claude-fable-5-2 high: cef-algebra
Reviewer record, not the publication verdict. This preserves a completed model response, including unaccepted proposals and its stated source limitations. The curated report and repair note specify which conclusions were adopted. Seven initial source-label failures were reconciled in explicit derivatives; native statuses and original access declarations remain in the provenance record.
Completed visible assessment, preserved as a readable check record. It is a model assessment, not a formal certificate. This document contains no private reasoning stream.
A1 (Section 5.1 and Theorem 1.11) and A2 (Section 5.2) hold with no mathematical error found; A3 (Section 5.3) is false in its stated generality. A1: the only defects are an unprinted but immediate proof of pr:coinvariantfinite, typos, and loose wording about which sequence is representation stable. A2: the co-FI-ideal computation and the BS^1 identification check out; the result is conditional on the unsupplied [BS, Section 11.2] presentation and needs a one-line duality step the proof omits. A3: the setup wrongly calls the generators of J_n homogeneous, so the grading is undefined for non-monomial p. The proof's claim that rank varieties form an FI#-subscheme is false, with explicit matrices for p = T-1 and p = T^2. The theorem fails literally for the constant P=(1). Remark 5.3.3 fails for P=(T^2), r=(1), d=2 over C. What survives is the determinantal case p_l = c_l*T, where the printed proof works for all n >= 0, scheme and reduced. A new repair gives eventual polynomiality for monomial P. The scheme-theoretic 'all n >= 0' claim for P=(T^e), e >= 2, remains unresolved. All positive conclusions are conditional on core theorems (th:noetherian, th:FIequiv, thm:persinomial, thm:fisubalgebra, th:charFIsharp, thm:polyFIsharp) that were read but not audited in this packet. No tools, web access or external sources were used; line numbers inside the given ranges are hand-counted approximations; the journal text was not collated.
A1
Checked statement: (a) R(P)=k[M(1)]/((P)) is a graded FI-algebra of finite type, and R(P_d)^i_n is uniformly representation stable over Q. (b) W^inv is a co-FI-submodule and coinv(A)=A/((A^inv_{>0})) is a graded co-FI-algebra. (c) pr:coinvariantfinite: over a field of char 0, coinv(A) inherits finite type and slope <= m. (d) Theorem 1.11 (theorem:intro:polynomial:answer): the characters of R^{(r)}_J(n) are eventually polynomial of degree <= |J|, and dim R^{(r)}_J(n) is eventually a polynomial of degree <= |J|. (e) The three low-degree examples in eq:coinvariantexamples.
Returned assessment: no_issue_found
No mathematical error found; the conclusions are conditional on the cited core theorems (th:noetherian, th:FIequiv, thm:persinomial, thm:fisubalgebra), which I read but did not audit.
(a) k[M(1)] is generated by its grading-1 part M(1), which has V^0=0 and is finitely generated, so thm:fisubalgebra applies over any commutative k. The FI-ideal generated by homogeneous P_j is graded, and quotients of finite type are of finite type. The concrete description of R(P)_S is correct. Representation stability of R(P_d)^i over Q then follows from th:FIequiv.
(b) For a co-FI-module W, an injection f:T->T' and sigma in S_T, pick sigma' in S_{T'} with f sigma = sigma' f. Contravariance gives sigma_(f_ w) = f_(sigma'_ w) = f_* w for w invariant. Hence f_(W^inv_{T'}) lies in W^inv_T (the printed inclusion has a typo). Each f_ is a graded unital algebra map, so it sends the ideal generated by positive-degree invariants of A_{T'} into the corresponding ideal of A_T. Thus coinv(A) is a graded co-FI-algebra; no surjectivity of f_* is needed. The remark that the J_n do not form an FI-ideal for the covariant structure is correct.
(c) pr:coinvariantfinite has no printed proof. It follows at once from the co-FI paragraph before pr:cofisubalgebra: over a field, the surjection A^i ->> coinv(A)^i dualizes to an injection of FI-modules (coinv(A)^i)^* into (A^i)^*. The target is finitely generated by hypothesis, so th:noetherian (k contains Q) makes the submodule finitely generated. Weight passes to subquotients, which gives the slope statement.
