supporting the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main} are contained in \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}. In that section, we control the sizes of pieces in a generic cubical presentation and show that below a certain density, a cubic",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 23968,
            "char_end": 23985
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "de X$ and a $G$--action on a more general metric space $\\Upsilon$. We undertake this translation in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}, where we prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}. Finally, in \\Cref{Sec:Pentagonal}, we find the optimal multiplicative constants in a quas",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 24578,
            "char_end": 24600
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "al metric space $\\Upsilon$. We undertake this translation in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}, where we prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}. Finally, in \\Cref{Sec:Pentagonal}, we find the optimal multiplicative constants in a quasiisometry between a pentagonal tiling o",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 24617,
            "char_end": 24639
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "take this translation in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}, where we prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}. Finally, in \\Cref{Sec:Pentagonal}, we find the optimal multiplicative constants in a quasiisometry between a pentagonal tiling of $\\HH^2$ and the dual cube complex",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 24653,
            "char_end": 24674
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "stants in a quasiisometry between a pentagonal tiling of $\\HH^2$ and the dual cube complex, proving \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. In \\Cref{Sec:Problems}, we collect some problems and questions motivated by these results. \\subsectio",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 24814,
            "char_end": 24838
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:H2Action",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ween a pentagonal tiling of $\\HH^2$ and the dual cube complex, proving \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. In \\Cref{Sec:Problems}, we collect some problems and questions motivated by these results. \\subsection{Acklowledgements} We t",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 377,
            "line_end": 377,
            "char_start": 24843,
            "char_end": 24862
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Problems",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "f $\\HH^2$ and the dual cube complex, proving \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. In \\Cref{Sec:Problems}, we collect some problems and questions motivated by these results. \\subsection{Acklowledgements} We thank Eduardo Reyes and Sam",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 379,
            "line_end": 379,
            "char_start": 24869,
            "char_end": 24888
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "merous minor corrections, and for suggesting a potential improvement to our results, as sketched in \\Cref{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation} and \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces}. \\section{Growth} This section collects several definitions and results",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 382,
            "line_end": 382,
            "char_start": 25193,
            "char_end": 25230
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ng a potential improvement to our results, as sketched in \\Cref{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation} and \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces}. \\section{Growth} This section collects several definitions and results about the growth of hyperbolic group",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 382,
            "line_end": 382,
            "char_start": 25235,
            "char_end": 25267
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "n} \\leq p_n \\leq B e^{bn} . \\] Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}. Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 458,
            "char_start": 29838,
            "char_end": 29861
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "of} Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}. Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}. One co",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 458,
            "char_start": 29923,
            "char_end": 29950
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}. One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 464,
            "line_end": 464,
            "char_start": 30093,
            "char_end": 30119
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper constant $B$) on the num",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 464,
            "line_end": 464,
            "char_start": 30120,
            "char_end": 30143
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "m} The upper bound on the number $p_n$ of primitive classes in \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the number of non-primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 468,
            "line_end": 468,
            "char_start": 30584,
            "char_end": 30610
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "onPrimitive} The upper bound on the number $p_n$ of primitive classes in \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the number of non-primitive conjugacy classes of translation length at most $n$ is bounded above by \\[ \\sum_{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 468,
            "line_end": 468,
            "char_start": 30611,
            "char_end": 30638
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\sum_{j = 1}^{n/2} B e^{bj} < n B e^{bn/2} \\ll p_n. \\] Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most \\[ \\frac{ n^2 B}{A} e^{-bn",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 473,
            "line_end": 473,
            "char_start": 30861,
            "char_end": 30887
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "} < n B e^{bn/2} \\ll p_n. \\] Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most \\[ \\frac{ n^2 B}{A} e^{-bn/2} . \\] Hence, for large $n",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 473,
            "line_end": 473,
            "char_start": 30888,
            "char_end": 30915
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "tion theory. Our primary reference is Wise~\\cite[Chapters 3--5]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. We also prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, a properness criterion that follows from \\cite[Thm 5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy} but is easier to apply. \\subsection{Cubical pres",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 484,
            "line_end": 484,
            "char_start": 31460,
            "char_end": 31481
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:CubicalPres",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "with a cone on each $Y_i$. Accordingly, we call each $Y_i$ a cone of $X^*$. See \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for an example. In this paper, it will always be the case that $\\pi_1 Y_i \\cong \\integers$. However, this assumption is not prese",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 494,
            "line_end": 494,
            "char_start": 32092,
            "char_end": 32114
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:TransLength",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "} $\\systole{X}$ is the infimal length of an essential combinatorial closed path in $X$. In terms of \\Cref{Def:TransLength}, $\\systole{X}$ is the smallest translation length of a non-trivial element of $\\pi_1 X$ acting on $\\widetilde X$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 499,
            "line_end": 499,
            "char_start": 32549,
            "char_end": 32571
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "f each $\\pi_1 Y_i$ is maximal cyclic, then $\\pi_1X^*$ acts freely on $\\widetilde{X^*}$. \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} will be proved with the aid of \\cite[Thm 5.44 and Cor 5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. Setting up the proof using those results requir",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 543,
            "line_end": 543,
            "char_start": 35246,
            "char_end": 35267
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "B6:wallspace",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "raphics[width=5in]{CubicalPresentation.jpg} \\caption{A cubical presentation illustrating conditions \\eqref{B6:wallspace} and \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6}. In this example, as in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we have $\\pi_1 Y_i \\cong \\ZZ$ for each $Y_i$,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 552,
            "line_end": 552,
            "char_start": 36068,
            "char_end": 36088
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "B6:aut",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "lPresentation.jpg} \\caption{A cubical presentation illustrating conditions \\eqref{B6:wallspace} and \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6}. In this example, as in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we have $\\pi_1 Y_i \\cong \\ZZ$ for each $Y_i$, and the wallspace s",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 552,
            "line_end": 552,
            "char_start": 36093,
            "char_end": 36107
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\caption{A cubical presentation illustrating conditions \\eqref{B6:wallspace} and \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6}. In this example, as in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we have $\\pi_1 Y_i \\cong \\ZZ$ for each $Y_i$, and the wallspace structure on $Y_i$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 552,
            "line_end": 552,
            "char_start": 36111,
            "char_end": 36124
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "trating conditions \\eqref{B6:wallspace} and \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6}. In this example, as in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we have $\\pi_1 Y_i \\cong \\ZZ$ for each $Y_i$, and the wallspace structure on $Y_i$ has two diametrically opposed hyperplanes in",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 552,
            "line_end": 552,
            "char_start": 36149,
            "char_end": 36170
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ce structure on $Y_i$ has two diametrically opposed hyperplanes in each wall. Unlike the setting of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, $\\pi_1 X$ is not hyperbolic in this example.} [$B(6)$ and $B(8)$ conditions]\\l",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 552,
            "line_end": 552,
            "char_start": 36333,
            "char_end": 36354
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:CubicalPres",
          "to": "Def:B6",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "which is preserved by its automorphisms, and satisfies a certain small-cancellation condition (see \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for an example). More precisely: [\\:\\: ($1$)] \\item The collection of hyperplanes of each",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 557,
            "line_end": 557,
            "char_start": 36786,
            "char_end": 36808
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "B6:homotopy",
          "to": "Def:B6",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "s path-homotopic into $N(U)$. The $B(8)$ condition is defined by replacing \\eqref{B6:homotopy} with the stronger condition: [\\:\\: ($1'$)] \\setcounter{enumi}{2} \\item If $P$ is a path that is t",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 571,
            "line_end": 571,
            "char_start": 37799,
            "char_end": 37818
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "n{The properness criterion} We now collect some terminology that will be needed to state and apply \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. In our usage, geodesics are globally distance realizing. By contrast, a closed--geodesic $w \\rightarrow Y$ in a non-po",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 594,
            "line_end": 594,
            "char_start": 38522,
            "char_end": 38550
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "fig:KappaAndFriends",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ts with torsion stabilizers on the dual cube complex of the $B(6)$ structure. We refer to \\Cref{fig:KappaAndFriends} for a depiction of the notation in Hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. We will now use \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} to prove \\Cref",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 642,
            "line_end": 642,
            "char_start": 41596,
            "char_end": 41622
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:Separation",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ure. We refer to \\Cref{fig:KappaAndFriends} for a depiction of the notation in Hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. We will now use \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} to prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. [width=2.5in]{KappaA",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 642,
            "line_end": 642,
            "char_start": 41669,
            "char_end": 41691
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "paAndFriends} for a depiction of the notation in Hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. We will now use \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} to prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. [width=2.5in]{KappaAndFriends} \\put(10,48){$p$} \\put(76,72){$q$} \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 642,
            "line_end": 642,
            "char_start": 41709,
            "char_end": 41737
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "otation in Hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. We will now use \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} to prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. [width=2.5in]{KappaAndFriends} \\put(10,48){$p$} \\put(76,72){$q$} \\put(12,30){$\\kappa$} \\put(17,62",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 642,
            "line_end": 642,
            "char_start": 41747,
            "char_end": 41768
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:Separation",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "put(74,83){$u_1'$} \\put(55,48){$U_1$} \\caption{The scenario that arises in hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation} of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. For the geodesic $\\kappa$, we have to verify that neither $p$ nor $q$ is $2$--proximate to $U_2",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 659,
            "line_end": 659,
            "char_start": 42117,
            "char_end": 42139
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": ",48){$U_1$} \\caption{The scenario that arises in hypothesis~\\eqref{Itm:Separation} of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. For the geodesic $\\kappa$, we have to verify that neither $p$ nor $q$ is $2$--proximate to $U_2 = u_2 \\cup u_2'$.} \\label{fig:Ka",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 659,
            "line_end": 659,
            "char_start": 42143,
            "char_end": 42171
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "mate to $U_2 = u_2 \\cup u_2'$.} [Proof of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}] Observe that \\Cref{Def:Piece} of the $C'(\\alpha)$ condition involves a strict inequality. Since $X^*$ is a finite $C'(\\frac{1}{2",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 666,
            "line_end": 666,
            "char_start": 42356,
            "char_end": 42377
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "el{fig:KappaAndFriends} [Proof of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}] Observe that \\Cref{Def:Piece} of the $C'(\\alpha)$ condition involves a strict inequality. Since $X^*$ is a finite $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ presentation, we may choos",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 667,
            "line_end": 667,
            "char_start": 42392,
            "char_end": 42408
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:CubicalPres",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ll to consist of the pair of hyperplanes corresponding to a pair of antipodal edges of $w_i$. (See \\Cref{Fig:CubicalPres} for a partial illustration of such a pairing, where the closed--geodesics $w_i$ are presumed to run along the inner boundary of e",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 691,
            "line_end": 691,
            "char_start": 44725,
            "char_end": 44747
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cus on one relator $Y = Y_i$ and its closed--geodesic $w = w_i$. Before verifying the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}, we check an inequality that will be very useful in the sequel. Let $u,u' \\subset Y$ be a pair of hyperplanes in the same wall o",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 693,
            "line_end": 693,
            "char_start": 45022,
            "char_end": 45050
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "lpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $m$ is chosen so that $2^{-m}$ is tiny. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. In lieu of the $B(6)$ condition of \\Cref{Def:B6}, we will in fact verify the stronger $B(8)$ condition. To check Condition~\\e",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 706,
            "line_end": 706,
            "char_start": 45833,
            "char_end": 45861
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star}. In lieu of the $B(6)$ condition of \\Cref{Def:B6}, we will in fact verify the stronger $B(8)$ condition. To check Condition~\\eqref{B6:wallspace} of \\Cref{Def:B6}, let $u,u'$ be",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 706,
            "line_end": 706,
            "char_start": 45899,
            "char_end": 45912
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "B6:wallspace",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "dition of \\Cref{Def:B6}, we will in fact verify the stronger $B(8)$ condition. To check Condition~\\eqref{B6:wallspace} of \\Cref{Def:B6}, let $u,u'$ be distinct hyperplanes in the same wall of $Y$. Then each of $N(u)$ and $N(u')$ is embedded by hypo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 709,
            "line_end": 709,
            "char_start": 45989,
            "char_end": 46009
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "we will in fact verify the stronger $B(8)$ condition. To check Condition~\\eqref{B6:wallspace} of \\Cref{Def:B6}, let $u,u'$ be distinct hyperplanes in the same wall of $Y$. Then each of $N(u)$ and $N(u')$ is embedded by hypothesis. Furthemor",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 709,
            "line_end": 709,
            "char_start": 46013,
            "char_end": 46026
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nes in the same wall of $Y$. Then each of $N(u)$ and $N(u')$ is embedded by hypothesis. Furthemore, \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha} implies $N(u) \\cap N(u') = \\emptyset$. Thus $u \\cup u'$ partition $Y$ into two halfspaces. Condition \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 710,
            "line_end": 710,
            "char_start": 46159,
            "char_end": 46189
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "B6:aut",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "mplies $N(u) \\cap N(u') = \\emptyset$. Thus $u \\cup u'$ partition $Y$ into two halfspaces. Condition \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6} holds because our (revised) choice of $w$ ensures that $\\Aut(Y \\rightarrow X)$ stabilizes $w$, hence preserves",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 711,
            "line_end": 711,
            "char_start": 46291,
            "char_end": 46305
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "N(u') = \\emptyset$. Thus $u \\cup u'$ partition $Y$ into two halfspaces. Condition \\eqref{B6:aut} of \\Cref{Def:B6} holds because our (revised) choice of $w$ ensures that $\\Aut(Y \\rightarrow X)$ stabilizes $w$, hence preserves the wallspace str",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 711,
            "line_end": 711,
            "char_start": 46309,
            "char_end": 46322
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:B8",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\Aut(Y \\rightarrow X)$ stabilizes $w$, hence preserves the wallspace structure. For Condition~$(\\ref{Itm:B8}')$, consider $P=P_1\\cdots P_{8}$, a concatenation of $8$ piece-paths that starts on $N(u)$ and ends on either $N(u')$ or on $N(u)",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 713,
            "line_end": 713,
            "char_start": 46478,
            "char_end": 46490
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "thesis implies that $|P_i| < \\alpha \\systole{Y}$, hence $|P| < 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}$, contradicting \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha}. Now, consider the case where $P$ starts and ends on $N(u)$. Since we have already checked that $P$ is too short to reach $N(u",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 714,
            "line_end": 714,
            "char_start": 46822,
            "char_end": 46852
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:B8",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "of whose components is convex. Thus $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(u)$. We have verified Condition~$(\\ref{Itm:B8}')$ of \\Cref{Def:B6}. Hence $X^*$ satisfies the $B(8)$ condition, and hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hy",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 721,
            "line_end": 721,
            "char_start": 47230,
            "char_end": 47242
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "is convex. Thus $P$ is path-homotopic into $N(u)$. We have verified Condition~$(\\ref{Itm:B8}')$ of \\Cref{Def:B6}. Hence $X^*$ satisfies the $B(8)$ condition, and hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cu",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 721,
            "line_end": 721,
            "char_start": 47249,
            "char_end": 47262
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ion~$(\\ref{Itm:B8}')$ of \\Cref{Def:B6}. Hence $X^*$ satisfies the $B(8)$ condition, and hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 721,
            "line_end": 721,
            "char_start": 47324,
            "char_end": 47351
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:B6",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ef{Def:B6}. Hence $X^*$ satisfies the $B(8)$ condition, and hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 721,
            "line_end": 721,
            "char_start": 47352,
            "char_end": 47366
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "fies the $B(8)$ condition, and hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}. Indeed, le",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47381,
            "char_end": 47408
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:Pieceful",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nd hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:B6}. Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}. Indeed, let $x \\in N(\\widetilde",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47409,
            "char_end": 47429
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ing X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}. Indeed, let $x \\in N(\\widetilde u)$ and $x' \\in gN(\\widetilde u)$ be points on the carriers of two distinct lifts of $u$ to $\\wi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47497,
            "char_end": 47526
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanes",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "on the carriers of two distinct lifts of $u$ to $\\widetilde Y$. Then, by the same calculation as in \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes,Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha}, we have $\\dist(x,x') > 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}$, which exceeds the diameter of a piece. Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eq",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47704,
            "char_end": 47753
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "on the carriers of two distinct lifts of $u$ to $\\widetilde Y$. Then, by the same calculation as in \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes,Eqn:FarHyperplanesAlpha}, we have $\\dist(x,x') > 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}$, which exceeds the diameter of a piece. Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eq",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47704,
            "char_end": 47753
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "}, we have $\\dist(x,x') > 8 \\alpha \\systole{Y}$, which exceeds the diameter of a piece. Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:CutWall} holds vacuously, since each $Y$ is compact. We now verify Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 726,
            "line_end": 726,
            "char_start": 47852,
            "char_end": 47879
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:CutWall",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\alpha \\systole{Y}$, which exceeds the diameter of a piece. Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:CutWall} holds vacuously, since each $Y$ is compact. We now verify Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. Let $\\k",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 726,
            "line_end": 726,
            "char_start": 47880,
            "char_end": 47899
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "g X star}.\\eqref{Itm:CutWall} holds vacuously, since each $Y$ is compact. We now verify Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. Let $\\kappa \\to Y$ be a geodesic from $p$ to $q$, as in that condition. We begin by deriving upper and l",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 728,
            "line_end": 728,
            "char_start": 47970,
            "char_end": 47997
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:Separation",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "} holds vacuously, since each $Y$ is compact. We now verify Hypothesis~\\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Separation}. Let $\\kappa \\to Y$ be a geodesic from $p$ to $q$, as in that condition. We begin by deriving upper and lower bounds on $|\\kappa",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 728,
            "line_end": 728,
            "char_start": 47998,
            "char_end": 48020
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "fig:KappaAndFriends",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$, and either $u_1'$ is $1$--proximate to $q$ or $\\kappa$ traverses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1'$. See \\Cref{fig:KappaAndFriends}. If $\\kappa$ intersects $u_1'$, then \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes} implies \\[ |\\kappa| \\geq \\dist(N(u_1) , N(u'_1)) > \\left( \\frac{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 736,
            "line_end": 736,
            "char_start": 48995,
            "char_end": 49021
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanes",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ses a $1$--cell dual to $u_1'$. See \\Cref{fig:KappaAndFriends}. If $\\kappa$ intersects $u_1'$, then \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes} implies \\[ |\\kappa| \\geq \\dist(N(u_1) , N(u'_1)) > \\left( \\frac{1}{2} \\systole{Y} - 2^{-m} \\right) - 2\\alpha \\systole{Y}. \\] Ot",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 736,
            "line_end": 736,
            "char_start": 49059,
            "char_end": 49084
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:KappaLower",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "iangle inequality, the second inequality is the diameter bound on $N(u_2)$, the third inequality is \\Cref{Eqn:KappaLower}, and the final inequality follows because $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $2^{-m}$ is tiny. Similarly, for any $x' \\in N(u_2')$, we h",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 757,
            "line_end": 757,
            "char_start": 50405,
            "char_end": 50426
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FarHyperplanes",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "le{Y}. Here, the first inequality is the triangle inequality, the second inequality is \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes}, the third inequality is \\Cref{Eqn:KappaUpper}, and the final inequality holds because $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $2^{-m}$ is ti",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 767,
            "line_end": 767,
            "char_start": 51082,
            "char_end": 51107
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:KappaUpper",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "he triangle inequality, the second inequality is \\Cref{Eqn:FarHyperplanes}, the third inequality is \\Cref{Eqn:KappaUpper}, and the final inequality holds because $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$ and $2^{-m}$ is tiny. Thus neither $p$ nor $q$ can be $2$--proxim",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 767,
            "line_end": 767,
            "char_start": 51133,
            "char_end": 51154
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "tiny. Thus neither $p$ nor $q$ can be $2$--proximate to $u_2$ or $u_2'$. We have thus verified that \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} applies, hence $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts with torsion stabilizers on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace structure we have const",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 770,
            "line_end": 770,
            "char_start": 51335,
            "char_end": 51363
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eces in generic quotients} This section contains the proof of the main theorem, \\Cref{Thm:main}. In the proof, we need to control the sizes of pieces in a generic cubical presentation. Wall-pieces are controlled in \\Cref{Prop",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 792,
            "line_end": 792,
            "char_start": 52580,
