gpt-6.2-sol high: aht-repair-operations
Completed visible assessment, preserved as a readable check record. It is a model assessment, not a formal certificate. This document contains no private reasoning stream.
R1 passes. The schedule counts orbits correctly and terminates; the repeated-trim recurrence gives the claimed logarithmic stabilization bound per other pairing. The next-pivot transition is valid in the constant-pairing-count setting where the candidate uses it. No original running-time assertion is needed.
R1
Checked statement: The modified schedule is well-defined, preserves the orbit count after accounting for isolated points, and terminates. Fixed-pivot stabilization takes O(1+log N) transmissions per other pairing, and the next selection after a surviving truncation, absent an intervening merger, has a different pivot with a strictly smaller range start.
Returned assessment: no_issue_found
Normalize by inversion when necessary to put the smaller side start first. For equal starts, an increasing pairing is an identity; a decreasing pairing is a reflection of the common interval and is trimmed. A singleton paired to itself is an identity regardless of its sign, and either sign on a singleton paired to a different point represents the same edge. More generally, for an overlapping reflection x↦H−x with normalized domain start a and range end d, the integer trim keeps [a,ceil(H/2)−1] and [floor(H/2)+1,d]. If a nonloop reflection edge had its larger endpoint in the old domain, its smaller endpoint was also in that domain: it is at least the old range start and below the larger endpoint. Thus every nonloop edge survives as an unordered edge, and an integral midpoint contributes only a loop. An empty trim is discarded. Every surviving normalized pairing now has strictly ordered side starts and ends, so terminal coverage implies that a range reaches the current endpoint.
A merger uses only increasing pairings with positive periods and gapless spans, and checks the inclusive overlap width against the sum of the periods. In that overlap a block of length t1 and its translate by t2 both fit, so the second pairing joins the first span's residue classes modulo t1 by addition of t2. The symmetric argument applies on the second span. The overlap represents every residue modulo gcd(t1,t2), and neither old pairing connects distinct such residues. The merged pairing therefore has exactly the old orbits on the union, and its positive period and nonempty sides satisfy the periodic-pairing definition. A terminal uncovered suffix consists of singleton orbits and can be removed without renumbering any surviving point; if there are no pairings, count the whole remainder, including the empty case. Retaining interior static points needs no additional move.
During transmission, each moved endpoint is connected to its old endpoint by the unchanged pivot. Replacing the old pairing edges by the transmitted edges therefore preserves connectivity in both directions, whether one side moves or both do. For an increasing pivot of period t and range [c,n], a contained side starting at x takes exactly floor((x−c)/t)+1 inverse shifts: each application starts with the whole side in the pivot range, and the last shift puts its start below c. For a trimmed reversing pivot, one inverse application puts the whole side below c. An unshifted side already starts below c because its end is at most n. Inversion for normalization only exchanges sides, so only a new trim can make a range eligible again. At such a repeat the reflection's domain still starts below c: trimming leaves that start unchanged. A reversing pivot then moves only the range, making the pairing increasing, so it stabilizes or is deleted as an identity. For an increasing pivot, the repeat has range start u=floor(H/2)+1≥c. Moving only that range by distance m≥u−c+1 changes the reflection constant to H−m, which neither inversion nor restriction changes. With e=H−2c+2≥0, one has m≥floor(e/2)+1; if another repeat occurs its excess satisfies e_new+1≤ceil(e/2)≤(e+1)/2. Since H≤2N, a positive integer initially O(N) cannot undergo more than O(1+log N) such halvings. A stabilized pairing stays stabilized while the pivot is fixed, because processing another pairing does not change it.
At stabilization, every other range starts below c. Any competitor originally ending at n was eligible by widest-range selection and had width at most n−c+1. It cannot still end at n with a start below c, since that would require its width to have increased. Initially ineligible ranges are unchanged. Let B be the largest other range end, or 0 if there is none. All other domains end at or before B. The maximal exclusive suffix leaves n'=max(c−1,B)<n. For an increasing pivot the deleted points form terminal segments of translation chains, each attaching to a retained point: inverse steps from the deleted suffix are defined until the chain first reaches n' or below. For a trimmed reversing pivot each deleted point has one retained partner below c. In both cases restricting the pivot as specified deletes no whole orbit and cannot disconnect retained points; all other pairings are untouched. A surviving pivot keeps range start c and remains normalized and trimmed.
Survival means B≥c and n'=B, so another range ends at n' and starts strictly below c. There is no terminal cleanup or pending trim before the next selection. Without an intervening merger, the next pivot is different, starts strictly below c, and contains the shortened old range. It transmits that range in a completed constant-k macro step. If an identity deletion restarts the new step before that range is processed, this last processing assertion does not apply to the interrupted invocation; the deletion already drops k. Finally, a completed truncation reduces the endpoint, a restart by merger or deletion reduces the pairing count, and a nonempty terminal cleanup reduces the endpoint. Neither quantity increases. The fixed-pivot bound excludes infinite work between these events. Thus the schedule terminates at the empty system, and its isolated-point counter equals the original orbit count.
Premises used
- Finite integer intervals with inclusive widths and the supplied definitions of pairing, transmission, trimming, periodic merger, and truncation.
- The candidate holds the selected pivot fixed during stabilization and performs no interior contractions.
- The consecutive-pivot transmission assertion is used on completed steps without an intervening pairing-count drop.
Missing inputs
Scope changes
- This establishes local correctness, termination, and the fixed-pivot cost. Termination by a decreasing endpoint and pairing count is not itself a polynomial bound in k and log N.
- The result concerns the modified schedule, not the exact printed cycles.
Outside the audit
- Global halving and close-side amortization in candidate-R parts (2)–(3), including the claim that the total number of macro steps is polynomial.
- The conditional normal-surface and NP-certificate application, and the separate NP-hardness argument.
Additional supporting archive items are identified in the original report. View the manuscript hashes and repository snapshot.