(d) Checked step by step. The co-FI structure on M(1) (e_{f(s)} -> e_s, other e_t -> 0) has dual FI-module isomorphic to M(1), so W=M(1)^{+r} in grading 1 is of finite type with wt(W^)=1. pr:cofisubalgebra uses k{W}^ = k{W^}, valid because all pieces are finite-dimensional, followed by th:noetherian; it gives Q[M(1)^{+r}] finite type and slope <= 1. pr:coinvariantfinite passes this to R^{(r)}. The multigrading is preserved by the co-FI maps, and the ideal is multihomogeneous because multihomogeneous components of invariants are invariant. So (R^{(r)}_J)^ is a direct summand of ((R^{(r)})^{|J|})^*, hence finitely generated of weight <= |J|. thm:persinomial then gives a character polynomial of degree <= |J|. Characters of S_n-representations in char 0 are self-dual. Specializing to (n,0,0,...) gives dimension degree <= |J| since deg X_1 = 1. Passing from Q (proof) to a char-0 field k (statement in the introduction) is harmless: invariants and the ideal they generate commute with the flat base change.
(e) Verified by hand. Degree 1: quotient of the permutation representation by e_1 gives X_1 - 1 for n >= 1. Degree 2: Sym^2 has character C(X_1,2)+X_1+X_2; the ideal in degree 2 is e_1V_1 (character X_1) plus p_2, which is not in e_1V_1 for n >= 2; this gives C(X_1,2)+X_2-1, and the formula fails at n=1 as the stated range indicates. Bidegree (1,1): the ideal is e_xV_y + e_yV_x (dimension 2n-1) plus sum x_i y_i, independent for n >= 2; this gives X_1^2 - 2X_1 = 2C(X_1,2) - X_1.
Premises used
- thm:fisubalgebra: an algebra generated by a finite-type graded sub-FI-module V with V^0=0 is of finite type (any k); slope <= m is inherited (char 0)
- th:noetherian (k Noetherian containing Q): sub-FI-modules of finitely generated FI-modules are finitely generated
- pr:cofisubalgebra and the preceding co-FI paragraph (field of char 0)
- pr:Mmuweight: wt(M(1)) = 1
- thm:persinomial: finitely generated FI-module in char 0 has a character polynomial of degree <= weight, valid eventually
- th:FIequiv: finitely generated implies uniformly representation stable (char 0)
- Self-duality of S_n-representations in char 0
Missing inputs
- Chevalley's theorem, [CF, Thm 7.4] and [AAB, Cor 5.2] are cited only as comparisons; not supplied and not needed for the logic
- Journal full text not collated
Scope changes
- All finite-type conclusions for co-FI-algebras in Section 5.1 need a field of characteristic 0, as stated.
- Theorem 1.11 gives only eventual polynomiality; no explicit range is claimed or derivable from this argument (it goes through th:noetherian).
Located concern
pr:coinvariantfinite, approx. lines 1730-1733
Missing proof (not an error): the proposition is stated with no proof or pointer.
No proof environment follows the statement. The needed argument is the dualization plus th:noetherian given in the argument field; it uses only the co-FI paragraph before pr:cofisubalgebra.
Add one sentence: coinv(A) is a quotient co-FI-module of A, so its graded dual is a graded sub-FI-module of A^*; apply th:noetherian and monotonicity of weight under subquotients.
None.
Located concern
para 'Coinvariant algebras' approx. line 1724; proof of theorem:intro:polynomial:answer approx. line 1746; pr:cofisubalgebra statement
Typographical slips: 'f_(W^inv_{T'}) subset f_(W^inv_T)' should have target W^inv_T; 'wt <= J' and 'degree <= J' should read |J|; pr:cofisubalgebra says 'If V has slope' for W.
Direct reading; the intended statements are the ones verified above.
Correct the typos.
None.