            "char_end": 52595
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eed to control the sizes of pieces in a generic cubical presentation. Wall-pieces are controlled in \\Cref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and cone-pieces are controlled in a sequence of lemmas, culminating in \\Cref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}. Most of the work in this s",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 792,
            "line_end": 792,
            "char_start": 52715,
            "char_end": 52743
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\Cref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and cone-pieces are controlled in a sequence of lemmas, culminating in \\Cref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}. Most of the work in this section occurs in the language of loose pieces, which represent a coarsening of the overlaps d",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 792,
            "line_end": 792,
            "char_start": 52815,
            "char_end": 52843
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "urs in the language of loose pieces, which represent a coarsening of the overlaps defined in \\Cref{Def:Piece}. We define loose pieces in \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}. In \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}, we show that every wall-piece or cone-piece in the sens",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 794,
            "line_end": 794,
            "char_start": 52983,
            "char_end": 52999
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "which represent a coarsening of the overlaps defined in \\Cref{Def:Piece}. We define loose pieces in \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}. In \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}, we show that every wall-piece or cone-piece in the sense of \\Cref{Def:Piece} gives rise to a correspondi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 794,
            "line_end": 794,
            "char_start": 53027,
            "char_end": 53048
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ng of the overlaps defined in \\Cref{Def:Piece}. We define loose pieces in \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}. In \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}, we show that every wall-piece or cone-piece in the sense of \\Cref{Def:Piece} gives rise to a corresponding loose piece. Via loo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 794,
            "line_end": 794,
            "char_start": 53053,
            "char_end": 53072
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ef:LoosePiece}. In \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}, we show that every wall-piece or cone-piece in the sense of \\Cref{Def:Piece} gives rise to a corresponding loose piece. Via loose pieces, the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Pro",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 794,
            "line_end": 794,
            "char_start": 53134,
            "char_end": 53150
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Def:Piece} gives rise to a corresponding loose piece. Via loose pieces, the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} readily generalize to the context of non-cubical hyperbolic metric spaces in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetri",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 796,
            "line_end": 796,
            "char_start": 53240,
            "char_end": 53267
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "sponding loose piece. Via loose pieces, the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} readily generalize to the context of non-cubical hyperbolic metric spaces in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. \\subsection{Loose pieces an",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 796,
            "line_end": 796,
            "char_start": 53272,
            "char_end": 53299
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Prop:ConePieceSystole} readily generalize to the context of non-cubical hyperbolic metric spaces in \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. \\subsection{Loose pieces and convex hulls of quasi-axes} Let $\\Upsilon$ be a metric space. For any subset $s",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 796,
            "line_end": 796,
            "char_start": 53377,
            "char_end": 53399
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "hose quotient $Y = \\langle g \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde Y$ admits a local isometry into $X$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, $\\widetilde Y$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w$, hence its quotient $Y$ is compact. We say that $Y$ is \\em",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 838,
            "line_end": 838,
            "char_start": 56611,
            "char_end": 56642
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "circle defined by $g$}. If $g$ stabilizes an axis $\\widetilde w$, as will be the case following \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, then the quasi-circle $Y$ deformation retracts to the closed--geodesic $w = \\langle g \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde w$. Now,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 842,
            "line_end": 842,
            "char_start": 56883,
            "char_end": 56900
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Conv:NiceX",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "the following convention. From now until the start of the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main}, the symbol $X$ denotes a compact non-positively curved cube complex, such that $\\widetilde X$ is $\\delta$--hyperbolic for some $",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 849,
            "line_end": 849,
            "char_start": 57139,
            "char_end": 57154
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "geev2011}. Our arguments in this section will employ the following, looser analogue of \\Cref{Def:Piece}. [Loose pieces] Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. Fix a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. We defin",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 857,
            "line_end": 857,
            "char_start": 57874,
            "char_end": 57890
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "er analogue of \\Cref{Def:Piece}. [Loose pieces] Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. Fix a constant $J \\in \\naturals$. We define $J$--loose pieces first in $\\widetilde X$, then in $X$. Consider bi-infinite geodes",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 860,
            "line_end": 860,
            "char_start": 57959,
            "char_end": 57976
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eter $\\geq d$. Furthermore, we may take $J \\leq 3K$, where $K$ is the constant of \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}. First, consider cone-pieces. Let $p,q \\in \\widetilde Y_i \\cap \\widetilde Y_j$ be points such that $\\di",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 887,
            "line_end": 887,
            "char_start": 60460,
            "char_end": 60491
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "eces. Let $p,q \\in \\widetilde Y_i \\cap \\widetilde Y_j$ be points such that $\\dist(p,q) \\geq d$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ that are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively. Applying \\Cref{Lem:HullUniform",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 894,
            "line_end": 894,
            "char_start": 60642,
            "char_end": 60673
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "re points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ that are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively. Applying \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness} to the quasi-circle $Y_j$ shows that $p_i, q_i$ are $2K$--close to $\\widetilde w_j$. Since $\\widetilde w_i$ is a geodesic, we hav",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 895,
            "line_end": 895,
            "char_start": 60782,
            "char_end": 60813
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": ":MoreGeneralHyperplane} Besides the looseness constant $J$, there is one important respect in which \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece} is more general than \\Cref{Def:Piece}. Whereas the definition of a wall-piece in $Y_i$ requires the hyperplane $U$ to be disjoint",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61543,
            "char_end": 61564
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ss constant $J$, there is one important respect in which \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece} is more general than \\Cref{Def:Piece}. Whereas the definition of a wall-piece in $Y_i$ requires the hyperplane $U$ to be disjoint from $Y_i$, the definition of a $J$--",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61586,
            "char_end": 61602
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "piece in $\\widetilde w_i$ has no analogous restriction. Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces. When we apply \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we will care about all inte",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61843,
            "char_end": 61862
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:HyperplaneInY",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "w_i$ has no analogous restriction. Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces. When we apply \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we will care about all intersections between $Y_i$ an",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61863,
            "char_end": 61888
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces. When we apply \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, we will care about all intersections between $Y_i$ and hyperplane carriers in $X$, and all such intersections will be con",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61935,
            "char_end": 61956
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "a \\systole{Y_i}$. We formulate the criterion in terms of loose pieces, for greater applicability in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} and in the generalized setting of \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. Recall that by \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, we are assuming that $G$ is noneleme",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 912,
            "line_end": 912,
            "char_start": 62480,
            "char_end": 62501
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "loose pieces, for greater applicability in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} and in the generalized setting of \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. Recall that by \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, we are assuming that $G$ is nonelementary and the hyperplanes of $X$ are essential. By \\Cref{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 912,
            "line_end": 912,
            "char_start": 62536,
            "char_end": 62558
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "in \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} and in the generalized setting of \\Cref{Sec:OtherMetric}. Recall that by \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, we are assuming that $G$ is nonelementary and the hyperplanes of $X$ are essential. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the growth fu",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 914,
            "line_end": 914,
            "char_start": 62576,
            "char_end": 62593
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Conv:NiceX}, we are assuming that $G$ is nonelementary and the hyperplanes of $X$ are essential. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the growth function of $G$ acting on $\\widetilde X$ is bounded by constants times $e^{b\\ell}$, where $b > 0$ is the growth expon",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 914,
            "line_end": 914,
            "char_start": 62682,
            "char_end": 62708
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "t of any of the $J$--neighborhoods of the hyperplanes, for an arbitrary $J$. Recall that $a < b$ by \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth}. For each $\\ell > 0$, let $\\mathcal{G}(\\ell)$ denote the set of nontrivial conjugacy classes in $\\pi_1 X$ of length at most $\\el",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 918,
            "line_end": 918,
            "char_start": 63104,
            "char_end": 63129
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\mathcal G(\\ell)$, for large $\\ell$. Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. For each non-trivial conjugacy class $\\pi_1 X$, choose a representative closed--geodesic. Let $a < b$ be growth exponents as",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 924,
            "line_end": 924,
            "char_start": 63430,
            "char_end": 63447
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "es in $\\neb_J (N(\\widetilde{U}))$ for some hyperplane $\\widetilde U$, and $|s| \\geq \\alpha n$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 958,
            "line_end": 958,
            "char_start": 65332,
            "char_end": 65358
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "e{U}))$ for some hyperplane $\\widetilde U$, and $|s| \\geq \\alpha n$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded above by $B'e^{a|s|}$,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 958,
            "line_end": 958,
            "char_start": 65359,
            "char_end": 65382
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$\\widetilde U$, and $|s| \\geq \\alpha n$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded above by $B'e^{a|s|}$, for some constant $B'$ dependi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 958,
            "line_end": 958,
            "char_start": 65387,
            "char_end": 65412
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ell} \\cdot \\ell e^{(a-b)\\alpha \\ell } \\cdot \\frac{ B}{1 - e^{-a } } . Meanwhile, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$. Thus \\label{eq:bi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 982,
            "line_end": 982,
            "char_start": 66659,
            "char_end": 66685
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "lpha \\ell } \\cdot \\frac{ B}{1 - e^{-a } } . Meanwhile, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$. Thus \\Pi(\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 982,
            "line_end": 982,
            "char_start": 66686,
            "char_end": 66713
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "eq:bigwallpiece propertion",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "thcal{U}(n,\\alpha)$ is bounded above by $k \\Pi(\\alpha,\\ell)$. Since $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$, Equation~\\eqref{eq:bigwallpiece propertion} says that the total probability of a large piece is bounded by \\[ k \\Pi(\\alpha,\\ell) \\leq \\ell^2 e^{c \\ell +(a-b)\\alpha \\ell } \\c",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 996,
            "line_end": 997,
            "char_start": 67237,
            "char_end": 67271
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "robability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ declines exponentially with $d$. See \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces}. We will need to employ separate arguments for pieces between closed--geodesics $w$ and $w'$ chosen separately, and pieces betw",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1008,
            "line_end": 1008,
            "char_start": 68042,
            "char_end": 68067
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "4.5,12){$J$} \\put(53,10){$s$} \\put(53,18){$s'$} \\caption{The terminology and setup of \\Cref{Def:OverlapOrientation}. The $J$--loose piece $s = [p,q] $ is shown in yellow, and the companion $s' = [p',q']$ in orange. In this example, $h$ reverses",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1030,
            "line_end": 1030,
            "char_start": 68752,
            "char_end": 68781
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Overlap",
          "to": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$q'$ in the orientation on $h \\widetilde w$, and reverses orientation on $s$ otherwise. See \\Cref{Fig:Overlap}. The $h$--overlap in $s$ is the interval $u = s \\cap h^{-1} s'$. The main steps of the proof of \\Cref{Prop:F",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1041,
            "line_end": 1041,
            "char_start": 69857,
            "char_end": 69875
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "overlap in $s$} is the interval $u = s \\cap h^{-1} s'$. The main steps of the proof of \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} can be organized as follows: \\item In \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, we show that any orientation-reversing pie",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1046,
            "line_end": 1046,
            "char_start": 69993,
            "char_end": 70018
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eps of the proof of \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} can be organized as follows: \\item In \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, we show that any orientation-reversing piece between $w$ and itself has small overlap, universally bounded by a constant $R$. Th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1048,
            "line_end": 1048,
            "char_start": 70073,
            "char_end": 70104
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ersally bounded by a constant $R$. This is an unconditional (non-probabilistic) statement. \\item In \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}, we show that pieces between separately sampled closed--geodesics $w$ and $w'$ are exponentially rare. Similarly, pieces between",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1049,
            "line_end": 1049,
            "char_start": 70297,
            "char_end": 70323
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ieces between $w$ and itself with small overlap (of size $\\leq R$) are exponentially rare. \\item In \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}, we show that pieces between $w$ and itself with big overlap (of size $\\geq R$) are also exponentially rare. This allows us to co",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1050,
            "line_end": 1050,
            "char_start": 70539,
            "char_end": 70569
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$h$--overlap $u \\subset s$ has diameter $|u| \\leq R$. In the notation of \\Cref{Def:OverlapOrientation}, the overlap is $u = [p,q] \\cap h^{-1}[p', q']$. Since $h$ is orientation-reversing, the endpoints of $u$ are $x \\in \\{p, h^{-1}",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1074,
            "line_end": 1074,
            "char_start": 71977,
            "char_end": 72006
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "tsClose} \\dist(x, hy) \\leq L \\quad \\text{and} \\quad \\dist(y, hx) \\leq L. To prove \\eqref{Eqn:EndpointsClose}, we consider two cases. For the first case, suppose that $\\dist(p,h^{-1}q') \\leq 2J$ and $\\dist(q,h^{-1}p') \\leq 2J$. Since $x \\i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1081,
            "line_end": 1081,
            "char_start": 72375,
            "char_end": 72401
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Overlap",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "that $\\dist(q,h^{-1}p') > 2J$, then the endpoints of $u$ are $x=p$ and $y=h^{-1}p'$, as depicted in \\Cref{Fig:Overlap}. It follows immediately that \\[ \\dist(x,hy) = \\dist(p,p') = J. \\] Furthermore, as in \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad},",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1090,
            "line_end": 1090,
            "char_start": 73143,
            "char_end": 73161
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "f{Fig:Overlap}. It follows immediately that \\[ \\dist(x,hy) = \\dist(p,p') = J. \\] Furthermore, as in \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, every point of $[p,q]$ is $2\\delta$--close to some point of $[p,p'] \\cup [p'",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1094,
            "line_end": 1094,
            "char_start": 73247,
            "char_end": 73266
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "uad \\dist(y,hx) \\leq 4J + J + 2J = 7J. \\] Setting $L = \\max(7J, J+4\\delta)$ completes the proof of \\Cref{Eqn:EndpointsClose}. Now, we complete the proof of the lemma. Applying \\eqref{Eqn:EndpointsClose} twice shows that $\\dist(x,h^2 x) \\leq 2L$ and $\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1107,
            "line_end": 1107,
            "char_start": 74169,
            "char_end": 74194
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "mpletes the proof of \\Cref{Eqn:EndpointsClose}. Now, we complete the proof of the lemma. Applying \\eqref{Eqn:EndpointsClose} twice shows that $\\dist(x,h^2 x) \\leq 2L$ and $\\dist(h^{-1}x,hx) \\leq 2L$. By \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, $h$ has an invariant geodesic a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1110,
            "line_end": 1110,
            "char_start": 74248,
            "char_end": 74274
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{Eqn:EndpointsClose} twice shows that $\\dist(x,h^2 x) \\leq 2L$ and $\\dist(h^{-1}x,hx) \\leq 2L$. By \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}, $h$ has an invariant geodesic axis $\\widetilde v$ in $\\widetilde X$, hence $\\stabletrans{h} \\geq 1$. Thus the $\\langle h^2 \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1112,
            "line_end": 1112,
            "char_start": 74354,
            "char_end": 74371
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:EndpointsClose",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "s to $\\widetilde v$ gives \\[ \\dist(x, hx) \\leq r + \\stabletrans{h} + r \\leq 2 r + L. \\] Meanwhile \\Cref{Eqn:EndpointsClose} gives $\\dist(hx, y) \\leq L$. Thus $R = 2r + 2L$ is a uniform bound on $|u| = \\dist(x,y)$. Since $L \\geq 7J$ by definition, we hav",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1127,
            "line_end": 1127,
            "char_start": 75124,
            "char_end": 75149
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "the maximal number of vertices in a ball of radius $n_0$, where $n_0$ is the threshold constant of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}. Fix a basepoint $x_0 \\in \\widetilde X$. Suppose that $[g], [g']$ are conjugacy classes represented by closed--geodesics $w, w'$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1152,
            "line_end": 1152,
            "char_start": 76923,
            "char_end": 76949
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "e cone-piece. (For now, we do not place any constraint on the lengths of $w, w'$, or the piece.) By \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}, the piece in $w$ is the image of a geodesic segment $s \\subset \\widetilde w \\subset \\widetilde X$, which is a $J$--loose cone p",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1155,
            "line_end": 1155,
            "char_start": 77201,
            "char_end": 77222
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "lies $J$--close to $p \\in S$, hence within distance $D+J$ of the basepoint $x_0$. Furthermore, by \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, every point of $s'$ lies within distance $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$ of some point of $s$. Since conjugacy classes in $\\pi_1 X$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1156,
            "line_end": 1156,
            "char_start": 77784,
            "char_end": 77803
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SeparateSample",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "en as above is a fundamental domain for $(w')^{\\pm 1}$. \\smallskip Now, we proceed to the proof of \\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample}. Fix a conjugacy class $[g]$ and its representative closed--geodesic $w$. We will bound the number of conjugacy classes $[g']$,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1161,
            "line_end": 1161,
            "char_start": 78569,
            "char_end": 78595
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "As a warm-up case, suppose that $|s'| \\geq |w'| - n_0$, where $n_0$ is the threshold constant in \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}. As above, $(w')^{\\pm 1}$ has a fundamental domain $v' \\subset \\widetilde w'$ whose initial segment coincides with the initial se",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1165,
            "line_end": 1165,
            "char_start": 79332,
            "char_end": 79358
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "q']$ and $\\dist(q',r') \\leq n_0$. Then, by construction, we have $\\dist(p,p') = J$. Furthermore, by \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, we have $\\dist(q',q) \\leq \\mathring J$ for some point $q \\in s$. Observe that $|\\dist(p,q) - \\dist(p',q')| \\leq J + \\mathring J$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1167,
            "line_end": 1167,
            "char_start": 79722,
            "char_end": 79741
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "n to $y'$, observe that the endpoint of $s'$ is the starting point of $y'$. Since $|y'| \\geq n_0$, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth} imply that there are at most $B e^{b|y'|}$ choices of where $y'$ ends. Thu",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1182,
            "line_end": 1182,
            "char_start": 81371,
            "char_end": 81397
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:TotalGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "endpoint of $s'$ is the starting point of $y'$. Since $|y'| \\geq n_0$, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth} imply that there are at most $B e^{b|y'|}$ choices of where $y'$ ends. Thus, for every choice of $",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1182,
            "line_end": 1182,
            "char_start": 81398,
            "char_end": 81421
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "rting point of $y'$. Since $|y'| \\geq n_0$, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth} imply that there are at most $B e^{b|y'|}$ choices of where $y'$ ends. Thus, for every choice of $s$, the number of choices for",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1182,
            "line_end": 1182,
            "char_start": 81426,
            "char_end": 81451
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{G}(\\ell)$ denotes the set of nontrivial conjugacy classes of translation length at most $\\ell$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the number of such conjugacy classes satisfies \\[ | \\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{ b \\e",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1197,
            "line_end": 1197,
            "char_start": 82862,
            "char_end": 82888
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "of nontrivial conjugacy classes of translation length at most $\\ell$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the number of such conjugacy classes satisfies \\[ | \\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{ b \\ell} . \\] Dividing the previo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1197,
            "line_end": 1197,
            "char_start": 82889,
            "char_end": 82916
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "- e^{-b} )} $ is a constant that depends only on $X$ and $J$. \\smallskip The proof of Conclusion~\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap} is very similar. Suppose that $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ is a $J$--loose cone piece between $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$, of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1214,
            "line_end": 1214,
            "char_start": 83622,
            "char_end": 83655
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ece between $\\widetilde w$ and $h \\widetilde w$, of diameter $|s| \\geq d > 2J$. Since $d$ is large, \\Cref{Def:OverlapOrientation} applies. Let $s' \\subset h\\widetilde w$ be the companion of $s$, and let $u = s \\cap h^{-1}(s')$ be the overlap. By hypothesis, w",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1214,
            "line_end": 1214,
            "char_start": 83834,
            "char_end": 83863
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:InitialCountS",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "R \\geq |s| - 2J - R$ is entirely determined by $s$ and a bounded amount of extra data. Thus, as in \\Cref{Eqn:InitialCountS}, we compute that for every choice of $s$, the number of choices for $y_1 v' y_2$ up to path-homotopy is at most \\[ 2 \\ell \\, V^2",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1217,
            "line_end": 1217,
            "char_start": 84581,
            "char_end": 84605
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:InitialCountS",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "' y_2$ up to path-homotopy is at most \\[ 2 \\ell \\, V^2 B e^{b(\\ell - 2|s| + 2J +R)}. \\] Compared to \\eqref{Eqn:InitialCountS}, the extra factor of $\\ell$ comes from the choice of where in the fundamental domain the subword $v'$ occurs, and the extra const",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1221,
            "line_end": 1221,
            "char_start": 84780,
            "char_end": 84805
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SeparateSample",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "l - |s| + 2J +R)} \\leq 2 \\ell \\, V^2 B^2 e^{b(\\ell - d + 2J +R)}. \\] The remainder of the proof of \\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample}, comparing the above upper bound to the lower bound $\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) \\geq (A/\\ell) e^{b\\ell}$, goes through verbatim. We concl",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1226,
            "line_end": 1226,
            "char_start": 85267,
            "char_end": 85293
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "We can now use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, \\ref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}, and \\ref{Lem:InfiniteWord} to show that large $J$--loose pieces between a closed--geodesic and itself",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1256,
            "line_end": 1256,
            "char_start": 87278,
            "char_end": 87308
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "We can now use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, \\ref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}, and \\ref{Lem:InfiniteWord} to show that large $J$--loose pieces between a closed--geodesic and itself are exponentially rare. \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1256,
            "line_end": 1256,
            "char_start": 87310,
            "char_end": 87335
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "We can now use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, \\ref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}, and \\ref{Lem:InfiniteWord} to show that large $J$--loose pieces between a closed--geodesic and itself are exponentially rare. \\label{Lem:SelfPie",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1256,
            "line_end": 1256,
            "char_start": 87341,
            "char_end": 87363
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "possibility where $|w| \\leq 2 d$. Since $d \\leq \\ell/3$, it follows that $|w| \\leq 2 \\ell / 3$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the total number of conjugacy classes of length at most $2 \\ell/3$ is at most $B e^{2 \\ell/3}$, wher",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1266,
            "line_end": 1266,
            "char_start": 88197,
            "char_end": 88223
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "q 2 d$. Since $d \\leq \\ell/3$, it follows that $|w| \\leq 2 \\ell / 3$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the total number of conjugacy classes of length at most $2 \\ell/3$ is at most $B e^{2 \\ell/3}$, whereas the total number of leng",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1266,
            "line_end": 1266,
            "char_start": 88224,
            "char_end": 88251
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "desic $w$ representing the conjugacy class $[g]$ has a $J$--loose cone-piece with itself. Following \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}, let $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ be a preimage of the piece in $w$, where the endpoints of $s$ lie at distance $J$ from $h \\widetild",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1272,
            "line_end": 1272,
            "char_start": 88956,
            "char_end": 88977
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:OverlapOrientation",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "f the piece in $w$, where the endpoints of $s$ lie at distance $J$ from $h \\widetilde w$. Following \\Cref{Def:OverlapOrientation}, let $s' \\subset h \\widetilde w$ be the companion of $s$, and let $u = s \\cap h^{-1}s'$ be the $h$--overlap in $s$. Let $R = R(J",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1272,
            "line_end": 1272,
            "char_start": 89123,
            "char_end": 89152
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "= s \\cap h^{-1}s'$ be the $h$--overlap in $s$. Let $R = R(J, \\delta) \\geq 10J$ be the constant of \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}. By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with prob",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89321,
            "char_end": 89352
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "lap in $s$. Let $R = R(J, \\delta) \\geq 10J$ be the constant of \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}. By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with probability at most $M_2 \\ell^2 e^",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89357,
            "char_end": 89383
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\delta) \\geq 10J$ be the constant of \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}. By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with probability at most $M_2 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, where $M_2 = M_2 (X, J) =",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89384,
            "char_end": 89417
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "t most $M_2 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, where $M_2 = M_2 (X, J) = M_0(X, J, R(J,\\delta))$ in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}. Thus, we may suppose that $|u| > R$. By \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, $h$ preserves the orientation on $s$. We now consider t",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89591,
            "char_end": 89617
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "(J,\\delta))$ in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}. Thus, we may suppose that $|u| > R$. By \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, $h$ preserves the orientation on $s$. We now consider two cases. \\smallskip Case 1: $|s| \\leq \\frac{1}{2} |w|$. W",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89659,
            "char_end": 89690
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{-1} s'$ is the $h$--overlap. Then $|y_2| \\geq R \\geq 10J$, where the second inequality comes from \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}. Consequently, \\[ | y_1| = |y_1 y_2| - |y_2| \\leq |y_1 y_2| - 10J \\leq (|y_2 y_3| + 2J) - 10J \\leq \\tfrac{1}{2} |w| - 8J, \\] and",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1282,
            "line_end": 1282,
            "char_start": 90150,
            "char_end": 90181
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "between the terminal subpath of $y_1$ and the initial subpath of $h(y_1)$. Thus, in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:InfiniteWord}, we conclude that $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$ is an $\\eta$--quasigeodesic for some $\\eta = \\eta( \\delta, J) >0$. Likewise, $(y_3 x_3",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1294,
            "line_end": 1294,
            "char_start": 90920,
            "char_end": 90943
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "These quasigeodesics fellow-travel, since they are periodically joined by translates of $y_2$. See \\Cref{Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap}. {Staircases.pdf} \\put(7,-1.5){$y_1$} \\put(32,-1.5){$y_2$} \\put(58,-1.5){$y_3$} \\put(9.5,4){$x_1$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1297,
            "line_end": 1297,
            "char_start": 91211,
            "char_end": 91241
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "infty$, a copy of $(y_2 y_3)$, and a geodesic segment of length at most $\\delta'$ (shown dashed in \\Cref{Fig:ConePieceBigOverlap}). Since the dashed segment is $\\delta'$-short, all of $y_2 y_3$ is $2 \\delta'$-close to $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$. Since $|x_1| \\leq",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1332,
            "line_end": 1332,
            "char_start": 92706,
            "char_end": 92736
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "y_1$ and a universally bounded amount of data. Since $| y_2 y_3 | \\geq d$, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, shows that the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece with this configuration is at most $M_3",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1333,
            "line_end": 1333,
            "char_start": 93005,
            "char_end": 93031
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ded amount of data. Since $| y_2 y_3 | \\geq d$, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, shows that the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece with this configuration is at most $M_3 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, for a constant",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1333,
            "line_end": 1333,
            "char_start": 93032,
            "char_end": 93065
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "of $s$. Let $\\mathring s$ be the terminal sub-geodesic of $s$, of length $| \\mathring s| = d$. By \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, there is a sub-geodesic $\\mathring s' \\subset s'$ whose endpoints are $\\mathring J$--close to those of $\\mathring s$, for $\\math",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1338,
            "line_end": 1338,
            "char_start": 93574,
            "char_end": 93593
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "athring v'$ is determined by $\\mathring s$ and a universally bounded amount of extra data. Thus, by \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece containing this configuration is at most $M_4 \\ell^",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1340,
            "line_end": 1340,
            "char_start": 94182,
            "char_end": 94208
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "y $\\mathring s$ and a universally bounded amount of extra data. Thus, by \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece containing this configuration is at most $M_4 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, where $M_4 = M_4 (X,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1340,
            "line_end": 1340,
            "char_start": 94209,
            "char_end": 94242
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "4 \\ell^2 e^{-b d}$, where $M_4 = M_4 (X, J) = M_0(X, \\mathring J, R(J,\\delta))$ in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}. If $|\\mathring u| \\geq R = R(J, \\delta)$, we employ the argument of Case 1, with $\\mathring J$ in place of $J$, to show that th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1340,
            "line_end": 1340,
            "char_start": 94431,
            "char_end": 94457
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "desic and itself. Let $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}. Combining the two lemmas, we see that a $J$--loose cone-piece of d",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1361,
            "line_end": 1361,
            "char_start": 95892,
            "char_end": 95918
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:SeparateSample",
          "to": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "} Let $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}. Combining the two lemmas, we see that a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ in the",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1361,
            "line_end": 1361,
            "char_start": 95919,
            "char_end": 95945
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "to": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}. Combining the two lemmas, we see that a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ in the closed--geodesic representing $[g]",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1361,
            "line_end": 1361,
            "char_start": 95950,
            "char_end": 95980
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\subsection{Controlling pieces among many conjugacy classes} We can now apply \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} to bound the probability of a large $J$--loose cone-piece between a pair of conjugacy classes that are sampled from a large colle",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1376,
            "line_end": 1376,
            "char_start": 96859,
            "char_end": 96884
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "t are sampled from a large collection, where ``large'' is defined as a fraction of the systole. See \\Cref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}. We can then combine this result with \\Cref{Prop:WallPieceControl} to prove the main theorem. \\label{Lem:ConePieceDi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1376,
            "line_end": 1376,
            "char_start": 97082,
            "char_end": 97110
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "s a fraction of the systole. See \\Cref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}. We can then combine this result with \\Cref{Prop:WallPieceControl} to prove the main theorem. Fix constants $q \\in \\big( 0,\\frac{1}{6} \\big]$ and $J \\in",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1376,
            "line_end": 1376,
            "char_start": 97149,
            "char_end": 97177
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$. Since $d$ is bounded below by a linear function of $\\ell$, the logarithmic hypothesis on $d$ in \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} is satisfied for $\\ell \\gg 0$. The above choices imply that there are $k^2 \\leq e^{2c \\ell} < e^{2 q b \\phi^2 \\ell}$ pairs of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1392,
            "line_end": 1392,
            "char_start": 97992,
            "char_end": 98017
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "^{2c \\ell} < e^{2 q b \\phi^2 \\ell}$ pairs of indices $(i,j)$. When $\\ell$ is sufficiently large, \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} says that for every pair $(i,j)$, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ between $w_i$ and $w_j$ is",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1394,
            "line_end": 1394,
            "char_start": 98201,
            "char_end": 98226
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:Systole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "} \\geq (1-q)\\ell$. Let $w_i$ be a closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that $|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is \\[ \\frac{\\ma",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1416,
            "line_end": 1416,
            "char_start": 99487,
            "char_end": 99513
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:Systole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "} Let $w_i$ be a closed--geodesic representing $[g_i]$. By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that $|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is \\[ \\frac{\\mathcal{G}((1-q)\\ell)}{\\mathca",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1416,
            "line_end": 1416,
            "char_start": 99514,
            "char_end": 99541
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ter strictly less than $ \\alpha |g_i |$ for every $i$. We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$. Observe that the hypothesis $\\alpha \\leq \\frac{2}{5}$ implies $q \\leq \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1436,
            "line_end": 1436,
            "char_start": 100576,
            "char_end": 100603
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Systole",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "|g_i |$ for every $i$. We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$. Observe that the hypothesis $\\alpha \\leq \\frac{2}{5}$ implies $q \\leq \\frac{1}{6}$, as requir",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1436,
            "line_end": 1436,
            "char_start": 100608,
            "char_end": 100625
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Observe that the hypothesis $\\alpha \\leq \\frac{2}{5}$ implies $q \\leq \\frac{1}{6}$, as required for \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter}. With this value of $q$, \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} says that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all cone-pie",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1436,
            "line_end": 1436,
            "char_start": 100762,
            "char_end": 100790
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "mplies $q \\leq \\frac{1}{6}$, as required for \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter}. With this value of $q$, \\Cref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} says that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, all cone-pieces have diameter strictly less than $ \\frac{2 \\alpha}{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1438,
            "line_end": 1438,
            "char_start": 100817,
            "char_end": 100845
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Systole",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "y$, all cone-pieces have diameter strictly less than $ \\frac{2 \\alpha}{\\alpha+2} \\ell $. Meanwhile, \\Cref{Lem:Systole} says that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, $\\min_{i=1}^k \\{|g_i | \\} \\geq (1-q) \\ell = \\frac{2}{\\alpha+2} \\e",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1439,
            "line_end": 1439,
            "char_start": 101004,
            "char_end": 101022
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Systole",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "er of every cone-piece in $w_i$ is less than $\\alpha |w_i | $. In the same spirit as \\Cref{Lem:Systole}, we have Suppose $k \\leq e^{c \\ell}$ for some constant $c < b/2$. Then, with overwhelming proba",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1446,
            "line_end": 1446,
            "char_start": 101324,
            "char_end": 101342
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "to": "Lem:Primitive",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "y chosen conjugacy classes has the property that each one is primitive. By \\Cref{Rem:NonPrimitive}, the probability that $[g_i]$ is non-primitive is bounded above by \\[ \\frac{\\ell^2 B}{A} e^{-b\\ell/2} . \\] Thus the probability t",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1453,
            "line_end": 1453,
            "char_start": 101621,
            "char_end": 101644
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "of} We can now restate and prove \\Cref{Thm:main}. {Theorem~\\ref{Thm:main}} Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex, and suppose th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1466,
            "line_end": 1466,
            "char_start": 102108,
            "char_end": 102123
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "We can now restate and prove \\Cref{Thm:main}. {Theorem~\\ref{Thm:main}} Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex, and suppose that $G$ is hyperbolic. Let $b$ be the gr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1468,
            "line_end": 1468,
            "char_start": 102148,
            "char_end": 102162
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eorem holds vacuously. We begin by replacing $X$ with a closely related cube complex that satisfies \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. First, we perform a cubical subdivision of $X$, while retaining the original metric. Then every conjugacy class $[g] \\subset G",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1483,
            "line_end": 1483,
            "char_start": 103041,
            "char_end": 103058
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "uotient $Y_i = \\langle g_i \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde Y_i$ admits a local isometry into $X$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle. By",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1492,
            "line_end": 1492,
            "char_start": 103868,
            "char_end": 103899
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "d Y_1,\\ldots, Y_k\\rangle$ such that $\\pi_1 X^* = \\overline{G}$. Define $J = J(\\widetilde X)$ as in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}. Then every diameter $ \\geq d$ cone-piece of $X^*$ between $Y_i$ and $Y_j$ corresponds to a $J$--loose cone-piece between $w_i$ a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1495,
            "line_end": 1495,
            "char_start": 104287,
            "char_end": 104306
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "-a)$ and \\( c < \\frac{b/20}{1/20 + 2} = \\frac{b}{20} \\cdot \\frac{20}{41} . \\) Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1504,
            "line_end": 1504,
            "char_start": 104879,
            "char_end": 104906
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "20 + 2} = \\frac{b}{20} \\cdot \\frac{20}{41} . \\) Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diamete",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1504,
            "line_end": 1504,
            "char_start": 104911,
            "char_end": 104938
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$. Thus, by \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}, the wall-pieces and cone-pieces in a relator $Y_i$ of $X^*$ also have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$. Thu",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1504,
            "line_end": 1504,
            "char_start": 105137,
            "char_end": 105156
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Thus $X^*$ satisfies the $C'(\\alpha)$ small-cancellation condition. Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. We have verified that with overw",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1508,
            "line_end": 1508,
            "char_start": 105383,
            "char_end": 105409
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. We have verified that with overwhelming probability, $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ and that every $Y_i$ is a compact quasi-circle",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1510,
            "line_end": 1510,
            "char_start": 105484,
            "char_end": 105505
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "hat every $Y_i$ is a compact quasi-circle that deformation retracts to a closed--geodesic $w_i$. By \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY}, every hyperplane $U \\subset Y_i$ has a carrier $N(U)$ of diameter strictly less than $\\alpha \\systole",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1511,
            "line_end": 1511,
            "char_start": 105693,
            "char_end": 105712
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:HyperplaneInY",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "compact quasi-circle that deformation retracts to a closed--geodesic $w_i$. By \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY}, every hyperplane $U \\subset Y_i$ has a carrier $N(U)$ of diameter strictly less than $\\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$, which implies that",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1511,
            "line_end": 1511,
            "char_start": 105713,
            "char_end": 105738
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Primitive",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cut the closed--geodesic $w_i$, we also conclude that $Y_i \\setminus U$ is contractible. Finally, \\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $w_i$ is primitive. Therefore, \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1511,
            "line_end": 1511,
            "char_start": 106003,
            "char_end": 106023
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $w_i$ is primitive. Therefore, \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$. \\end",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1512,
            "line_end": 1512,
            "char_start": 106108,
            "char_end": 106129
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\section{Generalization to other metric spaces} In this section, we prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, which generalizes \\Cref{Thm:main} to the setting of groups acting on other, non-cubical metric spaces. The idea is to prove a pr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1519,
            "line_end": 1519,
            "char_start": 106368,
            "char_end": 106390
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "spaces} In this section, we prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, which generalizes \\Cref{Thm:main} to the setting of groups acting on other, non-cubical metric spaces. The idea is to prove a probabilistic statement for quotients",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1519,
            "line_end": 1519,
            "char_start": 106410,
            "char_end": 106425
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceUpsilon",
          "to": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": ":AuxiliarySmallCancel} Let $\\Upsilon$, $\\delta$, $\\upsilon$, $G$, and $H_1, \\ldots, H_m$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceUpsilon}. Let $\\kappa_j$ be the quasiconvexity constant of the orbit $H_j \\upsilon$, and let $\\kappa = \\max_j \\{ \\kappa_j \\} + 2 \\delta$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1551,
            "line_end": 1551,
            "char_start": 109913,
            "char_end": 109936
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:TransLength",
          "to": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\subset \\Upsilon$, we have $|\\gamma_i| = |g_i|_{{}_\\Upsilon} = \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$ in \\Cref{Def:TransLength}. The presentation $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is called \\emph{$C'(\\alpha)$ with respect to $(\\U",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1554,
            "line_end": 1554,
            "char_start": 110393,
            "char_end": 110415
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Pieces",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "r less than $ \\alpha \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$. The results of \\Cref{Sec:Pieces} have the following generalization to this context. Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1565,
            "line_end": 1565,
            "char_start": 111029,
            "char_end": 111046
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "text. Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ acting on $\\Upsilon$. Consider conjugacy classes $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ in $G$, chosen u",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1568,
            "line_end": 1568,
            "char_start": 111192,
            "char_end": 111223
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:GeneralConePiece",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nstant $c < b\\alpha/(\\alpha+2)$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralConePiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds. Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1572,
            "line_end": 1572,
            "char_start": 111566,
            "char_end": 111594
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralConePiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds. Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:Auxili",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1572,
            "line_end": 1572,
            "char_start": 111598,
            "char_end": 111629
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rop} Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$, and let $a$ be an upper bound on the growth exponents of the $H_j$. Note that all lengths",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1578,
            "line_end": 1578,
            "char_start": 111743,
            "char_end": 111774
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Itm:GeneralWallPiece",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ll}$ for some $c < \\alpha(b-a)$. Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralWallPiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds. [Sketch] The proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedCo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1580,
            "line_end": 1580,
            "char_start": 112236,
            "char_end": 112264
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Then, with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, property \\eqref{Itm:GeneralWallPiece} of \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds. [Sketch] The proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWa",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1580,
            "line_end": 1580,
            "char_start": 112269,
            "char_end": 112300
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel} holds. [Sketch] The proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} are nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:Wall",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1586,
            "line_end": 1586,
            "char_start": 112371,
            "char_end": 112402
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "alizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} are nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively. There are two differences in the argument. The primary difference is that $\\Upsil",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1587,
            "line_end": 1587,
            "char_start": 112486,
            "char_end": 112513
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "eneralizedWallPiece} are nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively. There are two differences in the argument. The primary difference is that $\\Upsilon$ is substituted for $\\widetil",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1587,
            "line_end": 1587,
            "char_start": 112518,
            "char_end": 112545
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The requirement that every infinite-order element of $\\pi_1 X$ stabilizes a geodesic axis (compare \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}), which was heavily used in the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, is mirrored i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1589,
            "line_end": 1589,
            "char_start": 112862,
            "char_end": 112879
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "s a geodesic axis (compare \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}), which was heavily used in the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, is mirrored in our setting by the same requirement in $\\Upsilon$. Note that in both Propositions",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1589,
            "line_end": 1589,
            "char_start": 112935,
            "char_end": 112962
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{Conv:NiceX}), which was heavily used in the proofs of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, is mirrored in our setting by the same requirement in $\\Upsilon$. Note that in both Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1589,
            "line_end": 1589,
            "char_start": 112967,
            "char_end": 112994
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "}, is mirrored in our setting by the same requirement in $\\Upsilon$. Note that in both Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}, we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfec",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1590,
            "line_end": 1590,
            "char_start": 113093,
            "char_end": 113120
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "the same requirement in $\\Upsilon$. Note that in both Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}, we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfectly well to the $G$--action on $",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1590,
            "line_end": 1590,
            "char_start": 113125,
            "char_end": 113152
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "allPieceControl} and~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole}, we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfectly well to the $G$--action on $\\Upsilon$. The second difference is more subtle. In the arguments of \\Cref{Se",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1590,