Located concern
Example after pr:coinvariantfinite, approx. line 1736
Imprecision: 'uniformly representation stable' is asserted for R^i_n, but the consistent sequence to which th:FIequiv applies is the dual FI-module (R^i)^*. The co-FI maps R_{n+1} -> R_n go the other way.
definition:repstab requires maps V_n -> V_{n+1}; these exist on the duals only.
State stability for the dual sequence. Multiplicity stability for R^i_n itself follows by self-duality.
None for multiplicities or characters.
A2
Checked statement: Proposition of Section 5.2: for k a field of char 0 there is a graded co-FI-algebra BS of finite type with BS_n = G(R_n/k) as graded S_n-representations (diagonal S_n in S_n x S_{n+1}); hence G(R_n/k)^i is uniformly representation stable. Also the displayed identification (BS^1)^* = M(1) tensor M(1) = M(2) + M(1,1) + M(1).
Returned assessment: no_issue_found
The construction and finite-type argument check out, conditional on the external presentation of G(R_n/k) from [BS, Section 11.2] and on th:noetherian and th:FIequiv.
Structure. R has R^0=M(0), R^1 = dual of the FI-module M(1), and zero above; it is a co-FI-algebra with maps x_{f(s)} -> x_s and x_t -> 0 for t outside f(S). The augmentation R ->> M(0) is a map of co-FI-algebras. So def:tensorbullet applies; functoriality holds because the augmentation commutes with the f_*.
Ideal. On the first factor, f_(x_t) is x_s if t=f(s) and 0 otherwise. On R^{tensor bullet}, a term with x_t in position t' is killed by the augmentation when t' is outside f(S); otherwise it goes to x_s in position s', or to 0. Hence f_(gamma_T(x_t)) = gamma_S(x_s) if t=f(s), and 0 otherwise. So J is a co-FI-ideal and BS_n = R_n^{tensor (n+1)}/J_n. The S_n action is the diagonal one, with S_n embedded in S_{n+1} fixing the extra tensor factor. There are no Koszul signs since R is treated as commutative.
Finite type. pr:Vtensorbullet is stated for FI-modules, while R is a co-FI-algebra; the proof leaves the bridge implicit. Since all pieces are finite-dimensional, (R^{tensor bullet})^* = (R^)^{tensor bullet}: the dual of 'augment the factors outside f(S)' is 'insert the unit M(0) -> R^ in the factors outside f(S)'. R^* is a graded FI-module with (R^)^0 = M(0) and (R^)^1 = M(1). I checked the printed proof of pr:Vtensorbullet; in this case it gives ((R^)^{tensor bullet})^i generated in degree <= 2i. pr:gradedtensor gives R^ tensor (R^)^{tensor bullet} of finite type. BS^ is a graded sub-FI-module of it, so th:noetherian (char 0) applies. th:FIequiv then gives representation stability of the dual sequence, and self-duality transfers multiplicities.
BS^1. In grading 1 the relations gamma(x_t) eliminate the position-0 generators, so BS^1 = (R^{tensor bullet})^1 as co-FI-modules. Its dual has basis the pairs (position t', variable t) in T x T with FI acting diagonally, i.e. M(1) tensor M(1). Splitting into equal and distinct pairs gives M(1) + M(2), and M(2) = M(k[S_2]) = M(trivial) + M(sign) in char 0. This matches the display.
Premises used
- External: [BS, Section 11.2], that the defining ideal of G(R_n/k) in R_n^{tensor (n+1)} is generated by the elements gamma_n(x_i). Imported with available_from = arXiv:1006.2562 (June 2010 by its identifier, before the 2013-07-14 cutoff); date_basis = arXiv identifier as cited in the bibliography; version and section number not verifiable here.