            "line_end": 1590,
            "char_start": 113204,
            "char_end": 113230
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Pieces",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "y well to the $G$--action on $\\Upsilon$. The second difference is more subtle. In the arguments of \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}, a loose piece $s \\subset \\widetilde w$ is always a combinatorial geodesic segment whose endpoints are at vertices of $\\widetilde",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1592,
            "line_end": 1592,
            "char_start": 113352,
            "char_end": 113369
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$y$ are both combinatorial geodesics, and the number of possibilities for $y$ can be estimated via \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}. Meanwhile, in $\\Upsilon$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1592,
            "line_end": 1592,
            "char_start": 113686,
            "char_end": 113712
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "desics, and the number of possibilities for $y$ can be estimated via \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}. Meanwhile, in $\\Upsilon$, the set of endpoints of loos",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1592,
            "line_end": 1592,
            "char_start": 113717,
            "char_end": 113742
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:WallPieceCyclicPerm",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "d additive error, which becomes absorbed into the multiplicative constants of calculations such as \\eqref{Eqn:WallPieceCyclicPerm} and \\eqref{Eqn:InitialCountS}. Thus perturbing $\\widetilde \\gamma$ to pass through the orbit $G\\upsilon$ does not affect the prob",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1596,
            "line_end": 1596,
            "char_start": 114323,
            "char_end": 114354
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:InitialCountS",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "rbed into the multiplicative constants of calculations such as \\eqref{Eqn:WallPieceCyclicPerm} and \\eqref{Eqn:InitialCountS}. Thus perturbing $\\widetilde \\gamma$ to pass through the orbit $G\\upsilon$ does not affect the probabilistic conclusions. \\end{pr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1596,
            "line_end": 1596,
            "char_start": 114359,
            "char_end": 114384
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rbit $G\\upsilon$ does not affect the probabilistic conclusions. Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives: Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1599,
            "line_end": 1599,
            "char_start": 114543,
            "char_end": 114574
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "probabilistic conclusions. Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives: Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1599,
            "line_end": 1599,
            "char_start": 114579,
            "char_end": 114610
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "e} gives: Let $G$, $\\Upsilon$, and $\\{ H_i \\}$ be as in \\Cref{Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel}. Let $b$ be the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$, and let $a$ be an upper bound on the growth exponents of the $",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1602,
            "line_end": 1602,
            "char_start": 114708,
            "char_end": 114739
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Sec:Pieces",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ilon, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$. \\subsection{Translation back to cube complexes} In \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}, we used \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp} to show that every piece in a cubical presentation is associated with a corresponding $J$--loose pie",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1612,
            "line_end": 1612,
            "char_start": 115543,
            "char_end": 115560
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "mma_k)$. \\subsection{Translation back to cube complexes} In \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}, we used \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp} to show that every piece in a cubical presentation is associated with a corresponding $J$--loose piece, in the sense of \\Cref{Def",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1612,
            "line_end": 1612,
            "char_start": 115570,
            "char_end": 115589
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:LoosePiece",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "iece in a cubical presentation is associated with a corresponding $J$--loose piece, in the sense of \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}. The following statement is an analogue of \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp} that allows us to compare pieces in a cubical presentation $\\langl",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1612,
            "line_end": 1612,
            "char_start": 115710,
            "char_end": 115731
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$J$--loose piece, in the sense of \\Cref{Def:LoosePiece}. The following statement is an analogue of \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp} that allows us to compare pieces in a cubical presentation $\\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ to loose pieces in a $G$--a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1612,
            "line_end": 1612,
            "char_start": 115775,
            "char_end": 115794
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:Lambda12",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{prop} We begin by recalling the above definition of a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry. By \\Cref{Eqn:Lambda12}, there is a ($G$--equivariant) function $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$, along with positive constants $\\lambda_1, \\lambda_2,",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1628,
            "line_end": 1628,
            "char_start": 117326,
            "char_end": 117345
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "ow relate the systole of $Y_i$ in $X$ to the (stable) translation length of $g_i$ in $\\Upsilon$. By \\Cref{Def:Piece} and \\Cref{Def:TransLength}, we have \\[ \\systole{Y_i} = |g_i|_{{}_X} \\geq \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1633,
            "line_end": 1633,
            "char_start": 117854,
            "char_end": 117870
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:TransLength",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "of $Y_i$ in $X$ to the (stable) translation length of $g_i$ in $\\Upsilon$. By \\Cref{Def:Piece} and \\Cref{Def:TransLength}, we have \\[ \\systole{Y_i} = |g_i|_{{}_X} \\geq \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} = \\lim_{n \\to \\infty} \\frac{\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(q, g_i^",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1633,
            "line_end": 1633,
            "char_start": 117875,
            "char_end": 117897
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$Y_i$ and $Y_j$, where $d$ is very large (the precise criterion will be described below). Following \\Cref{Def:Piece}, this piece is a component of $\\widetilde Y_i \\cap \\widetilde Y_j$ for appropriate preimages $\\widetilde Y_i$ and $\\widetilde Y_",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1649,
            "line_end": 1649,
            "char_start": 119095,
            "char_end": 119111
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "x,y \\in \\widetilde Y_i \\cap \\widetilde Y_j$ be points such that $\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) = d$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ and $x_j, y_j \\in \\widetilde w_j$ that are $K$--close to $x$ and $y$, respective",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1649,
            "line_end": 1649,
            "char_start": 119350,
            "char_end": 119381
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:InfinitelyManyPrimes",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "--close to $x$ and $y$, respectively. The following construction in $\\Upsilon$ is illustrated in \\Cref{Fig:InfinitelyManyPrimes}. Let $\\widetilde \\gamma_i, \\widetilde \\gamma_j$ be the representative axes for $g_i, g_j$, respectively, in $\\Upsilon$. Let $\\w",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1651,
            "line_end": 1651,
            "char_start": 119577,
            "char_end": 119608
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:LambdaRestate",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": ", y_i''']$.} Observe that the second inequality in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate} gives \\[ \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i'', x_j'') \\leq \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i', x_j') + 2 \\eta \\leq \\lambda_2 \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x_i, x_j) + \\e",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1688,
            "line_end": 1688,
            "char_start": 121673,
            "char_end": 121697
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:LambdaRestate",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "i'', y_j'') \\leq \\lambda_2 \\cdot 2K + \\epsilon + 2 \\eta$. At the same time, the first inequality in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate} gives \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i'', y_i'') \\geq \\dist_\\Upsilon(x_i', y_i') - 2 \\eta \\g",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1692,
            "line_end": 1692,
            "char_start": 122023,
            "char_end": 122047
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:SystoleComparison",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "lambda_2 K + 6 \\eta + 4 \\delta + 3 \\epsilon ). Combining the last computation with \\Cref{Eqn:SystoleComparison}, we obtain \\[ \\frac{ \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2}{ \\overline \\lambda } \\, \\alpha \\systole{Y_i} \\geq \\frac{ \\lambda_1}{\\: \\overlin",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1720,
            "line_end": 1720,
            "char_start": 124427,
            "char_end": 124455
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Piece",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "$P$ may or may not be disjoint from $\\widetilde Y_i$, hence might not be a wall-piece, according to \\Cref{Def:Piece}. Compare \\Cref{Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane}.) Let $x,y \\in P$ be points realizing the diameter. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1737,
            "line_end": 1737,
            "char_start": 125627,
            "char_end": 125643
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "oint from $\\widetilde Y_i$, hence might not be a wall-piece, according to \\Cref{Def:Piece}. Compare \\Cref{Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane}.) Let $x,y \\in P$ be points realizing the diameter. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in \\wideti",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1737,
            "line_end": 1737,
            "char_start": 125653,
            "char_end": 125685
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": ". Compare \\Cref{Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane}.) Let $x,y \\in P$ be points realizing the diameter. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ that are $K$--close to $x$ and $y$, respectively. Similarly, there are point",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1738,
            "line_end": 1738,
            "char_start": 125743,
            "char_end": 125774
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:SystoleComparison",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "mbda_2 (K + 1) + 2\\epsilon + \\psi + \\delta ) . Combining the last computation with \\Cref{Eqn:SystoleComparison}, we obtain \\[ \\frac{ \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2}{ \\overline \\lambda } \\, \\alpha \\systole{Y_i} \\geq \\frac{ \\lambda_1 }{ \\: \\overli",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1785,
            "line_end": 1785,
            "char_start": 129378,
            "char_end": 129406
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "presentation is $C'(\\alpha)$. \\subsection{Main result} We can now restate and prove \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}. After the proof, we discuss a potential strengthening. {Theorem~\\ref{Thm:OtherSample}} Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1804,
            "line_end": 1804,
            "char_start": 130375,
            "char_end": 130397
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ref{Thm:OtherSample}. After the proof, we discuss a potential strengthening. {Theorem~\\ref{Thm:OtherSample}} Let $G=\\pi_1X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex, and suppose that $G$ is hyperbolic. Suppose that $G$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1806,
            "line_end": 1806,
            "char_start": 130477,
            "char_end": 130498
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "d c < \\frac{b \\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda}} { \\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda} + 2}. \\] As in the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main}, we replace $X$ by its essential core, so that all hyperplanes are essential. This does not affect the multiplicative constant $\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1836,
            "line_end": 1836,
            "char_start": 131993,
            "char_end": 132008
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "is represented by a closed--geodesic. Both operations preserve the growth exponents $a$ and $b$. \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon} implies that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the presentation $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1838,
            "line_end": 1838,
            "char_start": 132455,
            "char_end": 132484
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "uotient $Y_i = \\langle g_i \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde Y_i$ admits a local isometry into $X$. By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle. By",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1842,
            "line_end": 1842,
            "char_start": 133045,
            "char_end": 133076
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "entation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1,\\ldots, Y_k\\rangle$ such that $\\pi_1 X^* = \\overline{G}$. Now, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} implies that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1844,
            "line_end": 1844,
            "char_start": 133409,
            "char_end": 133434
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$ of every $Y_i$ satisfies $\\diameter{N(U)} < \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$. Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. We have verified that with overw",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1845,
            "line_end": 1845,
            "char_start": 133752,
            "char_end": 133778
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic. Next, we check the hypotheses of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}. We have verified that with overwhelming probability, $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{20})$ and that every $Y_i$ is compact and deformation",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1847,
            "line_end": 1847,
            "char_start": 133853,
            "char_end": 133874
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "'(\\frac{1}{20})$ and that every $Y_i$ is compact and deformation retracts to a closed--geodesic. By \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}, every hyperplane $U \\subset Y_i$ has a carrier $N(U)$ of diameter strictly less than $\\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$, which implies that",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1848,
            "line_end": 1848,
            "char_start": 134040,
            "char_end": 134065
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Primitive",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ic $w_i$, we also conclude that $Y_i \\setminus U$ is contractible. Finally, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $g_i$ is primitive. Therefore, \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1848,
            "line_end": 1848,
            "char_start": 134353,
            "char_end": 134373
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:OtherMetric",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $g_i$ is primitive. Therefore, \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$. \\end",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1849,
            "line_end": 1849,
            "char_start": 134458,
            "char_end": 134479
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "tilde{X^*}$. In the above proof of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, all of the probabilistic arguments happen inside \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon}, which combines Propositions~\\ref{Prop:Generalize",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1854,
            "line_end": 1854,
            "char_start": 134691,
            "char_end": 134713
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ion} In the above proof of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, all of the probabilistic arguments happen inside \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon}, which combines Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece}. By contrast, \\Cref{Prop:QITran",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1854,
            "line_end": 1854,
            "char_start": 134764,
            "char_end": 134793
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "he probabilistic arguments happen inside \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon}, which combines Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece}. By contrast, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} involves a global assumption (a $G$--equivariant $\\l",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1854,
            "line_end": 1854,
            "char_start": 134823,
            "char_end": 134854
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "side \\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon}, which combines Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece}. By contrast, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} involves a global assumption (a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry), and the proo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1854,
            "line_end": 1854,
            "char_start": 134859,
            "char_end": 134890
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nes Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece}. By contrast, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} involves a global assumption (a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry), and the proof works entirely in the language of coars",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1855,
            "line_end": 1855,
            "char_start": 134906,
            "char_end": 134931
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "coarse geometry without invoking any counting or probability. One can envision a strengthening of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} that tracks the behavior of a typical conjugacy class and a typical piece. To make this precise, choose a basepoint $x \\in \\wid",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1856,
            "line_end": 1856,
            "char_start": 135155,
            "char_end": 135180
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:Growth",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "g \\in G : \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x, gx) \\leq n\\}$. Define $B_n(\\Upsilon)$ similarly, and recall from \\Cref{Def:Growth} that $f_{G, \\Upsilon}(n)$ counts the cardinality of $B_n(\\Upsilon)$. Define the \\emph{mean distortion of $\\widetilde X$ with resp",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1860,
            "line_end": 1860,
            "char_start": 135451,
            "char_end": 135468
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:LambdaRestate",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ose there is a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$, as in \\Cref{Eqn:LambdaRestate}, so that $f(x) = \\upsilon$. Then \\[ \\frac{1}{\\lambda_1} \\leq \\frac{1}{\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon)} \\leq \\lambda_2. \\] For a ch",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1873,
            "line_end": 1873,
            "char_start": 136657,
            "char_end": 136681
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "s:MarkedLengthSpectrum}. We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}. The proof begins by observing that every conjugacy class $[g_i]$ satisfies $ \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} \\geq (\\lambda_2)^{-1} \\st",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1888,
            "line_end": 1888,
            "char_start": 137940,
            "char_end": 137965
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:SystoleComparison",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$ satisfies $ \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_X} \\geq (\\lambda_2)^{-1} \\stabletrans{g_i}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$; see \\Cref{Eqn:SystoleComparison}. Since $[g_i]$ is $\\Upsilon$--typical with overwhelming probability, we may replace $(\\lambda_2)^{-1}$ by $\\big( \\tau(\\widetilde",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1888,
            "line_end": 1888,
            "char_start": 138130,
            "char_end": 138158
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ce $(\\lambda_2)^{-1}$ by $\\big( \\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Upsilon) - \\epsilon \\big)$. Next, the proof of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} uses the constant $\\lambda_1$ to pass from the diameter of a piece in $X^*$ to the diameter of a loose piece in $\\Upsilon$; see \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1889,
            "line_end": 1889,
            "char_start": 138340,
            "char_end": 138365
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:PieceDistortionUpsilon",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$ to pass from the diameter of a piece in $X^*$ to the diameter of a loose piece in $\\Upsilon$; see \\Cref{Eqn:PieceDistortionUpsilon}. If one knew that a cone-piece or wall-piece in $X^*$, coming from a random presentation as in the statement of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSa",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1889,
            "line_end": 1889,
            "char_start": 138494,
            "char_end": 138527
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "that a cone-piece or wall-piece in $X^*$, coming from a random presentation as in the statement of \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, also corresponds to an $\\Upsilon$--typical group element of $G$, one could replace $\\lambda_1$ by $\\big(\\tau(\\widetilde X / \\Up",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1889,
            "line_end": 1889,
            "char_start": 138640,
            "char_end": 138662
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\Upsilon$) can be represented by $\\Upsilon$--typical group elements is an interesting problem. See \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces}. \\section{Pentagonal surfaces} Throughout this section, we consider the setting where $\\Ups",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1892,
            "line_end": 1892,
            "char_start": 139253,
            "char_end": 139285
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "etry from $\\widetilde X$ to $\\Upsilon$. This can be considered the first interesting example where \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} applies. Let $T$ be the tiling of $\\HH^2$ by regular right-angled pentagons, with hyper",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1901,
            "line_end": 1901,
            "char_start": 139746,
            "char_end": 139768
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rmore, this value of $\\lambda$ is optimal. As mentioned in the introduction, combining \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. The proof of \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1914,
            "char_start": 140499,
            "char_end": 140521
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "a$ is optimal. As mentioned in the introduction, combining \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. The proof of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is ent",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1914,
            "char_start": 140527,
            "char_end": 140551
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:H2Action",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. The proof of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is entirely elementary and largely pictorial; see Figures~\\ref{Fig:PentagonLengths}--\\ref",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1914,
            "char_start": 140615,
            "char_end": 140634
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. The proof of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is entirely elementary and largely pictorial; see Figures~\\ref{Fig:PentagonLengths}--\\ref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments}. The proof als",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 140650,
            "char_end": 140674
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "}. The proof of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is entirely elementary and largely pictorial; see Figures~\\ref{Fig:PentagonLengths}--\\ref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments}. The proof also trades the coarse geometry that has dominated most of this paper for the fine geom",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 140733,
            "char_end": 140758
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:LengthThreeSegments",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": ":PentagonalQI} is entirely elementary and largely pictorial; see Figures~\\ref{Fig:PentagonLengths}--\\ref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments}. The proof also trades the coarse geometry that has dominated most of this paper for the fine geometry of $\\HH^2$. We begin with",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 140760,
            "char_end": 140789
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "arse geometry that has dominated most of this paper for the fine geometry of $\\HH^2$. We begin with \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}, which computes a number of lengths in a single right-angled pentagon using the hyperbolic laws of sines and cosines \\cite{Fenche",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 140919,
            "char_end": 140945
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "f sines and cosines \\cite{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry, Ratcliffe:Foundations}. We then continue with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate}, which considers a number of combinatorial possibilities for how a hyperbolic geodesic segment can cross a sequence of several ad",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 141143,
            "char_end": 141172
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "{Lem:PentagonLengths} Let $P \\subset \\HH^2$ be a regular right-angled pentagon. Label lengths as in \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}. Set $K = \\cos \\big( \\frac{2\\pi}{5} \\big)$. Then the labeled lengths can be expressed as follows: a &= \\arccosh \\bi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1919,
            "line_end": 1919,
            "char_start": 141438,
            "char_end": 141464
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rmore, the length $g$ of a geodesic segment contained in two adjacent right-angled pentagons, as in \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, satisfies 2g = \\arccosh(1+2K (8 K^2+8K+1)^2) \\approx 3.1838.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1970,
            "line_end": 1970,
            "char_start": 142978,
            "char_end": 143004
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "In \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths}, left, the right-angled pentagon $P$ is subdivided into five isometric quadrilaterals, arranged symmetrically about the center po",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1980,
            "line_end": 1980,
            "char_start": 143203,
            "char_end": 143229
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:ALength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "tcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ K = \\cos \\theta = \\sinh^2 a, \\] hence $K+1 = \\cosh^2 a$, implying \\Cref{Eqn:ALength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.8]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ \\cosh^2 b = \\left( \\frac{\\cos \\theta \\cdot \\cos (\\tfrac{\\pi}{2}) + \\cosh",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1985,
            "line_end": 1985,
            "char_start": 143825,
            "char_end": 143843
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:BLength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "{2})} \\right)^2 = \\frac{\\cosh^2 a}{\\sin^2 \\theta} = \\frac{1+K}{1-K^2} = \\frac{1}{1-K}, \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:BLength}. The hyperbolic law of cosines \\cite[Thm 3.5.3]{Ratcliffe:Foundations} implies the following version of the Pythagorean theorem",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1991,
            "line_end": 1991,
            "char_start": 144111,
            "char_end": 144129
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "} Now, consider the distances between the midpoints of edges in the right-angled pentagon $P$. By \\eqref{Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean}, the midpoints of two adjacent edges are separated by distance $c$, where \\[ \\cosh c = \\cosh^2 a = \\sinh^2 a + 1 = K + 1, \\] impl",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1999,
            "line_end": 1999,
            "char_start": 144582,
            "char_end": 144615
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:CLength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "es are separated by distance $c$, where \\[ \\cosh c = \\cosh^2 a = \\sinh^2 a + 1 = K + 1, \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:CLength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.3]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, the midpoints of two non-adjacent edges are separated by distance $d$, where \\[ \\cos",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2003,
            "line_end": 2003,
            "char_start": 144750,
            "char_end": 144768
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:DLength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "2K^2 -1$ gives \\[ \\cosh d = \\frac{1}{1-K} - \\frac{K (2K^2 -1)}{1-K} = 2 K^2 + 2K + 1, \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:DLength}. To compute the lengths $e$ and $f$, observe that \\[ \\cosh a = \\sqrt{\\sinh^2 a +1} = \\sqrt{K+1} \\qquad \\text{and} \\qquad",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2012,
            "line_end": 2012,
            "char_start": 145153,
            "char_end": 145171
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "rt{\\sinh^2 a +1} = \\sqrt{K+1} \\qquad \\text{and} \\qquad \\cosh(2a) = 2 \\sinh^2 a + 1 = 2K +1. \\] Now, \\eqref{Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean} gives \\[ \\cosh(e) = \\cosh(2a) \\cdot \\cosh a = (2K+1) \\sqrt{K+1} , \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:ELength}. Similarly, \\eqref{Eqn:Hyperbo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2021,
            "line_end": 2021,
            "char_start": 145346,
            "char_end": 145379
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:ELength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "perbolicPythagorean} gives \\[ \\cosh(e) = \\cosh(2a) \\cdot \\cosh a = (2K+1) \\sqrt{K+1} , \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:ELength}. Similarly, \\eqref{Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean} gives \\cosh(f) = \\cosh(2a)^2 = (2K+1)^2 = 4K",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2025,
            "line_end": 2025,
            "char_start": 145459,
            "char_end": 145477
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "osh(e) = \\cosh(2a) \\cdot \\cosh a = (2K+1) \\sqrt{K+1} , \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:ELength}. Similarly, \\eqref{Eqn:HyperbolicPythagorean} gives \\cosh(f) = \\cosh(2a)^2 = (2K+1)^2 = 4K^2 + 4K + 1, implying \\Cref{Eqn",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2026,
            "line_end": 2026,
            "char_start": 145491,
            "char_end": 145524
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:FLength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "n*} \\cosh(f) = \\cosh(2a)^2 = (2K+1)^2 = 4K^2 + 4K + 1, implying \\Cref{Eqn:FLength}. Finally, we use \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths} to compute the length $g$. In that figure, we have a hyperbolic quadrilateral with",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2030,
            "line_end": 2030,
            "char_start": 145645,
            "char_end": 145663
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "h(2a)^2 = (2K+1)^2 = 4K^2 + 4K + 1, implying \\Cref{Eqn:FLength}. Finally, we use \\Cref{Fig:PentagonLengths} to compute the length $g$. In that figure, we have a hyperbolic quadrilateral with two right angles at the ends of a side of leng",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2033,
            "line_end": 2033,
            "char_start": 145683,
            "char_end": 145709
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:Fenchel",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "(2a)=2K+1$, hence \\[ \\cosh(4a) = 2 \\cosh^2(2a) - 1 = 8 K^2 + 8K + 1. \\] Substituting all this into \\Cref{Eqn:Fenchel} gives \\cosh(2g) & = - \\sinh^2(4a) + \\cosh^2(4a) \\cosh(2a) \\\\ & = 1 - \\cosh^2(4a) + \\cosh(2a) \\cosh^2(4a) \\\\ & = 1+",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2041,
            "line_end": 2041,
            "char_start": 146283,
            "char_end": 146301
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:GLength",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "candidate_proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "^2(4a) \\\\ & = 1+ (\\cosh(2a) -1) \\cosh^2(4a) \\\\ & = 1 + 2K (8 K^2 + 8K + 1)^2, implying \\Cref{Eqn:GLength}. For the rest of this section, the symbols $a, \\ldots, g$ will always denote the constants computed in the above lem",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2048,
            "line_end": 2048,
            "char_start": 146515,
            "char_end": 146533
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "detilde X}(x,y) + \\epsilon, where the constants $c,d$ are as in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Furthermore, the multiplicative constants $c,d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} are sharp. Observe that the constant $\\la",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2059,
            "line_end": 2059,
            "char_start": 147494,
            "char_end": 147520
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ants $c,d$ are as in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Furthermore, the multiplicative constants $c,d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} are sharp. Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$. Thus \\C",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2059,
            "line_end": 2059,
            "char_start": 147573,
            "char_end": 147596
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ref{Eqn:HypLessCube} are sharp. Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$. Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}. [height=3",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2062,
            "line_end": 2062,
            "char_start": 147676,
            "char_end": 147700
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rve that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$. Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}. [height=3.5in]{SoftTurns.pdf} \\put(7,3){$x$} \\put(34,95){$y$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2062,
            "line_end": 2062,
            "char_start": 147724,
            "char_end": 147753
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$. Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}. [height=3.5in]{SoftTurns.pdf} \\put(7,3){$x$} \\put(34,95){$y$} \\put(16,60){$w$} \\put(26,60){",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2062,
            "line_end": 2062,
            "char_start": 147762,
            "char_end": 147786
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\gamma$ in a pentagon of $T$ has length $c$ or $d$. The sharpness of the constants $c$ and $d$ in \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} is demonstrated by the right and left panels, respectively.} We begin by proving",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2079,
            "line_end": 2079,
            "char_start": 148398,
            "char_end": 148421
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ely.} We begin by proving the second inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube}. Let $w \\to \\widetilde X$ be a combinatorial geodesic in $\\widetilde X$ with endpoints $x, y \\in \\widetilde X^{0}$. By choosing a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2084,
            "line_end": 2084,
            "char_start": 148577,
            "char_end": 148600
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "the combinatorial geodesic $w$ is a concatenation of two or more edges of the dual tiling $T^*$. By \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}, every edge of $w$ has hyperbolic length $2b$. Since edges of $T^*$ meet at angles of $\\theta = \\frac{2\\pi}{5}$ or $2\\theta = \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2085,
            "line_end": 2085,
            "char_start": 149005,
            "char_end": 149031
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Shortcut",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "esic path $\\gamma$ by constructing hyperbolic shortcuts between midpoints of consecutive edges. See \\Cref{Fig:Shortcut}. Each such shortcut replaces two cubical half-edges (of combined cubical length $1$) by a hyperbolic segment of length either $c$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2089,
            "line_end": 2089,
            "char_start": 149324,
            "char_end": 149343
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Shortcut",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "y segments of length $d$ in adjacent pentagons to form a hyperbolic geodesic. See the left panel of \\Cref{Fig:Shortcut}. By the same token, sharpness of the multiplicative constant $c$ in the first inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} holds becaus",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2095,
            "line_end": 2095,
            "char_start": 149978,
            "char_end": 149997
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "rtcut}. By the same token, sharpness of the multiplicative constant $c$ in the first inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube} holds because one may concatenate arbitrarily many segments of length $c$ in adjacent pentagons to form a hyperbolic geodesic, a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2097,
            "line_end": 2097,
            "char_start": 150091,
            "char_end": 150114
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Shortcut",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "egments of length $c$ in adjacent pentagons to form a hyperbolic geodesic, as in the right panel of \\Cref{Fig:Shortcut}. [ht] [width=2.5in]{Altitudes.pdf} \\put(15,28){$s$} \\put(69,17){$s$} \\put(23,20){$\\el",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2098,
            "line_end": 2098,
            "char_start": 150268,
            "char_end": 150287
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "tude associated to each $s$.} To prove the first inequality of \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube}, with its optimal multiplicative constant, we make the following definitions. An altitude of a right-angled pentagon $P$ i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2119,
            "line_end": 2119,
            "char_start": 150749,
            "char_end": 150772
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Altitudes",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ique altitude $\\ell$ with the property that reflection in $\\ell$ interchanges $E_1$ with $E_2$. See \\Cref{Fig:Altitudes}. Let $\\gamma \\to \\HH^2$ be a hyperbolic geodesic with endpoints $x, y \\in \\widetilde X^{0}$. Then $ \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y)$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2119,
            "line_end": 2119,
            "char_start": 151219,
            "char_end": 151239
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nd every remaining $\\gamma_i$ connects the altitudes in adjacent right-angled pentagons. To prove \\eqref{Eqn:HypLessCube}, we will show that the average length of a segment $\\gamma_i$ for $0<i<n$ is at least $c \\approx 0.7672$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2126,
            "line_end": 2126,
            "char_start": 152243,
            "char_end": 152266
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:Types",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "udes, corresponding to five types of intersections between $\\gamma$ and two adjacent pentagons. See \\Cref{Fig:Types}. If $\\ell$ and $\\ell'$ are the altitudes in adjacent pentagons $P$ and $P'$, respectively, the convexity of distance functions im",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2150,
            "line_end": 2150,
            "char_start": 153330,
            "char_end": 153346
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:TypesWithLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "onsequently, it is not hard to determine the shortest possible length from $\\ell$ to $\\ell'$; see \\Cref{Fig:TypesWithLengths}. [h] [width=1in]{Type_I_shortest.pdf} \\put(35,95){I} \\put(48,40){$a$} \\hspace{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2151,
            "line_end": 2151,
            "char_start": 153692,
            "char_end": 153719
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:TypesWithLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "s the infimal length between the altitudes.} In type I, \\Cref{Fig:TypesWithLengths} shows that the worst-case scenario for $\\len(\\gamma_i)$ is $a \\approx 0.5306$; since $a < c$, this complicated case is analyzed b",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2190,
            "line_end": 2190,
            "char_start": 154589,
            "char_end": 154616
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:TypesWithLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "amma_i)$ is $a \\approx 0.5306$; since $a < c$, this complicated case is analyzed below. In type II, \\Cref{Fig:TypesWithLengths} shows that we always have $\\len(\\gamma_i) \\geq 2a > c$. In type III, we always have $\\len(\\gamma_i) \\geq d > c$. In type IV, we a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2190,
            "line_end": 2190,
            "char_start": 154764,
            "char_end": 154791
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ys have $\\len(\\gamma_i) \\geq c$. The comparisons to $c$ come from the numerical values computed in \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Thus, in every case except type I, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i) \\geq c$. It remains to analyze segments $\\gamma_i$ of type I. We cla",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2190,
            "line_end": 2190,
            "char_start": 155090,
            "char_end": 155116
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentType",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "eq 2e > 3c$. Assuming these claims, we can complete the proof as follows. By Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType}, every segment $\\gamma_i$ of type I (where $3 \\leq i \\leq n-2$) borrows some of the length from an adjacent segment $\\gamma_j$ of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2200,
            "line_end": 2200,
            "char_start": 156074,
            "char_end": 156098
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentII",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "2$) borrows some of the length from an adjacent segment $\\gamma_j$ of type II, III, or IV. By Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}, every segment $\\gamma_j$ of type II or IV acts as a ``lender'' to at most one segment of type I. Every segment $\\gamma_j$ of ty",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2200,
            "line_end": 2200,
            "char_start": 156259,
            "char_end": 156281
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:TotalLength",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\gamma_j$ of type III acts as a ``lender'' to at most two segments of type I. In all cases, Claims~\\ref{Claim:TotalLength} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentIII} say that the average length of $\\gamma_j$ and its adjacent type--I segments is more than $c$. Puttin",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2200,
            "line_end": 2200,
            "char_start": 156495,
            "char_end": 156518
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentIII",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "as a ``lender'' to at most two segments of type I. In all cases, Claims~\\ref{Claim:TotalLength} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentIII} say that the average length of $\\gamma_j$ and its adjacent type--I segments is more than $c$. Putting it all together, we have \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2200,
            "line_end": 2200,
            "char_start": 156523,
            "char_end": 156546
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "_{i=3}^{n-2} c = (n-4) c = c \\cdot \\dist_{\\widetilde X}(x,y) - 4 c, \\] which completes the proof of \\Cref{Eqn:HypLessCube}. [h] [width=4in]{TypeINeighbors.pdf} \\put(8,6){$P$} \\put(24,20){$Q$} \\put(58,15){$R$} \\put(73,9){II",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2205,
            "line_end": 2205,
            "char_start": 156848,
            "char_end": 156870
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:TypeINeighbors",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$ in pentagons $Q \\cup R$ must be of type II, III, or IV.} \\Cref{Fig:TypeINeighbors} illustrates the proof of Claims~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}. The geodesic $\\gamma$ intersects the left-mo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2225,
            "line_end": 2225,
            "char_start": 157387,
            "char_end": 157412
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentType",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\Cref{Fig:TypeINeighbors} illustrates the proof of Claims~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}. The geodesic $\\gamma$ intersects the left-most pair of pentagons $\\{P, Q\\}$ in a segment $\\gamma_i \\s",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2225,
            "line_end": 2225,
            "char_start": 157445,
            "char_end": 157469
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentII",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "end{figure} \\Cref{Fig:TypeINeighbors} illustrates the proof of Claims~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType} and~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}. The geodesic $\\gamma$ intersects the left-most pair of pentagons $\\{P, Q\\}$ in a segment $\\gamma_i \\subset \\gamma$ of type I. We",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2225,
            "line_end": 2225,
            "char_start": 157474,
            "char_end": 157496
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentType",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "sides marked II, III, or IV, because $\\gamma$ cannot intersect $\\delta$ twice. This proves Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentType}. If the next segment $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$ is of type II, then the following segment $\\gamma_k = \\gamma_{i+2}$ cannot be of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2225,
            "line_end": 2225,
            "char_start": 157929,
            "char_end": 157953
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentII",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "cannot be of type I, because $\\gamma$ cannot intersect the geodesic $\\xi$ twice. This proves Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentII}. [h] [width=3.5in]{LengthTwoSegments.pdf} \\put(96,3){II} \\put(88,42){III} \\put(53,41){IV} \\put(30,4",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2225,
            "line_end": 2225,
            "char_start": 158363,
            "char_end": 158385
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:LengthTwoSegments",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "g:LengthTwoSegments} For the three combinatorial types of $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$, \\Cref{Fig:LengthTwoSegments} illustrates the infimal lengths of $(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j)$. Let $\\ell_{\\rm II}, \\ell_{\\rm III}, \\ell_{\\rm IV}$ be the terminal",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2248,
            "line_end": 2248,
            "char_start": 159290,
            "char_end": 159318
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\delta$, hence we obtain $\\len(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j) > 3a > 2c$, where the final inequality uses \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. If $\\gamma_j$ is of type IV, then the worst-case scenario is when $\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j$ starts at the endpoint of an altitude",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2249,
            "line_end": 2249,
            "char_start": 159694,
            "char_end": 159720
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "In this case, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j) \\geq g > 2c$, where the final inequality is by \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. Finally, observe that if $\\gamma_j$ is of type III, then $\\gamma_j$ must intersect either $\\ell_{\\rm II}$ or $\\ell_{\\rm IV}$. Th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2249,
            "line_end": 2249,
            "char_start": 159993,
            "char_end": 160019
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:TotalLength",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "hus, by the cases already discussed, we have $\\len(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j) > 2c$. This proves Claim~\\ref{Claim:TotalLength}. [h] [width=3.5in]{LengthThreeSegments.pdf} \\put(25,10){$\\gamma_i$} \\put(40,24){$\\gamma_{i+1}$} \\pu",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2249,
            "line_end": 2249,
            "char_start": 160248,
            "char_end": 160271
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Fig:LengthThreeSegments",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "\\gamma_{i+2})$ is a segment of length $e$.} Finally, \\Cref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments} illustrates the proof of Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentIII}. If $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$ is of type III and $\\gamma_i, \\gamma_{i+2}$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2262,
            "line_end": 2262,
            "char_start": 160792,
            "char_end": 160822
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Claim:AdjacentIII",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "hreeSegments} Finally, \\Cref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments} illustrates the proof of Claim~\\ref{Claim:AdjacentIII}. If $\\gamma_j = \\gamma_{i+1}$ is of type III and $\\gamma_i, \\gamma_{i+2}$ are both of type I, then the shortest possible length o",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2262,
            "line_end": 2262,
            "char_start": 160854,
            "char_end": 160877
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "length of $(\\gamma_i \\cup \\gamma_j \\cup \\gamma_k)$ is $2e > 3c$, where the inequality follows from \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. This completes the proof of the Claims, implying \\Cref{Eqn:HypLessCube} and the Proposition. \\section{Problems}\\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2262,
            "line_end": 2262,
            "char_start": 161099,
            "char_end": 161125
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:HypLessCube",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "quality follows from \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}. This completes the proof of the Claims, implying \\Cref{Eqn:HypLessCube} and the Proposition. \\section{Problems} This section collects several problems and suggested d",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2262,
            "line_end": 2262,
            "char_start": 161178,
            "char_end": 161200
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "prob:line:2295",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "The following problem has not even been studied for virtually free groups: Generalize \\Cref{Thm:main} to cubulated hyperbolic groups with torsion. The main challenge is that cubical small-cancellation theory was not des",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2296,
            "line_end": 2296,
            "char_start": 163092,
            "char_end": 163107
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient, and subsequently apply the criterion of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} which can instead be applied to $\\widetilde{X^*}$.) Let $G$ be a non-elementary relatively hyperbolic group. Prove",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2300,
            "line_end": 2300,
            "char_start": 163600,
            "char_end": 163621
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "r \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}. An unlikely but more fanciful possibility is to use \\Cref{Thm:main} to find new examples of hyperbolic groups that are not cubulated. Let $M = \\H",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2307,
            "line_end": 2307,
            "char_start": 164026,
            "char_end": 164041
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:Lambda12",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "to $\\widetilde M$. Recall that the definition of a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry appears in \\Cref{Eqn:Lambda12}. \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} is supported by the following intuition. If $M$ is a surface, then there is a plethora of c",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2315,
            "line_end": 2315,
            "char_start": 164595,
            "char_end": 164614
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "nd{conj} Recall that the definition of a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry appears in \\Cref{Eqn:Lambda12}. \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} is supported by the following intuition. If $M$ is a surface, then there is a plethora of cubulations of $M$ via closed--geodesic",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2317,
            "line_end": 2317,
            "char_start": 164617,
            "char_end": 164652
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ng $p$ from $q$. Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations} have very recently proved \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold}, formalizing the intuition in the above discussion. An ambitious generalization of \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} asks for",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2321,
            "line_end": 2321,
            "char_start": 165937,
            "char_end": 165972
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "bulateManifold}, formalizing the intuition in the above discussion. An ambitious generalization of \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} asks for arbitrarily homogeneous cubulations of more general groups: Let $G$ be a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2323,
            "line_end": 2323,
            "char_start": 166057,
            "char_end": 166092
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "psilon$? Finally, we pose a probabilistic question about pieces that is prompted by \\Cref{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation}. Suppose, as in \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, that $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X$ is a com",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2329,
            "line_end": 2329,
            "char_start": 166631,
            "char_end": 166668
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation}. Suppose, as in \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample}, that $G = \\pi_1 X$, where $X$ is a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Suppose $G$ is hyperbolic, and acts properly and",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2332,
            "line_end": 2332,
            "char_start": 166736,
            "char_end": 166758
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Eqn:UpsilonTypical",
          "to": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "$\\dist_{\\widetilde X}(gx, y) \\leq D$. Recall that $\\Upsilon$--typical group elements are defined in \\Cref{Eqn:UpsilonTypical}, using an additive constant $\\epsilon$. Suppose that $[g_1], \\ldots, [g_k]$ have been sampled uniformly from among all the conju",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2334,
            "line_end": 2334,
            "char_start": 167371,
            "char_end": 167396
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "ll sufficiently large pieces of $X^*$ are $\\Upsilon$--typical? A positive answer to \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces} would enable one to complete the line of argument outlined in \\Cref{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation}. We suspect that the answer i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2341,
            "line_end": 2341,
            "char_start": 167947,
            "char_end": 167979
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "internal_reference",
          "evidence": "r to \\Cref{Ques:UpsilonTypicalPieces} would enable one to complete the line of argument outlined in \\Cref{Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation}. We suspect that the answer is ``yes'' for cone-pieces. We are less confident about wall-pieces, because the distribution of wall",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2341,
            "line_end": 2341,
            "char_start": 168042,
            "char_end": 168079
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Gromov93",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ch supported by NSF and NSERC} \\maketitle \\section{Introduction} Gromov introduced the density model of random groups \\cite[Chapter 9]{Gromov93}. Given a free group $F$, let $S_{\\ell}(F)$ be the set of length $\\ell$ words. For a density $d \\in (0,1)$, choose a set $R \\subset S_\\ell$ by selecting $\\lfloor | S_\\ell |^{d} \\rfloor$ elements from",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 245,
            "line_end": 245,
            "char_start": 7448,
            "char_end": 7474
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Chapter 9",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "Ollivier proved that the same phase transition at density $\\frac{1}{2}$ occurs in quotients of any torsion-free hyperbolic group \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}. While Gromov's intention was perhaps to illustrate the ubiquity of hyperbolic groups, his construction initiated a fertile topic of study. For instance, \\.Zuk showed that random groups at density $",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 255,
            "line_end": 255,
            "char_start": 8407,
            "char_end": 8438
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Zuk03",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "tance, \\.Zuk showed that random groups at density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ satisfy Kazhdan's property (T), with overwhelming probability \\cite{Zuk03}. See Kotowski and Kotowski \\cite{KotowskiSquared} for full details, and Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier05invitation} for an excellent survey of related topics. Very recently, Ashcroft extended this resul",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 257,
            "line_end": 257,
            "char_start": 8717,
            "char_end": 8729