- def:tensorbullet (co-FI version), pr:Vtensorbullet (hypothesis V^0 = M(0), V of finite type), pr:gradedtensor
- th:noetherian (char 0) for passage to the quotient BS
- th:FIequiv for representation stability
Missing inputs
- Text of [BS] Section 11.2 (not supplied): the exact statement, its characteristic hypotheses, and the grading on G(R_n/k). From my recollection of the Bhargava-Satriano definition (relations e_j(a^(1),...,a^(n+1)) = s_j(a) for all a), the claim is consistent in char 0: for nilpotent nu with nu^2=0 one has e_1^m = m! e_m, so the higher relations lie in the ideal generated by the e_1's. This rests on an unsupplied definition and is not a verification.
Scope changes
- Conclusion is conditional on the [BS] presentation and on char 0 (used for th:noetherian, and plausibly for the presentation itself).
- No stable range is claimed. The argument does give (BS^i)^* inside an FI-module generated in degree <= 2i, hence weight <= 2i.
Located concern
Proof, approx. line 1780 ('Since R is of finite type, Propositions pr:Vtensorbullet and pr:gradedtensor imply...')
Minor exposition gap: pr:Vtensorbullet is an FI-module statement applied to a co-FI-algebra without the identification (R^{tensor bullet})^* = (R^*)^{tensor bullet}.
Finite type for co-FI-modules is defined via the dual (para 'Co-FI-algebras'). The dual of the co-FI structure map of def:tensorbullet is the FI structure map of def:tensorbullet for R^* with unit M(0) -> R^*; this holds because R_T is finite-dimensional.
Insert the one-line duality identification.
None.
Located concern
Proposition statement, approx. lines 1761-1762
Imprecision: uniform representation stability holds for the dual consistent sequence (BS^i_n)^*; the co-FI maps on BS^i_n go from n+1 to n. 'Diagonal subgroup' tacitly uses the standard embedding of S_n in S_{n+1}.
Same as in A1; the proof itself writes (BS^i)^* = BS^i.
State stability for the dual FI-module and multiplicity stability for G(R_n/k)^i.
None for multiplicities or characters.
A3
Checked statement: Setup of Section 5.3 (J_n generated by 'homogeneous polynomials' det(B(p_l(A))), with O(X_{P,r}(n)) inheriting a grading). Theorem 5.3.2 (theorem:sections:polygrowth): for arbitrary P, r, d over any field, dim O(X_{P,r}(n))^d is a polynomial in n of degree <= 2d for all n >= 0, and likewise the characters in char 0. Remark 5.3.3: the same holds for the reduced variety by the same argument.
Returned assessment: claim_false
Three things must be kept apart: an ill-posed setup, a false step in the proof, and false statements.
(1) Setup. Entries of p(A) are homogeneous only when p is a monomial c*T^e. For other p the minors are inhomogeneous, J_n is not a homogeneous ideal, and k[x]/J_n inherits no grading. So O(X_{P,r}(n))^d is undefined for general P.
(2) Proof step. The FI# maps on Mat are 'restrict to the principal A x A block, then extend by zero'. Rank varieties are not preserved in general. Extension by zero fails when p(0) is nonzero, since p(M + 0) = p(M) + p(0)*I. Principal restriction fails already for p = T^2. So X_{P,r} is not an FI#-subscheme and O(X_{P,r}) is not a quotient FI#-algebra of O(Mat). Explicit matrices are in the issues.
(3) Theorem as stated. It is literally false for the constant polynomial P=(1), r=(1), d=1; here J_n is homogeneous, so the statement is meaningful. For non-monomial P it is ill-posed. For monomials T^e with e >= 2, the scheme-theoretic 'all n >= 0' claim is unproved and I could not decide it by hand.
(4) Remark 5.3.3. False for the nonconstant, homogeneous case P=(T^2), r=(1), d=2 over C: the reduced coordinate ring has degree-2 dimension 0, 1, then n^2(n^2+1)/2 - 1 for n >= 2, which is not a polynomial on all n >= 0. Full proof in the issues.