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:KotowskiSquared",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ satisfy Kazhdan's property (T), with overwhelming probability \\cite{Zuk03}. See Kotowski and Kotowski \\cite{KotowskiSquared} for full details, and Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier05invitation} for an excellent survey of related topics. Very recently, Ashcroft extended this result, proving that random quotients of a hyperbolic gr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 257,
            "line_end": 257,
            "char_start": 8758,
            "char_end": 8780
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier05invitation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "(T), with overwhelming probability \\cite{Zuk03}. See Kotowski and Kotowski \\cite{KotowskiSquared} for full details, and Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier05invitation} for an excellent survey of related topics. Very recently, Ashcroft extended this result, proving that random quotients of a hyperbolic group at density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ have property (T) \\cite{A",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 257,
            "line_end": 257,
            "char_start": 8812,
            "char_end": 8839
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ashcroft:PropertyT",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "shcroft extended this result, proving that random quotients of a hyperbolic group at density $d > \\frac{1}{3}$ have property (T) \\cite{Ashcroft:PropertyT}. The property of being cocompactly cubulated -- acting properly and cocompactly on a CAT(0) cube complex -- can be viewed as a strong negation of property (T) \\cite{NibloRoller98}. In this di",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 259,
            "line_end": 259,
            "char_start": 9032,
            "char_end": 9057
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:NibloRoller98",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ctly cubulated} -- acting properly and cocompactly on a CAT(0) cube complex -- can be viewed as a strong negation of property (T) \\cite{NibloRoller98}. In this direction, a simple computation shows that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, random groups at density $d<\\frac{1}{12}$ satisfy the $C'(\\frac16)$ small-cancellation condi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 261,
            "line_end": 261,
            "char_start": 9225,
            "char_end": 9245
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseSmallCanCube04",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "groups at density $d<\\frac{1}{12}$ satisfy the $C'(\\frac16)$ small-cancellation condition, hence are cocompactly cubulated by \\cite{WiseSmallCanCube04}. Ollivier and Wise \\cite{OllivierWiseDensity} showed that the same conclusion holds at density $d < \\frac{1}{6}$. A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Mont",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 262,
            "line_end": 262,
            "char_start": 9487,
            "char_end": 9512
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:OllivierWiseDensity",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "the $C'(\\frac16)$ small-cancellation condition, hence are cocompactly cubulated by \\cite{WiseSmallCanCube04}. Ollivier and Wise \\cite{OllivierWiseDensity} showed that the same conclusion holds at density $d < \\frac{1}{6}$. A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cub",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 263,
            "line_end": 263,
            "char_start": 9533,
            "char_end": 9559
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:MackayPrzytycki",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "livierWiseDensity} showed that the same conclusion holds at density $d < \\frac{1}{6}$. A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$. See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z \\cite{Odrzy",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 263,
            "line_end": 263,
            "char_start": 9671,
            "char_end": 9693
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Montee:Cubulation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "the same conclusion holds at density $d < \\frac{1}{6}$. A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$. See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thes",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 263,
            "line_end": 263,
            "char_start": 9702,
            "char_end": 9726
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ashcroft:Cubulation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "< \\frac{1}{6}$. A series of papers by Mackay and Przytycki \\cite{MackayPrzytycki}, Montee \\cite{Montee:Cubulation}, and Ashcroft \\cite{Ashcroft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$. See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thesis} for cubulation results in the square",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 263,
            "line_end": 263,
            "char_start": 9741,
            "char_end": 9767
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Odrzygozdz",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "oft:Cubulation} produced a nontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$. See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thesis} for cubulation results in the square probability model. The purpose of this text is to extend these cubulation results from quotients of a free group (the fundamental g",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 264,
            "line_end": 264,
            "char_start": 9882,
            "char_end": 9899
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Duong:Thesis",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ontrivial action on a a CAT(0) cube complex at density $d < \\frac{1}{4}$. See also Odrzyg\\'o\\'zd\\'z \\cite{Odrzygozdz} and Duong \\cite{Duong:Thesis} for cubulation results in the square probability model. The purpose of this text is to extend these cubulation results from quotients of a free group (the fundamental group of a graph) to quotients",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 264,
            "line_end": 264,
            "char_start": 9910,
            "char_end": 9929
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "riations in the model of randomness tend to have no effect on the conclusions one can reach about random quotients. See Ollivier (\\cite[Sections 4--5]{Ollivier:PhaseTransition} and \\cite[Section I.2.c]{Ollivier05invitation}) for a detailed and axiomatic discussion of this phenomenon. The conclusion of \\Cref{Thm:main} --- that $\\overline G = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 294,
            "line_end": 294,
            "char_start": 12918,
            "char_end": 12964
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Sections 4--5",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier05invitation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "effect on the conclusions one can reach about random quotients. See Ollivier (\\cite[Sections 4--5]{Ollivier:PhaseTransition} and \\cite[Section I.2.c]{Ollivier05invitation}) for a detailed and axiomatic discussion of this phenomenon. The conclusion of \\Cref{Thm:main} --- that $\\overline G = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and cocompactly cubulated --- has",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 294,
            "line_end": 294,
            "char_start": 12969,
            "char_end": 13011
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Section I.2.c",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Agol:VirtualHaken",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "erline G = G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is hyperbolic and cocompactly cubulated --- has powerful consequences. A theorem of Agol~\\cite{Agol:VirtualHaken} implies $\\overline G$ is virtually special, meaning $\\overline G$ virtually embeds into a right-angled Artin group. Then, by a theorem of Haglund and Wise~\\cite{HaglundWiseCoxeter}, all quasic",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13253,
            "char_end": 13277
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:HaglundWiseCoxeter",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "irtually special}, meaning $\\overline G$ virtually embeds into a right-angled Artin group. Then, by a theorem of Haglund and Wise~\\cite{HaglundWiseCoxeter}, all quasiconvex subgroups of $\\overline G$ are separable. Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{An",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13440,
            "char_end": 13465
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:HsuWiseGraphProducts",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "te{HaglundWiseCoxeter}, all quasiconvex subgroups of $\\overline G$ are separable. Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}. \\subsection{Density and optimality of constants} In \\Cref{Thm:main}, the density of the random presentation $G/ \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13573,
            "char_end": 13612
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DavisJan00",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "te{HaglundWiseCoxeter}, all quasiconvex subgroups of $\\overline G$ are separable. Furthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}. \\subsection{Density and optimality of constants} In \\Cref{Thm:main}, the density of the random presentation $G/ \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13573,
            "char_end": 13612
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "rthermore, $\\overline G$ is linear over $\\ZZ$ \\cite{HsuWiseGraphProducts, DavisJan00} and virtually surjects the free group $F_2$ \\cite{AntolinMinasyan:TitsAlternative}. \\subsection{Density and optimality of constants} In \\Cref{Thm:main}, the density of the random presentation $G/ \\nclose{g_1, \\ldots, g_k}$ is $\\frac{c}{b}$. Thus all densities in the conclusion of",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 297,
            "line_end": 297,
            "char_start": 13657,
            "char_end": 13695
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier05invitation",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "'(\\frac{1}{20})$ plus several mild hypotheses implies cubulation of the quotient.) Indeed, the probabilistic pigeonhole principle \\cite[p. 31]{Ollivier05invitation} implies that at any density larger than $\\frac{1}{40}$ there will almost surely be pieces that fellow-travel for more than $\\frac{1}{20}$ of their length. Thus our density hypotheses are nearly optim",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 302,
            "line_end": 302,
            "char_start": 14528,
            "char_end": 14562
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "p. 31",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:OllivierWiseDensity",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "theory entirely, for instance by employing isoperimetric inequalities for van Kampen diagrams as in the work of Ollivier and Wise~\\cite{OllivierWiseDensity}. This is also the approach employed in Ollivier's work on quotients of torsion-free hyperbolic groups~\\cite[Thm 3]{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}, which applies at all densities up to $\\frac{1}{2}$ but o",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 306,
            "line_end": 306,
            "char_start": 15263,
            "char_end": 15289
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "\\cite{OllivierWiseDensity}. This is also the approach employed in Ollivier's work on quotients of torsion-free hyperbolic groups~\\cite[Thm 3]{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}, which applies at all densities up to $\\frac{1}{2}$ but only ensures the hyperbolicity of the quotient. We remark that so long as $G \\ncong \\integers$, the main theorem is non-vacuous, meaning $a <",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 307,
            "line_end": 307,
            "char_start": 15393,
            "char_end": 15431
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "is non-vacuous, meaning $a < b$, because hyperplane stabilizers in $G$ have strictly lower growth exponents than $G$ itself. See \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below. Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary: Let $X$ be a compact non-positivel",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 310,
            "line_end": 310,
            "char_start": 15732,
            "char_end": 15764
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 1.3",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "s of pseudo-metrics on $G$ is itself an interesting metric space $\\mathscr D(G)$, studied topologically since the work of Furman~\\cite{Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective}, and metrically since the work of Reyes~\\cite[Def 1.2]{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics}. In Reyes's natural metric on $\\mathscr D(G)$, the distance between $[d_1]$ and $[d_2]$ is precisely $\\log \\lambda$ for th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 334,
            "line_end": 334,
            "char_start": 18934,
            "char_end": 18974
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "studied topologically since the work of Furman~\\cite{Furman:CoarseGeometricPerspective}, and metrically since the work of Reyes~\\cite[Def 1.2]{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics}. In Reyes's natural metric on $\\mathscr D(G)$, the distance between $[d_1]$ and $[d_2]$ is precisely $\\log \\lambda$ for the optimal constant $\\lambda = \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2$ in a $G$--equivariant quas",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 334,
            "line_end": 334,
            "char_start": 19015,
            "char_end": 19051
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Def 1.2",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "da$ for the optimal constant $\\lambda = \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2$ in a $G$--equivariant quasiisometry $\\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$. See \\cite{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics,CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum,BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}. We are interested in quotients of $G$, where the conjugacy classes of relators are drawn uniformly from among all elements of $\\Upsilon$--length less than $\\ell$. At sufficiently low density, depe",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 335,
            "line_end": 335,
            "char_start": 19294,
            "char_end": 19389
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "da$ for the optimal constant $\\lambda = \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2$ in a $G$--equivariant quasiisometry $\\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$. See \\cite{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics,CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum,BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}. We are interested in quotients of $G$, where the conjugacy classes of relators are drawn uniformly from among all elements of $\\Upsilon$--length less than $\\ell$. At sufficiently low density, depe",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 335,
            "line_end": 335,
            "char_start": 19294,
            "char_end": 19389
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "da$ for the optimal constant $\\lambda = \\lambda_1 \\lambda_2$ in a $G$--equivariant quasiisometry $\\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$. See \\cite{Reyes:SpaceOfMetrics,CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum,BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}. We are interested in quotients of $G$, where the conjugacy classes of relators are drawn uniformly from among all elements of $\\Upsilon$--length less than $\\ell$. At sufficiently low density, depe",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 335,
            "line_end": 335,
            "char_start": 19294,
            "char_end": 19389
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Huber",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ery hyperplane is a line, hence hyperplane stabilizers are cyclic and have exponential growth rate $a = 0$. By a theorem of Huber \\cite{Huber}, generalized by Margulis \\cite{Margulis:Growth}, the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\HH^2$ is $b=1$. Furthermore, in \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}, we show that the optimal multiplicative constan",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 359,
            "line_end": 359,
            "char_start": 21286,
            "char_end": 21298
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Margulis:Growth",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "lane stabilizers are cyclic and have exponential growth rate $a = 0$. By a theorem of Huber \\cite{Huber}, generalized by Margulis \\cite{Margulis:Growth}, the growth exponent of $G$ with respect to $\\HH^2$ is $b=1$. Furthermore, in \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}, we show that the optimal multiplicative constant in a $\\lambda$--quasiisometry from $\\widetilde",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 359,
            "line_end": 359,
            "char_start": 21324,
            "char_end": 21346
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ee \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} and the subsequent discussion. This conjecture has been recently proved by Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations}. \\subsection{Overview} \\Cref{sec:growth} reviews several results about the growth of a hyperbolic group, including the existence of a growth exponent and the statement that infinite-index quasicon",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 370,
            "line_end": 370,
            "char_start": 23196,
            "char_end": 23235
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:JankiewiczWise",
          "to": "section:1",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "nts of a cubulated group. This criterion is of independent interest, and has already been used in the work of Jankiewicz and Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}. The probabilistic arguments supporting the proof of \\Cref{Thm:main} are contained in \\Cref{Sec:Pieces}. In that section, we control the sizes of pieces in a generic cubical presentation and show th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 375,
            "line_end": 375,
            "char_start": 23859,
            "char_end": 23880
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:BridsonHaefliger",
          "to": "Def:TransLength",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "itrary $x \\in \\Upsilon$. It is a standard property of isometries of metric spaces that the limit exists and is independent of $x$ \\cite[page 230]{BridsonHaefliger}. Observe that each of $|g|_{{}_\\Upsilon}$ and $\\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon}$ only depends on the conjugacy class $[g]$. By triangle inequalities, $\\stabletrans{g}_{{}_\\Upsilon} \\leq",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 394,
            "line_end": 394,
            "char_start": 26080,
            "char_end": 26113
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "page 230",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "to": "sec:growth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "xi_H(\\Upsilon)$. However, the two notions carry the same information. The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}. See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ i",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28167,
            "char_end": 28199
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 1.1",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:MYJ",
          "to": "sec:growth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}. See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ is a CAT(0) cube complex and $H$ is a hyperplane stabilizer. \\begin{th",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28251,
            "char_end": 28270
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Cor 2.8",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "to": "sec:growth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "nd the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}. See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ is a CAT(0) cube complex and $H$ is a hyperplane stabilizer. Let $G$ be a no",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28282,
            "char_end": 28314
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 1.3",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Coornaert93",
          "to": "sec:growth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "st, and \\[ \\xi_H(\\Upsilon) < \\xi_G (\\Upsilon). \\] The following theorem combines two results of Coornaert and Knieper \\cite{Coornaert93, CoornaertKnieper2002}. Recall that a non-trivial element $g \\in G$ is primitive if $g \\neq h^n$ for any $n > 1$. Primitive conjugacy classes are defined similarly. Let $G$ be",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 437,
            "line_end": 437,
            "char_start": 28839,
            "char_end": 28879
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "to": "sec:growth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "st, and \\[ \\xi_H(\\Upsilon) < \\xi_G (\\Upsilon). \\] The following theorem combines two results of Coornaert and Knieper \\cite{Coornaert93, CoornaertKnieper2002}. Recall that a non-trivial element $g \\in G$ is primitive if $g \\neq h^n$ for any $n > 1$. Primitive conjugacy classes are defined similarly. Let $G$ be",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 437,
            "line_end": 437,
            "char_start": 28839,
            "char_end": 28879
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Coornaert93",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "eq B e^{bn} . \\] Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}. Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}. One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:Conjuga",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 458,
            "char_start": 29882,
            "char_end": 29910
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 7.12",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "lGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}. Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}. One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 458,
            "char_start": 29983,
            "char_end": 30019
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 1.1",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ground} This section reviews some definitions and results about cubical small-cancellation theory. Our primary reference is Wise~\\cite[Chapters 3--5]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. We also prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, a properness criterion that follows from \\cite[Thm 5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy} but is easier to apply. \\subsection{Cubical presentations and pieces} \\begin{de",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 484,
            "line_end": 484,
            "char_start": 31403,
            "char_end": 31444
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Chapters 3--5",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "is Wise~\\cite[Chapters 3--5]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. We also prove \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper}, a properness criterion that follows from \\cite[Thm 5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy} but is easier to apply. \\subsection{Cubical presentations and pieces} [Cubical presentation] A cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X | Y_1, \\ldots, Y_m \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 484,
            "line_end": 484,
            "char_start": 31524,
            "char_end": 31560
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 5.44",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "Lem:1/12 lift",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "$. When pieces are small, the topological space $X^*$ satisfies a number of pleasant properties. [\\hbox{\\cite[Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}] If $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac{1}{12})$, then every cone $Y_i \\looparrowright X^*$ lifts to an embedding $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$. In a generalization of ordi",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 515,
            "line_end": 515,
            "char_start": 33601,
            "char_end": 33649
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "zation of ordinary small-cancellation theory, small pieces guarantee the persistence of hypebolicity in $X^*$: [\\hbox{\\cite[Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}] If $\\pi_1 X$ is hyperbolic and $X^*$ is compact and $C'(\\frac{1}{14})$, then $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic. The main result of this section is the following theore",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 523,
            "line_end": 523,
            "char_start": 33965,
            "char_end": 34013
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "aximal cyclic, then $\\pi_1X^*$ acts freely on $\\widetilde{X^*}$. \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} will be proved with the aid of \\cite[Thm 5.44 and Cor 5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. Setting up the proof using those results requires a number of auxiliary definitions, beginning with the $B(8)$ condition. \\subsection{Wallspace small-cancellation conditions} We will construct a wa",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 543,
            "line_end": 543,
            "char_start": 35299,
            "char_end": 35348
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 5.44 and Cor 5.45",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "otopic in $Y$ to a path $\\mu\\rightarrow N(u)$. We will verify pieceful convexity via the following criterion. [\\hbox{\\cite[Rem~5.43]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}] Let $M$ be the maximal diameter of any piece of $Y$ in $X^*$. Then a hyperplane $u$ of $Y$ is piecefully convex provided its carrier $N=N(u)$ satisfies: $\\dist_{\\wide",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 617,
            "line_end": 617,
            "char_start": 39933,
            "char_end": 39969
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Rem~5.43",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "for any translate $g\\widetilde N\\neq \\widetilde N\\subset \\widetilde Y$. The following is a simplified restatement of \\cite[Thm~5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, which also incorporates \\cite[Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. Suppose that $X^* = \\langle X \\mid \\{Y_i\\} \\rangle$ satisfies the following hypo",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 624,
            "line_end": 624,
            "char_start": 40338,
            "char_end": 40374
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm~5.44",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "etilde Y$. The following is a simplified restatement of \\cite[Thm~5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, which also incorporates \\cite[Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}. Suppose that $X^* = \\langle X \\mid \\{Y_i\\} \\rangle$ satisfies the following hypotheses: [\\:\\: $(1)$] \\item $X^*$ is $C'(\\frac",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 625,
            "line_end": 625,
            "char_start": 40401,
            "char_end": 40450
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:HaglundSemiSimple",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "Y_i})$. Since we have subdivided $X$ at least once, $g$ stabilizes a geodesic axis $\\widetilde{v_i} \\subset \\widetilde{Y_i}$, by \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}. Let $v_i = \\langle g \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde{v_i}$. Now, we may choose $w_i = \\langle g^n \\rangle \\backslash \\widetilde{v_i}$, where $g^n$ generates $\\pi_1(Y_i)$. After the first subdivisio",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 684,
            "line_end": 684,
            "char_start": 44120,
            "char_end": 44144
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "sec:cubical presentation background",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "abilizers must be torsion. By \\cite[Thm 4.2 and Rem 4.3]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, we know that when $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$, any torsion element in $\\pi_1X^*$ lies in $\\Aut(Y_i \\rightarrow X)$ for some lift $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$. Recall that $\\widetilde Y_i$ is",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 778,
            "line_end": 778,
            "char_start": 51789,
            "char_end": 51836
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 4.2 and Rem 4.3",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:SageevWiseCores",
          "to": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "CAT(0) (non-combinatorial) geodesic segment from $p$ to $\\widetilde w$, oriented outward from $p$. Sageev and Wise have observed \\cite[Remark~3.2]{SageevWiseCores} that the first cube met by $s$ contains a midcube of a hyperplane $H$ that intersects $s$ at an angle bounded away from $0$. The angle bound depends only on the dimension of the cube, hence can be t",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 825,
            "line_end": 825,
            "char_start": 55245,
            "char_end": 55279
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Remark~3.2",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:HaglundSemiSimple",
          "to": "Conv:NiceX",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ary. We assume that $X$ has been subdivided at least once, so that every $g \\neq 1$ stabilizes a geodesic axis in $\\widetilde X$ \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}. Finally, we assume that every hyperplane of $X$ is essential. This assumption is harmless, because every non-positively curved cube complex $X'$ contains a convex essential core, whose hyperplanes",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 851,
            "line_end": 851,
            "char_start": 57465,
            "char_end": 57489
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CapraceSageev2011",
          "to": "Conv:NiceX",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "curved cube complex $X'$ contains a convex essential core, whose hyperplanes are essential. See, for instance, Caprace and Sageev \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}. Our arguments in this section will employ the following, looser analogue of \\Cref{Def:Piece}. [Loose pieces] Let $X$ be as in \\Cref{Conv:NiceX}. Fix a",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 853,
            "line_end": 853,
            "char_start": 57742,
            "char_end": 57783
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Proposition 3.5",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
          "to": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "L$ on the length of backtracking in $(yx)h(y)$. Now, apply a ``local to global'' principle for quasi-geodesics. See e.g.\\ Cannon~\\cite[Thm 4]{cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1250,
            "line_end": 1250,
            "char_start": 86993,
            "char_end": 87034
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 4",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CapraceSageev2011",
          "to": "Sec:Pieces",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "representative $w \\rightarrow X$. Second, if some hyperplane of $X$ is inessential, we replace $X$ by its essential core, as in \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}, which has the same growth exponents $a$ and $b$. For every relator $[g_i]$ in the statement of the theorem, let $w_i \\to X$ be the chosen closed--geodesic. Let $\\widetilde w_i \\subset \\widetilde X",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1486,
            "line_end": 1486,
            "char_start": 103354,
            "char_end": 103395
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Proposition 3.5",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "of $G$ sampled using $\\Upsilon$ gets stretched in $\\widetilde X$. See~\\cite[Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve} for a proof that the limit exists. The mean distortion can be bounded as follows. Suppose there is a $G$--equivariant $\\lambda$--quasiisometry $f \\from \\widetilde X \\to \\Upsilon$, as in \\Cref{Eqn:La",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1870,
            "line_end": 1870,
            "char_start": 136410,
            "char_end": 136469
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "s the Cayley graph of $G$ with respect to some generating set, this follows from a large deviation result of Cantrell and Tanaka~\\cite[Thm 4.23]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve}. If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}. For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee info",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1884,
            "line_end": 1884,
            "char_start": 137508,
            "char_end": 137554
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 4.23",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ManhattanCurve}. If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}. For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}. We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\la",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1884,
            "line_end": 1884,
            "char_start": 137669,
            "char_end": 137712
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 1.4",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}. For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}. We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}. The proof begins by observing that every conjugacy class $[g_i]$ satisfies $ \\stabletrans{g_i}_{",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1886,
            "line_end": 1886,
            "char_start": 137811,
            "char_end": 137863
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Eqn (5.2)",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Huber",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "As mentioned in the introduction, combining \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}. The proof of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is entirely elementary and largely pictorial; see Figures~\\ref{Fig:PentagonLengths}--\\ref{Fig:LengthThreeSegments}. The p",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1914,
            "char_start": 140584,
            "char_end": 140596
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "agonLengths}, which computes a number of lengths in a single right-angled pentagon using the hyperbolic laws of sines and cosines \\cite{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry, Ratcliffe:Foundations}. We then continue with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate}, which considers a number of combinatorial possibilities for how a hyperbolic geodesic segment can cross a sequence of several adjacent pentagons.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 141063,
            "char_end": 141119
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Sec:Pentagonal",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "agonLengths}, which computes a number of lengths in a single right-angled pentagon using the hyperbolic laws of sines and cosines \\cite{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry, Ratcliffe:Foundations}. We then continue with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate}, which considers a number of combinatorial possibilities for how a hyperbolic geodesic segment can cross a sequence of several adjacent pentagons.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1916,
            "line_end": 1916,
            "char_start": 141063,
            "char_end": 141119
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "right angles makes $Q$ a Lambert quadrilateral or almost rectangular quadrilateral in the terminology of Ratcliffe \\cite[Sec 3.5]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ K = \\cos \\theta = \\sinh^2 a, \\] hence $K+1 = \\cosh^2 a$, implying \\Cref{Eqn:ALength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.8]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1980,
            "line_end": 1980,
            "char_start": 143664,
            "char_end": 143701
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Sec 3.5",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "drilateral} or almost rectangular quadrilateral in the terminology of Ratcliffe \\cite[Sec 3.5]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ K = \\cos \\theta = \\sinh^2 a, \\] hence $K+1 = \\cosh^2 a$, implying \\Cref{Eqn:ALength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.8]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ \\cosh^2 b = \\left( \\frac{\\cos \\theta \\cdot \\c",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1981,
            "line_end": 1981,
            "char_start": 143706,
            "char_end": 143745
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3.5.9",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ K = \\cos \\theta = \\sinh^2 a, \\] hence $K+1 = \\cosh^2 a$, implying \\Cref{Eqn:ALength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.8]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have \\[ \\cosh^2 b = \\left( \\frac{\\cos \\theta \\cdot \\cos (\\tfrac{\\pi}{2}) + \\cosh a}{\\sin \\theta \\cdot \\sin (\\tfrac{\\pi}{2})} \\right)^2 = \\frac{\\cosh^2 a}{\\sin^2 \\theta} = \\frac{1+K}{1-K^2} = \\fr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1986,
            "line_end": 1986,
            "char_start": 143848,
            "char_end": 143887
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3.5.8",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "rac{\\cosh^2 a}{\\sin^2 \\theta} = \\frac{1+K}{1-K^2} = \\frac{1}{1-K}, \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:BLength}. The hyperbolic law of cosines \\cite[Thm 3.5.3]{Ratcliffe:Foundations} implies the following version of the Pythagorean theorem as a special case. In a hyperbolic right triangle, with legs of length $x,y$ and hypotenuse of length $z$, the lengths satisfy \\begin{equation",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1993,
            "line_end": 1993,
            "char_start": 144162,
            "char_end": 144201
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3.5.3",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ent edges are separated by distance $c$, where \\[ \\cosh c = \\cosh^2 a = \\sinh^2 a + 1 = K + 1, \\] implying \\Cref{Eqn:CLength}. By \\cite[Thm 3.5.3]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, the midpoints of two non-adjacent edges are separated by distance $d$, where \\[ \\cosh d = \\cosh^2 b - \\sinh^2 b \\cdot \\cos (2\\theta). \\] Substituting $\\cosh^2 b = \\frac{1}{1-K}$ and $\\sinh^2 b = \\fr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2004,
            "line_end": 2004,
            "char_start": 144773,
            "char_end": 144812
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "Thm 3.5.3",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "sides of length $4a$, and the fourth side of length $2g$. According to first formula in the last block of displayed equations on \\cite[page 88]{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry}, we have \\cosh(2g) = - \\sinh^2(4a) + \\cosh^2(4a) \\cosh(2a). Above, we have already computed that $\\cosh(2a)=2K+1$, hence \\[ \\cosh(4a) = 2 \\cosh^2(2",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2033,
            "line_end": 2033,
            "char_start": 145986,
            "char_end": 146028
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "page 88",
          "context": "proof"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:MartinSteenbock",
          "to": "Prob:FreeProdOptimalDensity",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "s an arc glued to $X_1$ and $X_2$ at its endpoints. Does the optimal density depend on the length of $A$? See Martin--Steenbock~\\cite{MartinSteenbock} and Jankiewicz--Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}. Let $G$ be a relatively hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2282,
            "line_end": 2282,
            "char_start": 162436,
            "char_end": 162458
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:JankiewiczWise",
          "to": "Prob:FreeProdOptimalDensity",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "dpoints. Does the optimal density depend on the length of $A$? See Martin--Steenbock~\\cite{MartinSteenbock} and Jankiewicz--Wise~\\cite{JankiewiczWise}. Let $G$ be a relatively hyperbolic group that is the fundamental group of a compact non-positively curved cube complex. Show that there is a density at which random quotient",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2282,
            "line_end": 2282,
            "char_start": 162480,
            "char_end": 162501
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Osin2007",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "where there is torsion. One could either develop that theory, or use another hyperbolic Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient, and subsequently apply the criterion of \\",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2300,
            "line_end": 2300,
            "char_start": 163386,
            "char_end": 163401
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:GrovesManning2008",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ither develop that theory, or use another hyperbolic Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient, and subsequently apply the criterion of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} which can instead be ap",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2300,
            "line_end": 2300,
            "char_start": 163421,
            "char_end": 163445
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DGO",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "Dehn filling theory with walls (e.g.~Osin~\\cite{Osin2007} or Groves--Manning~\\cite{GrovesManning2008} or Dahmani--Guirardel--Osin~\\cite{DGO}) to ensure that the relators embed in the universal cover of the quotient, and subsequently apply the criterion of \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} which can instead be applied to $\\widetilde{X^*}$.) \\begin{pr",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2300,
            "line_end": 2300,
            "char_start": 163474,
            "char_end": 163484
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ollivier:PhaseTransition",
          "to": "prob:line:2303",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "ty quotients of $G$ are again relatively hyperbolic. Note that the (torsion-free) hyperbolic case was already handled by Ollivier \\cite{Ollivier:PhaseTransition}. An unlikely but more fanciful possibility is to use \\Cref{Thm:main} to find new examples of hyperbolic groups that are not cubulated.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2304,
            "line_end": 2304,
            "char_start": 163928,
            "char_end": 163959
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "statement"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:KahnMarkovic09",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "as a plethora of cubulations via nearly geodesic surfaces that are similarly nearly equidistributed in $M$. See Kahn and Markovic \\cite{KahnMarkovic09}. Similarly, an arithmetic hyperbolic manifold $M = \\HH^n / \\Gamma$ of simplest type always contains totally geodesic (codimension-1) hypersurfaces. Since the commensurator $\\operatorname{Comm}(\\Gam",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2317,
            "line_end": 2317,
            "char_start": 165318,
            "char_end": 165339
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:BergeronHaglundWiseSimple",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "(\\Gamma)$ is dense in $\\Isom(\\HH^n)$, one may move a single hypersurface by many elements of $\\operatorname{Comm}(\\Gamma)$, as in \\cite{BergeronHaglundWiseSimple}, to achieve a cubulation of $\\Gamma$ such that, again, $\\dist_{\\HH^n}(p,q)$ is nearly proportional to the number of hypersurfaces separating $p$ from $q$. Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:Hyperbol",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2319,
            "line_end": 2319,
            "char_start": 165664,
            "char_end": 165696
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations",
          "to": "Sec:Problems",
          "type": "external_reference",
          "evidence": "that, again, $\\dist_{\\HH^n}(p,q)$ is nearly proportional to the number of hypersurfaces separating $p$ from $q$. Brody and Reyes~\\cite{BrodyReyes:HyperbolicCubulations} have very recently proved \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold}, formalizing the intuition in the above discussion. An ambitious generalization of \\Cref{Conj:OptimalCubulateManifold} asks for arbitrar",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2321,
            "line_end": 2321,
            "char_start": 165871,
            "char_end": 165910
          },
          "origin": "source_reference",
          "locator": "",
          "context": "narrative"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1492,
            "line_end": 1492,
            "char_start": 103865,
            "char_end": 104026
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Define $J = J(\\widetilde X)$ as in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1495,
            "line_end": 1495,
            "char_start": 104252,
            "char_end": 104307
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Define $J = J(\\widetilde X)$ as in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1504,
            "line_end": 1504,
            "char_start": 104861,
            "char_end": 105127
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1504,
            "line_end": 1504,
            "char_start": 104861,
            "char_end": 105127
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Then Propositions~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl} and \\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} ensure that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$,  the $J$--loose (wall or cone) pieces in every $w_i$ have diameter strictly less than $\\alpha |w_i| = \\alpha \\systole{Y_i}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1508,
            "line_end": 1508,
            "char_start": 105352,
            "char_end": 105448
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1512,
            "line_end": 1512,
            "char_start": 106096,
            "char_end": 106253
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Primitive",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $w_i$ is  primitive.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1511,
            "line_end": 1511,
            "char_start": 106003,
            "char_end": 106094
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "\\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $w_i$ is  primitive."
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CapraceSageev2011",
          "to": "Thm:main",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Second, if some hyperplane of $X$ is inessential, we replace $X$ by its essential core, as in \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}, which has the same growth exponents $a$ and $b$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1486,
            "line_end": 1487,
            "char_start": 103260,
            "char_end": 103445
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Second, if some hyperplane of $X$ is inessential, we replace $X$ by its essential core, as in \\cite[Proposition 3.5]{CapraceSageev2011}, which has the same growth exponents $a$ and $b$.",
          "locator": "Proposition 3.5",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Proposition 3.5, used to replace the action by an essential convex core without changing the growth exponents or the relevant coarse geometry.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The original proper cocompact cubical action must satisfy the hypotheses of the essential-core proposition.",
            "The selected core must be invariant, convex, and cocompact.",
            "Its essential hyperplane stabilizers must correspond to those used in the definition of a."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:main",
          "to": "Cor:LowDensity",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary:",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 310,
            "line_end": 311,
            "char_start": 15802,
            "char_end": 15892
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Thus we may always pick $c > 0$ in \\Cref{Thm:main}. This leads to the following corollary:"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "to": "Cor:LowDensity",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "See  \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 310,
            "line_end": 310,
            "char_start": 15727,
            "char_end": 15801
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "See  \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} and \\Cref{Thm:SubgroupGrowth} below."
        },
        {
          "from": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon} implies that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the presentation  $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ and any choice of basepoint and axes.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1838,
            "line_end": 1838,
            "char_start": 132455,
            "char_end": 132729
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "\\Cref{Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon} implies that with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the presentation  $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha/ \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $\\Upsilon$ and any choice of basepoint and axes."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1492,
            "line_end": 1492,
            "char_start": 103865,
            "char_end": 104026
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness},  $\\widetilde Y_i$ lies in a uniform neighborhood of $\\widetilde w_i$, hence its quotient $Y_i$ is compact and a quasi-circle."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Now, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} implies that  with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha)$ with $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1844,
            "line_end": 1844,
            "char_start": 133404,
            "char_end": 133619
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Now, \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation} implies that  with overwhelming probability as $\\ell \\to \\infty$, the cubical presentation $X^* = \\langle X \\mid Y_1, \\ldots, Y_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha)$ with $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1508,
            "line_end": 1508,
            "char_start": 105352,
            "char_end": 105448
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Since $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{14}$, \\Cref{lem:1/14 hyperbolic} ensures that $\\pi_1X^*$ is hyperbolic."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Primitive",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Finally, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $g_i$ is  primitive.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1848,
            "line_end": 1848,
            "char_start": 134320,
            "char_end": 134444
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Finally, the same argument as in \\Cref{Lem:Primitive} implies that with overwhelming probability, every $g_i$ is  primitive."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "to": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1512,
            "line_end": 1512,
            "char_start": 106096,
            "char_end": 106253
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Therefore,  \\Cref{Thm:C'20Proper} ensures that $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts freely and cocompactly on the CAT(0) cube complex dual to the wallspace on $\\widetilde{X^*}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:OtherSample",
          "to": "Cor:H2Action",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1915,
            "char_start": 140488,
            "char_end": 140635
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "to": "Cor:H2Action",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1915,
            "char_start": 140488,
            "char_end": 140635
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}."
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Huber",
          "to": "Cor:H2Action",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1914,
            "line_end": 1915,
            "char_start": 140488,
            "char_end": 140635
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "combining  \\Cref{Thm:OtherSample} with \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} and the classical work of Huber \\cite{Huber} yields a proof of \\Cref{Cor:H2Action}.",
          "locator": "No theorem number supplied",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "The curvature-minus-one compact hyperbolic surface growth exponent is 1.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The surface group is a cocompact lattice in Isom(H^2).",
            "Lengths are measured in the curvature-minus-one hyperbolic metric."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "to": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28108,
            "char_end": 28271
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 1.1",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, invoked for existence of growth exponents and strict growth separation of an infinite-index quasiconvex subgroup.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "G is a nonelementary hyperbolic group.",
            "H is quasiconvex and infinite index.",
            "The ambient action satisfies the source theorem's metric-space hypotheses; those hypotheses must be checked rather than replaced by arbitrary proper cocompact metric actions."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:MYJ",
          "to": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28108,
            "char_end": 28271
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "The following result was proved by Dahmani and the authors~\\cite[Thm 1.1]{DahmaniFuterWise}, and independently Matsuzaki, Yabuki, and Jaerisch \\cite[Cor 2.8]{MYJ}.",
          "locator": "Corollary 2.8",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Corollary 2.8, cited as an independent source of the same growth-separation conclusion.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The group, subgroup, and ambient metric action satisfy the exact source hypotheses.",
            "In particular, the source must justify finite exponential growth in the chosen metric."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:DahmaniFuterWise",
          "to": "Thm:SubgroupGrowth",
          "type": "background",
          "evidence": "See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ is a CAT(0) cube complex and $H$ is a hyperplane stabilizer.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 426,
            "line_end": 426,
            "char_start": 28273,
            "char_end": 28458
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "See also \\cite[Thm 1.3]{DahmaniFuterWise} for a statement that does not assume $G$ is hyperbolic, but does assume $\\Upsilon$ is a CAT(0) cube complex and $H$ is a hyperplane stabilizer.",
          "locator": "Theorem 1.3",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "",
          "required_hypotheses": [],
          "reference_role": "background"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Coornaert93",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 458,
            "char_start": 29827,
            "char_end": 29911
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is due to Coornaert \\cite[Thm 7.12]{Coornaert93}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 7.12",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 7.12, used for A exp(bn) <= f(n) <= B exp(bn).",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "A nonelementary group acts properly and cocompactly on a hyperbolic space satisfying the source's geometric hypotheses.",
            "The growth exponent is computed in that same orbit metric."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CoornaertKnieper2002",
          "to": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 458,
            "line_end": 459,
            "char_start": 29912,
            "char_end": 30020
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Conclusion \\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} is due to Coornaert and Knieper \\cite[Thm 1.1]{CoornaertKnieper2002}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 1.1",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 1.1, used for the primitive conjugacy-class bounds A exp(bn)/n <= p_n <= B exp(bn).",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The exact source hypotheses must cover the group action and the manuscript's notion of primitive conjugacy class.",
            "The length convention must agree with translation length, or differ from it by a uniformly bounded amount."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper constant $B$) on the number of vertices in a metric ball in $\\Upsilon$, where the vertices being counted are not required to be in the $G$--orbit of the basepoint $x$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 464,
            "line_end": 464,
            "char_start": 30074,
            "char_end": 30416
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "One consequence of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} is that when $\\Upsilon$ is a cell complex, we get the same upper and lower bounds (with a modified upper constant $B$) on the number of vertices in a metric ball in $\\Upsilon$, where the vertices being counted are not required to be in the $G$--orbit of the basepoint $x$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}  implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 473,
            "line_end": 474,
            "char_start": 30817,
            "char_end": 30990
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Combining this fact with the lower bound of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}  implies that the proportion of non-primitive conjugacy classes is at most"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "Lem:1/12 lift",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{Lem:1/12 lift}",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 515,
            "line_end": 516,
            "char_start": 33583,
            "char_end": 33672
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Thm 3.32 and Thm 4.1]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{Lem:1/12 lift}",
          "locator": "Theorems 3.32 and 4.1",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorems 3.32 and 4.1, invoked to embed every cone Y_i in the universal cover of X* under C'(1/12).",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "X* is a cubical presentation by local isometries of nonpositively curved cube complexes.",
            "The presentation satisfies the source's C'(1/12) condition, including its conventions for pieces and symmetries."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "lem:1/14 hyperbolic",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{lem:1/14 hyperbolic}",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 523,
            "line_end": 524,
            "char_start": 33947,
            "char_end": 34042
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "\\begin{lem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Lem 3.70 and Thm 4.7]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{lem:1/14 hyperbolic}",
          "locator": "Lemma 3.70 and Theorem 4.7",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Lemma 3.70 and Theorem 4.7, used to deduce hyperbolicity of pi_1 X*.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "pi_1 X is hyperbolic.",
            "X* is compact.",
            "X* satisfies cubical C'(1/14) with the source's piece conventions."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "to": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "We have thus verified that \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} applies, hence $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts with torsion stabilizers",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 770,
            "line_end": 771,
            "char_start": 51308,
            "char_end": 51420
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "We have thus verified that \\Cref{Thm:cubulating X star} applies, hence $\\pi_1 X^*$ acts with torsion stabilizers"
        },
        {
          "from": "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "to": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 724,
            "line_end": 724,
            "char_start": 47370,
            "char_end": 47527
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Hypothesis \\ref{Thm:cubulating X star}.\\eqref{Itm:Pieceful}, namely pieceful convexity of the hyperplanes of $Y$, follows from \\Cref{rem:pieceful convexity}."