(5) What survives. Determinantal case (every p_l a nonzero scalar multiple of T, or zero): minors go to minors or 0 under both kinds of FI# map, J is a homogeneous FI#-ideal, and the printed proof works. O(X)^d is a quotient FI#-module of Sym^d(M(1) tensor M(1)), generated in degree <= 2d as an FI-module by pr:tensor (any k). thm:polyFIsharp (vi)/(vii) gives polynomial dimension over any field, and polynomial characters in char 0, for all n >= 0, of degree <= 2d. In positive characteristic the degree bound must come from generation degree, not from 'slope', which is defined only in char 0. The reduced version also holds here: if g^m lies in J_T then f^*(g)^m lies in J_S, so the radical of an FI#-ideal is an FI#-ideal, and it is homogeneous.
(6) New repair (my argument, not the printed proof): eventual polynomiality for monomial P. Suppose every p_l = c_l*T^{e_l} with e_l >= 1. Then J_n is homogeneous. The pullback along extension by zero (x_{f(s)f(s')} -> x_{ss'}, other variables -> 0) sends the generic matrix to A_S + 0, and p(A_S + 0) = p(A_S) + 0, so minors go to minors or 0. Thus J and its radical are co-FI-ideals, and O(X)^d and O(X_red)^d are quotient co-FI-modules of O(Mat)^d. The dual of O(Mat)^d is the FI-module of symmetric d-tensors on M(1) tensor M(1): a permutation module on size-d multisets of ordered pairs, generated in degree <= 2d, of weight <= 2d. In char 0, th:noetherian makes the dual of O(X)^d finitely generated, and thm:persinomial gives characters and dimensions eventually polynomial of degree <= 2d. In positive characteristic the same argument needs the Noetherian property and eventual polynomiality of dimension over arbitrary fields from [CEFN] (arXiv:1210.1854, October 2012 by identifier, before the cutoff; cited in the paper as Theorem A; version content not verified here). This gives 'for n >> 0', not 'for all n >= 0'.
Disclosure: I cannot remove later knowledge from model weights. Nothing above relies on post-cutoff results. I am not aware of, and do not cite, any published correction.
Premises used
- remark:FIsharpremarks (FI# isomorphic to its opposite), thm:fisubalgebra, pr:tensor, thm:polyFIsharp, th:charFIsharp, thm:persinomial (for the determinantal case)
- th:noetherian and thm:persinomial (for the new char-0 repair)
- Elementary linear algebra: Jordan form; quadrics vanishing on rank <= 1 matrices are spanned by the 2x2 minors (proved in the issue below)
- Hilbert Nullstellensatz over C (to identify the reduced ideal with the vanishing ideal)
Missing inputs
- A proof or disproof of the scheme-theoretic 'all n >= 0' statement for P=(T^e), e >= 2. Unverified heuristic only: for P=(T^2), r=1, the relation [A tensor 1 + 1 tensor A, Lambda^2(A^2)] = 0 gives linear syzygies among the generators of J_n in degree 5 whose count suggests the same small-n defect as in the reduced case. I did not prove these are all the syzygies.
- [CEFN] text (for the positive-characteristic version of the repair); exact theorem numbers and version not verified
- Eisenbud-Saltman [ES] and Weyman [Wey] are not supplied; they are not used in the logic
Scope changes
- Theorem 5.3.2 as printed is established only for determinantal varieties (each p_l a nonzero scalar multiple of T, or zero): any field, all n >= 0, degree <= 2d, both scheme and reduced versions.
- For p_l = c_l*T^{e_l}, e_l >= 1: only eventual polynomiality (degree <= 2d) is available, via the new repair. Char 0 uses th:noetherian and thm:persinomial; positive characteristic is conditional on [CEFN]. Scheme version for all n >= 0 is unresolved; reduced version for all n >= 0 is false.
- For non-monomial p_l the graded statement is ill-posed; a filtered reformulation would be a different theorem and is not audited here.
- table:examples item 5 and cor:polydim:app: for general P the entry is not justified as a finitely generated FI-module. For monomial P with e_l >= 1 the dual of O(X_{P,r})^d is a finitely generated FI-module (char 0), which suffices for the eventual-polynomiality conclusion of cor:polydim:app.
Located concern
Section 5.3 setup, approx. lines 1801-1802 ('generated by the homogeneous polynomials ... inherits a grading')
Incorrect intermediate assertion: the generators of J_n are not homogeneous unless every p_l is a monomial, so the grading on O(X_{P,r}(n)) is undefined for general P.
P=(T-1), r=(1), n=2: J_2 is the principal ideal generated by (x_11 - 1)(x_22 - 1) - x_12 x_21. A principal ideal with an inhomogeneous generator is not homogeneous.
Restrict to monomial p_l (in particular p_l(0)=0), or replace the grading by the degree filtration (functions that are restrictions of polynomials of degree <= d) and restate the theorem.
The theorem is ill-posed for non-monomial P.
Located concern
Proof of theorem:sections:polygrowth, approx. line 1820 ('The rank varieties X_{P,r}(S) in Mat_{SxS} are preserved by these maps')
False step. Neither half of the FI# structure preserves rank varieties in general.
(i) Extension by zero, p(0) nonzero: P=(T-1), r=(1). A=(1) lies in X(1) since A-I=0. Its extension diag(1,0,0) has A'-I = diag(0,-1,-1) of rank 2 > 1, so it is not in X(3). (ii) Principal restriction, P=(T^2), r=(1), any characteristic: M = [[I_2, I_2],[-I_2, -I_2]] in Mat_4 has M^2=0, so M is in X(4). Its principal block on {1,2} is I_2 with rank(I_2^2)=2 > 1, not in X(2). On rings: det((A restricted to {1,2})^2) lies in J_2, but as an element of k[x_ij : i,j <= 4] it is nonzero at M in V(J_4), so it is not in J_4 or its radical. The covariant map O(X(2)) -> O(X(4)) therefore does not exist.
Restrict the FI# argument to the determinantal case p_l = c_lT with c_l nonzero. For monomial p_l = c_lT^{e_l}, e_l >= 1, only the co-FI half (extension by zero) survives; use it with th:noetherian to get eventual polynomiality (new repair, argument item 6).
The printed proof establishes the theorem only in the determinantal case.
Located concern
theorem:sections:polygrowth, approx. lines 1811-1818 ('Fix P, r, and d ... for all n >= 0')
False as stated in full generality: a degenerate literal counterexample satisfies every stated hypothesis.
P=(1) (constant polynomial in k[T]), r=(1), d=1, any field. p(A)=I_n. For n <= 1 there are no 2x2 minors, so J_n=0 and O = k[x_ij]. For n >= 2 the principal 2x2 minor of I_n is 1, so J_n=(1) and O=0. All generators are constants, so J_n is homogeneous and the statement is meaningful. dim O(X(n))^1 = 0, 1, 0, 0, ... for n = 0, 1, 2, 3, ...; a polynomial vanishing for all n >= 2 is zero, contradicting the value 1 at n=1.
Add hypotheses. With p_l = c_lT (c_l nonzero) the printed statement and proof hold. With p_l = c_lT^{e_l}, e_l >= 1, claim polynomiality only for n >> 0.
Theorem 5.3.2 must be restricted. Outside the determinantal case the 'all n >= 0' assertion is unproved (scheme version unresolved for T^e, e >= 2).
Located concern
Remark after the proof (reduced variety), approx. line 1828
False statement, with a nonconstant homogeneous P: the reduced-variety version fails for 'all n >= 0'.
k=C, P=(T^2), r=(1), d=2, X(n) = {A : rank(A^2) <= 1} with reduced structure. Let c_2 = sum over i<j of (x_ii x_jj - x_ij x_ji).
Claim: for n >= 2 the quadrics vanishing on X(n) are exactly the multiples of c_2.
(a) c_2 vanishes on X(n). A^2 is invertible on the sum of generalized eigenspaces for nonzero eigenvalues, so rank(A^2) <= 1 forces at most one nonzero eigenvalue with multiplicity, and c_2(A) = e_2(eigenvalues) = 0.