        },
        {
          "from": "external:HaglundSemiSimple",
          "to": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Since we have subdivided $X$ at least once, $g$ stabilizes a geodesic axis $\\widetilde{v_i} \\subset \\widetilde{Y_i}$, by \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 684,
            "line_end": 684,
            "char_start": 43999,
            "char_end": 44145
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Since we have subdivided $X$ at least once, $g$ stabilizes a geodesic axis $\\widetilde{v_i} \\subset \\widetilde{Y_i}$, by \\cite{HaglundSemiSimple}.",
          "locator": "No theorem number supplied",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "After cubical subdivision, the generator of the relevant cyclic stabilizer has an invariant combinatorial geodesic axis.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The isometry acts on the relevant CAT(0) cube complex.",
            "The subdivision removes the obstruction addressed by the source's axis theorem.",
            "The resulting axis lies in the invariant convex subcomplex under consideration."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "Thm:C'20Proper",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 4.2 and Rem 4.3]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, we know that when $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$,\nany torsion element in  $\\pi_1X^*$ lies in $\\Aut(Y_i \\rightarrow X)$ for some lift $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 778,
            "line_end": 779,
            "char_start": 51786,
            "char_end": 52002
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 4.2 and Rem 4.3]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, we know that when $\\alpha < \\frac{1}{20}$,\nany torsion element in  $\\pi_1X^*$ lies in $\\Aut(Y_i \\rightarrow X)$ for some lift $Y_i \\hookrightarrow \\widetilde{X^*}$.",
          "locator": "Theorem 4.2 and Remark 4.3",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 4.2 and Remark 4.3, used to place every torsion element in a relator automorphism group.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The presentation satisfies the small-cancellation and symmetry hypotheses of the torsion theorem.",
            "The relator automorphism groups are identified with the relevant cyclic extensions."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "rem:pieceful convexity",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "\\begin{rem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Rem~5.43]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{rem:pieceful convexity}",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 617,
            "line_end": 618,
            "char_start": 39915,
            "char_end": 40001
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "\\begin{rem}[\\hbox{\\cite[Rem~5.43]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}}]\\label{rem:pieceful convexity}",
          "locator": "Remark 5.43",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Remark 5.43: if distinct translates of a hyperplane carrier are farther apart than the maximal piece diameter, the hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The hyperplane and its carrier satisfy the source's embedding and cubical-presentation assumptions.",
            "M bounds every piece diameter in the cone.",
            "Every distinct carrier translate has distance greater than M."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:WiseIsraelHierarchy",
          "to": "Thm:cubulating X star",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The following is a simplified restatement of \\cite[Thm~5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, which also incorporates\n \\cite[Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 624,
            "line_end": 626,
            "char_start": 40293,
            "char_end": 40451
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "The following is a simplified restatement of \\cite[Thm~5.44]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}, which also incorporates\n \\cite[Lem~3.70 and Cor~5.45]{WiseIsraelHierarchy}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 5.44; Lemma 3.70; Corollary 5.45",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 5.44, combined with Lemma 3.70 and Corollary 5.45, as restated in the four numbered hypotheses of Theorem 3.8, yielding torsion cell stabilizers on the dual cube complex.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "C'(1/14) and B(6).",
            "Every cone hyperplane is piecefully convex.",
            "Every infinite-order cone automorphism is cut by a cone wall.",
            "The full separation condition in Hypothesis (4), including that the new wall separates p and q.",
            "Any additional source hypotheses needed for the claimed simplification."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:SageevWiseCores",
          "to": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Sageev and Wise have observed  \\cite[Remark~3.2]{SageevWiseCores} that the first cube met by $s$ contains a midcube of  a hyperplane $H$ that intersects $s$ at an angle bounded away from $0$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 825,
            "line_end": 825,
            "char_start": 55214,
            "char_end": 55405
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Sageev and Wise have observed  \\cite[Remark~3.2]{SageevWiseCores} that the first cube met by $s$ contains a midcube of  a hyperplane $H$ that intersects $s$ at an angle bounded away from $0$.",
          "locator": "Remark 3.2",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Remark 3.2, used for a dimension-dependent positive angle between a shortest CAT(0) segment and a hyperplane in its initial cube.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "A finite-dimensional CAT(0) cube complex.",
            "The segment and initial cube satisfy the geometric setup of the remark.",
            "The angle bound is uniform in the dimension."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ \nthat are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 894,
            "line_end": 895,
            "char_start": 60639,
            "char_end": 60772
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $p_i, q_i \\in \\widetilde w_i$ \nthat are $K$--close to $p$ and $q$, respectively."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:LoosenUp",
          "to": "Rem:MoreGeneralHyperplane",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 904,
            "line_end": 904,
            "char_start": 61799,
            "char_end": 61920
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Consequently, the $J$--loose wall-pieces in \\Cref{Lem:LoosenUp}.\\eqref{Itm:HyperplaneInY} need not come from wall-pieces."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Meanwhile, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 982,
            "line_end": 982,
            "char_start": 66648,
            "char_end": 66781
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Meanwhile, \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth} implies that $|\\mathcal{G}(\\ell) | \\geq \\frac{A}{\\ell} e^{b \\ell}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:GroupoidGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded above by $B'e^{a|s|}$, for some constant $B'$ depending on $J$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 958,
            "line_end": 958,
            "char_start": 65329,
            "char_end": 65552
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:TotalGrowth} and \\Cref{Rem:GroupoidGrowth}, the number of such paths $s$, up to homotopy in $\\widetilde X$, is bounded above by $B'e^{a|s|}$, for some constant $B'$ depending on $J$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Furthermore, as in \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad},",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1094,
            "line_end": 1095,
            "char_start": 73228,
            "char_end": 73267
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Furthermore, as in \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad},"
        },
        {
          "from": "Conv:NiceX",
          "to": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Conv:NiceX},\n$h$ has an invariant geodesic axis $\\widetilde v$ in \n$\\widetilde X$, hence\n $\\stabletrans{h} \\geq 1$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1112,
            "line_end": 1116,
            "char_start": 74351,
            "char_end": 74475
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Conv:NiceX},\n$h$ has an invariant geodesic axis $\\widetilde v$ in \n$\\widetilde X$, hence\n $\\stabletrans{h} \\geq 1$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ThinQuad",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Furthermore, by \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, every point of $s'$ lies within distance $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$ of some point of $s$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1156,
            "line_end": 1157,
            "char_start": 77768,
            "char_end": 77895
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Furthermore, by \\Cref{Lem:ThinQuad}, every point of $s'$ lies within distance $\\mathring J = J + 2\\delta$ of some point of $s$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the number of such conjugacy classes satisfies",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1197,
            "line_end": 1198,
            "char_start": 82859,
            "char_end": 82964
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the number of such conjugacy classes satisfies"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups",
          "to": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Now,  apply a ``local to global'' principle for quasi-geodesics. See e.g.\\ Cannon~\\cite[Thm 4]{cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1250,
            "line_end": 1251,
            "char_start": 86911,
            "char_end": 87035
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Now,  apply a ``local to global'' principle for quasi-geodesics. See e.g.\\ Cannon~\\cite[Thm 4]{cannon:cocompact-hyp-groups}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 4",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorem 4, invoked as a local-to-global principle converting uniformly controlled local quasi-geodesics into global quasi-geodesics.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The ambient geodesic space is delta-hyperbolic.",
            "The periodic path has suitable local quasi-geodesic constants on a scale exceeding the local-to-global threshold.",
            "The cited theorem must apply in this generality, not only to the geometric setting of its original formulation."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with probability at most $M_2 \\ell^2  e^{-b d}$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89354,
            "char_end": 89520
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SelfPieceSmallOverlap}, pieces with an overlap of diameter $|u| \\leq R$ occur with probability at most $M_2 \\ell^2  e^{-b d}$"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, $h$ preserves the orientation on $s$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1274,
            "line_end": 1274,
            "char_start": 89656,
            "char_end": 89729
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:ReversingPiecesSmall}, $h$ preserves the orientation on $s$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:InfiniteWord",
          "to": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Thus, in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:InfiniteWord}, we  conclude that  $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$ is an $\\eta$--quasigeodesic  for some $\\eta  = \\eta( \\delta, J) >0$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1294,
            "line_end": 1294,
            "char_start": 90895,
            "char_end": 91051
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Thus, in the notation of \\Cref{Lem:InfiniteWord}, we  conclude that  $(x_1 y_1)^\\infty$ is an $\\eta$--quasigeodesic  for some $\\eta  = \\eta( \\delta, J) >0$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PieceNonGeneric",
          "to": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1361,
            "line_end": 1361,
            "char_start": 95836,
            "char_end": 95981
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap",
          "to": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1361,
            "line_end": 1361,
            "char_start": 95836,
            "char_end": 95981
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Let  $M = M(X,J)$ be the larger of the two constants in \\Cref{Lem:PieceNonGeneric}.\\eqref{Itm:SeparateSample} and \\Cref{Lem:SelfPieceBigOverlap}."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:FewConePieces",
          "to": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "When $\\ell$ is sufficiently large,  \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} says that  for every pair $(i,j)$, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ between $w_i$ and $w_j$ is less than $e^{-bd\\phi}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1394,
            "line_end": 1394,
            "char_start": 98165,
            "char_end": 98381
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "When $\\ell$ is sufficiently large,  \\Cref{Prop:FewConePieces} says that  for every pair $(i,j)$, the probability of a $J$--loose cone-piece of diameter at least $d$ between $w_i$ and $w_j$ is less than $e^{-bd\\phi}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Lem:Systole",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that\n$|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1416,
            "line_end": 1418,
            "char_start": 99484,
            "char_end": 99630
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}.\\eqref{Itm:ConjugacyGrowth}, the conditional probability that $|w_i|\\leq (1-q) \\ell$ given that\n$|w_i| \\leq \\ell$ is"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:ConePieceDiameter",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1436,
            "line_end": 1436,
            "char_start": 100557,
            "char_end": 100661
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:Systole",
          "to": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1436,
            "line_end": 1436,
            "char_start": 100557,
            "char_end": 100661
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "We will use Lemmas~\\ref{Lem:ConePieceDiameter} and~\\ref{Lem:Systole} with $q = \\frac{\\alpha}{\\alpha+2}$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Rem:NonPrimitive",
          "to": "Lem:Primitive",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Rem:NonPrimitive}, the probability that $[g_i]$ is non-primitive is bounded above by",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1453,
            "line_end": 1454,
            "char_start": 101618,
            "char_end": 101711
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Rem:NonPrimitive}, the probability that $[g_i]$ is non-primitive is bounded above by"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:ConePieceSystole",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1585,
            "line_end": 1587,
            "char_start": 112343,
            "char_end": 112560
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively."
        },
        {
          "from": "Thm:ConjugacyGrowth",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfectly well to the $G$--action on $\\Upsilon$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1590,
            "line_end": 1591,
            "char_start": 113154,
            "char_end": 113292
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "we obtain genericity statements via the counts of \\Cref{Thm:ConjugacyGrowth}, which apply perfectly well to the $G$--action on $\\Upsilon$."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:WallPieceControl",
          "to": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1585,
            "line_end": 1587,
            "char_start": 112343,
            "char_end": 112560
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "The proofs of \nPropositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} \nare nearly identical to those of Propositions~\\ref{Prop:ConePieceSystole} and~\\ref{Prop:WallPieceControl}, respectively."
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedConePiece",
          "to": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1599,
            "line_end": 1600,
            "char_start": 114520,
            "char_end": 114617
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece",
          "to": "Cor:SmallCancelUpsilon",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1599,
            "line_end": 1600,
            "char_start": 114520,
            "char_end": 114617
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Combining Propositions~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedConePiece} and~\\ref{Prop:GeneralizedWallPiece} gives:"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:HullUniformThickness",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in  \\widetilde w_i$ and $x_j, y_j \\in \\widetilde w_j$ that are $K$--close to $x$ and $y$, respectively.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1649,
            "line_end": 1649,
            "char_start": 119347,
            "char_end": 119514
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:HullUniformThickness}, there are points $x_i, y_i \\in  \\widetilde w_i$ and $x_j, y_j \\in \\widetilde w_j$ that are $K$--close to $x$ and $y$, respectively."
        },
        {
          "from": "Def:AuxiliarySmallCancel",
          "to": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Since $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha / \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, p, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1707,
            "line_end": 1707,
            "char_start": 123455,
            "char_end": 123618
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Since $\\langle G : H_1, \\ldots, H_m \\mid g_1, \\ldots, g_k \\rangle$ is $C'(\\alpha / \\overline{\\lambda})$ with respect to $(\\Upsilon, p, \\gamma_1, \\ldots, \\gamma_k)$"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:QITranslation",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1888,
            "line_end": 1888,
            "char_start": 137866,
            "char_end": 137966
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "We now discuss the prospects for removing $\\lambda$ from the statement of \\Cref{Prop:QITranslation}."
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "See~\\cite[Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve} for a proof that the limit exists.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1870,
            "line_end": 1871,
            "char_start": 136406,
            "char_end": 136504
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "See~\\cite[Eqn (1.1) and Thm 1.2]{CantrellTanaka:ManhattanCurve} for a proof that the limit exists.",
          "locator": "Equation (1.1); Theorem 1.2; Theorem 4.23",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Equation (1.1), Theorem 1.2, and Theorem 4.23, used respectively for existence of mean distortion and a large-deviation typicality statement in the Cayley-graph setting.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The pair of metrics lies in the metric class covered by the cited version.",
            "The large-deviation statement applies to the manuscript's sampling of conjugacy classes, or a conversion from element sampling is supplied."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us\n that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1885,
            "line_end": 1887,
            "char_start": 137714,
            "char_end": 137864
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "For general $\\Upsilon$, the referee informs us\n that this can be derived from Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Eqn (5.2)]{CantrellReyes:MarkedLengthSpectrum}.",
          "locator": "Equation (5.2)",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "A claimed deduction from Equation (5.2) establishing typicality for conjugacy classes in general Upsilon.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The needed equation and deduction were available in a version on or before April 24, 2023.",
            "The result covers both metrics and the conjugacy-class sampling measure used here."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes",
          "to": "Rem:ProbabilisticQITranslation",
          "type": "excluded_input",
          "evidence": "If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1884,
            "line_end": 1885,
            "char_start": 137556,
            "char_end": 137713
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "If $\\Upsilon$ is itself a CAT(0) cube complex, this follows from a large deviation theorem of Cantrell and Reyes~\\cite[Thm 1.4]{CantrellReyes:RigidityCubes}.",
          "locator": "Theorem 1.4",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "",
          "required_hypotheses": [],
          "reference_role": "excluded"
        },
        {
          "from": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "to": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2062,
            "line_end": 2063,
            "char_start": 147719,
            "char_end": 147787
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Thus \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalRestate} implies \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI}."
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Prop:PentagonalQI",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2062,
            "line_end": 2062,
            "char_start": 147620,
            "char_end": 147718
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "Observe that the constant $\\lambda$ in the statement of \\Cref{Prop:PentagonalQI} is exactly $d/c$."
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Ratcliffe:Foundations",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 1981,
            "line_end": 1982,
            "char_start": 143703,
            "char_end": 143754
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\cite[Thm 3.5.9]{Ratcliffe:Foundations}, we have",
          "locator": "Theorems 3.5.3, 3.5.8, and 3.5.9",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "Theorems 3.5.8 and 3.5.9 for Lambert quadrilaterals, and Theorem 3.5.3 for the hyperbolic cosine rule.",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The quadrilateral has the right angles and side placement shown in the cited formulas.",
            "The triangles and metric have constant curvature -1.",
            "The source is the third edition, whose numbering is cited."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "external:Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry",
          "to": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "According to first formula in the last block of displayed equations on \\cite[page 88]{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry}, we have",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2033,
            "line_end": 2034,
            "char_start": 145915,
            "char_end": 146037
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "According to first formula in the last block of displayed equations on \\cite[page 88]{Fenchel:HyperbolicGeometry}, we have",
          "locator": "Page 88, first formula in the last block of displayed equations",
          "audit_status": "not_inspected",
          "imported_result": "The page-88 quadrilateral identity cosh(2g)=-sinh^2(4a)+cosh^2(4a)cosh(2a).",
          "required_hypotheses": [
            "The quadrilateral has two right angles at the ends of the side of length 2a.",
            "The adjacent sides both have length 4a.",
            "The side configuration matches the cited formula."
          ],
          "reference_role": "proof_input"
        },
        {
          "from": "Lem:PentagonLengths",
          "to": "Prop:PentagonalRestate",
          "type": "proof_dependency",
          "evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}, every edge of $w$ has hyperbolic length $2b$.",
          "anchor": {
            "source": "manuscript",
            "line_start": 2085,
            "line_end": 2086,
            "char_start": 149002,
            "char_end": 149078
          },
          "origin": "review_model_inference",
          "evidence_source_match": true,
          "evidence_verbatim_match": true,
          "evidence_match_mode": "exact",
          "source_evidence": "By \\Cref{Lem:PentagonLengths}, every edge of $w$ has hyperbolic length $2b$."
        }
      ],
      "coverage": {
        "mode": "native_latex_index",
        "claims": 58,
        "sections": 7,
        "external_references": 46,
        "source_bibliography_entries": 46,
        "unresolved_bibliography": 0,
        "unresolved": 0
      },
      "limitations": [
        "Reference edges are not certified proof dependencies. Edge direction is prerequisite \u2192 consumer.",
        "Numbers reflect simple source counters; labels and line anchors are authoritative.",
        "Extractive statements and proof openings are marked; they are not reconstructed proof gists.",
        "Macros, included files and custom counters require an expanded source or annotated fallback."
      ]
    }
  }
}