(b) X(n) contains all rank <= 1 matrices. A quadric q vanishing on all u v^T lies in the kernel of Sym^2(U tensor V)^* -> Sym^2 U^* tensor Sym^2 V^*. That map is surjective, so the kernel has dimension C(n,2)^2 and is spanned by the linearly independent 2x2 minors m_{I,J}. Write q = sum a_{I,J} m_{I,J}.
(c) I and J disjoint: A = E_{ij} + E_{i'j'} has A^2=0 and its only nonzero 2x2 minor is m_{I,J}(A)=1, so a_{I,J}=0.
(d) I={a,b}, J={a,c}, with a,b,c distinct: A = E_{aa} + E_{bc} has A^2 = E_{aa} of rank 1 and its only nonzero minor is +-m_{I,J}, so a_{I,J}=0.
(e) Principal minors: B = [[1,1,0],[-1,0,1],[1,0,-1]] has B^2 = [[0,1,1],[0,-1,-1],[0,1,1]] of rank 1 and B^3=0. Its principal 2x2 minors on {1,2}, {1,3}, {2,3} are 1, -1, 0. Placing B on rows and columns (a,b,c) and zero elsewhere gives a point of X(n) with q = a_{ab} - a_{ac}. Hence all a_{I,I} are equal and q is a multiple of c_2.
For n <= 1, X(n) = Mat_n and no quadric vanishes. So dim O(X_red(n))^2 = 0, 1 for n = 0, 1 and n^2(n^2+1)/2 - 1 for n >= 2 (values 9, 44, 135, 324, 665, ...). The only polynomial agreeing with these for n >= 2 takes the values -1 and 0 at n = 0 and 1. The same argument works for P=(T^e), any e >= 2.
Restrict the remark to the determinantal case (radicals of FI#-ideals are FI#-ideals), or weaken to 'for n >> 0' for monomial P via the co-FI structure and th:noetherian.
Remark 5.3.3 is false in the stated generality; only the eventual statement survives for monomial P.
Located concern
Proof, approx. lines 1824-1826 ('finite type and slope <= 2 ... follows from thm:persinomial and thm:polyFIsharp')
Minor gap in the surviving determinantal case: for a field of positive characteristic, the degree bound 2d cannot come from 'slope', since weight is defined only in char 0.
de:weight is restricted to char 0. The needed input is that O(X)^d is generated in FI-degree <= 2d, which follows from pr:tensor applied to (M(1) tensor M(1))^{tensor d} and passage to quotients. Then H_0 vanishes above 2d and thm:polyFIsharp (iii)=>(vi) gives degree <= 2d.
Cite generation in degree <= 2d instead of slope when char k > 0.
None in the determinantal case.
Outside the audit
- Proofs of th:noetherian, th:FIequiv, pr:stabdegstabrange, thm:persinomial, th:charFIsharp, thm:polyFIsharp, thm:fisubalgebra, pr:cofisubalgebra (used as stated; only interfaces checked)
- External sources: [BS] Section 11.2 and Theorem 7; Chevalley; [CF] Thm 7.4; [AAB]; [ES]; [Wey] Cor 6.1.5(d); [DK]; [CEFN]. None supplied.
- Example 5.1.A (Arnol'd algebra, arXiv-only) beyond noting it lies in the line range; its dependence on eq:dlmn and cor:subalgebraslope was not checked
- Scheme-theoretic Hilbert functions of rank(A^e) <= r varieties for e >= 2 beyond degrees <= 2e (unresolved)
- Sections 6-7 and all other parts of the paper; journal version
- Preserved source-access qualification: CEF-v4-TeX (context read for interfaces, not fully audited: th:noetherian, th:FIequiv, thm:persinomial, pr:Mmuweight, pr:tensor, remark:FIsharpremarks, th:charFIsharp, thm:polyFIsharp, pr:gradedtensor, thm:fisubalgebra, pr:cofisubalgebra, def:tensorbullet, pr:Vtensorbullet)
Additional supporting archive items are identified in the original report. View the manuscript hashes and repository snapshot.